Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael Mozina, can you spell "reconnection rate"

*IF* as you claim, plasma is optional in for reconnection to occur, then plasma would necessarily be optional to describe the rate of reconnection as well. Which is it, one or the other. You can't have it both ways.
Wrong - it is both ways because a reconnection rate is not mandatory fro reconnection to happen.
Your continuous misspelling of reconnection rate suggests that you do not know what it is. It is not a "rate of reconnection". It is a rate of plasma flow caused by reconnection.

Plasma is mandatory for a reconnection rate because otherwise it is undefined. You do not even have to do the math (where it is mathematically undefined :eye-poppi!). All you need to be able to do is read English (Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!).

Plasma is optional in for reconnection to occur as described in the literature, e.g.
And easily seen using undergraduate physics: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection without plasma :eye-poppi !
 
What the heck are you talking about? The "mass density' is necessarily ZERO without plasma RC. You can't use the Lundquist number in the first place because it all relates to current sheets and plasma physics!
You are getting further away from Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!

We cannot use Alfvén velocity in the first place because it relates to plasma physics!
We cannot use the Lundquist number in the second place because it relates to plasma physics!
We cannot use the ________ __________ in the third place because it relates to plasma physics!

Now what is the missing term, Michael Mozina?
A hint: It uses the Lundquist number.
 
Wrong - it is both ways because a reconnection rate is not mandatory fro reconnection to happen.

That's just BS. Reconnection is measure in terms of acceleration of charged particles over time. I'd cite the WIKI link that talks about reconnection *IN PLASMA* again, but you guys have a track record of futzing with Wiki links during a debate. You can't even come up with a rate or reconnection, so your claim 'reconnection happened" is dubious. You have no evidence that anything 'reconnected", rather than just "flux happens".

Your continuous misspelling of reconnection rate suggests that you do not know what it is. It is not a "rate of reconnection". It is a rate of plasma flow caused by reconnection.

I know it's your Waterloo. :)

Plasma is mandatory for a reconnection rate because otherwise it is undefined.

Therefore plasma is also mandatory for reconnection because otherwise it's undefined just like the reconnection RATE is undefined.

You do not even have to do the math (where it is mathematically undefined :eye-poppi!). All you need to be able to do is read English (Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!).

The clearly all state in english that they are based on MHD theory or particles are present in the process.

Plasma is optional in for reconnection to occur as described in the literature, e.g.

That is a false claim which is why you can't describe the rate of reconnection without plasma. Man, talk about denial. You and GM are in a class by yourselves.

Unless and until you come up with a way to express a reconnection RATE without plasma, your claims that plasma are optional are utter unpublished lies as most of your links actually demonstrated since most of them were DIRECTLY expressed in MHD theory. All of them *INCLUDED* and did not EXCLUDE charged particles in the reconnection process. The reason you can't define the reconnection rate without plasma is because there is no reconnection without plasma! It's that simple.
 
Every single image used in our papers comes from NASA and/or LMSAL sources.


In Oliver Manuel's acknowledgements he writes, "NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere." He is claiming NASA and LMSAL provided images showing rigid structures to support his claim that rigid structures exist. It's circular reasoning, a logical fallacy, and dishonest. In truth, NASA and the LMSAL TRACE team did not make any images of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere. Manuel's attribution is untrue, and when used to try to peddle a scientific paper it's fraud. It doesn't matter who chooses to share his blame for the attempt to defraud the scientific community or who chooses to share his failure. It doesn't change the fact that his paper is built on a lie.
 
The doubley jawdropping parts are that
  1. you still have not found out what the definition of magnteic reconection is or are just obsessing with teh Wikipedi definiotion.


  1. Bull. I'm obsessing with PHYSICS:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

    Here's the very first sentence:

    Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.

    Clinger didn't use plasma, didn't convert magnetic energy to kinetic energy and therefore DIDN'T describe 'reconnection'. All he actually managed to describe mathematically is the quadrapolar field and the NULL in that quadrapolar NULL. He did NOT describe reconnection nor the reconnection rate, nor could he ever do so without mass.
 
The papers clearly state that MR in vacuum and MR in plasma exist

That's just BS. Reconnection is measure in terms of acceleration of charged particles over time.
That's just BS. MR in MHD theory (plasma) has a parameter called reconnection rate.

Therefore plasma is also mandatory for reconnection because otherwise it's undefined just like the reconnection RATE is undefined.
How ignorant. Magnetic reconnection is defined as a specific change in magnetic field topology.
Try reading the textbook definitions that Tim Thompson has cited.

The clearly all state in english that they are based on MHD theory or particles are present in the process.
Stiull unable to read, MM.
Each paper clearly states in English that MR in vacuum exists:
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR
They also clearly states in English that MR in plasma exists :jaw-dropp !


Do you get the point?
The papers clearly state that MR in vacuum and MR in plasma exist.
​
That is a false claim which is why you can't describe the rate of reconnection without plasma.
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!

Man talk about unable to read!
 
Last edited:
In Oliver Manuel's acknowledgements he writes, "NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere." He is claiming NASA and LMSAL provided images showing rigid structures to support his claim that rigid structures exist.

They certainly created those images! We used images directly from NASA and LMSAL. The line in question was intended to explain where the images came from, not to suggest everyone or anyone at NASA agreed with our interpretation of the images.

It's circular reasoning, a logical fallacy, and dishonest.

No, what's dishonest is a guy who doesn't even own a book on the topic of plasma physics, that claims that electrical discharges in conductors are impossible, and they don't happen in flares, and who irrationally claims to have some knowledge of solar physics. That's PURE dishonesty.

In truth, NASA and the LMSAL TRACE team did not make any images of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere.

In TRUTH, yes they did as that first light SDO composite image demonstrates. The transition region is located UNDER the surface of the photosphere, not above it. In fact it shows it to be RIGHT where Kosovichev's work predicted it would be located.

Manuel's attribution is untrue,

No, he only attributed the IMAGES to them, not OUR interpretation of those images. He was just trying to explain WHERE the images came from and explain the were not altered in any way, shape or form.

The rest of your post is meaningless nonsense since you don't even personally OWN a book on the topic of plasma physics, therefore you are utterly ignorant of the topic under discussion. That's also why you can't come up with any maths to describe your rate of reconnection without PLASMA. It's also why you're in hardcore denial of Dungey's work that shows that discharges occur in flares. You judgement of me, our paper, our motives, etc, is utterly meaningless. You don't even understand the light source of the original images that the RD images are based upon, nor can you correctly explain the transition region color correctly in a standard composite image. You don't know the first thing about solar physics so your opinions of Manuel and myself are irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Bull. You are obsessing with WIKIPEDIA.

The PHYSICS is that the definition of MR does not contain plasma.

The MATHEMATICS is W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has no plasma :jaw-dropp !

A TEXTBOOK states that MR in vacuum exists: Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov

The Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR (and this fact is so minor that the papers just mention it in passing before going onto the interesting stuff - MR in plasma).
 
Bull. You are obsessing with WIKIPEDIA.

The PHYSICS is that the definition of MR does not contain plasma.

Pure denial. The first sentence describes both the plasma and the kinetic energy transfer. Deal with it.

Clinger's presentation is meaningless since it neither correctly describes the plasma physics process called 'reconnection", nor does it define any kind of reconnection rate. It's unpublished and unpublishable.
 
Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.

Your argument amounts to a combination of an equivocation fallacy and a oversimplification fallacy rolled into one. You're trying to REMOVE the plasma that reconnection occurs in, and REMOVE the kinetic energy transfer from the PROCESS and still call it the same thing. BOLONEY!
 
No, you're still unable to embrace the fact that the vacuum *ISN'T DEVOID OF CHARGED PARTICLES*. You're blatantly lying about that fact.
No, you're still unable to embrace the fact that the MR in vacuum happens where space *IS DEVOID OF CHARGED PARTICLES*.
You're blatantly lying about the fact that the papers mention MR in vacuum as well as MR in plasma:
Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990 (MR in a vacuuum)
Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection (vacuum reconnection)
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection (MR in vacuum)
 
Last edited:
You're trying to REMOVE the plasma that reconnection occurs in, and REMOVE the kinetic energy transfer from the PROCESS and still call it the same thing. BOLONEY!
BOLONEY!

These definitions in textbooks and reviews do not remove the plasma:
Magnetic Reconnection defined and Described.

None of these authors remove the plasma.
Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990 (MR in a vacuuum)
Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection (vacuum reconnection)
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection (MR in vacuum)

This text book does not remove the plasma: Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov (the next section puts the plasma in :jaw-dropp!)

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection starts with no plasma :jaw-dropp !
 
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//...00539.000.html
PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.
OK, I'm ready to discuss the math. Let's go.
 
They certainly created those images! We used images directly from NASA and LMSAL. The line in question was intended to explain where the images came from, not to suggest everyone or anyone at NASA agreed with our interpretation of the images.
I agree with you. NASA and LMSAL created the images.

You an O. Manuel though stated "NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere." and thus demonstrated that you were both ignorant of basic astrophysics:
no light comes from "beneath the fluid photosphere",
the images are from FE at a temperature of at least 160,000 K,
the TRACE "rigid structures" are an illusion created from running difference processing,
the temperature of the photosphere is ~5700 K (above the boiling point of Fe),
the temperature of the photosphere is ~9000K at ~400 km below the surface (even more above the boiling point of Fe),
and maybe even more (did the paper mention missing solar neutrinos?).

O. Manuel also implied that NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team were stupid enough to make the same mistakes.
 
What do you mean "nope'?
I mean "no".

Even single ions have various PROPERTIES such as EM field sensitivity, velocity, mass, etc. Bulk properties are simply derived from the individual particle tendencies, such as their direction of movement in an EM field, their total mass, etc.
Temperature is derived from the statistical properties of a large collection of particles. The concept just doesn't apply to a single particle.

Well, the single neutral atom is going to bounce around the chamber like any ordinary gas and be unaffected by any EM fields we introduce. A plamsa particle will also bounce around like a gas whereas it WILL be affected by EM fields because it's a PLASMA. The "pressure" in a vacuum is typically a function of the molecules present it the chamber. Even one atom means the pressure in the vacuum is greater than zero.
Pressure in an ideal gas can be derived from the kinetic theory of gases. Unfortunately one of the assumptions here is that, as wikipedia puts it, "The number of molecules is so large that statistical treatment can be applied".

You're telling me that the "currents" don't have any bulk properties, even when there are many charged particles present in the current?
No, I'm not telling you that.

Boloney. I can even make predictions about it's movement in an EM field based on the STATE of the matter based on whether it's an ion (plasma form) or not. I can make reliable models based on the movement of one particle. I can even give you the approximate pressure of that one particle in a vacuum if you give me the dimensions, and the temperature. PV=nRT.
Don't be ridiculous. That equation is for an ideal gas. Its a stupid equation to use for the following list of reasons (and almost certainly several more):
1) You don't know Avogadro's number to 24 decimal places (nobody does).
2) Temperature isn't defined for a single molecule, only a large collection of molecules.
3) Similarly, pressure is defined in terms of a large collection of molecules.
4) An ideal gas must obey the second law of thermodynamics. A molecule doesn't have to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom