Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Huh?I'm not bitching about induction equations, I'm bitching about the fact that the mainstream insists on "dumbing down" an ELECTROMAGNETIC process in plasma to ONE orientation, in this case the B orientation.
Once again you show your inability to understand the physics.
There is no dumbing down. The fact is that the "E orientation" canot be used in plasma physics as explained by Tim Thompson.
The reason is simple to state:
The equivalence between the E & B orientation in Maxwell's equations is broken by the addition of Newton's laws in plasma physics.
​
 
On the Solar Neutron-Star Core II

Reference my post On the Solar Neutron-Star Core and Mozina's response Post #6343. Mozina's response indicates a rather extreme misunderstanding of my post.

Your entire post seems to be tilting at windmills of your own design, and you expect me to EXPLAIN the INNER STRUCTURE of the neutron to you before you'll accept that they are STABLE UNDER GRAVITATIONAL PRESSURE, even though the MEASUREMENTS we've made recently show that they ARE stable, even MORE STABLE that first imagined.


I have no clue where all of this comes from. I never suggested that you need to explain the internal structure of a neutron at all, neither to my satisfaction, or anyone else. And I certainly never even hinted at the suggestion that they are not stable under gravitational pressure. If they were not, then neutron stars would not exist at all, and you never saw me suggest they don't. None of this is relevant to anything I said, and seems to me nothing more than an attempt to deflect the reader's attention away from the main point.

To begin with, this description of how neutrons avoid compression is not logically self consistent. After all, if you are going to argue that electrostatic repulsion of the negative outer layer is the explanation for neutron-neutron repulsion, then why don't you argue with equal force that the positive inner layer is electrostatically attracted to the negative core and negative outer layer, destroying the layered structure altogether?
I don't see how that's a logical argument frankly. I'm simply noting that neutrons have *INTERNAL STRUCTURE* that allows them to have a negative charge on the OUTSIDE, the side they present to protons, other neutrons and the world around them.


I explained the logic of the argument already.

Mozina's model of neutron-neutron repulsion relies on a classical interpretation of electromagnetism, the low-energy limit where Maxwell's equations rule.


The internal charge structure of a neutron is not physically possible in the context of classical electromagnetism and Maxwell's equations. Indeed, atoms are equally impossible under the same constraint, which was one of the original primary motivations behind the development of quantum mechanics.

It's simply a "what's on the outside of the shell" in terms of the MOST RELEVANT charge that it presents to the outside world, in this case a relatively NEGATIVE charge. This probably explains why it's attracted to protons, and why it's capable of repulsing other neutrons so efficiently under pressure.


That is where your logic fails. That is where you are self contradictory. The internal charge structure of the neutron is impossible in a classical interpretation of electromagnetism. But your claim that the charge distribution is probably responsible for the neutron's attraction to protons or repulsion from other neutrons requires a classical interpretation of electromagnetism. And you totally ignore the nuclear strong force, which cannot possibly be mistaken for electromagnetism, since it has an exponential Yukawa potential, which is the real and well known reason why neutrons are attracted to protons and to other neutrons. And you totally ignore the pressure from the Pauli Exclusion Principle, which is the real reason that neutrons (or any other fermions) will repel each other under extreme pressure. And you totally ignore the fact that gravity always overwhelms all other forces under the appropriate extreme circumstances. That's the point.
 
Plasma Physics: "E orientation" or "B orientation"? IV

Once again you show your inability to understand the physics.
There is no dumbing down. The fact is that the "E orientation" canot be used in plasma physics as explained by Tim Thompson.
The reason is simple to state:
The equivalence between the E & B orientation in Maxwell's equations is broken by the addition of Newton's laws in plasma physics.
​


Mozina's last response to me on these posts appears in post #6159 near the bottom of page 154. That is where I gave up. His responses on the "E" vs "B" topic are irrational, unreasonable and totally ignore all of the physics as if it did not exist at all. Indeed, in one of his responses we find this little gem:

It's just hero worship Tim, nothing more. I got over my hero worship of Alfven. I suggest you take Parker off that soapbox before you hurt yourself.


Mozina has little to offer but hero worship, and yet sees fit to accuse me of doing exactly what he does. It's not hero worship, it's simply physics, and I have given detail & reference to the real physics in the posts referenced here. Mozina ignores the physics and it is impossible to get him to admit that there is even any physics there ...

No there isn't Tim. You simply made another of your many HANDWAVES about why you personally (or some authority figure you personally WORSHIP) thinks one orientation has merit over another IN SOME circumstances. So what?


Well, there you have it. According to Mozina, appealing to the classical physics of Isaac Newton is "one of many HANDWAVES". It is not possible to engage Mozina in an intelligent conversation on the "E" vs "B" orientation.
 
My point is that what you're calling a "coronal loop" is nothing more than a Bennett pinch that is part of a "circuit" of current. That's why I have no problem calling it "current reconnection" or "circuit reconnection" when the topology changes over time.

Exactly what "topology changes over time"? Can you not even type it? The topology of the magnetic fields perchance? Indeed circuits do have a topology, though their circuitry is not inherent to that topology. One can just organize the components differently, a different 'circuit topology' and have the same circuit. Topology deals with fields much like a field of grass and the underlying topology. In these cases though, it is vectors not grass in the fields. A different topology changes where the vectors point. A concept I think you have yet to recognize


That is where your logic fails. That is where you are self contradictory. The internal charge structure of the neutron is impossible in a classical interpretation of electromagnetism. But your claim that the charge distribution is probably responsible for the neutron's attraction to protons or repulsion from other neutrons requires a classical interpretation of electromagnetism. And you totally ignore the nuclear strong force, which cannot possibly be mistaken for electromagnetism, since it has an exponential Yukawa potential, which is the real and well known reason why neutrons are attracted to protons and to other neutrons. And you totally ignore the pressure from the Pauli Exclusion Principle, which is the real reason that neutrons (or any other fermions) will repel each other under extreme pressure. And you totally ignore the fact that gravity always overwhelms all other forces under the appropriate extreme circumstances. That's the point.


Yep, It seems Michael Mozina has taken a somewhat new tact. Claiming no preference for E or B configurations, but clearly demonstrating the former. To such extent where even apparently degeneracy pressure and quantum mechanical applications are even supplicant to electromagnetic fields. Futile and obvious is this new tactic to attempt to ascribe to others the opposite of the denial that is , at least here, only his. Guess we can give up on QCD and Quantum field theory as Electroweak (emphasis on electro) must somehow dominate.
 
He started with Maxwell's equations, which are concise mathematical statements of basic physics.

No, it's just "math" until you add the PHYSICAL ITEMS it relates to, in this case CHARGED PARTICLES, AKA current, AKA plasma.

Then he deduced magnetic reconnection from these.

Unfortunately he started *WITHOUT* plasma and all he got was 0+0=0 and he demonstrated that particular point is NOT SPECIAL in that regard.

That is how doing real physics works.

No, he left *OUT* the physics. All you got was math devoid of any physics.

Apparently, the data are irrelevant. To you, not to us. We are on the side of the court where all of the data are.

Ya know....

I got to tell you that it's a wee discouraging to have gone all the trouble of "speaking your mathematical geek speak", by pointing out the *EXACT TWO FORMULAS* where your "High Priest of MR theory" turned particle kinetic energy, aka CURRENT into discrete magnetic UNITS at the point of "reconnection/electrical discharge" from the Z axis to the X,Y plane. Did it matter to any of you? No. You don't care that the PLASMA PHYSICAL PROCESS requires CURRENT or PARTICLES. It's all irrelevant from your perspective just because you saw a little math that amounted to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that the POINT ITSELF is NOT SPECIAL in any way, shape or form. Hoy Vey.

What's the point of pointing out the EXACT FORMULAS where the WATER CURRENT is turned into MAGNETIC WINE, if none you give a hoot about the PHYSICS that is REQUIRED to get an *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* to the X,Y axis, and thereby achieve "reconnection"?
 
The data are irrelevant to Michael Mozina. The rest of us know full well that magnetic reconnection is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations, and can be demonstrated under controlled laboratory conditions, within a vacuum, using magnetic fields that are generated by ordinary direct currents confined to wires that lie outside the vacuum chamber or region in which the magnetic reconnection occurs.

No, you're all DELUDED into believing some sort of equivocation fallacy where it doesn't matter in your MATH ONLY world that you NEED PLASMA PHYSICS and physical things to get "reconnection".

What is the point of me, of speaking your language, going through that paper by Priest, and showing you folks exactly WHERE IT TIED INTO YOUR WORK, and HOW IT REQUIRES CURRENT in the two equations I cited? You're all still simply ignoring reality altogether! Plasma PHYSICS and plasma physical processes like "reconnection" require PLASMA. Plasma *ISN'T OPTIONAL*. No Plasma, no DISCHARGE, no RECONNECTION, nothing in those two equations I cited from Priests paper. ZIP!
 
Last edited:
FYI, it's going to be a busy day for me today. I'll try to post as I can, but I'll probably have to wait till after work to respond to most of you. Don't take it personally. :)
 
Exactly what "topology changes over time"? Can you not even type it? The topology of the magnetic fields perchance?

They are two TWISTERS of flowing CURRENT including magnetic field energy PINCHING the filament into that THREAD. It's a lot more than SIMPLE MAGNETIC LINE. That's the point IMO. It's like equating a couple of tornadoes to "magnetic lines" and then calling it "magnetic reconnection".

Indeed circuits do have a topology, though their circuitry is not inherent to that topology.

The current flows along the loop and that is the "topology" of the current. If two current channels "reconnect" and there's a topology change in the CURRENT, it's still "current reconnection" every bit as much as it is "magnetic reconnection". The total MAXIMUM amount of energy that can be released in that short circuit process is directly related to the TOTAL CIRCUIT ENERGY of BOTH CIRCUITS.
 
Last edited:
No, it's just "math" until you add the PHYSICAL ITEMS it relates to, in this case CHARGED PARTICLES, AKA current, AKA plasma.


Math isn't just a bunch of hieroglyphics and chicken scratchin's as some against-the-mainstream advocates seem to perceive it. It's the language of physics. It's what makes objective, quantitative communication about physics possible. "Math" describes the PHYSICAL ITEMS it relates to, with or without the shouting and scare quotes.

Unfortunately he started *WITHOUT* plasma and all he got was 0+0=0 and he demonstrated that particular point is NOT SPECIAL in that regard.


Understanding physics requires being able to count higher than zero.

No, he left *OUT* the physics. All you got was math devoid of any physics.


No. He described the physics in the language of physics. People who don't understand the language may perceive the math as a bunch of squiggly lines or Chinese characters, but it really is physics.

Ya know....

I got to tell you that it's a wee discouraging to have gone all the trouble of "speaking your mathematical geek speak", [...]


I've been following this thread since before it began, and I haven't noticed any electric Sun advocates explaining the conjecture by "speaking your mathematical geek speak".

[...] by pointing out the *EXACT TWO FORMULAS* where your "High Priest of MR theory" turned particle kinetic energy, aka CURRENT into discrete magnetic UNITS at the point of "reconnection/electrical discharge" from the Z axis to the X,Y plane. Did it matter to any of you? No. You don't care that the PLASMA PHYSICAL PROCESS requires CURRENT or PARTICLES. It's all irrelevant from your perspective just because you saw a little math that amounted to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that the POINT ITSELF is NOT SPECIAL in any way, shape or form. Hoy Vey.


That looks a lot more like a complaint than an argument. And it's certainly not a quantitative objective explanation of the alleged science that makes any electric Sun conjectures physically plausible.

What's the point of pointing out the EXACT FORMULAS where the WATER CURRENT is turned into MAGNETIC WINE, if none you give a hoot about the PHYSICS that is REQUIRED to get an *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* to the X,Y axis, and thereby achieve "reconnection"?


And that's just gibberish, a collection of what appears to be English words that sort of look a little sciency, with shouting, quote marks, and asterisks for effect, but totally meaningless in every way.
 
Last edited:
Math isn't just a bunch of hieroglyphics and chicken scratchin's as some against-the-mainstream advocates seem to perceive it. It's the language of physics.

It might as well be chicken scratching to most of you since not one of you really cares about it. I took the time and made the effort to isolate the exact two mathematical formulas where Priest turned his current into discrete magnetic units (monopoles). It's not useful to point out the relevant math to you personally because you never acknowledge it or deal with it. "Discharges? What discharges?". You guys don't REALLY honor Dungey's work, just HALF OF IT, the HALF YOU LIKE! You don't care about the chicken scratching really, you just want to watch me do some chicken scratching personally so you can bitch about how *I* do it, as though *I* am even relevant.
 
Last edited:
It might as well be chicken scratching to most of you since not one of you really cares about it. I took the time and made the effort to isolate the exact two mathematical formulas where Priest turned his current into discrete magnetic units (monopoles). It's not useful to point out the relevant math to you personally because you never acknowledge it or deal with it. "Discharges? What discharges?".


So far there has been a complete failure to point out any math, relevant or otherwise, that shows how a lightning-like electrical discharge can occur within the conducting medium of the solar atmosphere. As long as that's the "electrical discharge" under discussion, nobody who understands physics, or even the basics of how electricity works, is going to agree that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by electrical discharges.

You guys don't REALLY honor Dungey's work, just HALF OF IT, the HALF YOU LIKE! You don't care about the chicken scratching really, you just want to watch me do some chicken scratching personally so you can bitch about how *I* do it, as though *I* am even relevant.


The reason anyone wants to see the electric Sun advocates present their own math is because all they have offered so far is irrelevant, grossly misunderstood, obsolete, or dishonestly cherry picked material from other people's work. There is no indication that they even understand the math they're claiming supports their conjectures. There has been an abject failure to describe the position in an understandable, even remotely linear way, quantitatively, so people knowledgeable in the field may independently assess the description and come to some objective agreement that the physics is even valid.

Oh, and "as though"? I don't think there's any controversy at all on that point.
 
So far there has been a complete failure to point out any math, relevant or otherwise, that shows how a lightning-like electrical discharge can occur within the conducting medium of the solar atmosphere.

PURE *UNADULTERATED* DENIAL OF FACT! Dungey *PERSONALLY* did that himself! It's a pity you didn't acknowledge it. Bruce did it. Birkeland did it too actually.

Pure denial is such an ugly thing. Creationists have nothing on EU haters. The DENIAL factor with EU haters is simply off scale. "Electrical Discharges in plasma? What Discharges?". Without denial, you're stuck with embracing the reality of Dungey's REAL work. You can't accept Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge in a plasma because it occurs *BY DEFINITION* in his definition. :) Round and round that denial-around goes, where it stops *NOBODY* knows.

Lee made that very same connection to electrical discharges and iron ion wavelengths of light *EMPIRICALLY* by the way. Your wimpy MR theory scored 1 of 7 and NOTHING as it relates to the ionization states of iron! What utter denial.
 
Last edited:
PURE *UNADULTERATED* DENIAL OF FACT! Dungey *PERSONALLY* did that himself! It's a pity you didn't acknowledge it. Bruce did it. Birkeland did it too actually.
PURE *UNADULTERATED* DENIAL OF FACT! Dungey *PERSONALLY DID NOT* that himself!
The crank Bruce did it.
Birkeland did not do it too actually.
 
Maxwell's equations have been verified to explain how the electric and magnetic fields behave under non-quantum-scale conditions. Once the experiements verify that the fields behave according to what the equations say, they become more than just mathematical equations. They now are known to describe the physics. They, in effect, have become the physics.

There is no need for any ions or anything for these equations to describe how the fields behave. You just don't understand physics. Many of us have grad degrees in physics or are even employed to do physics every day and do understand. That you are unwilling to learn from us is your problem, not ours.
 
Unfortunately he started *WITHOUT* plasma and all he got was 0+0=0 and he demonstrated that particular point is NOT SPECIAL in that regard.
...usual gibberish snipped...
MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement
First asked 5th December 2011 (82 days ago and counting).

What point?
Why is that point NOT SPECIAL?

Your position remains rather insane because W.D. Clinger showed that from Maxwell's equations you can get magnetic reconnection in a system of magnetic fields in a vacuum.

We do not even have to trust W.D. Clinger math since MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II includes REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES to MR in vacuum (where field lines also break and reconnect):
Somov's book describes reconnection in a vacuum but then you cannot understand even the English in it (forget about the science and math!)
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI
 
No, you're all DELUDED into believing ...usual rant snipped...
No you are the one DELUDED into believing that magnetic reconenction in a vaccuum cannot happen.

Standard electromagnetism states that you are wrong: magnetic reconnection is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations.


The plasma physics textbooks say that you are wrong:
The published literature says that you are wrong
 
MM repeats his delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper

I took the time and made the effort to isolate the exact two mathematical formulas where Priest turned his current into discrete magnetic units (monopoles).
Repeating your delusions about the Priest paper does not make them correct.
You took the time and made the effort to demonstrate that you cannot understand the science, math or even the English in that paper :eye-poppi.

At no point do they turn a current into monopoles.

Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper V


The main problems with your understanding of the paper are
  1. A multipole expansion of an equation is a standard mathematical technique. It results in a series of equations each labeled by l=0,1,2,etc. The values of l are called monopole, dipole, quadrupole, etc terms.
  2. Demoulin & Priest are careful to call the sources of their l=0 (monopole) approximation 'magnetic charges' - including the quotes.
  3. They explicitly prove that there can be no isolated 'magnetic charges' for a linear force-free field, i.e. no actual monopoles.
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV

Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper III, etc.


The current is a consequence of the magnteic field in the paper because it is caused by the magnteic field (equation 15). Read section 3 and note that before section 3 no currents are mentioned:
  1. Starts with equation 15
  2. Applies Ampere's theorem to get equation 16 (the current)
  3. Applies Gauss' theorem to get equations 17 and 18 (the magnetic charge densities).
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper II
 
Hey, Mozina:
Still waiting for you to explain the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

Or, since you love the "E side" so much, explain the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E[/latex]

:whistling
 
You don't care about the chicken scratching really, you just want to watch me do some chicken scratching personally so you can bitch about how *I* do it, as though *I* am even relevant.
You underestimate both your relevance and the relevance of your inability to scratch chickens.

Let's look at just one small example. With my highlighting:

Clingers MATHS amount to NOTHING. Literally! They literally amount to 0+0=0 in the absence of all plasma There's NOTHING that could BEGIN there. There's NOTHING that could end there. It's nothing more than an *ORDINARY NULL* and a NULL is absolutely, positively *NOT* the beginning of anything.
You posted that on 2 December 2011. I believe that was the start of your "0+0=0" meme.

You may have forgotten what you meant by "0+0=0", so I'll remind you. Your "0+0=0" is not a quotation. It is your own personal shorthand for your own personal incredulity that direct currents at some distance from the (arbitrary) origin of a Cartesian coordinate system could generate magnetic fields within a vacuum in the neighborhood of that origin. You think plasma is required.

Because your "0+0=0" argument is based on nothing more than your personal incredulity, your personal knowledge of the relevant physics became an essential foundation of your "0+0=0" argument. As is obvious from your ranting about the impossibility of magnetic fields sans plasma at some distance from any currents, you don't know what Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem mean.

Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem are essential parts of any decent freshman-level course on electromagnetism. Since you do not understand Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem, you do not understand freshman-level electromagnetism. Since freshman-level electromagnetism is prerequisite for plasma physics, and you do not understand freshman-level electromagnetism, you do not understand plasma physics, no matter how many books you claim to have read on that subject, and no matter how many times you claim to have understood those books.

Every time you repeat your "0+0=0" meme, you proclaim your near-total ignorance of basic electromagnetism (hence plasma physics).

You have reminded us often:

Been there, done that for a year now. 0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there.

Clinger's whole presentation is one giant "bait and switch" routine. He's SWAPPING out the physics of B fields and INSERTING in the physics related to E fields to play games with vector calculus that amounts to 0+0=0 in the absence of all plasma.

Clinger handwaves a little math that he personally seems to think is the "be all-end-all" of mathematics, when in fact it's BASIC STUFF. It amounts to exactly 0+0=0 in a vacuum. PERIOD. That CONCLUSIVELY DEMONSTRATES THAT NOTHING could reconnect there. NOTHING could begin there. NOTHING could end there.

Yep, you argue JUST EXACTLY LIKE A CREATIONIST alright. Your wussy maths amount to 0+0=0 and your Origin the DUD is a false god.

Clinger has been handwaving nothing but mathematical NONSENSE at me based on a SERIES of freshman *THEORETICAL* mistakes about BASIC EM theory. Nothing could ever 'begin' at Origin the NOTHING. His fancy looking equations amount to 0+0=0 in the absence of plasma.

All they will find there is KLUDGED NONSENSE and vector equations that amount to 0+0=0, proving conclusively that NOTHING could "begin" there or anywhere else.

Your simplistic vector calculus amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum, and you've KLUDGED EM theory since the moment you claimed B lines "begin" somewhere.

His math amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum. Miraculously this revelation somehow in his mind translates to: "Look, it's the "beginning" of a B line." It's a non-sequitur fallacy. He might as well be claiming that same 0+0=0 math proves that the moon is made of green cheese!

What you consider "proof" is a mathematical demonstration that 0+0=0! You utterly ignored the need for PHYSICAL PLASMA to get an "electrical discharge/reconnection" process, not just MATH! Holy cow!

Unfortunately he started *WITHOUT* plasma and all he got was 0+0=0 and he demonstrated that particular point is NOT SPECIAL in that regard.

....You don't care that the PLASMA PHYSICAL PROCESS requires CURRENT or PARTICLES. It's all irrelevant from your perspective just because you saw a little math that amounted to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that the POINT ITSELF is NOT SPECIAL in any way, shape or form. Hoy Vey.


You have found nothing wrong with the math and physics you've been ranting about. You invented your own strawman, put it in quotes so you could pretend someone else had said it, and repeated it often. That's how you argue.

There's a reason you argue like that: You don't understand the math or the physics. Your inability to scratch chickens or "bark math" is relevant because it's the reason you can't put together a reasoned scientific argument.

You are relevant, Michael Mozina. No other contributor to this forum has done so much to discredit Electric Sun and Electric Universe pseudoscience. Keep up the good work.
 
You underestimate both your relevance and the relevance of your inability to scratch chickens.

... 0 + 0 = 0 ...

You are relevant, Michael Mozina. No other contributor to this forum has done so much to discredit Electric Sun and Electric Universe pseudoscience. Keep up the good work.

The above is an insightful observation. It is possible that some naive layman, exposed to some slick and facile introduction to EU theory, might be momentarily seduced by a more persuasive crackpot. Mozina has amply demonstrated the absurdity of EU theory by being a poster boy for its non-scientific bedlam. He indeed does not scratch chickens and bark math because of his profound ignorance, which he amply demonstrates for all laymen to see, thereby highlighting the comical madness of EU conjectures.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom