Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

A normal person might respond in that way, but remember we're talking about Killtown. Asking for an internet link to a non internet video is precisely the sort of thing I would expect Killtown to do.

Which is why I'm not assuming anything. I'm just pointing out that this short sentence by Killclown might actually not have been AS stupid as we thought. In fact, I've never read it that way, since it was Stundied.

Moby said:
Killtown's quote was unaccompanied by any non-verbal cue (an emoticon, for example) to suggest he was either joking or ridiculing WWGHA's post. On top of that, WWGHA had never suggested that Killtown try downloading said file from the net - the topic of linking to a "normal" video (a word which WWGHA also put inside quotation marks, IIRC) was raised by Killtown, in an interrogative statement that had no defining traits with which to recognise it as intentional sarcasm or irony.

That seems irrelevant :

Hypothetical poster: "If you check a NORMAL video (not an internet compression), Belz..., you'll see that your interpretation makes no sense."
Belz...: "Link to a "normal" video ? How would you want me to do that ?"
H.P.: "You can WALK, Belz..."

Leaving out the last part of my hypothetical reply would not be unexpected from an internet poster. I find it hard to believe that even Killtown would want a link to something that, by definition, cannot have one.
 
That seems irrelevant :

Hypothetical poster: "If you check a NORMAL video (not an internet compression), Belz..., you'll see that your interpretation makes no sense."
Belz...: "Link to a "normal" video ? How would you want me to do that ?"
H.P.: "You can WALK, Belz..."

Leaving out the last part of my hypothetical reply would not be unexpected from an internet poster. I find it hard to believe that even Killtown would want a link to something that, by definition, cannot have one.

Were the exchange between Killtown and WWGHA to resemble what you have posted between your hypothetical poster and yourself you would have a point.

But your exchange and the exchange that actually took place are quite different.

Most importantly, Killtown's response was not, "Link to a "normal" video ? How would you want me to do that ?" It was simply, "Link to a "normal" video?" Given that the other part of that post was simply, "Example?" it would be reasonable to assume that both parts of the post were requests. There is nothing in Killtown's post that suggests his "Link to a "normal" video?" remark is anything other than a request for a link.

Next most importantly, your hypothetical poster's reply to your statement is an unnecessary addition, as there WAS in fact a follow-up to Killtown's post. WWGHA expressed confusion at Killtown's apparent request for a link to a non-internet video. Killtown did not do anything to clarify his nominated post. There was no ridiculing of WWGHA for his ridiculous suggestion that Killtown was asking for a link to a non-internet video or any other sort of clarification.

Yes, other interpretations of Killtown's post are possible. It is entirely within the realms of possibility that everything Killtown has ever posted has simply been part of a huge practical joke and that he's having a good laugh at us taking him and his ideas as though he is being serious.

But the interpretation of Killtown's post that is far and away the most probable interpretation, in fact to a degree that I would suggest gives any other interpretation only a very, very remote probability of being correct, is that Killtown was asking for a link to a video that is by definition not on the internet.

I really don't understand why this debate is even still taking place. WWGHA defined a "normal" video as a non-internet video. Killtown then asked for a link to a non-internet video. This is BASIC linguistic analysis...
 
I haven't argued the case for the original statement from a position of ignorance as you would like to think but as a Devil's Advocate.

I am trained in and used to the Newton-centric world view where Energy is essentially an abstract concept and mechanistic Forces acting upon Masses are the key outputs required.

From the opposite view point Energy is not abstract, it is tangible. It is as easy to conceptualise from an energetic point of view where forces are an incidental result of energy doing work. The direction of the resulting forces are aligned with how Energy has the ability to carry out this Work. Can you demonstrate how Gravitational Potential Energy working on a free body will spontaneously create a force that acts directly away from the two centres of mass? Of course the person who questioned the concept of vertical knew that working with Potential Energy requires a reference framework, one of the three axes that are commonly chosen to simplify the mathematics is commonly referred to as vertical.

Energy is a universal concept across many academic disciplines, doing work on a closed system will raise its Energy just as getting a closed system to do work will lower its Energy. This is true for Thermodynamics and it seems to be the general opinion that I introduced this concept to obfuscate but it was merely to show how Energy as a universal concept works.

The need for energy to move towards equilibrium makes the Potential Energy of an object Work on its mass to lower its Energy. That is the direction, the driving force. Mechanical systems are not immune from the law of Conservation of Energy so just as Energy behaves Thermodynamically so it does Mechanically.

This is why the Stundie nomination was not deserved.

I have tried to explain this in as close to layman's terms as I can so if it is not scientifically rigorous enough for you then I invite you to ask questions for further clarification rather than berate me for straying from text book science.

This is my last post on this particular nomination except where people require clarification. It has been sad for me that the journey could not have been more pleasant but it told me a lot about the forum.
 
Last edited:
This Killtown ‘debunking’ reminded me of what I always disliked about English Lit, namely the subjective interpretation of of somebody’s writing. If you want to know what an author really meant, just ask them! Sitting around guessing their intention doesn’t really get the debate anywhere; people can just defend whatever piece of guesswork best fits their own biases. You could just ask Killtown directly, and agree or disagree to take his answer, if one were forthcoming, as the final word.

Debunking a Stundie (or nominating one) on the basis of what you think somebody meant, from their somewhat ambiguous phrase, can lead to an unresolvable debate about meanings and intentions.

It reminded me of this exchange between Lisa Simpson and Amy Tan:

Lisa:
Miss Tan, I loved The Joy Luck Club. You really showed me how the mother-daughter bond could survive adversity.

Amy Tan:
No, no, that's not what I meant at all! I can't believe how wrong you got it.

Just sit down, I'm embarrassed for both of us.

My verdict, for what it's worth:

WR didn't succesfully debunk the Killtown nomination, for reasons stated above. He can have only as much certainty of what was meant by Killtown as any of the rest of us. I think that particular nomination was too much of an 'inside joke' than anything else; a new reader of this forum may not have any understanding of what that quote represented.
 
This Killtown ‘debunking’ reminded me of what I always disliked about English Lit, namely the subjective interpretation of of somebody’s writing. If you want to know what an author really meant, just ask them! Sitting around guessing their intention doesn’t really get the debate anywhere; people can just defend whatever piece of guesswork best fits their own biases. You could just ask Killtown directly, and agree or disagree to take his answer, if one were forthcoming, as the final word.
Debunking a Stundie (or nominating one) on the basis of what you think somebody meant, from their somewhat ambiguous phrase, can lead to an unresolvable debate about meanings and intentions.
It reminded me of this exchange between Lisa Simpson and Amy Tan:
My verdict, for what it's worth:
WR didn't succesfully debunk the Killtown nomination, for reasons stated above. He can have only as much certainty of what was meant by Killtown as any of the rest of us. I think that particular nomination was too much of an 'inside joke' than anything else; a new reader of this forum may not have any understanding of what that quote represented.

My success depended not upon showing the nominated interpretation as incorrect. I only needed to show that based upon the available facts, there were alternative interpretations that were just as if not more likely. I did that with considerable ease.

I couldn't agree with you more that the only way to truthfully know would be to ask the author of the post. I would point out that this was not done prior to the quote being accepted for nomination. In addition, there is so much personal dislike of Killtown that many would not believe his evidence anyway.

At the end of the day, this nomination is a straight down the middle ad hominem. It is an attack based not upon the known facts or facts that could be obtained with further investigation. It was nominated based upon hateful intent against the original poster and the fact that the poster is considered fair game by the forum.

To anyone that denies that, prove it by contacting Killtown or withdraw the nomination.
 
My success depended not upon showing the nominated interpretation as incorrect.

So you're trying to win something here? Were you successful? What did you win?

I only needed to show that based upon the available facts, there were alternative interpretations that were just as if not more likely.

According to your own personal interpretation.

I did that with considerable ease.

And yet the debate is still rolling on. You sure about this statement?

I couldn't agree with you more that the only way to truthfully know would be to ask the author of the post. I would point out that this was not done prior to the quote being accepted for nomination.

Nor was it done by you before you started your arguement.

In addition, there is so much personal dislike of Killtown that many would not believe his evidence anyway.

Speculation.

At the end of the day, this nomination is a straight down the middle ad hominem.

According to your own personal interpretation, that is.

It is an attack based not upon the known facts or facts that could be obtained with further investigation.

So find out. Go do a little investigation and then come back here to let us know if it was truly an unwarranted "attack".

It was nominated based upon hateful intent against the original poster

Now there's an unwarranted attack.

and the fact that the poster is considered fair game by the forum.

Aren't we all.

To anyone that denies that, prove it by contacting Killtown or withdraw the nomination.

We'll let you take care of this, since you're the one who has the issue.
 
<snip>
At the end of the day, this nomination is a straight down the middle ad hominem. It is an attack based not upon the known facts or facts that could be obtained with further investigation. It was nominated based upon hateful intent against the original poster and the fact that the poster is considered fair game by the forum.

To anyone that denies that, prove it by contacting Killtown or withdraw the nomination.
That is not an ad hominem argument.

Making fun of something stupid that someone says is FUNDEMENTALLY DIFFERENT than saying that their claim is false because they said something stupid.
 
My success depended not upon showing the nominated interpretation as incorrect. I only needed to show that based upon the available facts, there were alternative interpretations that were just as if not more likely. I did that with considerable ease.



Your "success" depended on completely altering the context of the quote. Winning is easy when you can just make stuff up. Winning while being truthful is slightly more challenging.

Not that you'd know that.
 
I haven't argued the case for the original statement from a position of ignorance as you would like to think but as a Devil's Advocate.

I am trained in and used to the Newton-centric world view where Energy is essentially an abstract concept and mechanistic Forces acting upon Masses are the key outputs required.

From the opposite view point Energy is not abstract, it is tangible. It is as easy to conceptualise from an energetic point of view where forces are an incidental result of energy doing work. The direction of the resulting forces are aligned with how Energy has the ability to carry out this Work. Can you demonstrate how Gravitational Potential Energy working on a free body will spontaneously create a force that acts directly away from the two centres of mass? Of course the person who questioned the concept of vertical knew that working with Potential Energy requires a reference framework, one of the three axes that are commonly chosen to simplify the mathematics is commonly referred to as vertical.

Energy is a universal concept across many academic disciplines, doing work on a closed system will raise its Energy just as getting a closed system to do work will lower its Energy. This is true for Thermodynamics and it seems to be the general opinion that I introduced this concept to obfuscate but it was merely to show how Energy as a universal concept works.

The need for energy to move towards equilibrium makes the Potential Energy of an object Work on its mass to lower its Energy. That is the direction, the driving force. Mechanical systems are not immune from the law of Conservation of Energy so just as Energy behaves Thermodynamically so it does Mechanically.
This is gibberish. It makes no more sense from a layman's viewpoint than it does from a physicist's.

This is why the Stundie nomination was not deserved.
I'm not sure what you think the "Stundies" are, but Griffin's statement was wrong, and he used that wrong statement to wrongly question the behavior of the collapsing WTC towers--he made a wrong statement in an area that was so clearly out of his league, and with such authority, that the person who nominated it thought we'd get a chuckle from it. And we did.

I have tried to explain this in as close to layman's terms as I can so if it is not scientifically rigorous enough for you then I invite you to ask questions for further clarification rather than berate me for straying from text book science.
Layman's terms still have to be accurate. When we explain something in layman's terms, it doesn't mean we explain something according to a layman's misconceptions, it means we explain something that a layman finds counterintuitive and/or complex using descriptive examples and analogies, in everyday, familiar language. But we do so while remaining accurate, the goal being to give the layman an accurate understanding of the concept.

If a layman were to read your gibberish above, do you suppose they'd have a better understanding of the relationships among energy, work and force?
 
I'm not sure what you think the "Stundies" are, but Griffin's statement was wrong, and he used that wrong statement to wrongly question the behavior of the collapsing WTC towers--he made a wrong statement in an area that was so clearly out of his league, and with such authority, that the person who nominated it thought we'd get a chuckle from it. And we did.

Could be...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448632#post2448632

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2480662#post2480662

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506344#post2506344

To be honest the only common definition I could find was that it was a chance to laugh at how stupid other people are, you can draw your own conclusion about the intent of the Stundies from that.
 
Could be...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448632#post2448632

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2480662#post2480662

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506344#post2506344

To be honest the only common definition I could find was that it was a chance to laugh at how stupid other people are, you can draw your own conclusion about the intent of the Stundies from that.
At truly stupid comments. You'll note that HeyLeroy had a quote nominated. Neither the person who nominated him, nor anyone else that I know of, considers him a stupid person. Quite the contrary.
 
At truly stupid comments. You'll note that HeyLeroy had a quote nominated. Neither the person who nominated him, nor anyone else that I know of, considers him a stupid person. Quite the contrary.

With respect, I would truely like to subscribe to your more generous interpretation, but experience tells me otherwise. :)

I digress.
 
With respect, I would truely like to subscribe to your more generous interpretation, but experience tells me otherwise. :)

I digress.
It just so happens that stupid people (people unable or unwilling to learn and to correct their errors) generate the most stupid quotes and the stupidest stupid quotes. :)

I digress.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom