Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ahh, OK. That does make sense even if you cannot yet make a reference. The written words "American Bigfoot" probably are not meant to denote that the film contains a Bigfoot filmed in America. It more likely is shorthand writing meant to indicate "American (National Enterprises) Bigfoot". The alpha-numeric writing probably indicates an internal stock number for the PGF footage (or possiblt it specifies this particular edited film copy of the PGF). ANE may have produced multiple versions of the PGF, and kept track of them all using special number codes. This version shows the "driftwood scene" twice among other differences that we see, when compared other available versions of the PGF. I have never seen any other version of the PGF which shows this repeated scene. It is quite obvious that this particular version of the PGF has received creative editing. The repeated driftwood scene can be observed in the NG program as well as the Henry May YouTube clip.

Repeated "driftwood scene"...
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/eb238399.jpg[/qimg]

It was MK Davis who pointed this out. The film has been copied so many times by so many different people that it could be imposssible to know the origin of any one copy.
 

Attachments

  • Writing1.jpg
    Writing1.jpg
    70.5 KB · Views: 5
I posted this earlier today on the BFF while lamenting the lack of tangible evidence for large hairy critters, but I see it works equally well on either forum.



Sounds like Simone is describing the origin of your bigfoot story.

Did you actually speak with your neighbors college roomate's brother? The clerk? Do you have one single shred of evidence that the story is more than a tall tale?

RayG

Where the men in brown are concerned its best to avoid anyone they've had dealings with. My neighbor was taking a big chance telling me the story. I later learned that the same neighbor was tailed for two nights in a row by a dark colored sedan as they were traveling home from work. As for shreds of evidence yes the men in brown shred evidence!
 
I sincerely hope you're not that gullible.

RayG

Gullible who me? Well I'm gullible enough to believe that a man in a monkey suit was filmed in Northern California in the late 60's. OMG there's a Grumman step van outside my house..........
 
OK fine..... saying that every possible position is equally *invalid* is just as wrong.


You didn't pay close-enough attention to what I said, Devnull. You misrepresented it.

Here's what I said, (in post #11962)...

.....I said that default positions....such as "Patty IS a human", or "Patty IS a Bigfoot" are meaningless, and worthless.


All I was talking about was those two default positions...and nothing else....because they're the only two possible positions (Man-in-suit, or real Bigfoot) which can reasonably be taken, with regards to Patty.

Sure, someone can take any wacky default position they want....but those positions are completely irrelevant to REALITY.

One key aspect of these two positions, is that they're worded in the "definite" sense...using the word "is", as opposed to "may be". That's why I emphasized the word "is" in both of them.

If a person says that Patty IS one thing, or the other...and doesn't base it on some piece of evidence which rises to the level of proof....it's a meaningless, and worthless statement.
It's exactly the same thing as saying "I think Patty is a man-in-a-suit (or a real Bigfoot)".

If there is a meaningful difference....I'd love to see someone try to explain what that difference is.

Why should it mean anything to you? Because it is based in *current reality*. Once again, we have solid evidence man exists. We have solid evidence that monkey suits exist. We have solid evidence monkey suits exist. We have no solid evidence that BF exists, in any form. Therefore, the default position must be that patty is a guy in a suit.


Unfortunately, we don't have ANY evidence whatsoever, (let alone solid evidence) that a monkey suit exists which can compare to the realism of Patty....when seen in motion.

If there is one...can you direct me to a video of it? I'd love to see it!


Claiming that it is just as invalid as "patty is 2 tonne of horse excrement" is the height of intellectual dishonesty.


Sorry...I never claimed that...:D....and wacky default positions aren't relevant to anything I had to say about default positions.


Patty is a guy in a suit until proven otherwise.

You think. ;)

You're just sore because there *is no proof*.


Devnull, you can't even tell what I'm saying when it's right in front of your eyes :eye-poppi...in black and white. How the heck are you able to know what's going on inside my head??? :boggled:


So, once again - provide solid evidence of BF's existence and we can start rethinking the default position.

You can think anything you want to, Devnull. :)
Have a wonderful day tomorrow....enjoy your thoughts!


One more thing......when you find proof positive that Patty is in fact a 'man-in-a-suit'....please let me know about it! ;)
 
Last edited:
Thank you, Henry. I have more questions because some things are not clear. You seem to be in a position to possibly provide some answers.

Your Bigfoot website features this NG clip of the PGF that we are talking about. Is your clip simply a link to another YouTube clip posting? IOW, I am asking you if this NG PGF clip is actually the product of some other YouTube member. If so, could you please provide the actual hyperlink to the original YouTube PGF video that you are featuring on your site?

You have talked to MK Davis about this clip, and you say he has examined it "frame by frame". In general, I think that that is a good thing. Did MK mention anything to you about seeing strange repeated scenes? Did he mention seeing the repeating driftwood scene, and pose any kind of outspoken mystery concerning this?

Did he mention the writing on the film? When I watch the NG program, I only see the writing after the Patty walk. Yet, the clip featured on your site shows writing before, and after the Patty walk. Did MK talk to you about this apparent mystery? Can you yourself solve this issue by watching the NG DVD that you have? Does that DVD show the writing before and after the Patty walk? Can anyone go and buy this NG Bigfoot DVD that you have now?

You mention that MK speculates that NG got their hands on the "original movie film" from ANE. Does he believe that this "original movie film" does indeed contain the repeated driftwood scene?

What about this reference to "1-inch tape copy"? Does MK have any information on this? Did he talk to NG and learn that their material on hand (showing the ANE original movie film) is in the form of 1-inch digital tape?

Henry, are you interested in trying to know these things just like I am? Can I possibly infect you with the same intrigue into the PGF that I hold? Many in the Bigfooter community say that the "original PGF" is lost (missing), or is really being held in some vault (Florida?).

I wonder if this NG PGF clip (from ANE) is actually a copy of what everyone is calling the "original PGF". Do you wonder this too?

I hope that I haven't asked too many questions of you. I think you can provide at least some of the answers. Maybe that is because you are friends with MK Davis, and he had a sort of connection to National Geographic during the 2006 production of Is It Real? Bigfoot.

I will attempt to answer your questions as best I can, William. First of all, I do not have the actual link you spoke of, but you might want to type in to YouTube National Geographic Patterson/Gimlin Film and you might find it. What M.K. did was, to determine that the copy of the film used on the National Geographic special was a 1-inch scan was that he recorded the show to DVD and then slowed down the film and examined it frame by frame, more especially the leader at the end, and found the writing on it which said American Bigfoot. He did not mention any of the other inconsistencies you mentioned. The video I got is done by another member of YouTube, not by M.K. From what I understand the DVD I mentioned was available I think at Barnes and Noble as a free promotional DVD, and a fellow from Missouri is selling it (I have a paper with all the details on it, but I have to find it). Where M.K. got his copy from was when he recorded the show off TV onto a DVD, and that is how he examined it. And yes, I am interested in knowing the things you mentioned, but I still have my own opinions on the film, which I may have made a discovery on regarding one of the footprint casts made by Patterson from the filmsite. On a 14-inch track I received from eBay, I may have found a large bump behind the big toe which corresponds to what we have behind our big toe on our foot. If indeed it is not a casting artifact or excess plaster, then it may be the indisputable proof the film shows a real creature and not a person in a suit. I will be taking that cast with me to Ohio for Don Keating's Bigfoot Conference in May to show to Dr. Jeff Meldrum to get his opinion on what it may be, If indeed it is a natural bump like we have in our foot, then that has shifted my belief in the film from about 90% to 98%. I will be sure to report here what Dr. Meldrum says when I return. I think it may possibly be a natural part of a foot, but I am not 100% sure on it. That is why I want Dr. Meldrum to examine it. Anyway, again, William, I hope I have answered your questions to the best of my ability.
 
One more thing......when you find proof positive that Patty is in fact a 'man-in-a-suit'....please let me know about it! ;)

Ahhh, there's the rub - I dont have to. Once again, for the billionth time, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Patty being some dude in a suit is not an extraordinary claim. No evidence required.
 
Ahhh, there's the rub - I dont have to.


That's right, Devnull...nobody here has to do anything.


Once again, for the billionth time, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.


You're right...they do!

Patty being some dude in a suit is not an extraordinary claim.


Sure it is.....since, after 40 years, no monkey-suit-in-motion has ever come close to replicating the realism of Patty.

Like I said in my post last night...can you direct me to a video of one? :)
 
Last edited:
Sure it is.....since, after 40 years, no monkey-suit-in-motion has ever come close to replicating the realism of Patty.

Come on Sweaty, admit it, you really love seeing Correa Neto's monster suit image file right? Is that why you keep bringing up this 'realism'? You know that is what will happen, there will be 10 posts asking you what a 'real' bigfoot looks like, and how can you compare the 'realism' of Patty to anything, and then CN will post a picture of REDKING, and you will say 'that doesn't look as 'real' as Patty'.
 
One more thing......when you find proof positive that Patty is in fact a 'man-in-a-suit'....please let me know about it! ;)

I guess you miss the point (continuously). The liklihood of it being a man in a suit is far greater than it being a real live bigfoot. As I have (and others have) stated previously, until you can provide more evidence that bigfoot exists as an actual living being, then people will always state that the PGF is likely a man in a suit and not a real bigfoot no matter how hard you and other proponents try to make it sound like it can not be.
I already stated that if you really think that bigfoot is real and this film is authentic, then get with all the other bigfoot proponents and come up with a real scientific way of catching evidence for bigfoot. I can think of a few right off the top of my head and they will be a lot more effective than hanging CDs from tree branches. It is time for proponents of bigfoot to spend the cash and prove skeptics wrong.
 
Sweaty's argument vs the skeptics argument concerning proof is a valid one. Because the issue of the PGF is inconclusive from both sides of the argument it is equally extraordinary to claim its a man in a suit as it is to claim its a real animal.
 
I think you need really to take some lesson in logic and science. I would really like to see how you can equate pgf=Man-in-suit as as probable as pgf=unknown-cryptid. Just for the kicker describe your model to come to such really extraordinary conclusion.
 
It happens over and over again....when it gets down to the point where the skeptic's argument is about to be exposed for what it truly is....garbage....the skeptic runs away. :)

kitakaze ran away on Melissa's board....and LTC just ran, here.

This happened several times over on the BFF, in debates I had with skeptics such as RayG, scotto, wolftrax...and others. They debated to a certain point...and then they refused to answer ANY more questions.

It says a lot when someone refuses to continue a debate, while on a discussion board. They're afraid.
Sweaty, you are lying. I have presented thorough responses to your posts and addressed your arguments point by point. You have ignored them and evaded multiple questions continually yet had the ridiculous audacity to talk about people evading you. This is the prime example of you pathologically projecting your intellectually dishonest behaviour on to others. Everyone here knows your tiresome games and you know it.

If you are an intellectually honest person interested in discussing bigfoot then you would address the arguments and questions I have put to you. You will not, because as I have shown to everyone time and again (what they're already well aware of), you have no interest in sincere critical debate.

Answer the why the Hoffman video is easily identifiable as a man in a suit. I and others think your lengthy post excuse is a total lie.

Define the 'realism' that you attribute to Patty.

If the arguments in the following posts are not valid, explain why that is the case:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3464064#post3464064

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3466952#post3466952

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3472481#post3472481

And here is a simple question for you. It is far, far more likely that the PGF depicts a man in a suit than a living bigfoot. Is this not true?

Do not dare to try answering that question using the words 'realistic' or 'realism' without first define them as you have been asked countless times yet ran from.

Finally, never dare to speak of people refusing to answer your questions when you are fully aware that this behaviour has been shown in you.
 
Sweaty's argument vs the skeptics argument concerning proof is a valid one. Because the issue of the PGF is inconclusive from both sides of the argument it is equally extraordinary to claim its a man in a suit as it is to claim its a real animal.
You are simply yet profoundly wrong. Patty is a man in a suit is not an extraordinary claim. Here are some reasons why:

Thinking that Patty is a man in a suit is not nothing more than a preferential belief with the same weight as Patty being a real bigfoot because:

1) Patterson is known to have created illusions and presented them as reality.

2) The subject of the PGF shows no features that are unable to be accounted for by a man in a suit.

3) Nobody saw Patty before or since despite the fact that 'she' was in an area being worked by a logging crew.

4) Patty is supposed to represent a species for which there is not one shred of reliable evidence.

People that are not possessed of a will to believe in bigfoot look at this an conclude that the film shows a person in a suit.
For these and many other reasons we can conclude that the PGF is most likely a hoax. That we do not have proof of that is irrelevant. We are completely justified in the complete and total dismissal of the film as being reliable evidence of bigfoot and equally justified to demand footers provide better evidence for their claims.

If you would like to say that Patty as a man in a suit is an extraordinary claim due to some perceived realism than you need to define that realism before you can proceed.

If you think the man in a suit scenario is an extraordinary claim because you are unsatisfied with the suits shown displaying the same features as are claimed in Patty then you need to provide a comprehensive list of concerted attempts to recreate the Patterson film subject and it's filming.

What you really need to do is stop the very tired attempts irresistable to bigfoot enthusiasts to switch the burden of proof.
 
Last edited:
I think you need really to take some lesson in logic and science. I would really like to see how you can equate pgf=Man-in-suit as as probable as pgf=unknown-cryptid. Just for the kicker describe your model to come to such really extraordinary conclusion.

The extraordinary element to be explained by the skeptics is the nature of the extraordinary suit. That is to say present a model of how it was made. Dosen't have to be actual suit just a good explaination. For the believer provide proof its not a suit. But the PGF and not the Bigfoot question in general is the topic of this thread so that is the item demanding extraordinary proof. Dfoot so far has provided the best skeptic evidence to date.

I can't prove its a suit and I can't explain how a suit was created. I can't explain an unknown hairy biped either. Both require extraordinary proof neither side has either. I just watched NOVA how science figured out how a certain ancient bird ancestor was able to fly in spite of many perplexing elements of the fossil. They did it by building a model of the creature and wind tunnel tested it. The only way they were able to prove the extraordinary claim that this thing flew was to build it and see if it would fly. Man in suit need working suit. Everything else is as much smoke and mirrors as the other sides claims. So lets get to work kids where's that fur and where's that 16mm Kodack K-100!
 
Last edited:
I asked.....
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me... or to anyone else?



Can you answer the question, kitty?
I think I've already made myself clear but as a person interested in sincere debate, I will answer again.

If you want to make an issue of the use of the definite article 'is' in your above question then you and anyone else is free to disregard it.

If the statement is rendered as "Patty is most likely a man in a suit based on the established facts until proven otherwise." then it should be meaningful to you and any other person who isn't engaging in willful belief in bigfoot. It is meaningful because it accurately states the nature of the circumstances regarding the film. I have already dismantled your arguments to the contrary which you have avoided dealing with.

Can you answer my questions, Sweaty? I don't think you can, so you run, you hide.
 
Ancient Mysteries - Bigfoot (1994) Part 1. Includes N/A references and totems, Byrne, Walker, Roosevelt, Krantz, etc.

Part 2. Includes the full-frame PGF (sometimes zoomed by the AM producers). Also watch for the full-frame of the "pole trees" (panned by the AM producers) that is supposed to precede the Patty walk.

Part 3. Includes a look inside the BFRO.

I can't find Part 4, or more.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom