Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd concur with that. Seems the sequences of the 2 lineages can not have occurred by transition and rather could be a sequencing error.
As in no one has confirmed the sequencing? :confused:

Several virologists have said lineage A precedes lineage B and given their reasons. At least one who did also allowed for questioning that conclusion.

As for multiple jumps, most dying out, the problem becomes where are these animals which the virus possibly jumped from?

It would have to be circulating somewhere if this were the case and evidence for such circulating hasn't been found in almost 2 years.

It could not have jumped multiple times eventually acquiring the ability to spread person to person without circulating in a species.

With SARS that was found within 4 months and multiple documented spillovers occurred in more than one wet market. Then the virus circulated in people in Guangdong for a couple months before it began to spread from there. More than likely the person to person spread improved during that time.

With influenza, cases are monitored very closely through sampling and analyzing their genomes. We have had a number of 'almost' pandemics that were identified. Typically the source animals are quickly found. Multiple spillovers have been documented and again are closely monitored.

Even with a small proportion of serious cases COVID would still have showed up; unless as I noted in another recent post, the virus acquired both the ability to spread and gained lethality at the same time. Not only that, but both A and B lineages would have had had to acquire the same variant mutations.

It makes no sense.

The article says:
can more parsimoniously be explained by sequencing error.
OK, that means there weren't 2 lineages. And that doesn't support multiple spillover events.

In other words, we looked at whether putative A/B intermediates shared with “pure” A or “pure” B virus genomes one or more mutations outside of those that define the two pure lineages. If so, then either those mutations arose independently in both the putative intermediate and its pure counterpart, or (more likely) the putative intermediate is not an intermediate at all, and is actually a pure A or B lineage very closely related to its pure-lineage counterpart.
So where is the evidence of 2 patient zeros that just happened to show up in Wuhan at nearly the same time?

Continuing the authors note this deus ex machina suggestion:
These findings cast substantial doubt on the veracity of C/C or T/T intermediate genomes in early 2020. We suggest that these early C/C and T/T genomes are erroneous and should be excluded from phylogenetic analyses.
The lineages don't fit, throw them out,

Yes, when one has outliers it is common to ignore them. Is that what these samples actually show, that one or more of them is an outlier?

As for being evidence of multiple jumps:
Capsid said:
Worobey seems to think so, "If a human-transmissible SARS-CoV-2 progenitor was circulating among such animals, the SARS1 story teaches us that it would be likely to jump multiple times into humans."
That is correct, but once again, with SARS that animal species was quickly found. If it were only circulating in a couple of animals then how did 2 lineages evolve? It would take a bit of circulating just as the author claims didn't happen after the jump to humans.
 
I can't say it enough apparently, BOTH options are on the table, neither has been supported with conclusive evidence.

The evidence does not support a natural event. Feel free to list the evidence you think does and/or to post why any particular piece of evidence for a lab leak is questioned.

That does not mean simply saying the evidence isn't direct proof. I've never said it did.

Don't know why you are trying to make this so complicated. What you have posted as evidence is simply not evidence. I agree that there is no evidence (that I have seen) to support a natural event, and I have none to provide. There is no evidence worthy of the word posted here to support any option. Not for a natural event, and not for a lab leak. Claiming that someone, somewhere, is hiding something does not rise to the level of evidence.

I have never used the word "proof" because with the lack of real evidence proof is out of the question. Please don't imply that I have.
 
Don't know why you are trying to make this so complicated. What you have posted as evidence is simply not evidence. I agree that there is no evidence (that I have seen) to support a natural event, and I have none to provide. There is no evidence worthy of the word posted here to support any option. Not for a natural event, and not for a lab leak. Claiming that someone, somewhere, is hiding something does not rise to the level of evidence.

I have never used the word "proof" because with the lack of real evidence proof is out of the question. Please don't imply that I have.

It's not complicated. Circumstantial evidence is evidence in any court of law. People are convicted on that evidence all the time.

So why in this thread is a wealth of circumstantial evidence defined as not evidence?


There are multiple sources corroborating the fact China is hiding evidence. It's not just me saying so.

It's a fact lab accidents in China have resulted in 4 cases of SARS1 and now 1 case of SARS2. All of those cases are openly recognized. (And these kinds of accidents are not confined to China.)

How is that not relevant evidence?

The cases are well documented in both a masters and a PhD thesis written close to the time the 6 miners in Yunnan fell ill. While they may have had secondary fungal infections, it was never considered the diagnosis at the time and one of them recovered without any anti-fungal medication. Now we have a statement from Shi they died of a fungal infection. Those 2 sets of facts don't mesh. (There is more evidence I've not bothered to repeat here.)

Now you can choose to ignore the 2 theses and believe Shi might not have been lying, but evidence supports the 2012 diagnosis and not Shi's claim it was a fungal disease.

How is that not evidence?

The list is much longer than that. The bottom line here is, stop claiming circumstantial evidence isn't evidence
You can counter it, please do. You can say you are not convinced, since we all seem to agree both options are on the table, please do. You can address each bit separately.

In this case there are different positions among different virologists.

But the application of your definition of "evidence" here as either all (directly incriminating) or none (everything short of proof) is ludicrous. And it's not just you, BTW.

And that's without even addressing the double standard of concluding a natural event is more likely when there really is a paucity of evidence, circumstantial or not, supporting that conclusion.

From what I see:
Natural event: no evidence
Lab origin: lots of circumstantial evidence​


There are a number of citations supporting different hypotheses as to how patient zero or patients zero could have occurred. There are a number of genetic walking the clock back from the genomes and some other miscellaneous theoretical models. I am not counting theoretical models in this particular post's discussion. I have posted some of those, other people have posted some. It's not such a stretch to say said models are not evidence. I can agree to that. Some models have more supporting substance than others. But if people want to say models are not evidence, I won't argue. I do think said people might want to consider their double standard applying these models, but that's a separate issue.

The fact lab accidents have happened is evidence. It's not a theoretical model. Pictures of students and WIV staff with bat bites is not a model, it is circumstantial evidence.
 
This is no court. This is (wannabe) scientific community. There is either irrefutable proof, or nothing. We can talk evidence, but as long as it's not proof, it's only good for further research.
 
I can't say it enough apparently, BOTH options are on the table, neither has been supported with conclusive evidence.
We also cannot say it enough apparently:
We know that both options are on the table
We know that neither option has been supported with conclusive evidence.
We also know that the evidence makes a leak from a lab incident much less likely than an animal origin which you omit in this post and others.

The evidence does support a natural event (zoonotic origin). You have been cited the WHO study many times. Here it is yet again: WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
There is also Wikipedia! Investigations into the origin of COVID-19
In January 2021, the World Health Assembly (decision-making body of the WHO) commissioned a study on the origins of the virus, to be conducted jointly between WHO experts and Chinese scientists. In March 2021, the findings of this study were published online in a report to the WHO Commissioner-General.[1][20][21] Echoing the assessment of most virologists,[22][23][24] the report determined that the virus most likely had a zoonotic origin in bats, possibly transmitted through an intermediate host. It also stated that a laboratory origin for the virus was "extremely unlikely."[8][25] Scientists found the conclusions of the WHO report to be helpful but noted that more work was needed.[26] In the US, the EU and other countries, some criticised the lack of transparency and data access in the report's formulation.[27][28] The WHO issued its 30 March report alongside a statement of the WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus saying that the matter "requires further investigation".[29][30][31] The U.S. government and 13 other countries and the European Union issued statements on the same day, echoing Tedros's critique of the report for lacking transparency and data access in its formulation.[32][33] In a later press conference, the WHO director-general said it was "premature" for the WHO's report to rule out a potential link between a laboratory leak and called on China to provide 'raw data' and lab audits in a second phase of investigations.[27][34]
The main evidence for a lab leak origin is just that there have been lab incidents around the world including China in the last 50 years.
 
Skeptic Ginger relies on probably fake news again yet?

It's a fact lab accidents in China have resulted in 4 cases of SARS1 and now 1 case of SARS2. All of those cases are openly recognized. ..
Wrong. Probably fake news is still not evidence of a lab accident case of SARS2. A rumor started by a web site, parroted by a couple of news agencies, and totally ignored by every major news agency in the world is not "openly recognized".
There have been four laboratory accidents in Singapore, Taiwan and China. The Chinese accident was 2 researchers who infected 6 others.
Severe acute respiratory syndrome
Laboratory accidents
After containment, there were four laboratory accidents that resulted in infections.
  • One doctoral student at Singapore General Hospital in Singapore in August 2003[73]
  • A 44-year-old senior scientist at the National Defense University in Taipei in December 2003. He was confirmed to have the SARS virus after working on a SARS study in Taiwan's only BSL-4 lab. The Taiwan CDC later stated the infection occurred due to laboratory misconduct.[74][75]
  • Two researchers at the Chinese Institute of Virology in Beijing, China around April 2004, who spread it to around six other people. The two researchers contracted it 2 weeks apart.[76]
  • Study of live SARS specimens requires a biosafety level 3 (BSL-3) facility; some studies of inactivated SARS specimens can be done at biosafety level 2 facilities.[77]
The 2004 accident in Beijing, China is an argument against a 2019 lab incident in Wuhan, China. When there are accident, safety is reviewed and usually improved. Chinese scientists would not have ignored the 2004 accident. 15 years is also time for the installation of improved safety equipment.

18 August 2021: If credible news sources have ignored a news article for almost 2 weeks (since 5 August), it is probably fake news.
24 August 2021: Skeptic Ginger cites probably fake news again.
6 September 2021: Skeptic Ginger relies on probably fake news again?
 
Last edited:
The fact lab accidents have happened is evidence. It's not a theoretical model. Pictures of students and WIV staff with bat bites is not a model, it is circumstantial evidence.
There is a single video first broadcast on state TV in China on Dec. 29, 2017.
Video shows Wuhan lab scientists admit to being bitten by bats (Taiwan News)
There is 1 person (Cui Jie) definitely bitten and an unidentified person’s limb badly swollen from an apparent bat bite. Team members got a rabies vaccine before each field sampling.
Missing is identification of the bats as ones that carry coronavirus such as horseshoe bats. Even so the lack of PPE use in 2017 is disturbing.
 
I can't say it enough apparently, BOTH options are on the table, neither has been supported with conclusive evidence.

This is mushy thinking. "You can't disprove it!" does not make the two equivalent.

eg You can't disprove the notion that god made the universe 6000 years all with the appearance of age, fossils already in the ground, and light already on it's way to the earth, etc. Just because "it can't be conclusively excluded" DOES NOT MAKE it an equivalent hypothesis.

The priors are overwhelmingly skewed towards zoonotic crossover. You need a lot of positive evidence to argue anything else, that's just how science works. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

post why any particular piece of evidence for a lab leak is questioned.

First you need to tell us what the evidence is.
 
So why in this thread is a wealth of circumstantial evidence defined as not evidence?

Most of what you've posted isn't even circumstantial evidence. Things that are likely to show up regardless of origin are NOT evidence.

Eg, China was never going to allow investigators from a foreign rival free reign to go through their national BSL-4 lab. It was not going to happen, period. full stop. It doesn't matter where the virus came from it wasn't and isn't going to happen. The fact that they don't, therefor, is not evidence for anything.

Likewise the fact that Chinese researchers worked with Corona viruses was always going to be the case. The danger of zoonotic crossover is why the lab was built in the first place it was always going to be used this way so the fact Corona-viruses were studied there is not evidence.


What we know from past experience is that pandemics caused by lab leaks are rare or non-existent but there is invariably some group that claims a lab leak. This means our starting point is that it was probably zoonotic and claims of a lab leak are probably woo. Additionally, all the meaningful fingerprints are consistent with a zoonotic event and inconsistent with a lab leak.

If the outbreak was zoonotic we'd expect it to be centers near a wildlife market. If it was a lab leak we'd expect it to be centered near the lab. The epicenter was near a wildlife market and nowhere near a lab.

If the outbreak were a lab leak we'd expect a significant number of early cases with connections to the lab. If the outbreak were zoonotic we'd expect a significant number of cases with a connection to a wildlife market. There are no early cases connected to the lab and many early cases connected to wildlife markets.

If the outbreak was a lab leak we'd expect the virus to be previously catalogued and documented. If it was zoonotic we would not expect this. The virus was not catalogued or previously documented.

If the outbreak was caused by a lab leak we'd expect non-natural markers in the virus. If it was zoonotic we'd expect to see similar traits evolving in wild relatives. We find similar traits in wild relatives and no markers for human intervention with the virus.

If the outbreak was caused by a lab leak we'd expect it to be optometrist for humans. If it were zoonotic we'd expect similar levels of optimization across multiple species. We see similar or even greater levels of optimization for other species.
 
It's not complicated. Circumstantial evidence is evidence in any court of law. People are convicted on that evidence all the time.

So why in this thread is a wealth of circumstantial evidence defined as not evidence?


There are multiple sources corroborating the fact China is hiding evidence. It's not just me saying so.

It's a fact lab accidents in China have resulted in 4 cases of SARS1 and now 1 case of SARS2. All of those cases are openly recognized. (And these kinds of accidents are not confined to China.)

How is that not relevant evidence?

The cases are well documented in both a masters and a PhD thesis written close to the time the 6 miners in Yunnan fell ill. While they may have had secondary fungal infections, it was never considered the diagnosis at the time and one of them recovered without any anti-fungal medication. Now we have a statement from Shi they died of a fungal infection. Those 2 sets of facts don't mesh. (There is more evidence I've not bothered to repeat here.)

Now you can choose to ignore the 2 theses and believe Shi might not have been lying, but evidence supports the 2012 diagnosis and not Shi's claim it was a fungal disease.

How is that not evidence?

The list is much longer than that. The bottom line here is, stop claiming circumstantial evidence isn't evidence
You can counter it, please do. You can say you are not convinced, since we all seem to agree both options are on the table, please do. You can address each bit separately.

In this case there are different positions among different virologists.

But the application of your definition of "evidence" here as either all (directly incriminating) or none (everything short of proof) is ludicrous. And it's not just you, BTW.

And that's without even addressing the double standard of concluding a natural event is more likely when there really is a paucity of evidence, circumstantial or not, supporting that conclusion.

From what I see:
Natural event: no evidence
Lab origin: lots of circumstantial evidence​


There are a number of citations supporting different hypotheses as to how patient zero or patients zero could have occurred. There are a number of genetic walking the clock back from the genomes and some other miscellaneous theoretical models. I am not counting theoretical models in this particular post's discussion. I have posted some of those, other people have posted some. It's not such a stretch to say said models are not evidence. I can agree to that. Some models have more supporting substance than others. But if people want to say models are not evidence, I won't argue. I do think said people might want to consider their double standard applying these models, but that's a separate issue.

The fact lab accidents have happened is evidence. It's not a theoretical model. Pictures of students and WIV staff with bat bites is not a model, it is circumstantial evidence.

Re your question above "So why in this thread is a wealth of circumstantial evidence defined as not evidence?": Because evidence of lab incidents unrelated to the origin of COVID 19 has no relevance to the actual origin of COVID 19.

The possibilities for the origin of the COVID 19 virus, and subsequent introduction into the human population - two separate issues - appear to be:
- created by humans in a lab before it was accidentally released
- created by humans in a lab before it was purposely released
- occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was accidentally released. Note that this implies that the "wild" virus only entered the human population via a lab release.
- occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was intentionally released. Note that this implies that the "wild" virus only entered the human population via a lab release.
- occurred "the wild" by natural mutation and passed on to the human population without ever being in a lab

In your opinion which of these scenarios is supported by your "evidence"?
 
This is no court. This is (wannabe) scientific community. There is either irrefutable proof, or nothing. We can talk evidence, but as long as it's not proof, it's only good for further research.

Can't see a way that you could be more wrong.

ETA: As far as I can see the only posters here who raised the idea of "proof" are Skeptic Ginger and yourself, as a disparagement of others who question the proposed "evidence".
 
Last edited:
Re your question above "So why in this thread is a wealth of circumstantial evidence defined as not evidence?": Because evidence of lab incidents unrelated to the origin of COVID 19 has no relevance to the actual origin of COVID 19.
Come on, that's just stupid. Past accidents in Chinese labs that infected workers is more specific evidence than saying past spillover events have led to pandemics.



The possibilities for the origin of the COVID 19 virus, and subsequent introduction into the human population - two separate issues - appear to be:
- created by humans in a lab before it was accidentally released
- created by humans in a lab before it was purposely released
- occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was accidentally released. Note that this implies that the "wild" virus only entered the human population via a lab release.
- occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was intentionally released. Note that this implies that the "wild" virus only entered the human population via a lab release.
- occurred "the wild" by natural mutation and passed on to the human population without ever being in a lab.

In your opinion which of these scenarios is supported by your "evidence"?
If you define "created" as some version of gain of function research with PPPs then:
created by humans in a lab before it was accidentally released​

This one is possible and supported by the evidence of the bat bites and multiple trips to the Yunnan cave:
occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was accidentally released.​
But you have to include transported to Wuhan via a student or worker at the WIV. If they were on WIV business and were infected as a direct result of that then it need not have entered the lab.

But we are stuck with the same problem and that is a virus ready-to-go infecting patient zero in Wuhan.


With the second one there have been rare or occasional spillover events in Yunnan with bat coronaviruses. There were the 6 miners infected with an unknown virus in 2012 and when area residents were tested a small percentage of them had relevant coronavirus antibodies.

If you are getting at there have been multiple spillover events that didn't take hold, I agree completely. I have no problem with such a scenario being considered. It is what we normally see in a zoonosis. And documenting such occurrences is circumstantial evidence.

But taking that another step forward, to claim that then resulted in a ready-to-go coronavirus exposure in Wuhan, that is where the evidence doesn't support the hypothesis.



I'm not big on the last one but it has not been ruled out:
- occurred "the wild" by natural mutation and passed on to the human population without ever being in a lab​
 
And speaking of gain of function research, we already know about Baric's work. COVID does not show evidence of an engineered virus such as the one Shi and Baric were working on. And I thought Daszak forwarded NIH money to the WIV without the NIH approving of it. Turns out the NIH may very well have approved of the grant. That is very disappointing if it meant the US blocked funding for that particular dangerous research in the US but didn't mind another country doing similar work.

Internal Documents Further Contradict Fauci’s ‘Gain-of-Function’ Research Denials
The internal documents detail the work of EcoHealth Alliance, an American research non-profit which used NIH funding to research novel bat coronaviruses at the Wuhan lab. Among the documents, which were obtained by The Intercept through a Freedom of Information Act request, is a previously unpublished EcoHealth Alliance grant proposal filed with the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease, which is run by Fauci.

The proposal requests $3.1 million for a project titled “Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence,” which involved screening thousands of lab workers for novel bat coronaviruses. The grant was awarded for five years, from 2014 to 2019, and was subsequently renewed before being suspended by the Trump administration. The proposal directs $599,000 of the total grant to the Wuhan Institute of Virology for research designed to make the viruses more dangerous and/or infectious — and its author acknowledged the danger associated with such work. ...

Dr. Richard Ebright, biosafety expert and professor of chemistry and chemical biology at Rutgers University, has also disputed Fauci’s claims. Primarily, he has rebutted Fauci’s chief declaration that the NIH “has not ever and does not now fund gain of function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology [WIV]” as “demonstrably false.” ...

That's then followed by a bunch of political crap in the article.



This article is mostly about the history of the WIV and the level 4 biosafety unit. It is a reminder coronaviruses weren't being handled in the level 4 lab. In addition it corroborates other citations that note the WIV did have live bats.

WA Po (not behind a paywall here): Inside the Wuhan lab: French engineering, deadly viruses and a big mystery
But just a couple of years after the P4 lab's ribbon-cutting, China was engulfed in a far deadlier outbreak. Yuan's team hadn't prevented it. And worse, some suspected they might have been involved in its genesis. ...

The new P4 lab was not being used for researching coronaviruses, however, which are classified at lower security levels. ...

In 2004, her team collected samples from 408 bats across China.

It was tough work. Shi and colleagues crawled on their stomachs through narrow caves, she recounted in a speech in June 2018. They caught bats with nets, releasing most of them after taking samples, and occasionally taking a few bats back to the lab. ...
 
ETA: As far as I can see the only posters here who raised the idea of "proof" are Skeptic Ginger and yourself, as a disparagement of others who question the proposed "evidence".


The disparagement you speak of is about hand-waving off of circumstantial evidence. The only reason I brought up "proof" was to illustrate some persons here are claiming anything short of proof is not evidence.
 
...If you define "created" as some version of gain of function research with PPPs then:
created by humans in a lab before it was accidentally released
This one is possible and supported by the evidence of the bat bites and multiple trips to the Yunnan cave:
occurred in "the wild" by natural mutation and transported to a lab before it was accidentally released.
Skeptic Ginger is repeating her errors without trying to learn what happened.
Gain of function looks at making viruses more infectious nd so more deadly inside the human cell. SARS‑CoV‑2 also had to make the leap from contact transmission in bats to air-borne transmission for humans.
Inside the risky bat-virus engineering that links America to Wuhan
...Fauci denied the accusation, stating categorically: “The NIH has not ever, and does not now, fund gain-of-function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology.”

The denial rests on the NIH’s specific definition of what was covered by the moratorium: work that would have deliberately enhanced SARS-like viruses, MERS, or flu by—for example—making them easier to spread through the air. The Chinese research did not have the specific goal of making the viruses more deadly, and rather than SARS itself, it used SARS’s close cousins, whose real-world risk to humans was unknown—in fact, determining the risk was the point of the research. Just as when you trade in part of a poker hand for fresh cards, there was no way of knowing whether the final chimeras would be stronger or weaker.
The WIV was not trying to make an actual SARS virus more infectious and deadly and somehow creating SARS‑CoV‑2. They were looking at relatives of SARS with unknown infectious risk and evaluating that risk.

There is a single video first broadcast on state TV in China on Dec. 29, 2017. This does not support transmission to humans happening in 2019.
Of course there were multiple trips to the Yunnan cave and many other caves - they were researching the origin of SARS :eye-poppi!
Bat cave solves mystery of deadly SARS virus — and suggests new outbreak could occur
After a detective hunt across China, researchers chasing the origin of the deadly SARS virus have finally found their smoking gun. In a remote cave in Yunnan province, virologists have identified a single population of horseshoe bats that harbours virus strains with all the genetic building blocks of the one that jumped to humans in 2002, killing almost 800 people around the world.
 
Come on, that's just stupid. Past accidents in Chinese labs that infected workers is more specific evidence than saying past spillover events have led to pandemics.

Actually, what is stupid is claiming that there is evidence the virus was released from a lab without any evidence that the virus was ever in a lab prior to discovery of the first cases.
 
The disparagement you speak of is about hand-waving off of circumstantial evidence. The only reason I brought up "proof" was to illustrate some persons here are claiming anything short of proof is not evidence.

Then why did you bring it up after quoting me? That is certainly not a claim of mine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom