Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
*IF* as you claim, plasma is optional in for reconnection to occur, then plasma would necessarily be optional to describe the rate of reconnection as well. Which is it, one or the other. You can't have it both ways.

If a tree falls in a forest and there's nobody there to hear it, does it still make a sound?
If a ball rolls over a cliff and there's nobody there to see it, does it still accelerate at 9.81 ms-2?
If magnetic field lines reconnect and there is no plasma there to measure the reconnection rate, do they still reconnect?
 
They certainly created those images! We used images directly from NASA and LMSAL. The line in question was intended to explain where the images came from, not to suggest everyone or anyone at NASA agreed with our interpretation of the images.


Nobody at NASA agrees that "NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere." Nobody made any "image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere." No such image exists. Oliver Manuel's implication that NASA was in any way involved in the creation of such an image is a lie. It's scientific fraud.

In TRUTH, yes they did as that first light SDO composite image demonstrates. The transition region is located UNDER the surface of the photosphere, not above it. In fact it shows it to be RIGHT where Kosovichev's work predicted it would be located.


Kosovichev didn't predict the transition region is below the photosphere. That's absolute nonsense and a dishonest misrepresentation of Kosovichev's helioseismology research. And there still has been no quantitative objective analysis of that SDO image which might explain how a RGB composite with a 75% transparent black disk overlay allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. But we'll have that explanation soon. I'm preparing some sample images that we can use to test the concept so we can all see through that 80,000 kilometers of plasma... or not.

The rest of your post is [...]


The rest of my post was pointing out the continued failure to objectively explain the alleged evidence of a rigid/solid surface with an actual quantitative analysis. Here is the running difference image created by the TRACE team at LMSAL, the image which allegedly shows us a surface some 4800 kilometers below the point where no light can escape from the Sun...

imagerd.jpg

And here are two images, the corresponding crops from the TRACE 171Å filter which were gathered within minutes of those used to create the image above...

image01.jpg


image02.jpg

Provide a quantitative objective analysis of the running difference image as it relates to the pair of original data images shown here. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to each pixel in the data images to generate the running difference result. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing 4800 kilometers through the photosphere.
 
Last edited:
Magnetic reconnection doesn't happen in a vaccum in the real world, despite what the field lines say; likewise, I wont ever physically bump into the equator of the Earth, despite what the map lines might say.

Can people agree on this analogy?

No, that's a terrible analogy, since the equator has nothing to do with topography. A good geographic analogy would be contour lines on a topographical map. Imagine a topographical map of two separate hills on a plane. The contour lines would be two sets of concentric rings. Now slowly move the hills together, and when the bases of the hills touch and the area between them begins to rise, suddenly the two lowest contour lines around the bases of the hills merge into a single line around both hills. As the hills get closer and the area between them rises, more and more lines merge.

This is a good analogy for magnetic reconnection. The hills are continuous and not composed of lines, just like the magnetic fields. But the lines used to mathematically represent the hills on the map display the fact that the hills are merging when the lines begin to merge.
 
No, that's a terrible analogy, since the equator has nothing to do with topography. A good geographic analogy would be contour lines on a topographical map. Imagine a topographical map of two separate hills on a plane. The contour lines would be two sets of concentric rings. Now slowly move the hills together, and when the bases of the hills touch and the area between them begins to rise, suddenly the two lowest contour lines around the bases of the hills merge into a single line around both hills. As the hills get closer and the area between them rises, more and more lines merge.

This is a good analogy for magnetic reconnection. The hills are continuous and not composed of lines, just like the magnetic fields. But the lines used to mathematically represent the hills on the map display the fact that the hills are merging when the lines begin to merge.


Yep. The lines are just a way to visualize a vector, essentially designating a series of points having an equal quantity of something like units of distance, temperature, altitude, depth, pressure, salinity, magnetic strength, etc. Another good and common example would be isobars on a weather map. Change the pressure and/or move the pressure centers and the isobars reconnect. It's a math thing.
 
Last edited:
Equation 16
[latex]\mu_0I(z) = 4\pi\alpha^{-1} cos(\alpha|z| +\phi__r)[/latex]
[latex] for z \leq0[/latex]

Equation 17:
[latex]\sigma(z) = -4\pi\alpha^{-1} sin(\alpha|z| + \phi_r) [/latex]
[latex] for z \leq 0[/latex]

OK, Mr. Mozina, I'm ready; explain why and how these equations *PROVE* reconnection requires plasma.

Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//...00539.000.html
...

PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it.
 
Last edited:
Outstanding questions for Michael Mozina

No published work makes such a claim. Somov's example INCLUDED moving charged particles, it didn't EXCLUDE them.
You are lying. These published works makes such a claim (MR happens in both vacuum and plasma):
Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990 (MR in a vacuum)
Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection (vacuum reconnection)
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection (MR in vacuum)

These published works define MR as topological changes in magnetic fields: Magnetic Reconnection defined and Described (Tim Thompson, 25th January 2012). They mention plasma because these topological changes have significant effects in plasma. But we can produce exactly the same topological changes without plasma, e.g. W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection starts with no plasma :jaw-dropp or just use a couple of fridge magnets.

You remain deluded: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IX!

And you remain ignorant:
Let us ignore that the currents in Somov's example are never described as "moving charged particles" and so are idealized currents (they could be a single moving charged particle - oops there goes your plasma :eek: !).
The fact they you still cannot grasp is that the MR happens at the null point and in vacuum!


And we still have outstanding questions (no surprise since Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked lists 75 questions about his idea and assertions about Birkeland's work to which MM has made no credible reply):
  1. MM: State your position on MR without plasma and list citations to support it
    Asked 20 March 2012
  2. MM: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
  3. MM What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trivial process..." mean?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
and a comment about your inability to spell (or maybe understand what a reconnection rate is): Michael Mozina, can you spell "reconnection rate":D
 
Last edited:
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection: Studies by 2D and 3D macro particle simulations
"A gedanken experiment that illustrates the meaning of electrical
resistivity for magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum, and (b) in a plasma
(dots represent plasma ions and electrons). The currents J1 and J2 flow
in the flux bundles, while J3 in the plasma does not exist initially and is
induced by the electric field Et during the reconnection process."



The interesting thing about that paper, Reality Check, is that it is all right there in the first few paragraphs. In a vacuum there is nothing to stop the reconnection process. Yet, in plasma the current J3 is induced balancing the opposing magnetic fields of J1 and J2. Reconnection can not progress. However, when the plasma is resistive (what the reconnection rate represent is the resistivity of the intervening plasma) the reconnection can progress as J3 can no longer balance the magnetic attraction of J1 and J2. That’s also the irony. What Michael Mozina apparently wants (a reconnection of the currents) can’t happen unless their two individual, opposing and current centric magnetic fields first combine (reconnect) into a singular composite field that encompasses both currents. He evidently just wants one without the other. Curent "reconnection" without the magnetic reconnection of their fields.
 
I think 80% of this thread is just down equivocation misunderstandings.

Electricty did it / Magnetism did it, is a classic, for example.

Someone versed in basic electromagnetism will know they are at a basic level, the same. The difference is way we conceptualize them. Magnetism with field lines, flux strength, vector fields, etc, and other constructs. Currents with motion, charge, particle properties, vector fields, etc. But you can still define magnetism with the concepts I list after currents, and vice versa. Both can lead to totally different results/predictions/models on occasions, as the conceptualizations used for both is different.

I am so versed, at least by SUNY (State Universities of New York) accreditation, with all those rights and privileges appertaining thereunto (as so the degrees say). Keeping me currently (pun intended) well employed but other than that it ain't worth much accolade in this particular realm. We are all well beyond the verses of "basic electromagnetism" in the regards considered here and that is exactly the interest.


Are EM fields constant, or quantized? Both. But they can't be, really. We end up back at 'is it a particle or wave?' type debate by the end. Or Bu and Ej approaches to various plasma related geo/stellar physics models.

I think you mean "Are EM fields" continuous (not discrete) "or quantized" (meaning discrete) . As "constant" only refers to the lack of time dependent variations. The answer is that the field is continuous only as long as the space (not just physical space but the mathematical space it is considered within) is continuous (at least as currently considered). Even if the mediating particles (photons) are discrete. Efforts to unify gravity (the continuous force which consequently defines the continuous nature of our physical space-time and its mathematical modeling) with the other three (already "quantized") forces may change that. We don't currently know, but given the astounding utility of the discrete concept of the other forces it would seem, at least to me and others, that it is the continuous perception of gravity, meaning basically space-time, that needs to change.

We end up back at 'is it a particle or wave?' type debate by the end. Or Bu and Ej approaches to various plasma related geo/stellar physics models.

Actually that "...'is it a particle or wave?' type debate..." ended quite some time ago for those other forces as it is exemplary of the types of false dichotomies our own intuitions at our scale of normal experience would impose upon the universe.
 
I Just did. Nothing physically happened :s

Evidently you didn't as one of the procedures of the experiment is for the free magnet to be physically turned then released. Perhaps you only imagined you did it and obviously failed in just that.



Exactly. "Only an idiot would think that magnetic field lines or map lines are real things". Thus why magnetic reconection in a vacuum is a misnomer past mathematical abstraction.


If you think "field lines or map lines" (contour lines on a map to be more specific for the latter) don't represent anything "real" then you can place no restrictions upon them, even if just to claim they are misnamed (a misnomer). So your assertion of a misnomer indicates that you do think they (at least field lines) must represent something real but just, well, misnamed. What exactly do you think that is for either field lines or contour lines?
 
No, actually you never elaborated fully enough to answer your question. As I stated the first time, there's an explicit heating of physical particles, specific wavelengths of energy, etc, that are typical and highly indicative of an "electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it.

Ah back peddling now, who would have figured, and that " explicit heating of physical particles, specific wavelengths of energy, etc, that are typical and highly indicative of an "electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" is explicitly asserted even in what you bolded as what an ""electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" is" " “usually accompanied by”. So all that is explicitly not required for an ""electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" by your own bolded citation.

Do your magnets actually generate the kinds of things that Peratt describes, like pinches and high energy wavelengths of light?

Again explicitly not required for an ""electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" by your own citation. Do please try to learn to read your own reference materials and what you choose to explicitly cite (this case by bolding) from them.

I can't answer your question without a few 'details' about the process you're describing. If you just move a couple of magnets a few centimeters, no. If you generate an electrical discharge, 'probably'.

You did answer that part of the question concerning" "electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" ...

...yes, that is in fact an "electrical discharge". It's not actually an "electrical discharge in plasma' however.

Now you claim you just "can't answer" the latter part and assert as a conditional back door "If you generate an electrical discharge, 'probably'". You evidently think this is some kind of trap. I'm not trying to trap you Michael Mozina, I'm trying to educate you. Unfortunately, as you apparently feel trapped by the implications of your own inclinations, assertion and citations that becomes rather difficult. So I must demonstrate to you by your own assertions the trap you have simply laid for, and sprung upon, yourself that you now attempt to back peddle out of. The only redeeming factor is that you may just back peddle yourself into some knowledge. Not only of your own assertions and their deficiencies (seems that part has worked as expected) but hopefully some, well, physics (I'm not holding my breath).

By all means, please, inquire as to what "few 'details' about the process" of the recommended experiment you feel may be lacking in the explicit descriptions already given.
 
Ah back peddling now, who would have figured, and that " explicit heating of physical particles, specific wavelengths of energy, etc, that are typical and highly indicative of an "electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" is explicitly asserted even in what you bolded as what an ""electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" is" " “usually accompanied by”. So all that is explicitly not required for an ""electrical discharge" as Peratt describes it" by your own bolded citation.

Huh? I'm terribly confused now. I posted Peratt's *ENTIRE* definition of a "discharge" to this thread. It's describes the process as a transfer of *LARGE* amounts of EM energy into particle kinetic energy. It describes the 'pinches', the high energy wavelengths, etc. From day one, I have acknowledged that his definition is *INCLUSIVE*, not "exclusive" of 'reconnection". Reconnection by the way is described as being a process in PLASMA whereby magnetic field energy is transferred into particle kinetic energy. By DEFINITION, Peratt's 'electrical discharge' and "magnetic reconnection" describe the same PROCESS in PLASMA. Both of the processes occur *IN PLASMA*. Peratt's definition includes (doesn't exclude) A) plasma, B) MASSIVE releases of energy inside that plasma that results in pinches and high energy wavelengths.

The "backpeddling" going on is directly related to to the equivocation fallacy that each of you is guilty of. Instead of acknowledging all the components, you want to remove all but one!

The DEFINITION of reconnection is clearly specified on Wiki as a process *INSIDE* (not without) plasma. It clearly specifies an ACCELERATION process, a HEATING process, and a TRANSFER OF ENERGY process. You're trying to dumb the whole thing down to localized "flux change", with or without plasma, with or without particle acceleration! Sorry, that oversimplification fallacy/equivocation fallacy is dead in the water.

The analogy that comes to mind is someone comes up with a definition of drag racing that describes it as a PROCESS whereby two or more VEHICLES turn potential chemical energy (battery or gas, or something else) into vehicle acceleration for up to 1/4 mile to see who can accelerate the fastest, and reach the finish line first. Both vehicles have to begin at the same time via a series of lights telling each driver when to accelerate.

You guys find a full gas can in your garage, and say "Hey look, there's been drag racing taking place in our garage, and we're already DRAG RACERS!" All you have is potential chemical energy in a can. You ignored the need for the vehicles. You didn't TRANSFER that potential chemical energy into kinetic energy, you didn't race, but you you want to call the gas in the can "drag racing" in your garage. Boloney.

FYI, I will be busy today catching up from being out of the office all day yesterday so I could attend a meeting at LMSAL. I probably won't respond much for a few days while I take care of business and get caught up at work.
 
Last edited:
FYI, I will be busy today catching up from being out of the office all day yesterday so I could attend a meeting at LMSAL. I probably won't respond much for a few days while I take care of business and get caught up at work.


This one has gone unanswered for almost seven years now...

Provide a quantitative objective analysis of the running difference image as it relates to the pair of original data images shown here. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to each pixel in the data images to generate the running difference result. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing 4800 kilometers through the photosphere.

A thorough explanation of the process would go a long way to supporting the alleged result. The only thing we've seen over all these years is an unqualified unsupported opinion that it's a picture that looks like something.
 
FYI, I will be busy today catching up from being out of the office all day yesterday so I could attend a meeting at LMSAL. I probably won't respond much for a few days while I take care of business and get caught up at work.
Great. When you're ready we can go over the two equations from Priest's paper that *PROVE* reconnection requires plasma.
 
Nobody at NASA agrees that "NASA and Lockheed Martin's TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere."

That may in fact be true that nobody at NASA believes it's a rigid surface in that image, but NASA did create the images. I doubt most folks who read my website or who read my papers doubt the fact that most folks (including most folks at NASA) think that the sun is a PLASMA, without a solid surface. That's pretty much a given.

Nobody made any "image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere."

Someone took those images and put them through a running difference process. It wasn't me and it wasn't Manuel. It absolutely was someone at NASA and/or LMSAL because the images came from them. That was all that was meant by the line in question in the first place.

No such image exists.

BS. The images exist. NASA created them. We can argue over the INTERPRETATION of the images, but the source and their existence isn't debatable.

Oliver Manuel's implication that NASA was in any way involved in the creation of such an image is a lie.

They absolutely, positively did create the images in question, including the RD images in question.

It's scientific fraud.

No, you're a a scientific fraud when it comes to claiming expertize in *SOLAR* satellite image analysis. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?" You incorrectly described the transition region color as a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images! You don't understand the light sources of a SINGLE STANDARD iron ion wavelength image, so there is no hope you could EVER understand a running difference or running averaged *SOLAR* image on one of those wavelengths.

What you might understand is pixels, and pixel intensities, and distances. What you won't understand is the PHYSICS. Do you even own a plasma physics textbook yet?

Kosovichev didn't predict the transition region is below the photosphere.

No, Kosovichev located a "stratification subsurface" located under the photosphere that redirected the vertical flow of plasma horizontal at around 4800 KM. I used that information to predict the location of the so called "transition region" which is located UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary in the SDO first light images.

And there still has been no quantitative objective analysis of that SDO image which might explain how a RGB composite with a 75% transparent black disk overlay allegedly allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma.

I already went through a whole conversation with you over opacity of your MISUSE of that term. I also explained that the atmosphere would need to be highly ionized (+4,+5 for neon) for the light to be seen at such depth. You don't care about those conversations.

I just don't have the time today (or any day) to rehash a 15 thread, multi-MONTH conversation with you about pixel counts and intensities of pixels, and processing methods with you. You and I already had that conversation at a completely DIFFERENT website, more than 5 years ago! I probably still have the original movie that Dave presented of the original images. As I recall you even posted the exact CODE that was used in the RD imaging process. As I remember, you then described the PROCESSING METHOD correctly, but utterly botched the solar physics. You completely ignored the rigid/persistent features in the image (over 1:40 minutes in length), the lack of any plasma drift between those persistent features, and claimed: "Flying stuff? What flying stuff?" when I asking you questions about the flare event as observed in the RD image. Sheesh.
 
Last edited:
Great. When you're ready we can go over the two equations from Priest's paper that *PROVE* reconnection requires plasma.

Ok, you're next. Did you figure out what the variables represent yet? I'm sure at least one of the variables that you asked me about is explained very clearly in the opening part of paper. Have you actually READ THE ENTIRE PAPER?
 
The interesting thing about that paper, Reality Check, is that it is all right there in the first few paragraphs. In a vacuum there is nothing to stop the reconnection process.

The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you seem to be ignoring the fact that his "vacuum" is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of two FILAMENTS that MERGE! He's talking about the RECONNECTION or merging of two PLASMA FILAMENTS in a VACUUM. The interesting thing is you're both ignoring the fact that charged particles 'reconnect' in his example.

If the filaments with radius r0 are placed in vacuum as shown in Fig. 1(a), there is nothing to stop the process; the filaments should merge in a time.....

What exactly do you figure he means by the term "filaments" and merging of "filaments"?
 
I guess you just did a Google search for the terms "Reconnection" and "Vacuum" and you don't much care what that VACUUM contains. It doesn't matter if it contains current filaments, currents, or 15 pound, heavily charged bowling balls. If it's not devoid of moving charged objects, it's not "reconnection' *WITHOUT* charged objects!

This still all comes back to my drag racing example. You want to dumb down the term to the point of meaningless so that the mere finding of a gas can with a gallon of gas makes you a bunch of drag racers.

First you'll need to BUILD/GET/ACQUIRE a vehicle/plasma, ACCELERATE that vehicle/plasma and then you can call yourselves drag racers. :)
 
That may in fact be true that nobody at NASA believes it's a rigid surface in that image, but NASA did create the images. I doubt most folks who read my website or who read my papers doubt the fact that most folks (including most folks at NASA) think that the sun is a PLASMA, without a solid surface. That's pretty much a given.


For good reason. No quantitative objective evidence exists to suggest otherwise. That's why the electric/iron Sun conjecture is likely to remain forever in the realms of crackpot pseudoscience.

Someone took those images and put them through a running difference process. It wasn't me and it wasn't Manuel. It absolutely was someone at NASA and/or LMSAL because the images came from them. That was all that was meant by the line in question in the first place.


The actual words in the acknowledgements of "On the Cosmic Nuclear Cycle and the Similarity of Nuclei and Stars" are "NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere and the movie of a solar flare coming from that region (Fig. 2)." That is an attempt to imply that NASA and LMSAL made images of rigid structures, which is a lie of course. Oliver Manuel is a crackpot and a fraud. He can retract that falsehood. To the best of my knowledge he never has.

BS. The images exist. NASA created them. We can argue over the INTERPRETATION of the images, but the source and their existence isn't debatable.

They absolutely, positively did create the images in question, including the RD images in question.


Of the hundreds of thousands of images NASA and the LMSAL did create, none of them were images of "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere" as the acknowledgements in that paper imply. As for the interpretation, it is 100% looks-like-a-bunny crackpot pseudoscience. And even when given every opportunity, there is not now nor has there ever been any quantitative analysis of the imagery which would objectively indicate that it shows "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere".

No, you're a a scientific fraud when it comes to claiming expertize in *SOLAR* satellite image analysis. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?" You incorrectly described the transition region color as a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images! You don't understand the light sources of a SINGLE STANDARD iron ion wavelength image, so there is no hope you could EVER understand a running difference or running averaged *SOLAR* image on one of those wavelengths.


The persistent incivility and unsupported personal attacks are noted.

What you might understand is pixels, and pixel intensities, and distances. What you won't understand is the PHYSICS. Do you even own a plasma physics textbook yet?


My expertise is in the acquisition and processing of the satellite imagery under discussion. Much of my understanding of the associated physics comes from exchanging communication with people at NASA and LMSAL who are directly involved in acquiring and processing those images. My analysis corresponds exactly with theirs. No alternative objective analyses have ever been provided by anyone.

And I'm not sure if I own any textbooks on the subject of plasma physics. But I have been around the web for over 20 years reading some of the crazy nonsense being spouted by various against-the-mainstream crackpots, cranks, and physics-expert wannabes. It is certain that I understand the topic far better than some people who do claim to own plasma physics textbooks.

No, Kosovichev located a "stratification subsurface" located under the photosphere that redirected the vertical flow of plasma horizontal at around 4800 KM. I used that information to predict the location of the so called "transition region" which is located UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary in the SDO first light images.


No. Kosovichev did not predict the transition region is below the photosphere. He's not stupid. To suggest he did is a severe misunderstanding of Kosovichev's helioseismology research, willfully ignorant of previous discussions on the issue, or intentionally dishonest. What his helioseismology research does show is that there is plasma moving up, down, and sideways at thousands of kilometers per hour directly through the region that some claim is rigid or solid. Kosovichev's findings directly refute that solid/rigid surface nonsense.

I already went through a whole conversation with you over opacity of your MISUSE of that term. I also explained that the atmosphere would need to be highly ionized (+4,+5 for neon) for the light to be seen at such depth. You don't care about those conversations.

I just don't have the time today (or any day) to rehash a 15 thread, multi-MONTH conversation with you about pixel counts and intensities of pixels, and processing methods with you. You and I already had that conversation at a completely DIFFERENT website, more than 5 years ago! I probably still have the original movie that Dave presented of the original images. As I recall you even posted the exact CODE that was used in the RD imaging process. As I remember, you then described the PROCESSING METHOD correctly, but utterly botched the solar physics. You completely ignored the rigid/persistent features in the image (over 1:40 minutes in length), the lack of any plasma drift between those persistent features, and claimed: "Flying stuff? What flying stuff?" when I asking you questions about the flare event as observed in the RD image. Sheesh.


The persistent uncivil and dishonest misrepresentation of my position and lack of relevance to, well, any part of reality is noted.

But relevant to the topic, never in any discussion about the TRACE running difference image has any solid/rigid surface proponent ever provided a quantitative objective analysis. All the quantitative analyses have been done by other people, and have objectively concluded that the solid/rigid surface claims cannot be supported by that sort of image processing. I have asked again for such an explanation and posted images to facilitate it. The six-plus years of willful ignorance of that request and the continuing refusal to address the issue is noted.

Maybe when I post some samples of SDO images we can get a quantitative objective analysis showing how a simple RGB composite with a semi-transparent black disk overlay allegedly lets us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. I do predict that will also be met with the same willful ignorance and refusal to quantitatively explain it.
 
For good reason. No quantitative objective evidence exists to suggest otherwise. That's why the electric/iron Sun conjecture is likely to remain forever in the realms of crackpot pseudoscience.

Nope. Crackpot pseudoscience is your claim that electrical discharges do not occur in conductors. They can ONLY happen in conductors. Your beliefs are complete crackpot pseudoscience as demonstrated by the fact that you can't even produce any math to express a "reconnection rate" in the absence of mass acceleration. Crackpot claims by people that don't even own a book on MHD theory.

The actual words in the acknowledgements of "On the Cosmic Nuclear Cycle and the Similarity of Nuclei and Stars" are "NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere and the movie of a solar flare coming from that region (Fig. 2)."

They did!

That is an attempt to imply that NASA and LMSAL made images of rigid structures,

They did!

which is a lie of course.

No, it's not. They took the images and processed the images.

You lied when you claimed that discharges did not occur in conductors when they can ONLY happen in/through conductors. You've never retracted that lie either. Care to?

Oliver Manuel is a crackpot and a fraud.

No, you are the crackpot and the fraud for denying Dungey's work on discharges in solar flares, and the ultimate crackpot on all topics related to solar physics. "Discharges in solar flares? What discharges? " Do you even own a book of the topic of plasma physics, yes or no?

He can retract that falsehood. To the best of my knowledge he never has.

He probably never will. I never will unless I see evidence to the contrary.

Of the hundreds of thousands of images NASA and the LMSAL did create, none of them were images of "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere" as the acknowledgements in that paper imply.

No, that's false. The RD IRON ION images do show rigid features under the surface of the photosphere. Not every image on every wavelength shows those features, but iron ion RD images do show them.

As for the interpretation, it is 100% looks-like-a-bunny crackpot pseudoscience.

No, it's real science by folks that understand the images, including the light source, including the CAUSE of the rigid outlines, including the CAUSE of the flare itself. Your interpretation is based on willful ignorance of the subject material, demonstrated by the fact that you can't even EXPRESS a reconnection rate in the absence of mass.

The persistent incivility and unsupported personal attacks are noted.

What do you know about civil dialog? You've effectively called me and everyone associated with my work a fraud about a dozen times in the last two days. You use the term "crackpot" as your emotional crutch in every single post in the utter absence of anything intelligent to say on the topics being discussed. When asked any intelligent questions on the topic of solar physics you always give the WRONG answer. "Discharges? What discharges?" You don't have the expertize to call me a fraud in the first place. The only fraud being perpetrated is by you and you alone since you don't own a book on the topic of the topic of plasma physics!

I'm tired of your personal attack and willfully ignorant crap today. I'll just stop here.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom