That is a demonstrable lie. Kevin criticized me for suggesting that adaptive behavior or nature has anything to do with morality.
That is a fact.
You've now demonstrated that you agree with me and disagree with Kevin but you haven't the intellectual honesty to admit it.
This will be obvious to anyone who has actually been following the thread and understanding it, but on this point Cain is right and RandFan is wrong. Cain gets it, and RandFan doesn't.
To sum up RandFan's position, which inherently involves making a set of self-contradictory statements:
1. There is not eternal,
a priori morality. (This is correct).
2. Therefore any objective moral statement that applies to all people in relevantly similar circumstances is empty. (This does not follow from point 1, but RandFan has repeatedly failed to grasp this despite many, many attempts to explain this).
3. We have some adaptive intuitions about how we should act. (This is correct).
4. Therefore we base all our moral claims on these adaptive intuitions. (This does not follow from point 3, but RandFan has repeatedly failed to grasp this despite many, many attempts to explain this).
5. Here comes the core contradiction: Although all our moral claims originate in adaptive intuitions about how we should act, we can use "reason" to beat these adaptive intuitions into different shapes that are better in some sense.
6. When someone says "Hang on there buddy, you just denied the existence of any moral values higher than adaptive intuitions, so how are you deciding what is better than just following our adaptive intuitions?" he responds with something vague about making society run better. Rape is not bad because we have an intuition that it's bad, it's bad because it gums up the works of society.
So to sum up the story so far, RandFan thinks we start by mindlessly following adaptive imperatives, and then we use "reason" to modify those imperatives to behave more efficiently as a society, and that's all morality is.
7. When someone says "So what about horrible things that
don't gum up the works of society? Suppose it was efficient to slaughter our neighbours and rape their fertile women, or allow men to rape their wives, or allow prostitutes to be raped without legal consequences, or shoot street children, or gas the mentally disabled, or keep slaves, or burn shoplifters at the stake in public to deter others?" then RandFan runs the hell away and finds some distraction to hide behind until the scary question goes away, because he has absolutely no answer to it.
He's started with false assumptions and reasoned himself into a position where the only thing morally wrong with the great atrocities of history is that they were an inefficient use of social resources.
Interestingly, if he applied his position consistently he'd end up with something very much like an utterly brutal,objectivist consequentialism that didn't care about anything except the overall efficiency of a society.
I'm not calling him a fascist, by the way. I just think that he's incapable of critically reasoning his way through the things he types, hell-bent on showing his own cleverness by incorporating the pop literature about adaptive moral intuitions into his own half-baked moral philosophy, and incapable of hearing anything that casts doubt on the ill-made "moral" philosophy he's cobbled together. He's much more like a perpetual motion kook than a Nazi - a layperson convinced he's revolutionised a whole field of academic endeavour when in fact he's just stuck on some very basic errors.