I would say the evidence is that the most influential paper on the subject has been by Andersen et. al.
"Influential"? To whom besides yourself?
I think the things revealed by DRASTIC have been influential in getting people to recognize Daszak's conflict of interest, his manipulation of the direction of the investigation and his lying to other researchers about the Lancet opinion piece. DRASTIC's uncovering of the two contemporary theses based on the infected miners in Yunnan in 2012 did a lot to dispel Shi's claim the miners died of a fungus. And DRASTIC exposed the fact, with evidence, there are hundreds of SARS-like CoV specimens that have been collected from the area yet there is little record of them in what the WIV has released. They have also documented the fact there are indeed live bats kept at the WIV, another thing Shi denies.
Clearly we value different sources of information here.
I don’t know that this is what is being claimed.
Let’s say someone has a virus - the flu, HIV, a cold, herpes. Did they get this from the environment or did it come from a lab? In most cases, the answer is from the environment and ultimately from nature.
This is the baseline assumption.
Re that analogy: One doesn't get the viruses you note from the environment, they get them from another person and the epidemiological trail can very often be discovered.
After two years no such trail for COVID has been found. It took 4 months to find the proximal source of SARS 1. And at that time it was discovered the virus had gone through adapting to human cells while circulating in both civet cats and people before the pandemic took off.
Historically it may have taken longer to find the source of things like HIV, but there are many reasons why that was. In particular, the science of detecting the viral source of HIV was difficult in the 80s. It wasn't until after 1983 when
the PCR technique became readily available that research on genomes really took off.
The long incubation period of HIV before it leads to AIDS delayed discovery of the trail. We know the source of influenza because its evolution is monitored from sampling around the world. It's the most closely followed virus in the world. As for herpes, contact tracing plays a big role in determining the source of the infection.
The common cold is the result of a number of different viruses. When diagnosing a person's common cold infection one uses the information of any community outbreaks to make the determination. If it is flu season and flu is circulating one adds that to the mix. So for example, one's patient shows up in June with cold symptoms, with no history of travel, and when sentinel sampling of viral cultures of upper respiratory infections shows no flu, the suggested diagnosis is that it is not influenza.
Your oversimplification of how we trace infectious disease sources is affecting your assumptions about the origin of COVID-19.
However, because it was in Wuhan we now have an extra possibility of it being from a lab in addition to the likelihood of it being from nature. But it is also a new virus, so unlike the usual type of lab escape it would have to be an unusual lab escape as opposed to the type of zoonotic spillover that viruses tend to be.
This makes no logical sense whatsoever.
So what evidence furthers that? The fact that viruses have escaped from labs before? Well, not really, because we are not talking about the type of virus we would expect to be there but a new one. Trying to figure out how it got there is the interesting question not that viruses can escape.
Yes really. I fail to see how a new virus or a known pathogen is a relevant variable. Whereas knowing viruses have escaped from labs and infected people and animals before is a relevant variable.