If I Was An Evil Genius... Refuting Conspiracy Theories via Motive

FYI - engineers are scientists. Moreover, engineers can become lawyers if they want to, at least in the United States, which is where I live. I admit, it's pretty rare to find one, but I guess that's why us IP lawyers get paid more than lawyers that specialize in other fields. Kind of a supply and demand thing.

Strictly speaking, engineering and science are distinct if overlapping disciplines. Engineers and scientists are somewhat nebulous labels and open to some interpretation, but there is a difference. Engineers certainly can perform science, but then bus drivers and patent examiners can too.

I personally straddle that fence. I perform engineering tasks, namely design and development of products (mostly software). Some of my tasks, e.g. requirements development and system certification, are definitely not science. Others, such as research of low-maturity technology and mathematical algorithms, are definitely science. My training involves degrees in both pure sciences (mathematics and physics) and sciences heavily flavoured by engineering (aeronautics).

If pressed I will refer to myself as a scientist rather than an engineer, for the simple reason that I do not have nor require a Professional Engineer (PE) certification. This is one possible interpretation of the distinction, though there are many.

This is really a strange thing to be arguing about.
 
This is really a strange thing to be arguing about.
Actually, a sidetrack like this is to be expected when arguing w/ CT's. It's the equivalent of "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!".
 
Anyway, it never fails...

Never.

Every time I go on vacation for a week, by the time I get back, my once beautiful thread has been savaged by Troother philistines, diluting my message with odium and off-topic bickering. Alas, the Forum environment is a cold sea, and cruel to a young thread.

Nonetheless, my thanks to those who appreciated my original post. It appears even those in the Truth Movement enjoyed it, although the point seems to have escaped them to varying degrees.

As for new poster Golden Bear, I'm not inclined to offer a detailed reply, seeing as you didn't really rebut my whitepaper so much as reject its premise -- namely, you claimed that in all likelihood, the perpetrators of Sept. 11th were not Evil Geniuses at all, but in fact stupider than I:

The first mistake is your use of the moniker “Genius” to describe the planner(s) of 9/11. While many people may assume that those who rise to power in this country are the best and brightest we have to offer, this simply is not the case. [...] Notice that nowhere is super-intelligence listed there (again, look at our current leader). Of course they need some modicum of intelligence in order to succeed politically. However, it hardly takes a “genius” to rise to positions of power in the U.S., and, I would argue, the most important considerations are money and political connections. In fact, judging your intelligence from this post alone, I would say you are probably more intelligent than many, if not most, of the people that run this country. Thus, I think you may have given too much credit to the Evil Genius which is the topic of this post.

While I appreciate your flattery, I heartily disagree on this point -- to rise to such a position of influence, and to carry out such a vast conspiracy, requires not only uncommon intelligence, but also practice. This has nothing to do with the intelligence, real or imagined, of individual elected leaders, whom I think you also underestimate. Furthermore, your conduct over the past ten pages has spiked any interest I might have had in a more detailed discussion. Instead, let me simply offer a few gripes I have with your response:

1. You refer to many of my argued points as "strawmen:"

It’s very interesting and telling that you began with the ridiculous straw man “no planes” argument. I know it is great cannon fodder for official story defenders, but surely you of all people are smart enough to realize that no one with half a brain thinks that no planes hit the towers.
These are obvious strawmen. As with no planes, surely you are smart enough to know that no one really believes any of this.
They are not strawmen. Look, I went to extreme lengths to document where I found these ideas. I did not make them up, not a single one of them. This is all covered in the footnotes in my OP. I even explained why I went to all the trouble, viz. because some malcontent would just cry "Strawman!" as a way of dodging the argument if I didn't. Well, I referenced myself, and you did it anyway.

These arguments are not "strawmen" just because you personally think they're stupid. I think they're all stupid. It's only a "strawman" if I've misrepresented my opponents as a means to support my argument. I haven't misrepresented anything. If it bothers you that people in your precious Truth Movement believe such idiotic things, then perhaps you need to examine your Movement. Don't complain about me.

Folks in the Truth Movement do this all the time -- just see Alex Jones on video with Gravy at Ground Zero if you don't believe me. You need to learn what a "strawman" is before you use that word again. You, as in you personally, Golden Bear.​

2. I'm still perplexed at how someone claiming to be educated in chemical engineering could so readily believe that explosives, exposed to the incredible fires resulting from aircraft collisions, would be functionally unaffected. You should know better than I that this simply isn't true, and most definitely would pose an enormous operational risk. No further comment regarding the ridiculous nature of your preferred theory should be necessary.

3. I'm even more fascinated by your claim, referenced above, that Sept. 11th wasn't carried out by Evil Genius at all, but rather Evil Idiots. What this implies is that, in your personal theory, the organizers plotted for years in secret, and had the resources to buy, hire, threaten, or use and then disappear whatever talent they wanted:

If Evil Genius has the resources to pull off 9/11, he probably also has the resources to pay off and/or intimidate key editors and journalists to maintain the cover-up. [...] You are absolutely correct that the Evil Genius has such vast resources at his disposal, that it will extremely difficult, if not impossible, to expose the conspiracy. However, I think most that believe 9/11 was an inside job are doing what they think is right, and hoping for the best.

Yet, despite these enormous resources and time spent planning, not one person raised a single criticism of the plan that I did, on my own, in a single day's contemplation? That's what you'd have me believe?

As you rejected my premise outright, I now reject yours. And I believe you'll find my opinion is the more carefully considered.

-----

Again, thanks to all who enjoyed my whitepaper. The battle certainly seems to be winding down on scientific grounds -- I haven't seen anything worth responding to in weeks -- which led me to this argument instead. I find the responses so far to be encouraging.
 
Last edited:
Never.

Every time I go on vacation for a week, by the time I get back, my once beautiful thread has been savaged by Troother philistines, diluting my message with odium and off-topic bickering. Alas, the Forum environment is a cold sea, and cruel to a young thread.

Nonetheless, my thanks to those who appreciated my original post. It appears even those in the Truth Movement enjoyed it, although the point seems to have escaped them to varying degrees.

<snip> stuff about Golden Bear.

Again, thanks to all who enjoyed my whitepaper. The battle certainly seems to be winding down on scientific grounds -- I haven't seen anything worth responding to in weeks -- which led me to this argument instead. I find the responses so far to be encouraging.

In the last two days, I was contemplating a reply to your OP to say that your point had been proved, namely that the CT's won't discuss motive or logistics and so weren't able to address the OP in the spirit in which it was intended.

You were right, unfortunately. It was kind-of neat to think about.

ETA: Hope it was a good vacation
 
No, I said "like" a rigid solid. If you firmly connect a 3 foot steel beam with another 3 foot steel beam, you've got a 6 foot steel member that is "like" a rigid 6 foot steel beam. Thanks for twisting my words, though.


You would have a 6 foot beam that is like a rigid beam until you applied an outside force (like a plane strike or intense fire). Therefore, this rigid beam could fail at some point and the point of failure would most likely be the point where they are connected. Say that you use 3/4 inch bolts (overkill for your example, but we'll go with it) to tie the beams together. The bolts would be the point of failure and could lead to a catastrophic failure when coupled into a larger system.
 
The content of this post clearly demonstrates you couldn't even qualify as the village idiot, to wit:



FYI - engineers are scientists. Moreover, engineers can become lawyers if they want to, at least in the United States, which is where I live. I admit, it's pretty rare to find one, but I guess that's why us IP lawyers get paid more than lawyers that specialize in other fields. Kind of a supply and demand thing.
I have to say you need to seek a refund now for all the education you claim to have received. Base on your posts alone you were short changed on all but the BS you spout. I see no evidence you ever passed a course, you must sue the schools since they failed to educate you on any engineering or scientific methods. I am still waiting for some fact filled post to change my opinion that something is just not right with your claims of being a lawyer/engineer/scientist. I already know we can be anything we want with work some people are engineer/pilot/scientist/accident investigator/chief of safety/airlift coordinator/operations officer/air force officer/instructor pilot/airline transport pilot/computer engineer all in one person, and have worked at all these jobs professionally. I would expect them to also find lies in the 9/11 truth movement. You have failed to find facts or point out the lies of 9/11. Something a real engineer/scientist/lawyer could do with one hand tied behind his back.

How can you be an engineer, scientist, and lawyer who ignore facts and backs the lies of the 9/11 truth movement? It is not logical?

Your education was a failure, if not due to yourself, you need to seek a refund now for your failed education!
 
Last edited:
Dr. Frank Gayle did a historic forensic investigation to establish that precipitation hardening occurred during the casting of the Wright Brothers aluminum engine and enabled that historic first flight.

Aluminium alloys is not my field but, I found this quite interesting because most cast structures I am aware of are coarse and are subsequently optimised by a solution and age heat treatment. This enables careful control of the precipitates and hence the material properties. It appears that the Wright Brothers and their caster weren't aware of this phenomena on a microstructural scale (let alone a nanostructural scale) as it was actually scientifically explained how Al-Cu alloys work by Alfred Wilm 6 years later. I suspect that Wilm may also have been working with coarser precipitates anyway. It seems they selected aluminium purely based on the fact that it was light enough to fly.

I can't find an actual description on the casting process used so I won't comment on the mechanism for solution and subsequent precipitation

What I found really interesting was that the Wright brothers had no idea about the metallurgical facts behind the Aluminium-Copper alloy system let alone producing nano-preciptates. In fact, I don't believe it happened at all because I don't believe they could have achieved this feat of engineering without all the facts.
 
Last edited:
My study of the Axiom of Least Resistance is complete. Where should I publish the paper? Does anyone have the e-mail address of the Nobel Prize Committee?

Respectfully,
Myriad

A. Myriad, et. al.*, 2007
Chronopetroaerohydroplummetometric Testing Challenges Least Resistance Axiom
Abstract:
The Least Resistance Axiom, which states that a falling object follows the path of least resistance(1), is the basis of all modern dynamics(2, 3). This principle was tested by experimentation in a uniform graviational field. In Phase 1, it was established by means of a stopwatch, a rock, and a bucket that water offers significantly more resistance to the gravitational displacement of a rock than air (n = 20, p < .0005). In Phase 2, rocks were dropped above a bucket filled with water. Trials were binned in two groups: those in which the rock reached an equilibrium state outside the bucket having taken a path resisted only by air, and those in which the rocks reached an equilibrium state inside the bucket, having taken a path resisted in part by water. A planned verification procedure on the former group in which the rocks' dryness would be evaluated(4) could not be carried out due to the lack of any trials in that group; however, wetness measurements(5) on the latter group were able to confirm (p<.00001) that the rocks had indeed passed through the water. No damage to the water was observed in any trial. These results conclusively refute the Least Resistance Axiom, and thus call for a reexamination of the entire edifice of the physical sciences. Among the disturbing implications of the falsification of the LRA is that vehicles on a trajectory intersecting stationary obstacles might not, as is commonly believed, always take the path of least resistance around the obstacles(6), and might, instead, crash into them with deleterious effects. Transportation authorities should be notified, pending the results of a planned series of more extensive parametric studies (grant application pending).

*Thanks to al for the loan of his bucket.
 
Re: The difference between static and dynamic - This is another oft-relied upon and quite humorous claim by OCT defenders. Do you honestly believe that throughout the lifetime of the WTC, that it was experiencing a purely "static" load? What about the wind? Is that a static or dynamic force/load?

Just how fast is that downward wind going anyway?

How about the people walking around the entire building all day? How about the elevators going up and down all day with people getting on and off of them?

To sum it up:

WTC height: 1,368 ft (417.0 m)
WTC width: 208 feet (63.4 m)
WTC weight: 500.000 ton

500000 tons / 110 floors =~ 4545 tons / floor.
4545 tons / floor * 15 floors =~ 68200 tons.

Did you just compare people walking around the WTC offices to dropping a 68 kiloton object onto the bottom part of the WTC?
 
My study of the Axiom of Least Resistance is complete. Where should I publish the paper? Does anyone have the e-mail address of the Nobel Prize Committee?

Respectfully,
Myriad

I would suggest you submit your findings here. Best of luck to you.
 
William,

Is this not-to-scale diagram, where the small space between the blocks is understood to be illustrative





a reasonable representation of the forces present on the "upper" and "lower" portions of one of the Twin WTC Towers prior to September 11th, 2001?
 
Strictly speaking, engineering and science are distinct if overlapping disciplines.

Thanks for proving my point, although with the qualifier that there are some fringe segments that may not overlap.

This is really a strange thing to be arguing about.

I couldn't agree more. I was simply pointing out the stupidity of one poster here that kept asking if I was a scientist? lawyer? engineer? by making the obvious statement that engineers are scientists. The person that kept making these incessant 3-part inquiries either (1) knew that engineers were scientists, but purposefully separated them in an attempt to score rhetorical points, or (2) did not know engineers were scientists, and thus is an idiot.

In either case, the difference needed to be pointed out. The resulting argument, however, did not need to occur. Luckily for the poster I was correcting, s/he tows the JREF company line around here vis-a-vis conspiracy theories, and consequently others rushed to his/her defense by attempting to "prove" me wrong on a point I was obviously correct on.
 
William,

Is this not-to-scale diagram, where the small space between the blocks is understood to be illustrative


[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1404546070e684f429.png

[/URL]

a reasonable representation of the forces present on the "upper" and "lower" portions of one of the Twin WTC Towers prior to September 11th, 2001?

The starting boundary conditions will look something like below.

The Total Force Ft is proportional to the Total Mass Mt, g and the height of structure above the reference represented by the ratio h/419.

The nature of the structure as described in NIST is that 50% of the load is carried by the core and the outer walls carry the remaining 50% (this ratio has previously been quoted at 60 to 40 but I'll go with the latest NIST estimate). I have therefore distibuted the total load on the basis of an evenly distributed 50% load in the core and two 25% loads on each outer wall.

I have included a representation of the top hat structure to show connectivity between the core and the outer wall.

Also included to maintain equilibrium are the reaction forces Rt1 to 3 in the lower structure.

I have also assumed no lateral loads as per your original analysis.

It is also significant for this 2D representation that the core is a rectangle with sides of 41m and 26m. I have not attempted to represent this in scale.

To get an idea of the aspect ratio I have attempted to put a bitmap to scale in the second picture. Also included in yellow are scaled representations of the core structure. WTC 1 was struck in a direction perpendicular to the major axis of the core and WTC2 was struck to the side of the core wall in a direction aligned with the major axis. I have also included in red the estimated impact heights.
 

Attachments

  • Tower.jpg
    Tower.jpg
    18 KB · Views: 2
  • Tower 2.jpg
    Tower 2.jpg
    7.3 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
As for new poster Golden Bear, I'm not inclined to offer a detailed reply, seeing as you didn't really rebut my whitepaper so much as reject its premise

While I appreciate your flattery, I heartily disagree on this point -- to rise to such a position of influence, and to carry out such a vast conspiracy, requires not only uncommon intelligence, but also practice. This has nothing to do with the intelligence, real or imagined, of individual elected leaders, whom I think you also underestimate. Furthermore, your conduct over the past ten pages has spiked any interest I might have had in a more detailed discussion. Instead, let me simply offer a few gripes I have with your response:

What's wrong with rejecting a premise, so long as it is accompanied by specific reasons for doing so? Premise is a legitimate topic of discussion, especially a hypothetical argument like your OP.

You refer to many of my argued points as "strawmen:"

They are not strawmen.

One way to make a strawman argument is to present a position that is poorly defended or not defensible (ie. those that believe in space beams or no planes), easily defeat those arguments, and take the position that everyone that is in any way associated with the defender of the weak position you have just defeated have themselves been defeated. This is what you did by presenting these theories that only someone who was clinically insane could believe.

I still maintain my belief that you are smart enough to know that an extremely small section of the so-called "truth movement" believes these ridiculous theories. They are easy to knock down, impossible to defend, and they added a little bulk to your post. That's exactly why you included them.

2. I'm still perplexed at how someone claiming to be educated in chemical engineering could so readily believe that explosives, exposed to the incredible fires resulting from aircraft collisions, would be functionally unaffected. You should know better than I that this simply isn't true, and most definitely would pose an enormous operational risk. No further comment regarding the ridiculous nature of your preferred theory should be necessary.

I've never personally closely studied explosives, nor would I have any way of knowing what explosive technology the military has come up with. From the research I have done, I have seen some high powered explosives listed as being shock and temperature "insensitive". I have no way of knowing exactly what explosives they used, but obviously Evil Genius would have made sure there was little risk of the explosives being damaged or destroyed.

Moreover, apparently one of the demolitions didn't go perfectly. The top of one of the towers tilted quite a bit before falling straight down. This is an indication of an imperfect demolition job. Perhaps some displaced or functionally damaged explosives didn't go off at the right time, causing the tilt, before the explosions lower down from the impact zone, undamaged by the impact, removed all columnar support and righted the upper section.

3. I'm even more fascinated by your claim, referenced above, that Sept. 11th wasn't carried out by Evil Genius at all, but rather Evil Idiots. What this implies is that, in your personal theory, the organizers plotted for years in secret, and had the resources to buy, hire, threaten, or use and then disappear whatever talent they wanted:

At no time did I say the people running our country are Idiots. I'm just saying they are no smarter, on average, than you or me or anyone else that has gone to college. They are people who are extremely rich, well connected, typically good public speakers, and reasonably intelligent. Also, most of them are power hungry and/or egomaniacs.

While you are correct that it would take an Evil Genius to pull off 9/11 perfectly, it would not take an Evil Genius to think he could pull off 9/11. What it would take is a rich, powerful egomaniac, or a group of them, that think they are smarter than everyone else.

Yet, despite these enormous resources and time spent planning, not one person raised a single criticism of the plan that I did, on my own, in a single day's contemplation? That's what you'd have me believe?

Nowhere did I state that no one raised these concerns or criticisms. What I said is that an Evil Genius egotistical to think he could pull something like this off would have to have been comfortable, in his mind at least, that these risks had been reduced to a level he could accept. Any operation, military or otherwise, has inherent and concomitant risks that something will go wrong (Flight 93?). The decision is whether it is a risk worth taking. Obviously neither you nor I would have taken these risks, but that's because we could be more risk-averse than Evil Genius. In fact, my risk-aversion would probably have led me to avoid starting the current war in Iraq. This war was risky, but it was a risk the powers-that-be were willing to take.

As you rejected my premise outright, I now reject yours. And I believe you'll find my opinion is the more carefully considered.

Actually, if you would read my entire response, it does not entirely hinge upon Evil Genius not being as intelligent or cunning as you have given him credit for. In many cases I pointed out how the risks could have been reduced or eliminated by an intelligent Evil Genius. And, no, I don't find your opinion is the more carefully considered, as outlined in detail in my original response.
 
Thanks for proving my point, although with the qualifier that there are some fringe segments that may not overlap.



I couldn't agree more. I was simply pointing out the stupidity of one poster here that kept asking if I was a scientist? lawyer? engineer? by making the obvious statement that engineers are scientists. The person that kept making these incessant 3-part inquiries either (1) knew that engineers were scientists, but purposefully separated them in an attempt to score rhetorical points, or (2) did not know engineers were scientists, and thus is an idiot.

In either case, the difference needed to be pointed out. The resulting argument, however, did not need to occur. Luckily for the poster I was correcting, s/he tows the JREF company line around here vis-a-vis conspiracy theories, and consequently others rushed to his/her defense by attempting to "prove" me wrong on a point I was obviously correct on.
I missed the point. No educated person would be able to support the fact less CT world called the 9/11 truth movement. A lawyer, scientist, and engineer should be capable of rational, logical thought, based on facts. As you have proven, with numerous posts, I was wrong.
 
Last edited:
I see that my efforts to get Golden Bear back to the issue of the tower stories above each impact zone and their effect upon falling downwards at each point of collapse have been largely ignored. I'm PMing Architect to see if he wished to join the (off-topic) discussion sort of in progress.
 
The starting boundary conditions will look something like below.

The nature of the structure as described in NIST is that 50% of the load is carried by the core and the outer walls carry the remaining 50% (this ratio has previously been quoted at 60 to 40 but I'll go with the latest NIST estimate). I have therefore distibuted the total load on the basis of an evenly distributed 50% load in the core and two 25% loads on each outer wall.

Are we simplyfing the model to ignore the component of the load carried by the outer wall sections that are parallel to the plane of the drawing?



In other words is the "outer load" distributed over the blue area I show above or as per your original diagram?

I have also assumed no lateral loads as per your original analysis.

Are there any lateral loads pre-crash you would include?
 
Last edited:
Are we simplyfing the model to ignore the component of the load carried by the outer wall sections that are parallel to the plane of the drawing?

[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/14045460ca975920c3.png[/URL]

In other words is the "outer load" distributed over the blue area I show above or as per your original diagram?

Are there any lateral loads pre-crash you would include?

If you wish to make the model 3D I have no objections but my Windows Paint skills aren't up to it so we'll have to use our imaginations for that. Maybe I can revert to scanning sketches if we go down that road as I am a better at drawing with a pencil.

I have no objections to adding lateral loads but at this stage I am happy to assume no buckling load or wind load.
 
Did you address the insurance money from the Twin Towers? Sorry, but I don't go click on several dozen links you provide. Provide a succinct statement of your belief and we can talk.

Regardless of whether Larry has received a dime to this day, it doesn't mean he didn't THINK he could get away with it beforehand. Maybe it didn't go according to plan. Again, these are not evil "geniuses". They are just real people who are politically connected and rich.
No facts when you started and less now. Why tap dance around your real ideas?

What are your true ideas on 9/11. The complete single integrated operation plan for 9/11? Can you post what you think happened on 9/11 with details and evidence.

 
If you wish to make the model 3D I have no objections but my Windows Paint skills aren't up to it so we'll have to use our imaginations for that. Maybe I can revert to scanning sketches if we go down that road as I am a better at drawing with a pencil.

Nothing wrong with sticking to the 2D version for simplicity and practicality, so long as we both agree that it's limited and for certain calculations we may have to revisit the cross-section load distribution.

I have no objections to adding lateral loads but at this stage I am happy to assume no buckling load or wind load.

Agreed on the wind load, and since this is the static "before" condition - no buckling load.

Since is now becoming a full fledged topic of it's own, do you wish to open a new Forum thread for this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom