W.D. Clinger is an Associate Professor in the College of Computer and Information Science at Northeastern University; his PhD (in computer science I presume) was earned at M.I.T.
My PhD is actually in mathematics. I was admitted to and completed my PhD in MIT's pure math program.
It would also be correct to say my PhD is in both mathematics
and computer science, because my PhD dissertation was interdisciplinary. My dissertation advisor, Professor Carl Hewitt of MIT's EE&CS department, completed his own PhD through MIT's pure math program.
Anyone who cannot follow the jargon has no business making assertions about the meaning of the papers. This certainly includes Mozina but it also includes well educated scientists from some unrelated discipline; there is no reason to assume that someone with a PhD in pure mathematics, for instance, will immediately understand all of the jargon in a plasma physics paper, without making an effort to learn that jargon.
Although I had enough background in physics and applied math to be familiar with some of the jargon (such as "open" versus "closed" field lines), I still had to make an effort to understand the jargon of plasma physics, and I still don't understand very much of it.
In particular, it took some effort to understand the
main results of Dungey's 1958 paper, partly because that paper contains some minor errors, partly because it's a response to a paper I haven't read, but mainly because it concerns the subject of plasma physics. On the other hand, the magnetic fields shown in
figures 1 and 2 of Dungey's paper are the obvious keys to that paper. Because I took a good freshman-level course in electromagnetism (using Volume 2 of the Berkeley Physics Course, Purcell's
Electricity and Magnetism), it was obvious to me that those magnetic fields
can be reproduced in a vacuum, without plasma.
Michael Mozina is still in denial about that.