Alfvén was awarded the Nobel prize for:
Nobel Committee said:
for fundamental work and discoveries in magnetohydrodynamics with fruitful applications in different parts of plasma physics
And although he may have had some strange ideas (especially near the end of his life), he will never be forgotten in physics because of his development of MHD, and his insights in plasma physics for things like
double layers and the
critical ionization velocity as well as setting up a great experimental plasma laboratory at the Royal Institue of Technology in Stockholm, Sweden, which now carries his name.
When crackpots claim the authority of legitimate scientists, and we accept that claim uncritically, we dishonor those scientists.
We should never trust what
Michael Mozina says about Hannes Alfvén. He's no more likely to be right about Alfvén than anything else.
Speaking of
Michael Mozina, I see he's been repeating several other memes:
When I confronted you with that paper by Priest and I pointed out two EXACT *AND HIGHLY RELEVANT* CHICKEN SCRATCHINGS where particle kinetic energy (aka CURRENT) was being turned into magnetic monopole wine, you all IGNORED IT, particularly and most importantly YOU PERSONALLY!
Michael Mozina asserts that relevance on the basis of his own authority, which is to say with no authority whatever.
It's obvious that
my calculations stand or fall on their own merit, independent of anything Priest may have written. If Priest made a mistake (and we have no reason to assume he did, apart from
Michael Mozina's assertion, which is to say we have no reason at all), then Priest's mistake is relevant to
my calculations only if I made the same mistake, in which case
Michael Mozina should be pointing to my mistake instead of bleating about Priest.
As it happens,
Michael Mozina's "magnetic monopole wine" proclaims the irrelevance of his argument. Although many here have told Mozina that monopoles have absolutely nothing to do with
my calculations, and I have provided
Michael Mozina with several different mathematical proofs of that fact on at least half a dozen occasions,
Michael Mozina continues to speak of monopoles, which he associates with Priest's paper.
And so, whenever
Michael Mozina speaks of monopoles or refers to the paper by Priest, he is proclaiming
his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.
Your math is meaningless without plasma. It's not "reconnection" of any *THING* because you have no *THING* that could possibly produce particle kinetic energy. You left out the MOST IMPORTANT THING. You left out the PHYSICS!
Ignorant shouting is not a scientific argument.
Ignorant shouting is, however, an effective way for
Michael Mozina to proclaim
his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.
The rest of your response isn't worth responding to because it is a personal attack against an individual because you cannot and never have produce a PUBLISHED WORK to support your nonsense.
That's another bare assertion by
Michael Mozina, with no more basis than his own authority, which is to say with no basis at all.
Consider, for example, the paper
DeiRenDopa cited yesterday:
In the second paragraph of Pontin's section 2.1, Pontin confirms that magnetic field lines can begin or end at null points. That's a soon-to-be-published work that supports what
Michael Mozina refers to as my "nonsense".
Whenever
Michael Mozina says I can't support my claims with published works, he is proclaiming
his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.
There you go, right back to attacking the individual and NOT DEALING with that actual math formulas I cited from Priest's work. You personally cannot and never will deal with those two formulas and their relevancy to this discussion. Therefore you will continue to attack *INDIVIDUALS* blindly, with hatred and malice, and you'll believe you're doing someone some good at the level of "science". You're only deluding yourself IMO. People can see for themselves how you have run from the two PRIEST equations by DISTRACTING the conversation. You can't handle the science. Therefore you attack the individual. If you want to discuss any math equations with me, start by addressing the two I cited from Priests Paper, and YOU TELL ME what they mean! I already cited the relevant work. If you're a "scientist", let's focus on the RELEVANT PHYSICS from Priest and get to it. Are you capable of actually discussing the PHYSICS, yes or no? If so, demonstrate it.
Coming from
Michael Mozina, that's pretty funny.
Michael Mozina has never demonstrated any ability to discuss
the relevant math or physics. When
Michael Mozina complains about personal attacks in lieu of physics, he's just hoping to distract our attention from
his near-total ignorance of the relevant science.
This place is one giant, constant, relentless personal assault. That's all you folks understand. Science? What science do you understand?
Oh, dear.
Shall we help him out?
This is
science:
[size=+2]∇ × B = μ0J[/size]
This is a personal assault:
[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/ae/Healthywealthy.jpg[/qimg]