The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

for a plasma ignoramus such as a few posters here, it's a difficult concept to get your head around.
As he has been told many times: Delusions and 45 years of abysmal ignorance about physics emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

The only "plasma ignoramus" is him since he has not understood any plasma physics that has been explained to him many times in this thread. He cannot even understand the English in Birkeland current:
A Birkeland current is a set of currents that flow along geomagnetic field lines connecting the Earth’s magnetosphere to the Earth's high latitude ionosphere.
Birkeland currents have only been detected around the Earth and needed a probe inserted into them :jaw-dropp!

'Birkeland current comet' has 8 abstracts indirectly referencing comets, e.g. "Mid-latitude Jovian aurora produced by the impact of comet Shoemaker-Levy-9".
 
Last edited:
So Reality Check.

Check mate...
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear. While activity from “cliffs” has been observed by Rosetta (Vincent et al. 2016a;Pajolaetal.2017b), it remains difficult to prove that it dominates the emission. The relationship of the uppermost (optically visible) surface to icy material just below the surface and the means of releasing the dust component remains a subject of speculation. Outburst phenomena are of interest as a means of lifting large chunks of material but it appears proven that the outbursts observed and quantified at 67P/C-G do not dominate the total visible particle emission of the comet. The exact mechanism is unknown and multiple mechanisms cannot be ruled out.

How is the dust released form the surface?

Sublimation is no longer tenable and this is from a MAINSTREAM ICES AND DUST PAPER!

Whipple's assumptions have proven to be wrong.
 
As he has been told many times: Delusions and 45 years of abysmal ignorance about physics emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

The only "plasma ignoramus" is him since he has not understood any plasma physics that has been explained to him many times in this thread. He cannot even understand the English in Birkeland current:

Birkeland currents have only been detected around the Earth and needed a probe inserted into them :jaw-dropp!

'Birkeland current comet' has 8 abstracts indirectly referencing comets, e.g. "Mid-latitude Jovian aurora produced by the impact of comet Shoemaker-Levy-9".

Birkeland currents and comets, cheers RC!
 
Whats the difference between flux ropes, flux tubes, fields aligned currents, force free currents and Birkeland currents?

Point form would be acceptable.
 
As he has been told many times: Delusions about physics emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

This is jonesdave116 listing a couple of the deluded claims.


Sol88 is lying about the insanity in the electric comet theory which does not include the ambipolar electric field. Ignorant delusions about what the ambipolar electric field inside a comet coma does are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.
Ignorant delusions about what charged dust inside a comet coma does are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

As a totally irrelevant aside, I suspect that the ambipolar electric field will be always changing direction. The comet coma is turbulent both physically and magnetically. It may be that on average it has no net acceleration on negatively charged dust and ice grains (the usual lie by omission).
Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko suggests that the ambipolar electric field acts as a damper for electrons


Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data

Spiky electric and magnetic field structures in flux rope experiments

or turbulent take your pick!

simpleton electrostatics it's not!
 
Your still thinking electrostatics 'ol mate.

How does a Birkeland current/current sheets keep - and + separate?

for a plasma ignoramus such as a few posters here, it's a difficult concept to get your head around.

That makes no sense whatsoever. Firstly, there are no Birkeland currents. Secondly, the ambipolar field is accelerating ions outward, and retarding electrons. If the dust is negatively charged, just like the electrons, what is happening to it? Assuming (wrongly) that the field is having any effect on it at all. As I said; this stuff is beyond you.
 
So Reality Check.

Check mate...

How is the dust released form the surface?

Sublimation is no longer tenable and this is from a MAINSTREAM ICES AND DUST PAPER!

Whipple's assumptions have proven to be wrong.

Which is another lie, with added strawman.
 
Whats the difference between flux ropes, flux tubes, fields aligned currents, force free currents and Birkeland currents?

Point form would be acceptable.

Tusenfem has already addressed this. And it has nothing to do with the complete failure of your woo.
 
Just to show how Sol is merely trolling, here are some posts from 2007 on BAUT/ Cosmoquest;

PhantomWolf to Starboy (Sol88);

And besides, aren't you pinning a lot on the MS being wrong? You willing to admit you are wrong when they find large amounts of ice under the surface of a comet?

Starboy:

Totally willing to admit that what I believe is wrong, with no reservations!

Starboy to Tusenfem:

Tusenfem, we can agree on that production of H2O by the impact, measured by infrared spectroscopy, showed an increase from 2.8 to 27 in units of 10-19W m-2, where the 2.8 should be considered the normal output for a Jupiter-family comet.

But we disagree on where it comes from. Is there ice, Tusenfem 1cm 2 cm 10 cm 100 cm 1000cm below the surface or indeed not on\in the nucleus at all?

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets/page17&highlight=electric+comet

The above was from February 2007.

The following paper was from January 2006;

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT
onto Comet 9P/Tempel 1

Schulz, R. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2006/12/aahi281.pdf

And this paper was from May 2007;

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Sunshine, J. M. et al.
http://planetary.brown.edu/pdfs/3546.pdf

The Deep Impact flyby spacecraft includes a 1.05 to 4.8 μm infrared (IR) spectrometer. Although ice was not observed on the surface in the impact region, strong absorptions near 3 μm due to water ice are detected in IR measurements of the ejecta from the impact event. Absorptions from water ice occur throughout the IR dataset beginning three seconds after impact through the end of observations,∼45 min after impact. Spatially and temporally resolved IR spectra of the ejecta are analyzed in conjunction with laboratory impact experiments. The results imply an internal stratigraphy for Tempel 1 consisting of devolatilized materials transitioning to unaltered components at a depth of approximately one meter. At greater depths, which are thermally isolated from the surface, water ice is present. Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depths excavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1±1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory impurities.

And the following from 2012;

Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2012/06/aa18718-11/aa18718-11.html

A sustained production of water is observed, which can be explained by the sublimation of pure ice grains with sizes less than 1 μm and comprising a mass of ice of (0.8−1.8) × 107 kg.

Which is 8 000 - 18 000 tonnes.

And yet here he is, many years later, still talking about this totally debunked nonsense. Totally debunked by his own admission from back in 2007.
 
Last edited:
The usual gibberish will not be answered

The usual gibberish will not be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
The usual gibberish will not be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
The usual gibberish will not be answered

The usual gibberish will not be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
The usual gibberish will not be answered


The usual gibberish will not be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
[/url]



And the following from 2012;

Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2012/06/aa18718-11/aa18718-11.html



Which is 8 000 - 18 000 tonnes.

And yet here he is, many years later, still talking about this totally debunked nonsense. Totally debunked by his own admission from back in 2007.

Absolute tripe!

But you,jonesdave116 would believe a paper from 2012 :rolleyes:
 
The usual gibberish to not to be answered

The usual gibberish to not be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
Just to show how Sol is merely trolling, here are some posts from 2007 on BAUT/ Cosmoquest;

PhantomWolf to Starboy (Sol88);

Quote:
And besides, aren't you pinning a lot on the MS being wrong? You willing to admit you are wrong when they find large amounts of ice under the surface of a comet?
Starboy:

Quote:
Totally willing to admit that what I believe is wrong, with no reservations!
Starboy to Tusenfem:

Quote:
Tusenfem, we can agree on that production of H2O by the impact, measured by infrared spectroscopy, showed an increase from 2.8 to 27 in units of 10-19W m-2, where the 2.8 should be considered the normal output for a Jupiter-family comet.

But we disagree on where it comes from. Is there ice, Tusenfem 1cm 2 cm 10 cm 100 cm 1000cm below the surface or indeed not on\in the nucleus at all?
https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthr...electric+comet

The above was from February 2007.

and from a 2018 paper

The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice. The total mass-loss ΔM puts hard constraints on the models of interpretation of the observations from other instruments on Rosetta.
The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

So either Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 were ice comets and 67P is a dusty comet or there are a few glaring problems with the mainstream model.

As I stated back in 2007,
Totally willing to admit that what I believe is wrong, with no reservations!

Seems ive been correct all along!

how do you feel jonesdave116?

again, becasue you seem slow to grasp the IMPLICATIONS of
The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice.
along with

So not feeling to worried by jd116's flawed paper from 12years ago.

Comets are mostly rock with EM (Plasma) forces dominate.
 
Last edited:
The implications are
Wha tare comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Whipple model??
1 Introduction By the middle of the XXth century,Whipple (1950) inferred, through his analysis of the non keplerian motion of comets, the existence of cometary nuclei consisting of ices embedded with dust, i.e. micron-sized non-volatile particles. Dust ejected with gases from the nuclei, in combination with solar gravity and radiation pressure when comets approach the Sun, was recognized as the means by which the long-yellowish cometary dust tails are produced (e.g., Brandt and Chapman 1981). Significant progress in our understanding of cometary dust has been achieved, since the 1980’s, by a series of space missions performing flyby of nuclei and by remote observations of dust in cometary environments, as summarized below.
LINK

You're snookered champ!

Jonesdave116 links to A'Hearn's OLD papers where he envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice but absolutely refuses to accept A'Hearn's LASTEST paper (mainstream) understanding is EVOLVING. (evolve to change or develop gradually)

Why does your understanding have trouble evolving, jonesdave116?

Because the ELECTRIC COMET mob predicted that comets are rock and you're on some evangelical mission across multiple fora to "save" Whipple's outdated model of comets?

Kudos sport!
 
Last edited:
The usual gibberish not to be answered

The usual gibberish not to be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom