Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
We have Shi's paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records and that is absurd given they had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for a decade.
Argument from incredulity or ignorance is not evidence.
There would be an an appropriate amount of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records because that is what they were researching and publishing papers on :eye-poppi.
A "paucity" Shi found was that the WIV labs did not have any SARS-CoV-2 virus genome.
 
You can't comprehend the reference? Really? :rolleyes:

This is another of your avoidance tactics like fussing about one link when I've just posted 7 different links.

I want a quote from you!

Don’t just post a bunch of links and tell me to read them to back up your claims. That is YOUR job.

Here, I will make a prediction. I cannot read the paywalled article but I can promise you that the author will not have accused Peter Daszak of money laundering unless it had already been determined by a court of law. That is libelous and UK courts are notoriously easy to convict people of libel.

By the way, do you even know what money laundering is or did you just think it sounded good?
 
Yeah can’t read that Times article. Behind a Paywall. Do you have a non-paywalled link? I presume you must have read it somewhere. A Matt Ridley article perhaps? As for the other one…. Washington Examiner?

You might not be making things up but you seem to pass on a lot of stuff that is made up.
Aaaand here it is again, ignore any and every bit of evidence in a citation by attacking the source. All the while not posting a single bit of rebuttal evidence.


Not my problem, take it or leave it. Those posts were in response to Capsid, not to you. And they were not there to introduce new material. It is material already discussed ad nauseum here.
 
Yeah, Daszak himself has said that the specific bats for coronavirus research are caught, swabbed and released on the spot.
:rolleyes:

Of course he said that. He has a motive to lie about it.

The evidence live bats and live cultures were maintained at the WIV has been provided up thread from at least 2 different sources, neither of which was Daszak. And no, I am not going to spoon feed it to you again. You have proven you forget the evidence within a day or so anyway.
 
Sources for speculations about cases in September 201S

It's not hard to see with a genetic timeline how the first cases do go a couple patients back to early Sept.
It is even easier to see that this is made up.
The actual genetic timeline gives an average of 11 December 2019 as the earliest common ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. See WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part page 80. The earliest known case is in early December.

13 August 2021: Searching this 50 page thread for Sept 2019 does not give any sources for speculations about cases in September 2019. Please link to them.
 
It would be pointless to lie about that stuff anyway. The only reason why the lab leakers claim that there are bats is because then they could say “See! Daszak told a lie! If he lied about that, what else is he lying about amirite?”

Is the idea that there are bats there so that there is a ready supply of off-the-books coronaviruses? That they can do gain of function research on them using “humanized mice” from Baric’s lab?

But why? Honestly, the idea is that they are mad scientists running a global money laundering operation. How is that not Bond Villain-esque?

I don't see one bit of evidence in that post.
 
Cite your sources that give evidence of alive bats at the WIV.

The evidence live bats and live cultures were maintained at the WIV has been provided up thread from at least 2 different sources, neither of which was Daszak.
Just calling Daszak a liar with no evidence does not make make your position credible.
1 September 2021: Cite your sources that give evidence of live bats at the WIV.
How about the foreign scientists who visited the WIV labs? What about the published papers stating the source of the samples? Chinese scientists in China and elsewhere stating they saw bats there? Statements from the workers keeping the bats? Records of the building of cages and supply of insects to feed the bats?

Australian journalist Sherri Markson's coverup paranoia and some lying about a video on Jun 13, 2021? The Chinese Academy of Sciences produced a video for the launch of the Wuhan level 4 laboratory back in May 2017. An obvious lie of
no biosafety experience when the video has back in 2004, they had no experience in setting up a BSL-4 lab. Shi Zhengli talks about the need for a BSL-4 lab. Sherri is incredulous about 15,000 bat samples collected in a decade (wait - where are the live bat numbers!). Sherri basically lies about the sequencing database going down when any journalist would know that the sequences are available elsewhere (so the WHO team did not need that database). Sherri relies on the DRASTIC clowns. A video has bats in a cage with no door, a "researcher" feeding a worm to a bat, researchers at a bat cave with no captured bats!, irrelevant mouse cages, the "humanized" mice thing. Sherri stupidity about gain of function research that was well known for years. Sherri lies that there were live bats at the Wuhan labs when all she has is a video about bats somewhere (probably China). Sherri lies that "not manmade or generically modified" is false when the scientific consensus for over a year is that no one made the virus (leaving a natural origin via animals or a lab leak). Idiocy about the funding of research in China (the bats, etc. are there - duh!). Back to the CAS video and a clip showing the biosafety features of the lab. Once again - no live bats! Sherri "admission" stupidity when lab accidents happen and labs plan for them. A "common" lie. Back to the CAS video stating what did happen - sharing of the latest discoveries with the world. Sherri's "coverup" and "lab creation" paranoia. Plugs her book!
 
Last edited:
Argument from incredulity or ignorance is not evidence.
There would be an an appropriate amount of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records because that is what they were researching and publishing papers on :eye-poppi.
A "paucity" Shi found was that the WIV labs did not have any SARS-CoV-2 virus genome.
No, not from incredulity though it doesn't surprise me you too have forgotten any and all sources of evidence about the data bases Shi and China have made unavailable.

I posted a citation on this at 1:30 PDT just today. Why look, what a surprise. See if you can find the cite and the rest of what I quoted:
No information about this research has been released to the public since the start of the pandemic, including data on the eight chimeric viruses the WIV had been infecting the mice with. In fact, all of the institute's databases have been offline since the start of the pandemic for alleged "cybersecurity issues," including 100 unpublished sequences of bat betacoronaviruses, which need to be sequenced by international scientists, according to Bostickson.

Your oversimplified attempt to dismiss my posts once again comes up against the evidence I have posted.
 
I want a quote from you!

Don’t just post a bunch of links and tell me to read them to back up your claims. That is YOUR job.

Here, I will make a prediction. I cannot read the paywalled article but I can promise you that the author will not have accused Peter Daszak of money laundering unless it had already been determined by a court of law. That is libelous and UK courts are notoriously easy to convict people of libel.

By the way, do you even know what money laundering is or did you just think it sounded good?
You may dismiss the money laundering reference if it was too abstract for you.

It doesn't change my arguments.
 
Alright boys, I'm going to go watch some comedy on Youtube. I might be back to this thread tonight but I probably won't be.
 
You may dismiss the money laundering reference if it was too abstract for you.

It doesn't change my arguments.

I haven't seen an argument. I have seen assertions of money laundering.

Definition: "the concealment of the origins of illegally obtained money, typically by means of transfers involving foreign banks or legitimate businesses."

Give me a quote for that! Don't just say that you have made the argument and that if people don't get it that is their problem.

Money laundering is the process of changing large amounts of money obtained from crimes, such as drug trafficking, into origination from a legitimate source. It is a crime in many jurisdictions with varying definitions. It is a key operation of the underground economy.

In US law it is the practice of engaging in financial transactions to conceal the identity, source, or destination of illegally gained money. In UK law the common law definition is wider. The act is defined as taking any action with property of any form which is either wholly or in part the proceeds of a crime that will disguise the fact that that property is the proceeds of a crime or obscure the beneficial ownership of said property.

Link

How has he been money laundering?

Do you actually mean embezzlement?

Embezzlement is the act of withholding assets for the purpose of conversion of such assets, by one or more persons to whom the assets were entrusted, either to be held or to be used for specific purposes.

Link

Are you saying Daszak has been embezzling funds?
 
Aaaand here it is again, ignore any and every bit of evidence in a citation by attacking the source. All the while not posting a single bit of rebuttal evidence.

Did you miss the part where I told you that the Times article was behind a paywall?

How am I to read it?

Have you read it yourself, or did you just Google "Bad Peter Daszak" grabbed the link and posted it here?

Because that would certainly explain why most of your posts are from "LunaticRightWingConspiracies.com"

As with most of what you link to, I cannot work out whether it is more damning that you didn't even read the links, or that you did and still posted them. :D
 
No, this is BS. It has been answered....
A BS post when I have seen no answer to my question. If there was all she needs to so is link to it. If there was there would be a post replying to my question.
28 August 2021: Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence".
That is what you wrote in response to my post about the WHO study. The quotes are from your post. Actually answer the question instead of linking to an irrelevant news report.
Skeptic Ginger, give the pages of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.

ETA: Alternatively. Skeptic Ginger, give the posts of the "whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence" in the WHO study.
Note that your "this was so" is that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme.

The 14 February BBC news report is microbiologist Dominic Dwyer complaining about actual evidence (patient data) being a summary, not raw data. "The investigators had asked for raw data on the 174 identified cases of Covid-19 from Wuhan in December 2019, Professor Dwyer told Reuters.". There would be an issue of patient confidentiality. On the other hand, this is a pandemic.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger ignores why her "paucity" argument is from incredibility or ignorance.

No, not from incredulity...
1 September 2021: Skeptic Ginger ignores why her "paucity" argument is from incredibility or ignorance.
She wrote: We have Shi's paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records and that is absurd given they had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for a decade.
The WIV scaintitis have been publishing papers on coronavirus for decades. There is no "paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records". They had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for decades.
Hacking made the WIV take their web site down and so their database became unavailable from the web site. This happened on 12th Sep 2019 before the first known case of COVID-19.Nothing happened to the actual coronavirus genome database. Presumably it is still available in-house. Anyone can access the sequences because they were published elsewhere.
Exclusive: Intel agencies scour reams of genetic data from Wuhan lab in Covid origins hunt August 6, 2021
 
keptic Ginger cites an article relying on the DRASTIC clowns

1 September 2021: Skeptic Ginger cites an article relying on the DRASTIC clowns.
Shi Zhengl, Hu Ben and other WIV scientists conducted gain of function research with Ralph S. Baric of the University of North Carolina starting in 2017.
The anonymous Billy Bostickson thinks that the COVID-19 pandemic resulted from this work. Also the Taiwan Times may be slightly biased against mainland China :rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
Ignoring the opinions, accusations, insinuations and side tracks being bantered about in this thread it appears that, as of Sept 1 2021, there is precious little hard evidence pointing to an actual day one, single location origin of COVI-19. At this time, with 6+ million dead and the disease endemic in the world population I really don't see that the determination matters much any more, outside of academic scientific curiosity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom