Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I prefer to think of it as prior probability. A billion years worth of examples of zoonosis means the prior probability for zoonosis is 100%. If you want to move that needle you need positive evidence for something else.

That said there is real evidence that suggests it's not a lab leak.
- there is no catalogued proximal ancestor as you would expect if it were a lab leak
- The key feature that allows SARS-CoV-2 to infect humans (it's receptor binding domain) shows a clear evolutionary pattern in closely related corona viruses suggesting that it's a naturally evolving feature.
- bats and Pangolins sampled in Thailand showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 reactive antibodies(meaning they had been infected with a close covid relative in the wild)
- environmental samples showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 at and near where animals were kept in the Wuhan Fish Market, but not elsewhere.
- SARS-CoV-2 shows traits that are inconsistent with how a real researcher would engineer a virus.
- Key parts of the SARS-CoV-2 genome contain elements that were completely unknown prior to researching SARS-CoV-2. Unless the researchers had traveled backwards in time there is no way for them to design these.
- The earliest know cases ALL come from either the vicinity of the market or from people with direct contact with the market.
- None of the early case have any connection with the lab and are located 20Km away from the lab
- The highest concentration of early cases start showing up near the market and radiate outwards over time as you would expect for an outbreak that started in the market.
- Excess deaths follow the same pattern, showing a rise near the market then progressively radiating outwards over time.
- The concentration of cases and excess deaths radiated towards the lab, not away from it as you'd expect from a lab leak
- the existence of 2 SARS-CoV-2 lineages at the time the virus jumped to humans suggests animal origin. Multiple crossover events from a population of infected animals could explain the early existence of distinct lineages.
- If there were only a single crossover event it's 75% likely the virus dies out within a week or two. A population of infected animals would create multiple infections and raise the probability of a successful jump to humans dramatically.

Yes. that’s an excellent summary.
 
I'm not going over all that nonsense lomiller, those are BS claims.

For example this ignores the fact China has covered up this data:
- there is no catalogued proximal ancestor as you would expect if it were a lab leak

You claim the head of the WHO merely said more investigation is needed when in reality he said the lab leak hypothesis was not thoroughly examined.

All of those things on your list are just as erroneous as these examples.
 
Because you keep conflating supporting evidence with conclusive evidence.

As for not ruling out the seafood market, like I said, we haven't ruled out a space alien attack either.

So stupid. We have evidence that people got sick at the market. No evidence of space aliens and no evidence of people getting sick from the lab. If you cannot trace anyone who is sick from the lab then that right there puts the market as a higher possibility of a spillover location than the WIV even if the cases we know about happened later than the spillover event. Equating a market origin with a space alien attack is pants on the head ridiculous.

Remember, I am NOT saying it came from the market. I am saying that IF you think the market MUST be ruled out, then you need better evidence than that the KNOWN first case had no relation to the market, because that kind of reasoning leads you to rule out almost everything including most obviously the LAB. Yet here you are trying to have your cake and eat it - laughing at the very idea that the market which absolutely was the source of a large number of infections (the majority of known infections at one point!) is on a par with a space alien attack. Seriously, who do you think you are convincing with this self-satisfied drivel?
 
So stupid. We have evidence that people got sick at the market. No evidence of space aliens and no evidence of people getting sick from the lab. If you cannot trace anyone who is sick from the lab then that right there puts the market as a higher possibility of a spillover location than the WIV even if the cases we know about happened later than the spillover event. Equating a market origin with a space alien attack is pants on the head ridiculous.

Remember, I am NOT saying it came from the market. I am saying that IF you think the market MUST be ruled out, then you need better evidence than that the KNOWN first case had no relation to the market, because that kind of reasoning leads you to rule out almost everything including most obviously the LAB. Yet here you are trying to have your cake and eat it - laughing at the very idea that the market which absolutely was the source of a large number of infections (the majority of known infections at one point!) is on a par with a space alien attack. Seriously, who do you think you are convincing with this self-satisfied drivel?
I know what you are saying Soba. I have not failed to understand your premise. I can't see any evidence whatsoever to keep that market on the origin table.

Did you miss this post where a year ago even the Chinese dismissed the seafood market?

We are so far past the seafood market, you really need to make an effort to understand the difference between no evidence except claiming it is possible and evidence supporting one conclusion or another that isn't necessarily conclusive.

That zoonoses are common is one thing, that SARS came from a wet market does not implicate every wet market in China as a potential source without at least some shred of evidence. ...

LiveScience, a year ago! : The coronavirus didn't really start at that Wuhan 'wet market'I think there is another citation here somewhere with the CCDC also confirming the seafood market was not the location of the spillover.

"... know when to fold them and when to walk away..."
 
I know what you are saying Soba. I have not failed to understand your premise. I can't see any evidence whatsoever to keep that market on the origin table.

Did you miss this post where a year ago even the Chinese dismissed the seafood market?

Well, that’s the first time you have accepted anything from the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

Again, nobody disputes that the first known case did not originate there, and that is what is being said here:

The first case of SARS-CoV-2 didn't emerge from a Wuhan wet market, according to experts at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV).

But it’s somewhat hilarious that you think that the WIV is debunking the market theory and that it therefore implicates the WIV itself. Don’t you think that gives it a certain credence when they say anything else about the virus or do you only cherry pick what supports your presuppositions?

Also interesting is what else is in that article:
Carlson said his colleagues in China have been careful and precise in their work, publishing data according to international regulations that any scientist anywhere in the world can examine, and that strongly supports the conclusion that the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market wasn't the source of the virus.

One reason this idea has gained such traction is that it dovetails with conservation efforts. Many wet markets sell exotic, endangered and highly trafficked animals such as pangolins. And it would be a victory for animal conservation, he said, if markets like this one were shut down after being blamed for the disease. But that doesn't mean that the evidence is there. "This is an animal-origin virus that made the leap, maybe from bats to humans, maybe through… another animal, maybe through livestock. And we don't have the data yet to know where or how," he said. "That takes time. The study that really definitively showed the bats that SARS came from was published in 2017," roughly 15 years after the outbreak first occurred.

Indeed! That is what I have been telling you! Yet for some reason, you seem surprised that the origins of Covid have not been found, and yet it seems to be completely normal and unexceptional that hunting the source of a zoonotic virus (particularly one with asymptomatic spread) takes a lot of time. Yet you reach instinctively for the lab leak of the gaps argument.
 
You got nothing and you drifted off-topic to avoid addressing the fact you got nothing.

The seafood market origin has been debunked by both the CCDC and Shi's boss. Citations are posted in this thread. Full stop.

You want to talk about another issue, fine, but drifting into other subjects and saying, "see this supports that" when the discussion was about you not letting go of the seafood market doesn't cut it.

There are still people who refuse to look at the lab leak origin, there are people who are neutral and there are people who believe the lab leak has the most supporting evidence.

Here are the evidence supported facts:

Daszak misled a lot of people.

Knowledgeable people are now taking a closer look at the lab leak hypothesis.

China has been uncooperative and has hidden some data.
 
You got nothing and you drifted off-topic to avoid addressing the fact you got nothing.

The seafood market origin has been debunked by both the CCDC and Shi's boss. Citations are posted in this thread. Full stop.

You want to talk about another issue, fine, but drifting into other subjects and saying, "see this supports that" when the discussion was about you not letting go of the seafood market doesn't cut it.

There are still people who refuse to look at the lab leak origin, there are people who are neutral and there are people who believe the lab leak has the most supporting evidence.

Here are the evidence supported facts:

Daszak misled a lot of people.

Knowledgeable people are now taking a closer look at the lab leak hypothesis.

China has been uncooperative and has hidden some data.

Just keep them Gish Gallops coming!
 
Checking in to see if anyone agrees with anyone in here or if everyone's still at each other's throats...

*scarpers*
 
Politicians mislead readers about a review article by Yuan Zhiming

Jesus Christ, did I not say corroborating evidence was needed here?...
Read what I wrote and you quoted.
Back to politics, not science, Skeptic Ginger. That is a report from politicians with their own agenda and ignoring that places like laboratories have ongoing maintenance and renovation.
These politicians have no evidence that needs to be collaborated! They cite the expected maintenance and renovation on functioning equipment.
Read the content of the review article by Yuan Zhiming, Skeptic Ginger, that the rest of my post is about. The politicians obviously mislead readers about Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China with "Entitled, “Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China,” the article discusses at length the construction of the WNBL. Yuan identifies multiple key issues,..."
There is a single paragraph stating the BSL-4 laboratory was constructed.
On January 31st 2015, the first Chinese BSL-4 laboratory (National Biosafety Laboratory, Wuhan) constructed by the Chinese Academy of Sciences was physically completed.[7], [15] After several years of commissioning and validation by relevant local and international authorities, the facility was finally accredited by the Chinese National Accreditation Service for Conformity Assessment (CNAS) and fully certified by the National Health Commission for manipulating the Ebola, Nipah, and Crimean-Cong
The challenges are not as implied specifically with the WNBL.
However, we have encountered some challenges; there are insufficient laboratories in industry and in clinical units, an unbalanced distribution of regions and associations, a lack of proper national coordination and resource sharing management, as well as an uncertainty about the financial support for laboratory construction, operation, and maintenance.[9], [12], [16] These bottlenecks hamper the capacity of well-established laboratories to quickly respond to public health emergencies.
 
Last edited:
The report was from the head of the WIV over Shi...
Not quite right and irrelevant, Skeptic Ginger. The head of the WIV is Dr. Wang Yanyi (KEY PEOPLE section "Director General of the Wuhan Institute of Virology.").
Dr. Yuan Zhiming is the director of the WNBL BSL-4 lab. Dr. Shi Zheng-li is a senior scientist at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) and Deputy Director of the Wuhan National Biosafety Laboratory’s Biosafety-Level 4 lab.
Dr. Yuan Zhiming is the head of the WNBL BSL-4 lab over Dr. Shi Zheng-li.
 
Last edited:
You got nothing and you drifted off-topic to avoid addressing the fact you got nothing.

The seafood market origin has been debunked by both the CCDC and Shi's boss. Citations are posted in this thread. Full stop.

You want to talk about another issue, fine, but drifting into other subjects and saying, "see this supports that" when the discussion was about you not letting go of the seafood market doesn't cut it.

There are still people who refuse to look at the lab leak origin, there are people who are neutral and there are people who believe the lab leak has the most supporting evidence.

Here are the evidence supported facts:

Daszak misled a lot of people.

Knowledgeable people are now taking a closer look at the lab leak hypothesis.

China has been uncooperative and has hidden some data.

Funny thing is China didn't do a very good cover up now did they ?
 
What is your evidence that the majority of scientist support a lab leak.

JAs for the assertion the spillover is generally supported by scientists, that is no longer true and in fact it has come out that Daszak did his best to slant the consensus.
A "no longer true/Daszak " fantasy, Skeptic Ginger, until you provide evidence that the majority of scientist support a lab leak.
Read COVID-19 lab leak theory
Scientists have largely remained skeptical of a lab leak origin, describing it as a remote possibility and citing a lack of supporting evidence. Most scientists agree that a natural origin is far more likely.[15] Some scientists, despite being concerned about the risks of politicization,[16][17] agree that the possibility of a lab leak should be examined as part of the ongoing investigations into the origin of COVID-19.[18][19]
Reference [15} is a list of recent news articles about the majority opinion of scientists. For example The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know in Nature, 8 June 2021.

Give your evidence that Peter Daszak "did his best to slant the consensus", Skeptic Ginger.
Multiple public health experts including Daszak signed an open letter to the Lancelet in February 2020: Statement in support of the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of China combatting COVID-19. The letter condemned conspiracy theories about non-0natural origins which was rightfully criticized. Daszak neglected to add his indirect connection with WIV (funding from the EcoHealth Alliance group which had a relationship with WIV) which was fixed in Addendum: competing interests and the origins of SARS-CoV-2
 
Last edited:
Summing things up here because all of this stuff has been covered ad nauseum in this thread not to mention some people here are just having a cow over my posts instead of a debate of the issues. Read the thread before asking people to post the evidence again and again.

Why are you guys so bent on attacking me here? Never mind, I can guess. Seriously, please address the issues and look at what has already been posted on them before wasting everyone's time on these long posts.

Yes RC, I read what you wrote. Yes RC, I understand what you wrote. There are a lot of sources of information that have political influence including the GOP report. You don't toss the whole damn thing out, you look to see what in that report can be corroborated and what can't.

Daszak's dishonesty has been corroborated and then some. No one needs to prove that to anyone who is keeping up on the evidence and on the thread. Good grief just Google Daszak and COVID dishonesty to get a rundown.

And this is a straw man: "What is your evidence that the majority of scientist support a lab leak." Most scientists involved now agree the lab leak origin is still on the table. That's quite different from you thinking I posted that they support the lab leak origin.

CC, China is still doing their best not to release a lot of information they have been asked for. That is well covered in this thread. That more and more is leaking out should not be a surprise to anyone. And we'll see what comes of the vast amount of genetic data that was just reported on by the news media. It hasn't been clear yet who got that data and from where did they get it. The investigation Biden has asked for is I believe where the information was obtained but I don't recall it was clear.


RC, I posted information from the person described as Shi's boss. Again, please address the link I posted and not some meaningless (without the link) drivel about who is whose boss.

Where you did post about the link I really fail to see how those paragraphs rebut what I posted. The labs had safety issues. There are multiple labs at the WIV and the nearby CCDC. It was not a perfect place to be studying a potentially pandemic virus yet they were. Maybe you could explain exactly what it is you are citing those paragraphs for because it isn't clear to me.

So to sum up: the lab leak origin has been back on the table for months despite Daszak's trying to steer the media and other scientists away from it.

Daszak has a serious conflict of interest which I believe angrysoba conceded.

China has not provided data the WHO asked them to provide.

No animal source has yet been found.

Multiple researchers looking at the data agree the seafood wet market was a super-spreader event not the location of the initial jump to humans.

There is no evidence of any other wet market involved in those earliest cases.

It's not clear if Oct 2019 was the beginning as there is some inconclusive evidence that Sept might have been.

There were cases in Italy, France and the US which date back to at least Dec 2019 if not earlier. This evidence goes further than just antibodies in stored blood. At least one of those early cases in Italy (or France?) had a specimen preserved from which a positive PCR test result was obtained.

In addition to the military games in Wuhan in Oct there were a couple other big events involving people from other countries who then went home to where COVID spread. They were in Oct and I believe Sept 2019.


There's more but that should be enough for now.


Please one of you having a cow over my posts list all the evidence you think supports the natural spillover origin.

It's more common.

It's possible.

Daszak said the lab origin hypothesis was a CT.


WTF else you got?
 
Last edited:
Daszak's dishonesty has been corroborated and then some. No one needs to prove that to anyone who is keeping up on the evidence and on the thread. Good grief just Google Daszak and COVID dishonesty to get a rundown.

...

So to sum up: the lab leak origin has been back on the table for months despite Daszak's trying to steer the media and other scientists away from it.

Daszak has a serious conflict of interest which I believe angrysoba conceded.

I have not "conceded" that Daszak has a conflict of interest.

I have acknowledged what has long been known, which is that Daszak's colleagues work at the Wuhan Institute of Virology and much of what is known about SARS (as well as many other viruses such as Hendra and Nipah) have involved his company, EcoHealth Alliance and scientists who have worked for them.

The "conflict of interest" is simply that his work and that of the WIV has a big overlap.

As for the idea of "just Google Daszak and COVID dishonesty" that's a pretty loaded way of investigoogling isn't it.

I could just as well tell people to "9/11 inside job" to prove 9/11 was an inside job.

It is not for us to go looking for eividence of Peter Daszak's dishonesty, it is for you to demonstrate your claims.

That said, when I asked you to quote exactly what he had said that "incriminated" him in the This Week in Virology podcast, you consistently evaded doing so.

If you don't like to feel attacked, then support your claims with evidence.
 
CC, China is still doing their best not to release a lot of information they have been asked for. That is well covered in this thread. That more and more is leaking out should not be a surprise to anyone. And we'll see what comes of the vast amount of genetic data that was just reported on by the news media. It hasn't been clear yet who got that data and from where did they get it. The investigation Biden has asked for is I believe where the information was obtained but I don't recall it was clear.

I have a hunch that the report in CNN could be a bluff to make China more willing to open up adn give them an incentive to try to get ahead of the story, but of course, this is pure speculation on my part.
 
A "Daszak has a serious conflict of interest" lie.

Repeating unsupported assertions does not make them true, Skeptic Ginger. Read what you wrote: As for the assertion the spillover is generally supported by scientists, that is no longer true ...
Thus What is your evidence that the majority of scientists support a lab leak, Skeptic Ginger?
The evidence that I cited is that the majority of scientists support a zoonotic origin with a lab leak being a remote possibility. A "spillover" is still generally supported by scientists. A remotely possible lab leak was always an alternative.

Give your evidence that Peter Daszak "did his best to slant the consensus", Skeptic Ginger?
Insulting Daszak as dishonest is not that evidence which might be as simple as a link to where in this thread that evidence is presented.

Even the head of the WHO has questioned the conclusions of the WHO investigation is also wrong.
WHO calls for further studies, data on origin of SARS-CoV-2 virus, reiterates that all hypotheses remain open. WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus agreed with the report conclusions, including the need for further studies. This is obvious. If we have not found the zoonotic source of a virus, more study is needed. If we have a very unlikely lab leak, more study is needed.

You wrote a "The report was from the head of the WIV over Shi" error (The head of the WIV is Dr. Wang Yanyi ) error.

A "Daszak has a serious conflict of interest" lie there is no serious conflict of interest (and some may have the opinion there is no conflict of interest at all) in Addendum: competing interests and the origins of SARS-CoV-2.
In February, 2020, 27 public health experts co-authored a Correspondence in The Lancet (“Statement in support of the scientists, public health professionals, and medical professionals of China combatting COVID-19”),1 supporting health professionals and physicians in China during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. In this letter, the authors declared no competing interests. Some readers have questioned the validity of this disclosure, particularly as it relates to one of the authors, Peter Daszak. In line with guidance from the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, medical journals ask authors to report financial and non-financial relationships that may be relevant to interpreting the content of their manuscript.2 There may be differences in opinion as to what constitutes a competing interest. Transparent reporting allows readers to make judgments about these interests. Readers, in turn, have their own interests that could influence their evaluation of the work in question. With these facts in mind, The Lancet invited the 27 authors of the letter to re-evaluate their competing interests. Peter Daszak has expanded on his disclosure statements for three pieces relating to COVID-19 that he co-authored or contributed to in The Lancet—the February, 2020, Correspondence,1 as well as a Commission Statement3 and a Comment4 for the Lancet COVID-19 Commission. The updated disclosure statement from Peter Daszak is:
...
Acknowledgments
We declare no competing interests.
There was a salary from EcoHealth Alliance which is funded by the US NIH and USAID. Daszak never received Chinese money. Daszak was an independent expert in a private capacity in the WHO investigation.
 
Last edited:
I have not "conceded" that Daszak has a conflict of interest.
I thought you wrote it in GIANT letters?

The "conflict of interest" is simply that his work and that of the WIV has a big overlap.
Yeah...no. His company had millions of dollars in grant money that would dry up in a flash if it turns out the WIV was the origin.

As for the idea of "just Google Daszak and COVID dishonesty" that's a pretty loaded way of investigoogling isn't it.

I could just as well tell people to "9/11 inside job" to prove 9/11 was an inside job.
I assume people in this thread could discriminate better than that.

It is not for us to go looking for eividence of Peter Daszak's dishonesty, it is for you to demonstrate your claims.
Of course. But evidence has been posted ad nauseum here. If you still think I haven't what would me posting more do? Stop with this ******** telling me to support something I have supported MULTIPLE TIMES!!!!!!!!!!

Enough is enough. Seriously.


That said, when I asked you to quote exactly what he had said that "incriminated" him in the This Week in Virology podcast, you consistently evaded doing so.

If you don't like to feel attacked, then support your claims with evidence.
And there you ******* go again with that same crap. Oh for pity's sake.

Daszak referenced how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab. What do you suppose he meant by that?


As for not attacking me, this thread is in the science forum. And as much as I know some of you are just chomping at the bit to drag it back into the CT forum it's about the evidence and the science and not about Ginger and all those attempts to discredit me when you should be discrediting the cited evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom