Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Stating that it is a non sequitur doesn't make it such.

No, it's a non sequitur because it does not follow -- are we really going to do this again now? Where you cry and whine and, in addition to "demonstrably" put out the one-word non-responses like "rhetoric"? Because I've done it all before.

Can the vampires exist without eating human blood?

They can, but remember vampires are adapted to feed on humans and much prefer it.

Look in the mirror my friend.

Do you have any other awesome comebacks from 40 year-old issues of Mad Magazine? That Bob Dylan line was hilarious. And what did you say about not believing in God.

From what perspective are these things "awful"? You beg the question. You and I agree that they are immoral but we didn't evolve to perceive them as moral nor does our society deem them moral. Further our moral reasoning does not deem them moral. If we had evolved to see them as moral then we would. End of story. You answer your own question. Next time answer it yourself.

You don't even know what it means to beg the question, and this answer is, not surprisingly, evasive. If you want to avoid the naturalistic fallacy, then you have to maintain that behavior is moral or immoral regardless of adaptation. This goes back to a fundamental distinction between what we regard as moral or immoral. People may regard slavery as OK, but that doesn't make it OK. A society may think genocide is laudable, and so on.

RandFan writes:
He knows there is no such thing and so he will just ignore answering.

This is a riot. The same comment Thaiboxerken took issue with you said:

"Duh! As I've said time and time again. Sheesh. Tell us something we don't know for once."
 
...put out the one-word non-responses like "rhetoric"?
It is just rhetoric.

They can, but remember vampires are adapted to feed on humans and much prefer it.
Easy. If they are capable of empathy then I would try to reason with them and get them to stop eating human blood. Otherwise we are screwed.

That Bob Dylan line was hilarious.
Thank you, I enjoyd it myself.

You don't even know what it means to beg the question, and this answer is, not surprisingly, evasive. If you want to avoid the naturalistic fallacy, then you have to maintain that behavior is moral or immoral regardless of adaptation.
I don't hold that anything is a priori moral or immoral regardless of adaptive traits.

You: There are objective moral truths.
Me: There are no objective moral truths. Morality is not a priori.


Let's cut to the chase.
  1. Moral sentiment is an adaptive behavior (see Dawkins, Shermer, Pinker, Wright, de Waal, etc.)
  2. What we percieve as "moral" is formed by many things including evolved adaptive traits.
  3. We can reason beyond our adaptive traits (we need not be slaves to our nature, and besides, our nature is contradictory as it is).
  4. That something is natural doesn't make it right (we should not confuse "is" with "ought").
Now, identify which premise you deem wrong and we will address that.

This goes back to a fundamental distinction between what we regard as moral or immoral. People may regard slavery as OK, but that doesn't make it OK. A society may think genocide is laudable, and so on.
No argument. *That is what I have said from day one.

*(of this thread) I'll concede that my views of morality have changed some since I first came to this forum but I hold the scientific perspective that beliefs should be provisional.
 
Last edited:
Cain,

One more thing regarding your vampire hypo. Logic cannot resolve all moral dillemas. It's the nature of the beast so to speak.

From: Atheism Logic & Fallacies.

... logic is not a set of rules which govern human behavior. Humans may have logically conflicting goals. For example:
  • John wishes to speak to whomever is in charge.
  • The person in charge is Steve.
  • Therefore John wishes to speak to Steve.
Unfortunately, John may have a conflicting goal of avoiding Steve, meaning that the reasoned answer may be inapplicable to real life.
 
Last edited:
I feel like a Daily Show correspondent sent out to interview a nutter.

Easy. If they are capable of empathy then I would try to reason with them and get them to stop eating human blood. Otherwise we are screwed.

But they're all like "noooooo, it tastes too good; have a little empathy for us." More seriously, my question asked how you arbitrate right from wrong, and I didn't mean negotiating a deal. They have a set of adapted behaviors -- feeding on humans is good. I mean, that's just science.

Thank you, I enjoyd it myself.

This is where I give a wide-eyed look to the camera.


Let's cut to the chase.
  1. Moral sentiment is an adaptive behavior (see Dawkins, Shermer, Pinker, Wright, de Waal, etc.)
  2. What we percieve as "moral" is formed by many things including evolved adaptive traits.
  3. We can reason beyond our adaptive traits (we need not be slaves to our nature, and besides, our nature is contradictory as it is).
  4. That something is natural doesn't make it right (we should not confuse "is" with "ought").
Now, identify which premise you deem wrong and we will address that.

I do not disagree with any of them. The problem, as I said, is in the application.

So there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).

Any sort of decent theory strives to be as spare as possible. So suppose we genetically engineer a human to enjoy rape. He appeals to his innate feelings, which tell him to do it... and he likes violently attacking women, enjoys the distress it causes. So for him it's moral, right? For you it's immoral. But there's no way for you to arbitrate these differences. He has his natural, biological feelings, and you have yours. Now, if you want to appeal higher still, then why not cut out all of this silly gobblygook about your feelings and mirror neurons? You're like a person trying to read into the Bible whatever moral belief system you already have but instead of the Bible it's the human genome.

As for resolving matters, one can think of morality as trumps. Of course it's difficult.
 
Last edited:
That is a demonstrable lie. Kevin criticized me for suggesting that adaptive behavior or nature has anything to do with morality.

That is a fact.

You've now demonstrated that you agree with me and disagree with Kevin but you haven't the intellectual honesty to admit it.

This will be obvious to anyone who has actually been following the thread and understanding it, but on this point Cain is right and RandFan is wrong. Cain gets it, and RandFan doesn't.

To sum up RandFan's position, which inherently involves making a set of self-contradictory statements:

1. There is not eternal, a priori morality. (This is correct).

2. Therefore any objective moral statement that applies to all people in relevantly similar circumstances is empty. (This does not follow from point 1, but RandFan has repeatedly failed to grasp this despite many, many attempts to explain this).

3. We have some adaptive intuitions about how we should act. (This is correct).

4. Therefore we base all our moral claims on these adaptive intuitions. (This does not follow from point 3, but RandFan has repeatedly failed to grasp this despite many, many attempts to explain this).

5. Here comes the core contradiction: Although all our moral claims originate in adaptive intuitions about how we should act, we can use "reason" to beat these adaptive intuitions into different shapes that are better in some sense.

6. When someone says "Hang on there buddy, you just denied the existence of any moral values higher than adaptive intuitions, so how are you deciding what is better than just following our adaptive intuitions?" he responds with something vague about making society run better. Rape is not bad because we have an intuition that it's bad, it's bad because it gums up the works of society.

So to sum up the story so far, RandFan thinks we start by mindlessly following adaptive imperatives, and then we use "reason" to modify those imperatives to behave more efficiently as a society, and that's all morality is.

7. When someone says "So what about horrible things that don't gum up the works of society? Suppose it was efficient to slaughter our neighbours and rape their fertile women, or allow men to rape their wives, or allow prostitutes to be raped without legal consequences, or shoot street children, or gas the mentally disabled, or keep slaves, or burn shoplifters at the stake in public to deter others?" then RandFan runs the hell away and finds some distraction to hide behind until the scary question goes away, because he has absolutely no answer to it.

He's started with false assumptions and reasoned himself into a position where the only thing morally wrong with the great atrocities of history is that they were an inefficient use of social resources.

Interestingly, if he applied his position consistently he'd end up with something very much like an utterly brutal,objectivist consequentialism that didn't care about anything except the overall efficiency of a society.

I'm not calling him a fascist, by the way. I just think that he's incapable of critically reasoning his way through the things he types, hell-bent on showing his own cleverness by incorporating the pop literature about adaptive moral intuitions into his own half-baked moral philosophy, and incapable of hearing anything that casts doubt on the ill-made "moral" philosophy he's cobbled together. He's much more like a perpetual motion kook than a Nazi - a layperson convinced he's revolutionised a whole field of academic endeavour when in fact he's just stuck on some very basic errors.
 
...my question asked how you arbitrate right from wrong...
(see post 563)

Not all moral conflicts can be arbitrated. I'm sorry Cain but there is not always a right or wrong answer.

I do not disagree with any of them. The problem, as I said, is in the application.
Then, if you are honest, you don't have an argument with me as that is all my position consists of. End of story.

So for him it's moral, right? For you it's immoral. But there's no way for you to arbitrate these differences.
Is there a society filled with these individuals? Has this behavior resulted in an ESS?

He has his natural, biological feelings, and you have yours.
Here you err. You are making a hypo in a vacuum. There are a number of other variables important to the equation and your hypo is worthless as it is.

No one I know, least of all me, is arguing that an individuals feelings alone justify behavior. Yet you continue to make arguments as if someone were.

...why not cut out all of this silly gobblygook about your feelings and mirror neurons?
You give me reason not to cut out feelings.

From your post.

...the ask first principle ("Is it okay if I torture you?" as a thought experiment only, of course)...
I don't want to be tortured because it causes suffering. Suffering is a feeling. A bad feeling. To base my morality on this I must consider my feelings.

That's what I've been trying to get accross to Kevin. We can't really navigate morality without feelings. In the end we have to "care" about something even if it is our own desires not to suffer.

Why that is so hard to understand is beyond me.

You're like a person trying to read into the Bible whatever moral belief system you already have but instead of the Bible it's the human genome.
I'm not doing anything that Shermer, Dawkins, et al aren't doing.
 
Last edited:
And Cain, your Sig is still dishonest as I've stated that I find rape repugnant. But you won't include that in your Sig because it doesn't serve your ego.
 
my question asked how you arbitrate right from wrong, and I didn't mean negotiating a deal. They have a set of adapted behaviors -- feeding on humans is good. I mean, that's just science.
It just dawned on me just how much of the mark you missed the point.

I'm not trying to negotiate a deal. I'm trying to make a compelling argument that my morals are superior to theirs (assuming they are capable of empathy). Suffering is bad. Killing humans for their blood causes suffering. If the suffering of others is of concern to them then they should forgo killing humans.

One more time. Though I've no doubt you will ignore it.

I DON'T hold that personal feelings, adaptive or otherwise, are a sole basis for moral judgement. Nor do I believe that one can argue that simply because something is natural makes it right. Nor do I believe that what "is" should dictate what "ought" to be.

I don't argue that the Vampires are right simply because they evolved to eat human blood. I argue that because it is an evolved trait it is understandable why they might percieve it as right. I would also arge that if it were the only way for them to survive then to them it would be right.

Unless they evolved to percieve that their own survival was insignificant to suffering. But you and I both know that is not a an ESS.
 
Last edited:
It just dawned on me just how much of the mark you missed the point.

I'm not trying to negotiate a deal. I'm trying to make a compelling argument that my morals are superior to theirs (assuming they are capable of empathy). Suffering is bad. Killing humans for their blood causes suffering. If the suffering of others is of concern to them then they should forgo killing humans.

Hey presto, now RandFan's an objectivist, specifically a hedonistic utilitarian.

Don't worry, he'll be back to moral relativism or fascist consequentialism in a minute and he'll still be denying that he's ever moved an inch.
 
(see post 563)

Not all moral conflicts can be arbitrated. I'm sorry Cain but there is not always a right or wrong answer.

Wow, that's a long way from your previous answer which began with the one-word sentence "Easy." I'm not talking about resolving the situation. Slavery in America was difficult enough to resolve, but somehow, given the kind distance of history, we recognize the institution of slavery as obviously wrong.

Are you really going to seek refuge in your excerpted quote from some webpage? Put trumps aside, have you never heard the expression "competing values"?

-Greg wants to do well on his ethics test.
-Greg does NOT want to cheat.

Then, if you are honest, you don't have an argument with me as that is all my position consists of. End of story.

Noooooo. See Kevin's last post, points 5-7 in particular. (Oh wait, you put him on ignore).

Kevin wrote:
So to sum up the story so far, RandFan thinks we start by mindlessly following adaptive imperatives, and then we use "reason" to modify those imperatives to behave more efficiently as a society, and that's all morality is.... When someone says "So what about horrible things that don't gum up the works of society... then RandFan runs the hell away and finds some distraction to hide behind until the scary question goes away, because he has absolutely no answer to it.

Is there a society filled with these individuals? Has this behavior resulted in an ESS?

What difference does it make? You're avoiding the question with a vague appeal to society. Are you looking for an efficient ratio of rapists to non-rapists?

Here you err. You are making a hypo in a vacuum. There are a number of other variables important to the equation and your hypo is worthless as it is.

And those variables would be what, exactly? Whether or not society is filled with these individuals? Whether or not it has "stabilized?" You're just trying to avoid answering the question, and your concerns are those of a crackpot. A... crackpot!

No one I know, least of all me, is arguing that an individuals feelings alone justify behavior. Yet you continue to make arguments as if someone were.

You give me reason not to cut out feelings.

You mix and match, reminding me of the proverbial advice from an old lawyer to a young grad: "If the law is on your side, pound the law. If the facts are on your side, pound the facts. If neither the law, nor the facts are on your side, pound the table."

I'm not doing anything that Shermer, Dawkins, et al aren't doing.

This is not a good argument. You consistently surrender whatever thinking is your own to those authorities. I remember in the other thread somebody posted a video of Dawkins coming out in favor of rights for gorillas, and then, lo and behold, you were in favor of rights for gorillas. Not that it matters but Dawkins has also compared eating animals to slavery, and claimed he lacks the "social courage" (maybe he said "moral courage" -- something courage). Who cares? Those guys are scientists, not moral philosophers.

I'm not trying to negotiate a deal. I'm trying to make a compelling argument that my morals are superior to theirs (assuming they are capable of empathy). Suffering is bad. Killing humans for their blood causes suffering. If the suffering of others is of concern to them then they should forgo killing humans.

OK, assuming they are not capable of empathizing with humans then how are your morals superior to theirs? How can you even say yours are superior to theirs? To use the term "superior" means you have reached a value judgment. How?
 
Hey presto, now RandFan's an objectivist, specifically a hedonistic utilitarian.

Don't worry, he'll be back to moral relativism or fascist consequentialism in a minute and he'll still be denying that he's ever moved an inch.

This isn't college debate class, so it's not like one has to stick dogmatically to one school of thought. Welcome to the world of greys.
 
Are you really going to seek refuge in your excerpted quote from some webpage? Put trumps aside, have you never heard the expression "competing values"?
?

You are a bit late. I allready covered that (see post 563).

Kevin wrote: So to sum up the story so far, RandFan thinks we start by mindlessly following adaptive imperatives, and then we use "reason" to modify those imperatives to behave more efficiently as a society, and that's all morality is.... When someone says "So what about horrible things that don't gum up the works of society... then RandFan runs the hell away and finds some distraction to hide behind until the scary question goes away, because he has absolutely no answer to it.
To sum up. Kevin is engaging in a strawman.

You're just trying to avoid answering the question, and your concerns are those of a crackpot. A... crackpot!
No. I answered the question so accusing me of avoiding it is a lie.

This is not a good argument. You consistently surrender whatever thinking is your own to those authorities. I remember in the other thread somebody posted a video of Dawkins coming out in favor of rights for gorillas, and then, lo and behold, you were in favor of rights for gorillas.
Actually, Kevin introduced me to Singer's expanding circle long before that.

OK, assuming they are not capable of empathizing with humans then how are your morals superior to theirs? How can you even say yours are superior to theirs? To use the term "superior" means you have reached a value judgment. How?
That's right. I did reach a value judgement based on reason and considering feelings. My morals produce greater well being for a greater number of people for a small sacrifice of giving up the Vampires desire to consume human blood. And my morals can resolve the first person question posed in your Shermer post.
 
Hey presto, now RandFan's an objectivist, specifically a hedonistic utilitarian.

Don't worry, he'll be back to moral relativism or fascist consequentialism in a minute and he'll still be denying that he's ever moved an inch.
I've never been an objectivist. I'm not now nor have I ever advocated strict relativism. My morals are, as Shermer says, provisional.

I'm not the one trying to defend moral absolutism all the while denying it.

Kevin, you are just projecting.

This isn't college debate class, so it's not like one has to stick dogmatically to one school of thought. Welcome to the world of greys.
And this is the problem of Kevin and Cain. They've painted themselves into a corner and no logic or reason can sway them.
 
Last edited:
This isn't college debate class, so it's not like one has to stick dogmatically to one school of thought. Welcome to the world of greys.

If you want to start a meta-ethical debate, then you open yourself up to being called on meta-ethical inconsistencies and/or contradictions.

What RandFan's doing now is endorsing something which is indistinguishable, when the rubber meets the road, from an objectivist, hedonistic utilitarian position.

You don't get to do that without being called on it if you're been claiming for ten pages that you're a moral relativist.
 
  1. Moral sentiment is an adaptive behavior (see Dawkins, Shermer, Pinker, Wright, de Waal, etc.)
  2. What we percieve as "moral" is formed by many things including evolved adaptive traits.
  3. We can reason beyond our adaptive traits (we need not be slaves to our nature, and besides, our nature is contradictory as it is).
  4. That something is natural doesn't make it right (we should not confuse "is" with "ought").
Now, identify which premise you deem wrong and we will address that.
Note that this is and has been my position and no one, not Kevin or Cain has invalidated a single premise.

So, they invent arguments for me AKA strawmen.
 
If you want to start a meta-ethical debate, then you open yourself up to being called on meta-ethical inconsistencies and/or contradictions.

What RandFan's doing now is endorsing something which is indistinguishable, when the rubber meets the road, from an objectivist, hedonistic utilitarian position.

You don't get to do that without being called on it if you're been claiming for ten pages that you're a moral relativist.

NTSA.jpg


Now I see why RandFan has you on ignore. You're persistence with the circular argument is melodramatic enough to qualify for reality TV.
 
I've never been an objectivist. I'm not now nor have I ever advocated strict relativism. My morals are, as Shermer says, provisional.

Here's quite a good response to Shermer's attempts at discussing morality.

I offer this link to people capable of rigorous, joined-up thought. RandFan, based on his previous behaviour in this thread, will read it without understanding it, then cut and paste some snippets he thinks look like something he's said in the past, and present them as if it proves that his position is coherent.

Calling your morality "provisional" is simply a cop-out. Human beings, at least the smarter ones on their good days, are capable of rationality and consistency. You don't get to excuse yourself from judgement on those grounds by saying "Oh, my position is provisional, it doesn't answer to criticisms of irrationality and inconsistency". In fact if you were being intellectually honest, the fact that your provisional position has been shown to have such problems should be the trigger for you to change it.

I'm not the one trying to defend moral absolutism all the while denying it.

GreNME has already run the "claim that Cain and Kevin are moral absolutists, when they have been completely consistent from the very beginning that they are objectivists if they are anything" gambit into the ground.

It does you no credit to sink to GreNME's level.

The fact that you can't grasp this after being told so very many times is somewhat worrying. Do you really not grasp the distinction?

And this is the problem of Kevin and Cain. They've painted themselves into a corner and no logic or reason can sway them.

I submit that you would have to have tried it in order to know.
 
I keep referring to you Kevin and that seems dishonest to have you on ignore all the while taking pot shots at you.

So I'll take you off ignore until I tire of this affair.

Calling your morality "provisional" is simply a cop-out.
Saying so doesn't make it true.

Human beings, at least the smarter ones on their good days, are capable of rationality and consistency. You don't get to excuse yourself from judgment on those grounds by saying "Oh, my position is provisional, it doesn't answer to criticisms of irrationality and inconsistency".
I've never done this. I've never tried to excuse myself from any judgment. You know that and I know that. And I can prove it. Well, I can't prove it but I can demonstrate that you won't disprove it.

That should be sufficient.


In fact if you were being intellectually honest, the fact that your provisional position has been shown to have such problems should be the trigger for you to change it.
You've shown no problems. You've invented a strawman for you to tear down. I've given you my position and you've not rebutted a single premise.
  1. Moral sentiment is an adaptive behavior (see Dawkins, Shermer, Pinker, Wright, de Waal, etc.)
  2. What we perceive as "moral" is formed by many things including evolved adaptive traits.
  3. We can reason beyond our adaptive traits (we need not be slaves to our nature, and besides, our nature is contradictory as it is).
  4. That something is natural doesn't make it right (we should not confuse "is" with "ought").
Now, identify which premise you deem wrong and we will address that. Anything else is an invention in your head.
 
Last edited:
Here's quite a good response to Shermer's attempts at discussing morality.

From the link.
In the end, the golden rule is invoked as a test for morality. We all know the problems with this: It is moral to cheat on my wife provided that I don't mind her cheating on me?

Is based on a profoundly over-literal misreading of the Golden Rule and Shermer's as well as most intelligent people's reading of it. Let's see, I like ham so does the golden rule mean I should give people ham? That's the level he's interpreting it at.

There are some moral principles that we are quite certain of. For example: 'Improved self-esteem leads to a better life'.
That's not a moral principle, it's a claim (unsubstantiated) about a causal relationship with vague criteria

I could go on, but that would involve picking apart the whole article, as there's no reasonable points made in the whole thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom