Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The hallmark of any good cult is how well it villianizes the competition. Your little cult has taken the slander factor to new heights. Since you can't call anyone evil, it's 'crackpot', crank, whatever. Pitiful.

What do you call "Time Cube" guy? I call him a crackpot. Am I villianizing him? No, I'm disagreeing with him. I think he's comically incompetent in his chosen fields of science, and that he's reached nonsensical conclusions using unreliable and/or delusional methods.

What are my other options, Michael? Are the choices only "agree with time cube" or "villainize time cube" or "publish peer-reviewed paper disproving time cube"?

it will be impossible
for your educated stupid brain to know that
4 different corner harmonic 24 hour Days
rotate simultaneously within a single 4
quadrant rotation of a squared equator
and cubed Earth. The Solar system, the
Universe, the Earth and all humans are
composed of + 0 - antipodes, and equal
to nothing if added as a ONE or Entity.
All Creation occurs between Opposites.
Academic ONEism destroys +0- brain.

Do you agree with time cube?
 
Well, it certainly can't be for Clinger's benefit since it relates to the KINETIC behaviors of plasma and Clinger doesn't have a plasma particle to his name.
Well, you are really obsessed with recording your continued inability to understand that W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection was for magnetic reconnection in a vacuum.


Your belief that magnetic reconnection in a vacuum cannot happen is easily seen to be a delusion:
 
Last edited:
When I confronted you with that paper by Priest ...usual ranting and delusions...
MM repeats his delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!

You have NEVER and COULD NEVER produce particle acceleration ...gibberish snipped...
That is a really stupid statement. This is really simple MM:
Vacuum = no particles = no particles to accelerate :jaw-dropp!
​
As soon as you put a plasma into W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum you of course get acceleration of particles from the electric fields induced by the reconnection.
Read Somov for example: Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Chapter 4. Motion of a Particle in a Field
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
...
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.

But then: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI (etc.)
 
I do find it interesting that you honor his work in double layers and you fail to see how it's not related to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and "reconnection" events in general. :(
I do find it interesting that you honor his work in double layers and you fail to see that it's NOT related to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and "reconnection" events in general. :(

I do find it interesting that you are still obsessing about Alfvén and ignoring the rest of the plasma scientists. :(


I do find it interesting that you are still obsessing about trivial and outdated plasma physics from Alfvén and ignoring the last 30 years of progress in plasma physics. :(

It takes a special ignorance to think that double layers in plasma is related to electrical discharges since electrical discharges are physically impossible in plasmas :jaw-dropp!

It takes a special ignorance to think that double layers in plasma have any relationship to the obsolete term "electrical discharge" that Dungey used in the context of magnetic reconnection.

It takes a special ignorance to think that Alfvén would be so stupid as to think that there were electrical discharges in plasmas, especially since he never wrote about them (or at least you have never cited him doing so).
 
No amount of LYING TO YOURSELF is going to change history.
No amount of LYING TO EVERYONE is going to change history MM.

Dungey associated "reconnection" with "electrical discharges" and flares.
That is your first lie: I have often stated that Dungey associated "reconnection" with "electrical discharges" and flares.
You are continuing with your delusion that Dungey's "electrical discharges" are electrical discharges. They are not.

What an absolutely pathetic argument citing someone who states that you are wrong :jaw-dropp!

Dungey's obsolete usage does not support your delusion.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (4 months and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
    8th November 2011 (4 months and counting)
Bruce CERTAINLY wrote about electrical discharges and solar flare.
Your second lie. I said that the crank Bruce CERTAINLY wrote about electrical discharges and solar flares.

No amount of pure denial can ever change history RC.

And the next lie: I have never denied the history that
  • Dungey described a large current density caused by magnetic reconnection as an 'electrical discharge":
  • Bruce was a crank who was stupid enough to think that actual lightning happening on the Sun.
  • Birkeland never stated that there were electrical discharges on the Sun. He used the images from his experiments as analogies for solar activity. He was very careful to use the term anology throughout his book.
    If someone was stupid enough to think that his pictures were support for physically impossible electrical discharges on the Sun than they would also be stupid enough to believe that:
    The rings of Saturn are electrical discharges :eye-poppi!
    Galaxies are electrical discharges :eye-poppi!
    Planets are created from the solar wind :eek:!
And just who is this Lee? Where is his work citing Bruce? How did he show that there is lightning happening on the Sun?
 
Last edited:
Well, put it this way: The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere, and current flows between them.....
Well, put it this way: You do not know what a CATHODE is and you are demonstrating ignorance of basic astronomy.

No current flows between the Sun and the heliosphere.

Electrially neutral mass (the solar wind) flows out from the Sun to the heliosphere and beyond.
 
Dungey himself coined the term "reconnection' and purposefully associated the process with 'electrical discharges' in plasmas/conductors.

Obsessing about Dungey's obsolete usage does not help you.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (4 months and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
    8th November 2011 (4 months and counting)
Mann and Onel applies Alfven's circuit theory to actual satellite images.
Lying about Mann and Onel and Alfvén does not help you.
Alfvén does not have any "circuit theory".
Mann and Onel do not apply any Alfvén's "circuit theory" to images. They just have 1 reference to the Alfvén and Carlquist paper as a part of a list of previous work using circuit modelling of flares. They never refer to anything inside the paper.

The stupidity of citing Mann and Onel as support for your fantasy is that the paper is about the acceleration of electrons. No electrical discharges!
 
Last edited:
Well, put it this way: You do not know what a CATHODE is and you are demonstrating ignorance of basic astronomy.

No current flows between the Sun and the heliosphere.

That statement is false. It's called solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving charged particles, AKA CURRENT. The moment that current slams into a stationary magnetic field, like the Earth's magnetic field, that current is directed into the Earth!

Electrially neutral mass (the solar wind) flows out from the Sun to the heliosphere and beyond.

It's "electrically neutral" like a lightening bolt is "electrically neutral". It's CURRENT CARRYING plasma.
 
Obsessing about Dungey's obsolete usage does not help you.....

Lying about Mann and Onel and Alfvén does not help you.
Alfvén does not have any "circuit theory".
Mann and Onel do not apply any Alfvén's "circuit theory" to images.....

I've certainly seen pure denial used to defend belief systems in my day, but your use of pure denial if way worse than any creationist I've ever met in cyberspace, and that's saying something. Dungey PERSONALLY linked "reconnection" to "electrical discharges" and solar flares RC. No amount of denial will change history. Likewise Alfven's ENTIRE VIEW OF THE UNIVERSE was based on the application of circuit theory to events in space, including events in the solar atmosphere. Lee made an *EMPIRICAL* (IN THE LAB) connection between iron ion wavelengths like we observe in satellite images and "electrical discharges". Mann and Onel wrote a BEAUTIFUL paper tying all that work together and showing how it relates to solar satellite images. It's a pity you refuse to embrace reality. Hate isn't rational.
 
What do you call "Time Cube" guy? I call him a crackpot. Am I villianizing him? No, I'm disagreeing with him.

Right. That's like starting a conversation with someone by calling them "evil" or "*******" and claiming "Oh, I'm just "disagreeing" with him. BS. It's a cheap shot and you folks use it LIKE A CRUTCH in debate.

I think he's comically incompetent in his chosen fields of science, and that he's reached nonsensical conclusions using unreliable and/or delusional methods.

Ya, but you called Hannes Aflven a crackpot too, and yet where's your Nobel Prize ben? You evidently villianize EVERYONE exactly the same way, you put them ALL IN THE SAME CATEGORY. Someone can be wrong without being a "crackpot" or being "evil" or being "stupid". You make no distinction at all. Everyone that you personally disagree with, including and up to Hannes Alfven is a "crackpot" in your book.
 
That statement is false. It's called solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving charged particles, AKA CURRENT.
That statement is ignorant. An electrical current is a movement of charge, e.g. electrons in a conductor.

The solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving equal amounts of negative and positive particles, AKA NEUTRAL MASS.

It's "electrically neutral" like a lightening bolt is "electrically neutral". It's CURRENT CARRYING plasma.
That is even nore ignorant.
A lightning bolt is a current of electrons (not electrically neutral).

All plasmas are CURRENT CARRYING - they have currents inside them.
A moving plasma (AKA the solar wind) is not a current. It is a mass flow.

The true idiocy is shown by simple examples: An asteroid is made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles. Only an idiot would call an asteroid a current.
I am made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles. When I walk I am not an electrical current :eye-poppi!

Likewise the solar wind is made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles - guess who would call that an electrical current.
 
Last edited:
MM: Cite Alfvén's use of circuit theory in his "ENTIRE VIEW OF THE UNIVERSE"

...usual list of delusions sniipped....
Obsessing about Dungey's obsolete usage yet again does not help you.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (4 months and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
    8th November 2011 (4 months and counting)
But the list includes a new delusion:
MM: Cite Alfvén's use of circuit theory in his "ENTIRE VIEW OF THE UNIVERSE".
​
The statement is at first reading really stupid because Alfvén got the Nobel prize for his work on MHD not circuit theory. You have cited one paper out of his entire work that has a circuit model in it.
 
MM: Cite Lee

Lee made an *EMPIRICAL* (IN THE LAB) connection between iron ion wavelengths like we observe in satellite images and "electrical discharges".
MM: Cite Lee.

The post sounds like a delusion that the Fe ions detected in satellite images are not ions created by the temperatures of greater than 160,000 K (the 171A passband of the TRACE satellite) but are magical Fe ions created by physically impossible electrical discharges.
 
I can see I'm going to be spending more time at Thunderbolts and a lot less time here worrying about ridiculous comments like this:

Obsessing about Dungey's obsolete usage yet again does not help you.

I've seen PITIFUL rationalization in my day, but that is PATHETIC. I can't decide what's worse, the fact RC says stuff like that, and GM claims that discharges cannot occur in "conductors", or the fact that you folks don't lift a finger to correct them. Pitiful.
 
I've seen PITIFUL rationalization in my day, but that is PATHETIC. I can't decide what's worse, the fact RC says stuff like that, and GM claims that discharges cannot occur in "conductors", or the fact that you folks don't lift a finger to correct them. Pitiful.
I've seen PITIFUL ignorance in my day, but that is PATHETIC.
I and GM state the same thing as any one who knows anything about physics would state:
Electrical discharges (e.g. lightning) are physically impossible in conductors such as plasma.
​
You obviously cannot read. There are posts in this thread from other posters agreeing with this basic physics.

The fact is that many decades (59 years ago!) ago Dungey used "electrical discharge" to mean large current density in the magnetic reconnection that he states causes solar flares.
There is no evidence that this term was used other by a few scientists around the same date. It is certainly not in use today (I recall one paper citing Dungey that correcly used his term).
Thus your citation of Dungey is doubly stupid
  • He refutes your claim.
  • His term is obsolete.
P.S.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (4 months and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
    8th November 2011 (4 months and counting)
 
Right. That's like starting a conversation with someone by calling them "evil" or "*******" and claiming "Oh, I'm just "disagreeing" with him. BS. It's a cheap shot and you folks use it LIKE A CRUTCH in debate.

Nope. I've had lots of debates here (including with people I disagreed strongly with) whom I did not call crackpots. I call you a crackpot because I think you're a crackpot.

Ya, but you called Hannes Aflven a crackpot too, and yet where's your Nobel Prize ben?

Yes, I think Alfven (after a successful career in plasma theory) lost some his critical thinking skills in his old age, and became a crackpot. It's not uncommon---Brian Josephson did exactly the same thing.

But it's not a generic label for disagreement. Kary Mullis is wacky, but he's not a crackpot, I think. James Watson believes a number of things I disagree with (to put it mildly) but he's not a crackpot.
 
Considering you STILL believe that the color of the horizon is somehow related to an alignment problem in an iron line composite image, and electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors, you have no right to complain about anyone and what they know or don't know about a solar satellite image.
Still wrong, MM.
The green line in that PR image is due to the (mis)alignment of the separate images used to create the image. That is what the creators of the image state.
Electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors (they require the breakdown of a dielectric medium).

Some of the posters on the Thunderbolts site are ignorant of what solar images contain. For example, one repeats your delusion that the TRACE images from light emitted from Fe ions at a temperature of > 160,000 K are images of an iron surface below the photosphere :jaw-dropp!

As for the suthors of the Thunderbolts site
 
Alfvén was awarded the Nobel prize for:

Nobel Committee said:
for fundamental work and discoveries in magnetohydrodynamics with fruitful applications in different parts of plasma physics


And although he may have had some strange ideas (especially near the end of his life), he will never be forgotten in physics because of his development of MHD, and his insights in plasma physics for things like double layers and the critical ionization velocity as well as setting up a great experimental plasma laboratory at the Royal Institue of Technology in Stockholm, Sweden, which now carries his name.
When crackpots claim the authority of legitimate scientists, and we accept that claim uncritically, we dishonor those scientists.

We should never trust what Michael Mozina says about Hannes Alfvén. He's no more likely to be right about Alfvén than anything else.

Speaking of Michael Mozina, I see he's been repeating several other memes:

When I confronted you with that paper by Priest and I pointed out two EXACT *AND HIGHLY RELEVANT* CHICKEN SCRATCHINGS where particle kinetic energy (aka CURRENT) was being turned into magnetic monopole wine, you all IGNORED IT, particularly and most importantly YOU PERSONALLY!
Michael Mozina asserts that relevance on the basis of his own authority, which is to say with no authority whatever.

It's obvious that my calculations stand or fall on their own merit, independent of anything Priest may have written. If Priest made a mistake (and we have no reason to assume he did, apart from Michael Mozina's assertion, which is to say we have no reason at all), then Priest's mistake is relevant to my calculations only if I made the same mistake, in which case Michael Mozina should be pointing to my mistake instead of bleating about Priest.

As it happens, Michael Mozina's "magnetic monopole wine" proclaims the irrelevance of his argument. Although many here have told Mozina that monopoles have absolutely nothing to do with my calculations, and I have provided Michael Mozina with several different mathematical proofs of that fact on at least half a dozen occasions, Michael Mozina continues to speak of monopoles, which he associates with Priest's paper.

And so, whenever Michael Mozina speaks of monopoles or refers to the paper by Priest, he is proclaiming his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.

Your math is meaningless without plasma. It's not "reconnection" of any *THING* because you have no *THING* that could possibly produce particle kinetic energy. You left out the MOST IMPORTANT THING. You left out the PHYSICS!
Ignorant shouting is not a scientific argument.

Ignorant shouting is, however, an effective way for Michael Mozina to proclaim his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.

The rest of your response isn't worth responding to because it is a personal attack against an individual because you cannot and never have produce a PUBLISHED WORK to support your nonsense.
That's another bare assertion by Michael Mozina, with no more basis than his own authority, which is to say with no basis at all.

Consider, for example, the paper DeiRenDopa cited yesterday:
D I Pontin. Theory of magnetic reconnection in solar and astrophysical plasmas. To appear in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.​
In the second paragraph of Pontin's section 2.1, Pontin confirms that magnetic field lines can begin or end at null points. That's a soon-to-be-published work that supports what Michael Mozina refers to as my "nonsense".

Whenever Michael Mozina says I can't support my claims with published works, he is proclaiming his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.

There you go, right back to attacking the individual and NOT DEALING with that actual math formulas I cited from Priest's work. You personally cannot and never will deal with those two formulas and their relevancy to this discussion. Therefore you will continue to attack *INDIVIDUALS* blindly, with hatred and malice, and you'll believe you're doing someone some good at the level of "science". You're only deluding yourself IMO. People can see for themselves how you have run from the two PRIEST equations by DISTRACTING the conversation. You can't handle the science. Therefore you attack the individual. If you want to discuss any math equations with me, start by addressing the two I cited from Priests Paper, and YOU TELL ME what they mean! I already cited the relevant work. If you're a "scientist", let's focus on the RELEVANT PHYSICS from Priest and get to it. Are you capable of actually discussing the PHYSICS, yes or no? If so, demonstrate it.
Coming from Michael Mozina, that's pretty funny.

Michael Mozina has never demonstrated any ability to discuss the relevant math or physics. When Michael Mozina complains about personal attacks in lieu of physics, he's just hoping to distract our attention from his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.

This place is one giant, constant, relentless personal assault. That's all you folks understand. Science? What science do you understand?
Oh, dear.

Shall we help him out?

This is science:
[size=+2]∇ × B = μ0J[/size]​

This is a personal assault:
[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/ae/Healthywealthy.jpg[/qimg]​
 
Michael Mozina said:
That statement is false. It's called solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving charged particles, AKA CURRENT.
That statement is ignorant. An electrical current is a movement of charge, e.g. electrons in a conductor.

The solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving equal amounts of negative and positive particles, AKA NEUTRAL MASS.

[...]

All plasmas are CURRENT CARRYING - they have currents inside them.
A moving plasma (AKA the solar wind) is not a current. It is a mass flow.

The true idiocy is shown by simple examples: An asteroid is made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles. Only an idiot would call an asteroid a current.
I am made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles. When I walk I am not an electrical current :eye-poppi!

Likewise the solar wind is made of equal amounts of negative and positive particles - guess who would call that an electrical current.

Say it isn't so, RC, say it isn't so.

Did MM really, truly, write that? Is he truly so profoundly ignorant?

Let's see now ... the Gulf Stream is a several miles per hour stream of charged particles (sodium and chloride ions, among others). Per MM-logic, "AKA CURRENT" (as in, electrical current). I wonder how many million volts Jamaica is, with respect to Iceland and Ireland? And which is the cathode (or is it CATHODE)?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom