angrysoba
Philosophile
I prefer to think of it as prior probability. A billion years worth of examples of zoonosis means the prior probability for zoonosis is 100%. If you want to move that needle you need positive evidence for something else.
That said there is real evidence that suggests it's not a lab leak.
- there is no catalogued proximal ancestor as you would expect if it were a lab leak
- The key feature that allows SARS-CoV-2 to infect humans (it's receptor binding domain) shows a clear evolutionary pattern in closely related corona viruses suggesting that it's a naturally evolving feature.
- bats and Pangolins sampled in Thailand showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 reactive antibodies(meaning they had been infected with a close covid relative in the wild)
- environmental samples showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 at and near where animals were kept in the Wuhan Fish Market, but not elsewhere.
- SARS-CoV-2 shows traits that are inconsistent with how a real researcher would engineer a virus.
- Key parts of the SARS-CoV-2 genome contain elements that were completely unknown prior to researching SARS-CoV-2. Unless the researchers had traveled backwards in time there is no way for them to design these.
- The earliest know cases ALL come from either the vicinity of the market or from people with direct contact with the market.
- None of the early case have any connection with the lab and are located 20Km away from the lab
- The highest concentration of early cases start showing up near the market and radiate outwards over time as you would expect for an outbreak that started in the market.
- Excess deaths follow the same pattern, showing a rise near the market then progressively radiating outwards over time.
- The concentration of cases and excess deaths radiated towards the lab, not away from it as you'd expect from a lab leak
- the existence of 2 SARS-CoV-2 lineages at the time the virus jumped to humans suggests animal origin. Multiple crossover events from a population of infected animals could explain the early existence of distinct lineages.
- If there were only a single crossover event it's 75% likely the virus dies out within a week or two. A population of infected animals would create multiple infections and raise the probability of a successful jump to humans dramatically.
Yes. that’s an excellent summary.