Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Er, no. We have nothing but more HERESAY claims that were made by GM. This is also the same guy who made an utterly BOGUS claim about the green color above the "transition region" of a standard composite image being due to a "misalignment" of RGB images.
Er, no. We have:
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.
I have contacted the SDO science team at NASA and have received word back on the image that occupied pretty much all of Michael's attention for the past week. Since he first started crowing about his discovery, over a thousand posts have gone by. During that time Michael has been insulting, belligerent, ignorant of relevant questions, badgering, uncivil, and treated pretty much everyone in this discussion like crap.

Here's the word straight from NASA. When they map the color values, the behavior of the pixels outside the limb is treated differently than the portion of the image over the disk. A gradient filter is applied to the image so the off-disk area will be enhanced to bring out details. That filter causes a discontinuity at the apparent limb because of a slight inequality of the radius of the filter and the solar image.


The green line is there because of the processing. In this image, which I sent along with my communication in order to get a definitive reply, you see arrow "A" pointing to the edge of the filter applied in the image processing software. The arrow "B" is pointing to what amounts to the actual limb of the Sun. The apparent roughness of that "B" edge is due to the emissions picked up by the three filters used to make the composite, all of which are coming from above the photosphere.
(the image is no longer in imageshack)

Plus the fact that this is a PR image (thus manipluated further to make it pretty) and so it is insane to analyse it.

Plus your laziness in not confirming GeeMack's post with the NASA team.
 
It's been just about two years since NASA informed us, thanks to GeeMack, that Michael was counting pixels in a processing artifact and calling it the surface of the sun. And he still persists. Michael is the tenacious bulldog of fractal wrongness.


Also there has never been a quantitative objective explanation offered as to how a RGB composite image plus a gradient overlay can possibly allow us to see through roughly 80,000 kilometers of plasma that would have been opaque without the image processing. :p
 
Because it's solid.

When I look at the sun, it looks brighter than deep space. In fact, when I see unretouched satellite pictures of the sun, it looks like a bright white ball against a dark background.

Can you elaborate on how being solid can make a 5800K ball look darker than 4K space? Why does the surface of the sun appear to be much, much darker than the background stars? Shouldn't it have similar brightness?
 
When I look at the sun, it looks brighter than deep space. In fact, when I see unretouched satellite pictures of the sun, it looks like a bright white ball against a dark background.

Can you elaborate on how being solid can make a 5800K ball look darker than 4K space? Why does the surface of the sun appear to be much, much darker than the background stars? Shouldn't it have similar brightness?

What wavelength(s) are we talking about? That seems to matter.
 
Somewhere in one of these threads Sol *CORRECTLY* explained the scientific definition of the term 'opaque'. I suggest you read it.
There is no scientific defintion of opaque.
Scientist use the term opacity. The opacity of the Sun means that the entire sun would emit an average of 1 photon every 4 years from 3000 km below the surface of the photosphere.

Thus my question: How can we detect the less than 1 photon per year from your iron crust?
I am even being charitable here. Your claim is that you can see light from 4800 km - that would be 1 photon every few 100 million years.
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VII

You folks have *NEVER* provided a PUBLISHED paper or book to corroborate that RIDICULOUS claim.
You are still lying. We have:
MR in a vacuum is described in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
But you have the delusion that he has plasma in his vacuum: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI.

MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:
MR in a vacuum is a simple derivation from Maxwell's equations: to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection

He uses CURRENT because it's "not optional" in the "reconnection" process. The particle acceleration is a PROCESS that is CAUSED by the 'flux changes'.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI.

Somov usues CURRENT it's "not optional" in the "create a magntreic field" process he is describing.

Another delusion :eye-poppi!
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov has no particle acceleration that is caused by 'flux changes'. What he states at the end of the section after describing MR without any plasma is
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic
field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as

the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charged particle or
particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.


In this sense, a collisionless reconnection – the physical process in a hightemperature rarefied plasma such as the solar corona, geomagnetic tail, fusion plasmas, and so on – is simpler for understanding than reconnection in a highly-conducting collisional space plasma
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VIII

MR in a vacuum is described in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
But you persist in the delusion that this section is about MR in plasma. However look at the titles and contents of this section and the next section
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
4.4.3 starts:
Let us try to predict plasma behavior near the X-point as reconnection proceeds on the basis of our knowledge about the motion of a charge particle in given magnetic and electric fields.

Do you really think that Somov was dumb enough to think that a section titled "Reconnection in vacuum" that really contains plasma (according to you) should not be separate from a section titled "Reconnection in plasma".
 
Last edited:
Well, in that case, since you've had two years in which to contact NASA yourself...what did they say about the image when you asked?
You did contact NASA, didn't you Michael?
 
Maybe I'm misinterpreting you, but it seems that if the lines can stretch and twist but can't cross, break, or begin/end at a null, then even in a vacuum you'd get terribly twisted field lines. If we take a simple case of 2 bar magnets with some gap between them, and rotate one of the magnets 360 deg, wouldn't the field lines have to wrap around the magnet:

(pardon the quality of my art)
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=741&pictureid=5700[/qimg]

. . . I really don't think that's what happens, but are you asserting that it does? And if it doesn't, then wouldn't that violate some of your assertions?

P.S. the diagram would be slightly more clear if "N" and "S" didn't look exactly the same when rotated 180 deg.

That's pretty cool! :D

Now what if we rotate the second (right hand) magnet 90 degrees out of the plane of the paper, so that N is facing towards us (the reader). Then spin it round a few tens of thousands of times. Back 90 degrees, spin a few thousand more times. Etc.

Serious spaghetti ...

But, more important, didn't I read that lots of lines squished into a small volume means lots of stored energy? So perhaps MM has discovered a wonderful source of free energy! :jaw-dropp Just get two bar magnets, ...
 
As Sweet pointed out for us, the CONDUCTIVE ENVIRONMENT is REQUIRED in order for that magnetic flux change to induce any CURRENTS, or cause any particle acceleration.
As Maxwell pointed out to us ANY magnetic field change will induce ELECTRICAL FIELDS that can cause any charged particle that is present to accelerate.

Sweet, 1958 is about MR in plasma. The CONDUCTIVE ENVIRONMENT is ASSUMED because the paper is about MR in plasma! The CONDUCTIVE ENVIRONMENT is ASSUMED so that there are particles to be accelerated. The CONDUCTIVE ENVIRONMENT is ASSUMED so that Sweet can model solar flares which have plasma.

Another possible delusion from you: Sweet, 1958 does not mention magnetic flux. So maybe you are thinking about another Sweet paper? If so can you cite it.
 
There are two whole fields until you physically and literally RECONNECT the physical magnets. That that point you've RECONNECTED the PHYSICAL THINGS that can 'reconnect'. The H lines "reconnect" inside the magnet where they touch. The B "lines" were never actually discrete "lines" to begin with, but the whole FIELDS join and become one when you RECONNECT the PHYSICAL magnets. What more is there to explain? We've been through this a dozen or more times now.

We've been through this so many times because you keep repeating the same nonsense. Physical contact is not necessary at all.

Do you agree that figure 1 in dasmiller's picture is a perfectly normal arrangement of magnetic field lines? If so, what happens if you pull those magnets far apart? Do the lines stretch forever?
 
Emphasis mine. Notice that Somov understands the difference between "magnetic fluxes" and the PROCESS he calls "reconnection" which REQUIRES those "currents", AKA *PLASMA PARTICLES*!
is r
OMG. I'm utterly stunned that you can't tell the difference between FLUX and RECONNECTION. Wow! You really should reread Somov's work. You need to listen to the part where he *ADDS CURRENT* to his "flux" to achieve 'reconnection". You evidently missed the part where he adds plasma to get "reconnection" rather than "magnetic fluxes" that do absolutely nothing by themselves. Without particles added to the vacuum, nothing happens. "Reconnection" requires *PARTICLES*.

wow i am stunned that you cannot read that Somov says that "reconnection in vacuum is a real process." Typical MM behaviour, cherry picking and misunderstanding.
 
wow i am stunned that you cannot read that Somov says that "reconnection in vacuum is a real process." Typical MM behaviour, cherry picking and misunderstanding.

Typical MM behaviour, deliberate, cynical, and hypocritical cherry picking and gross, grotesque, and willfully ignorant misunderstanding.

Fixed that for you. ;)
 
Missed this:
People who disagree with you are not necessarily "lying".
You are actually lying because you state that we have not given you any references to MR wthout any plasma (MR in vacuum). We have.
MR in a vacuum is described in Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov. However you still have the delusion that a section titled "Reconnection in vacuum" which describes MR in vacuum is about MR in plasma. You still cannot understand that the next section is titled "Reconnection in plasma" and is about MR in plasma :eye-poppi!
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VIII


MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:
MR in a vacuum is a simple derivation from Maxwell's equations: to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
 
Last edited:
Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.


I agree with most of this, but its the entire concept that I am still unnerved about.

When people start to define things such as the wavelength of the filed lines, and then try to tie down the reconnection rate to physically experimentally testable processes, they are left with an issue. The wavelength is chosen by us. Like contour lines on a map. You could model the magnetic field with say 100 lines in a certain area, or you could use less lines to represent the exactly same vector field, say five. They both represent the same field. So a reconnection rate is surely more dependant on a totally subjective human artefact, a choice made by the person modelling the field. The field lines represent a continuum, not a quantized set of events/lines you can attribute such things as a reconnection rate to, which need a physical basis.

I'm still waiting for someone to show experimental evidence for magnetic reconnection where the wavelength and reconnection rate of the field lines is defined, an then this is matched to experimental data for verification.
 
When people start to define things such as the wavelength of the filed lines, and then try to tie down the reconnection rate ....
Can you give a citation where people do this?

I find no reference to people "defining the wavelength of (magnetic?) field lines" and relating this to reconnection rates.
That seems insane since magnetic field lines are not waves and have no wavelength.

There are papers on reconnection rate on magnetic reconnection that mention observations in multiple wavelengths. Is that what you are talking about?

P.S. There is nothing to get unnerved about. The "entire concept" is quite basic. See for example, W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. Adding plasma and looking at MR in 3D does make the concept complex. That is why there are entire books written about MR.

P.P.S. The field lines represent a continuum. But no one is dumb enough to try to draw an infinite number of field lines! So they just draw a small number of field lines and observe what happens as the magnetic field changes. They observe the the field lines reconnect points - thus magnetic reconnection.
 
Last edited:
The field lines represent a continuum, not a quantized set of events/lines you can attribute such things as a reconnection rate to, which need a physical basis.


Velocity vectors aren't quantized either, but that doesn't stop us from defining acceleration.

Seriously: Rates are derivatives. Derivatives are easier to define for continuous things than for quantized things.

I am not a physicist, and I don't know what the plasma physicists mean when they talk about reconnection rates. I too have seen references to the number of field lines that reconnect per second, which is obviously an informal figure of speech, but there's nothing inherently unmathematical about defining various notions of the rate at which some continuous vector field is changing.
 
I'm still waiting for someone to show experimental evidence for magnetic reconnection where the wavelength and reconnection rate of the field lines is defined, an then this is matched to experimental data for verification.
You are unlikely to get such evidence since "wavelength" seems to be your invention.

But if you want an experiment that matches experimental reconenction rates to the model then look at Experimental test of the Sweet-Parker model of magnetic reconnection
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom