Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Could you explain this? I don't quite understand the "would happen regardless bit", but it seems like it would also apply to any evidence of something that happened in the past, including a natural spillover.

Why is the fact that natural spillover occurred in the past being used as evidence for a natural spillover theory, but the fact that lab leaks have occurred in the past discounted as evidence for a lab leak theory?

I would consider spillover to be the null hypothesis as it is for most outbreaks. That said, there are almost always accusations of lab leak or human engineering of viruses whenever there is a serious outbreak. They usually turn out not to be true (AIDS, Lassa fever, Ebola etc…)
 
Its not her ethnicity that is the issue, its the fact that she is a Chinese citizen and thus under the control of the CCP. China 2002 is not China 2021. If the CCP of 2021 tell her to hide evidence or delete databases or samples, or straight up lie, she will do those things or at best get jailed for "picking quarrels and causing trouble", "national security" or any other spurious charge; at worst she will get disappeared.

She may well be a paragon of scientific virtue. The CCP is not, and the sad fact is that we cannot really trust anything that comes out of China at the moment.

Sure, but we should at least listen to virologists who are not in the same situation, and most of them don’t see a reason to think it leaked from a lab.
 
Its not her ethnicity that is the issue, its the fact that she is a Chinese citizen and thus under the control of the CCP. China 2002 is not China 2021. If the CCP of 2021 tell her to hide evidence or delete databases or samples, or straight up lie, she will do those things or at best get jailed for "picking quarrels and causing trouble", "national security" or any other spurious charge; at worst she will get disappeared.

She may well be a paragon of scientific virtue.
Let's not mince words here. If she was a 'paragon of scientific virtue' then she wouldn't hide evidence or lie - so what you are really saying is you don't trust her.

I don't trust her either. Being a true skeptic, I don't trust anybody, especially anyone pushing conspiracy theories about 'lab leaks'.
 
Sure, but we should at least listen to virologists who are not in the same situation, and most of them don’t see a reason to think it leaked from a lab.
Do you have evidence of a survey of these virologists because what I see are that some support spillover, a few support the lab origin and the majority agree both origin hypotheses are still on the table.



... I don't trust her either. Being a true skeptic, I don't trust anybody, especially anyone pushing conspiracy theories about 'lab leaks'.
Posting evidence is not "pushing" a CT. I'm not sure what category to put denial of evidence and attacking every source of that evidence as not qualified unless they are specifically virologists in. And one virologist, Dr Redfield, was dismissed out of hand.

There was a well documented concerted effort by certain people with conflicts of interest involved (Daszak, Shi, the Chinese government) to portray anyone suggesting this virus leaked from a lab as a conspiracy theorist. There is no conspiracy unless you want to call the Chinese government's lack of transparency a conspiracy.

While we in this forum are mostly aware of the true Scotsman fallacy, I find it interesting that more than a few people posting in this thread have as a knee-jerk reaction put the lab origin hypothesis into the CT category as if it must belong there. You are not a true skeptic unless you believe the spillover hypothesis? :rolleyes:

A lab accident does not require a conspiracy. No one is asserting anything that is not supported by actual evidence. The lack of transparency by the Chinese government is well documented and persists despite multiple requests from the WHO to provide the information they have sought to investigate the origin of COVID. Daszak's efforts to claim the lab origin hypothesis is a CT before any evidence whatsoever was looked at re that origin hypothesis is well documented.
 
Last edited:
Do you have evidence of a survey of these virologists because what I see are that some support spillover, a few support the lab origin and the majority agree both origin hypotheses are still on the table.

I would say the evidence is that the most influential paper on the subject has been by Andersen et. al.

I don't think there are any that have had a similar number of citations, but I could be wrong.

Anyway, looks like a new WHO origins team has been convened, so I guess we will have to see what they conclude, if anything.
 
I second this question.

I don’t know that this is what is being claimed.

Let’s say someone has a virus - the flu, HIV, a cold, herpes. Did they get this from the environment or did it come from a lab? In most cases, the answer is from the environment and ultimately from nature.

This is the baseline assumption.

However, because it was in Wuhan we now have an extra possibility of it being from a lab in addition to the likelihood of it being from nature. But it is also a new virus, so unlike the usual type of lab escape it would have to be an unusual lab escape as opposed to the type of zoonotic spillover that viruses tend to be.

So what evidence furthers that? The fact that viruses have escaped from labs before? Well, not really, because we are not talking about the type of virus we would expect to be there but a new one. Trying to figure out how it got there is the interesting question not that viruses can escape.
 
Well the virus for sure came from nature. Question is, if it was aided by research in any way, be it simply sample collection, some basic research or gain of function research.
And claims of Chinese scientist are completely irrelevant, because of repression. Also claims of official WHO representatives are somewhat irrelevant .. as for them maintaining good relationship with China is more important even that the truth.
But nobody outside WHO and China can even know anything. So I guess this is were it will stay .. we can't prove anything, and we can't rule out anything.
 
I would say the evidence is that the most influential paper on the subject has been by Andersen et. al.
"Influential"? To whom besides yourself?

I think the things revealed by DRASTIC have been influential in getting people to recognize Daszak's conflict of interest, his manipulation of the direction of the investigation and his lying to other researchers about the Lancet opinion piece. DRASTIC's uncovering of the two contemporary theses based on the infected miners in Yunnan in 2012 did a lot to dispel Shi's claim the miners died of a fungus. And DRASTIC exposed the fact, with evidence, there are hundreds of SARS-like CoV specimens that have been collected from the area yet there is little record of them in what the WIV has released. They have also documented the fact there are indeed live bats kept at the WIV, another thing Shi denies.

Clearly we value different sources of information here.


I don’t know that this is what is being claimed.

Let’s say someone has a virus - the flu, HIV, a cold, herpes. Did they get this from the environment or did it come from a lab? In most cases, the answer is from the environment and ultimately from nature.

This is the baseline assumption.
Re that analogy: One doesn't get the viruses you note from the environment, they get them from another person and the epidemiological trail can very often be discovered.

After two years no such trail for COVID has been found. It took 4 months to find the proximal source of SARS 1. And at that time it was discovered the virus had gone through adapting to human cells while circulating in both civet cats and people before the pandemic took off.

Historically it may have taken longer to find the source of things like HIV, but there are many reasons why that was. In particular, the science of detecting the viral source of HIV was difficult in the 80s. It wasn't until after 1983 when the PCR technique became readily available that research on genomes really took off.

The long incubation period of HIV before it leads to AIDS delayed discovery of the trail. We know the source of influenza because its evolution is monitored from sampling around the world. It's the most closely followed virus in the world. As for herpes, contact tracing plays a big role in determining the source of the infection.

The common cold is the result of a number of different viruses. When diagnosing a person's common cold infection one uses the information of any community outbreaks to make the determination. If it is flu season and flu is circulating one adds that to the mix. So for example, one's patient shows up in June with cold symptoms, with no history of travel, and when sentinel sampling of viral cultures of upper respiratory infections shows no flu, the suggested diagnosis is that it is not influenza.

Your oversimplification of how we trace infectious disease sources is affecting your assumptions about the origin of COVID-19.


However, because it was in Wuhan we now have an extra possibility of it being from a lab in addition to the likelihood of it being from nature. But it is also a new virus, so unlike the usual type of lab escape it would have to be an unusual lab escape as opposed to the type of zoonotic spillover that viruses tend to be.
This makes no logical sense whatsoever.

So what evidence furthers that? The fact that viruses have escaped from labs before? Well, not really, because we are not talking about the type of virus we would expect to be there but a new one. Trying to figure out how it got there is the interesting question not that viruses can escape.
Yes really. I fail to see how a new virus or a known pathogen is a relevant variable. Whereas knowing viruses have escaped from labs and infected people and animals before is a relevant variable.
 
Skeptic Ginger repeats DRASTIC's stupidity and lies yet again.

DRASTIC's uncovering of the two contemporary theses based on the infected miners in Yunnan in 2012 did a lot to dispel Shi's claim the miners died of a fungus. ...
Theses are not published papers. Few people other than the authors and reviewers would know about their contents and speculation about the source of miner infections. The fact that there seem no published papers from the authors with the speculations says that the authors were not confident about their speculations. Or that they were quickly shown to be wrong - see below.
DRASTIC's contemporary stupidity. Sceince does not stop whenever someone wants it to.

There were no viruses close to SARS-CoV in the bat cave.
6 September 2021: Shi was correct that the miners [probably] had fungal infections (the bats did not have SARS-CoV or SARS-CoV 2 :eek:!)
There were no coronavirus found in blood samples from the miners analyzed 3 months after the became ill. ("Doctors sent her the samples for testing after something like three
months of illness").
8 September 2021: Shi has reported that her lab tested blood from the miners and did not find evidence of coronaviruses or antibodies to them.

1 September 2021: There were no Rhinolophus bats at WIV because no lab has been able to keep them in captivity :eye-poppi!
It is probably a (DRASTIC?) lie that Shi claimed that there were no live bats at WIV. There is no source for this cited by Skeptic Ginger in this thread. Researching gives a different claim. Daszak stated that no labs he had collaborated with had live (or dead) bats.
[URL="https://news.yahoo.com/evidence-mounts-wuhan-lab-studied-193700731.html]"Evidence mounts Wuhan lab studied live bats despite denials[/URL]
Daszak then tweeted back, “This is a widely circulated conspiracy theory. This piece describes work I'm the lead on & labs I've collaborated with for 15 years. They DO NOT have live or dead bats in them. There is no evidence anywhere that this happened.”
Daszak seemed to concede months later that the Wuhan lab may have had live bats after all, admitting he hadn’t asked about it when the WHO-China team visited the laboratory.

Jason Tetro of the Super Awesome Science Show tweeted: “A new angle for the lab leakers has been the alleged presence of ‘bat rooms’ in the WIV BSL4 … Any chance you can simply point out that the animal husbandry BSL4 is in Harbin and not WIV?”

Daszak replied: “You're right, labs in US & around world are trying to keep bats to test viral immune responses etc. None are successfully doing this at scale like lab mice & animals are always screened virus-free before experiments, so even if WIV were trying this, it's prob irrelevant for origins ... I also think it's in the WHO report (annexes) that they were working with animals in WIV at BSL-4, just like US labs.”
...
The WHO-China joint team’s numerous annexes totaled 193 pages, but the annex on its Feb. 3, 2021, visit to the Wuhan lab is just four pages and does not mention live bats being studied there.

DRASTIC probably lied by "quote mining" a video produced and released by the Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2017 about the opening of the then-new biosafety level four laboratory at WIV. DRASTIC show the outside of WIV and the bats somewhere in cages and a worker feeding a bat a worm.
 
Last edited:
A master's thesis and doctoral dissertation aren't peer reviewed?

:dl:

Why no, no they are not. That begs the question: so what?
Dissertations and theses may be considered scholarly sources since they are closely supervised by a dissertation committee made up of scholars, are directed at an academic audience, are extensively researched, follow research methodology, and are cited in other scholarly work.
 
Last edited:
Let's not mince words here. If she was a 'paragon of scientific virtue' then she wouldn't hide evidence or lie - so what you are really saying is you don't trust her.

I don't trust her either. Being a true skeptic, I don't trust anybody, especially anyone pushing conspiracy theories about 'lab leaks'.

No, completely wrong. I don't trust the CCP. Even a paragon of scientific virtue would think twice when their family is threatened. She is only human, and if that situation ever happened (and we are talking hypothetical anyway) I wouldn't blame her one bit.
 
Let's not mince words here. If she was a 'paragon of scientific virtue' then she wouldn't hide evidence or lie - so what you are really saying is you don't trust her.

I don't trust her either. Being a true skeptic, I don't trust anybody, especially anyone pushing conspiracy theories about 'lab leaks'.

In case it wasn't clear, my interjection here came because it was suggested that accusing Dr. Shi of anything nefarious was likely due to her ethnicity and hence de facto racism, wheras in fact the suspicions come about because of where she lives (under the control of the CCP), not her personal skin colour.
 
A master's thesis and doctoral dissertation aren't peer reviewed? ...
Read what I actually wrote.
Theses are not published papers. Few people other than the authors and reviewers would know about their contents and speculation about the source of miner infections. The fact that there seem no published papers from the authors with the speculations says that the authors were not confident about their speculations. Or that they were quickly shown to be wrong - see below.
DRASTIC's contemporary stupidity. Sceince does not stop whenever someone wants it to.
I have highlighted what the paragraph is about.
That paragraph is about knowledge of the existence of a thesis. A thesis sitting in a library is not read by the general scientific community. Theses can be made generally available, e.g. on a university web site, but scientists read published papers. They get to know about thesis contents from the published papers that reference the thesis. For example my thesis has been sitting in the Victoria University of Wellington library for 30 years. As far as I know no one has read it. The paper my supervisor and I published based on that thesis is the only public record of its existence.

You ignored the rest of the post. The theses were shown to be wrong within a few months. There is no evidence of live Rhinolophus bats at WIV (or apparently any lab in the world :eye-poppi!)
 
Last edited:
First the qualifications of these 2 authors since that seems to be a hand-waving off issue here. I cited them before.

Bioscience Resource founders:
Jonathan R Latham, PhD is co-founder and Executive Director of the Bioscience Resource Project and the Editor of Independent Science News. ...

Dr. Latham holds a Masters degree in Crop Genetics and a PhD in Virology. He was subsequently a postdoctoral research associate in the Department of Genetics, University of Wisconsin, Madison. He has published scientific papers in disciplines as diverse as plant ecology, plant virology, genetics and genetic engineering.

Allison K Wilson, PhD is co-founder and Science Director of the Bioscience Resource Project; Editor of the Bioscience Resource Project website; Assistant Editor of Independent Science News; ...

Dr. Wilson holds a BA in Biology from Cornell University, a doctorate in Molecular Biology and Genetics from Indiana University, Bloomington, and was formerly a postdoctoral research associate at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle and the John Innes Centre, Norwich, UK.



Next, their discussion of the origin of COVID. Sorry, I know I cited these two authors before but I want to come back to a couple of specific things in this citation.

Aug 2, 2021; Phylogeographic Mapping of Newly Discovered Coronaviruses Pinpoints the Direct Progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 as Originating from Mojiang, China

From the synopsis:
Many scientists are now openly considering whether a lab leak best explains the origin of SARS-CoV-2. Yet it is frequently also suggested in the media that the data ‘hasn’t changed’, only people’s opinions. This is far from the truth. One data set that has grown substantively since the pandemic broke out is the number of wild virus relatives of SARS-CoV-2 that have been identified and sequenced. In all, twelve isolates have now been described, ten obtained from bats and two from pangolins. All 12 isolates were found in Asia. These viruses constitute what we know of the SARS-CoV-2 reservoir population in its bat hosts.

If anyone wants to explain how one of these closely related viruses resulted in a spillover event in Wuhan, have at it.


The full paper:
The full article: Phylogeographic Mapping of Newly Discovered Coronaviruses Pinpoints the Direct Progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 as Originating from Mojiang, China
... according to that WHO report, scientists across China have sampled and tested over 80,000 animals, including 1,100 bats just in Hubei province, of which Wuhan is the capital. Yet beyond a few tantalising discoveries, which are discussed below, the search has been unsuccessful.

The broad failure of this enormous research effort has been scantly reported by the media and sometimes its significance has been dismissed entirely. ...

The Mojiang mine is also where RaTG13, the closest known natural relative of SARS-CoV-2 was found by Zheng-li Shi of the WIV. RaTG13 was collected during sampling efforts to determine the cause of the mine outbreak. For these and other reasons, the mine is already the focus of lab origin theories. ...

Our assessment of the widespread mischaracterisation of all this new evidence–in the media and the scientific literature–is therefore that most scientists and most media still resist evidence when it challenges a zoonotic origin or supports a lab leak. These new results do both.


By showing that the highest related genomes are all nearby and only less related ones far away, the association of the mine with SARS-CoV-2 is not a happenstance but part of a general phylogeographic pattern among the SARS-CoV-2 lineage. This pattern makes it highly probable that the direct bat precursor virus of SARS-CoV-2 came from, at most, within a few hundred kilometres of the Mojiang mine, with the mine itself being the epicentre of the probability gradient, i.e. the most likely single spot.

The paper contains a detailed discussion of how these authors concluded the viruses which led to SARS-CoV-2 came from the Yunnan mine. They then analyze the different origin hypotheses from spillover to lab origin and see how well they fit or do not fit with the phylogeographic pattern of sampled coronaviruses.

It's hard to fit a spillover scenario to the data. Likewise a lab constructed virus is unlikely, a finding that has indeed been concluded by a consensus among scientists.

A Mojiang location constrains other lab origin theories too.

Three distinct categories of lab accident theory have been proposed so far. The simplest scenario is that SARS-CoV-2 resulted from infection of a researcher on a sample collecting trip. This worker could have infected others when they returned to Wuhan. From the present analysis it can be inferred that any such collecting trip would have been to south/central Yunnan. Consequently, it may be possible to effectively rule out this possibility if it could be shown that no virologist from Wuhan travelled to Yunnan province in mid-to-late 2019.

A second category of lab origin postulates that RaTG13 (or a similar virus) was obtained from the Mojiang mine and enhanced or altered for some vaccine or technology-related research purpose.
The second category is supported by the phylogeographic pattern of sampled coronaviruses. But the authors propose a third hypothesis they feel has a better fit to the data.

The third category of lab escape is our Mojiang Miners Passage theory. This is based on the medical cases of the six miners, mentioned above, who all became sick in 2012 whilst shovelling bat guano at the Mojiang mine (Rahalkar and Bahulikar, 2020). ...

The theory proposes that a RaTG13-like coronavirus (or mixture of viruses that later recombined into one) from the mine infected the miners. Some of these miners were ill for almost six months. Our suggestion, therefore, is that the bat virus(es) that infected them evolved (through a passaging-like process) inside their bodies to become human-adapted.
That hypothesis is consistent with recent data that SARS-CoV-2 undergoes significant genetic changes in persons who are chronically infected.

Since it is known that numerous medical samples were taken from the miners and many were sent to the Wuhan Institute of Virology, this virus may have escaped when those medical samples were used for research, perhaps to culture the virus or to manipulate it.

We favour this theory because it explains numerous otherwise puzzling features of SARS-CoV-2. These features are (1) the high improbability of a zoonotic appearance of a SARS-related coronavirus in Wuhan; (2) the apparently pre-adapted nature of the virus to humans (Piplani et al., 2021; van Dorp et al., 2020; Zhan et al, 2020); (3) a miner’s passage predicts a single zoonotic jump to humans [which fits the data on early human sequences (Bloom, 2021)] and which is inconsistent with most viral zoonoses, which typically feature multiple jumps into humans; (4) a miner-derived virus also explains the proclivity of SARS-CoV-2 for human lungs, which is a characteristic that many coronaviruses lack; (5) the theory can also explain the extensive attempts to deny or obscure research occurring at the WIV (see also the Zhou P. et al., 2020a addendum). The Mojiang miners hypothesis even has an evolutionary explanation for the infamous furin cleavage site. However, none of this precludes the possibility that the miner-derived virus was also lab-altered.


We know or can guess why China and/or the WIV are withholding evidence about the origin of COVID. But why would EcoHealth Alliance be doing the same?
To date, both the Wuhan Institute of Virology and the EcoHealth Alliance (EHA) in New York have refused requests by Congress and others, to allow public access to their existing coronavirus samples and their viral databases.


Speculative opinion that makes sense:
The problem is not lack of data. As this article and the creative approaches of members of DRASTIC, and others, have shown, there is plenty of valuable data waiting to be brought forth. Rather, the obstacle is simply a deep and broad fear on the part of the scientific establishment that the trail might lead to a lab leak.
 
Last edited:
A master's thesis and doctoral dissertation aren't peer reviewed?

:dl:

Why no, no they are not. That begs the question: so what?
Dissertations and theses may be considered scholarly sources since they are closely supervised by a dissertation committee made up of scholars, are directed at an academic audience, are extensively researched, follow research methodology, and are cited in other scholarly work.
In the United States, a PhD dissertation is usually supervised by a single thesis advisor before being read and eventually approved by a dissertation committee that usually consists of three to five people. Many universities require at least one member of the dissertation committee to come from outside the department.

A US master's thesis is usually supervised by a single advisor, and may be read and approved by a small committee, but master's theses are generally held to a lower standard than PhD dissertations.

The quality of these supervision and approval processes varies by institution, and often varies by department even within a single institution.

Outside the US, standards vary quite widely, as illustrated by Sebastian Gorka's dissertation.

Generalizing, I'd say a PhD dissertation from a good university in the US or UK or Germany or a few other countries is likely to have been subjected to approximately the same scrutiny as peer-reviewed articles in reputable journals. On the other hand, I would not automatically assume some random master's thesis from China has been subjected to any more scrutiny than a random article published in one of the less reputable pay-to-publish online journals.
 
... I would not automatically assume some random master's thesis from China has been subjected to any more scrutiny than a random article published in one of the less reputable pay-to-publish online journals.
The thesis and dissertation speak for themselves. People looking at the thesis and dissertation cited the detailed documentation of the miners' symptoms. Anyone keeping up on this thread who is not just hand-waving away without looking, anything that doesn't confirm a spillover would know that.
 
The thesis and dissertation speak for themselves. ...
They do. The issue is how you and DRASTIC are speaking about them.
A thesis need not be generally known because they are not published in scientific journals. It is unlikely that Shi ever read the thesis and dissertation. Their existence is irrelevant to your accusation that Shi lied about the miners.

A thesis need not be correct forever. The speculation of the miners having virus infections from bats was shown to be wrong within 3 months of the event by testing their blood. Shi and her colleagues are researching the possible transmission of bat coronavirus to humans. Of course they asked for and analyzed samples from the miners! Shi and her colleagues knew that there was no coronavirus or antibodies in the blood samples. That leaves fungal infection as the probable cause of their illness and deaths.

The thesis and dissertation speak for themselves - they probably do not say that there were virial infections :jaw-dropp! DRASTIC do not quote anything from them stating this. It is DRASTIC who deny the blond samples having no coronavirus or antibodies. There is the DRASTIC idiocy of comparing the miner's symptoms to COVID-19 patients when COVID-19 did not exist ion 2012. Anyone who can use Google can find that fungal pneumonia exists and:
  1. The radiological picture seems consistent with pneumonia.
  2. Pneumonia causes elevated D-dimer values and pulmonary thromboembolism.
  3. Patients with pneumonia have lymphopenia.
  4. Pneumonia causes elevated serum amyloid A protein.
  5. The miners were treated for pneumonia with the addition of antifungals.
    COVID-19 patients have similar treatment for similar symptoms including antifungals for opportunist infections.
Fungal Diseases and COVID-19 from the CDC.
Symptoms of some fungal diseases can be similar to those of COVID-19, including fever, cough, and shortness of breath.1 Laboratory testing is necessary to determine if a person has a fungal infection or COVID-19. Some patients can have COVID-19 and a fungal infection at the same time.

People with severe COVID-19, such as those in an intensive care unit (ICU), are particularly vulnerable to bacterial and fungal infections. The most common fungal infections in patients with COVID-19 include aspergillosis or invasive candidiasis.1–6 These fungal co-infections are reported with increasing frequency and can be associated with severe illness and death.1,3,4,7,8 Awareness of the possibility of fungal co-infection is essential to reduce delays in diagnosis and treatment in order to help prevent severe illness and death from these infections.
 
Last edited:
Round and round the mulberry bush ...

Dr Shi claimed in an interview with Scientific American that the miners died of a fungal infection. She provided no evidence and no basis for that claim.


Reposting for thread readers with short memories: Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2 published in Frontiers in Public Health, Oct 2020.
Frontiers in Public Health is a multidisciplinary open-access journal which publishes rigorously peer-reviewed research and is at the forefront of disseminating and communicating scientific knowledge and impactful discoveries to researchers, academics, clinicians, policy makers and the public worldwide.



5. Elevated Serum Amyloid A protein: is an inflammatory marker that shows characteristic high values in cases of viral infection. A high SAA value or an increasing trend is an indicator of bad prognosis in the case of COVID-19 (15). In the miners' pneumonia, this marker showed high initial values in the first four serious patients and later showed peaks of up to 1,000–1,200 mg/L in some cases. ...

Based on the detailed evidence presented in the Master's thesis (7) and the Ph.D. thesis (9) and the discussion presented here, we do not think that fungus was the primary reason for the illness. Dr. Nanshan predicted the miners' illness to be a primary interstitial viral pneumonia (high probability) with invasive aspergillosis as a secondary infection (a condition commonly observed in COVID-19) (16). We think that if it was a fungal disease, only antifungals could have cured the illness. Vascular complications such as elevated D-dimer and thromboembolism are not common in fungal disease and have been observed in the miners' illness and COVID-19 (14). Elevated SAA (serum amyloid A) and declined lymphocytes are indicative of the fact that it was primary viral pneumonia (Supplementary Information C).

Remember, not only did the 2 theses list lab results for the miners, also included were images of their chest CT scans.
1. The radiological picture seen in the CT scans of COVID-19 patients (13) and miners cases (7) is very similar, which includes ground-glass opacities, peripheral consolidation, and clear indications of bilateral pneumonia (characteristic in COVID-19). This is highly evident on pages 25, 26 and 35, 37 in the translation



So other than Dr Shi's claim, what is the evidence? Why does not a single paper on the miners' illnesses support the diagnosis of a primary fungal infection? Multiple papers support the diagnosis of a viral infection and the most likely virus being a SARS-like CoV the miner's contracted while working in the mine.

If anyone has more than Dr Shi's word for it being a primary fungal infection, let's see it. And while you're at it, explain how one miner recovered without any anti-fungal drugs. Otherwise stop repeating an unsupported claim is a fact. Speculate all you want, repeat it to your heart's content, but stop saying without evidence it is a 'fact'.
 
Dr Shi claimed in an interview with Scientific American that the miners died of a fungal infection. She provided no evidence and no basis for that claim.
Shi does not need to present evidence an interview with basically a newspaper. Shi is speaking from personal experience. Shi and her colleagues knew that there was no coronavirus or antibodies in miner blood samples because they analyzed the samples.

Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2 published in Frontiers in Public Health, Oct 2020. That is the DRASTIC inspired paper that ignores the medical facts that fungal pneumonia exists, gives similar symptoms to COVID-10 and is treated similarly.

Read what Shi actually said in the interview. How China’s ‘Bat Woman’ Hunted Down Viruses from SARS to the New Coronavirus
Three years earlier Shi’s team had been called in to investigate the virus profile of a mine shaft in Yunnan’s mountainous Mojiang County—famous for its fermented Pu’er tea—where six miners suffered from pneumonialike diseases and two died. After sampling the cave for a year, the researchers discovered a diverse group of coronaviruses in six bat species. In many cases, multiple viral strains had infected a single animal, turning it into a flying factory for new viruses.

“The mine shaft stunk like hell,” says Shi, who, like her colleagues, went in wearing a protective mask and clothing. “Bat guano, covered in fungus, littered the cave.” Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.
That part in bold is from the reporter. It probably is their version of something that Shi stated. It could be part of the reporter's research. What it is not is a quote from Shi.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom