Anyway, it never fails...
Never.
Every time I go on vacation for a week, by the time I get back, my once beautiful thread has been savaged by Troother philistines, diluting my message with odium and off-topic bickering. Alas, the Forum environment is a cold sea, and cruel to a young thread.
Nonetheless, my thanks to those who appreciated my original post. It appears even those in the Truth Movement enjoyed it, although the point seems to have escaped them to varying degrees.
As for new poster
Golden Bear, I'm not inclined to offer a detailed reply, seeing as you didn't really rebut my whitepaper so much as reject its premise -- namely, you
claimed that in all likelihood, the perpetrators of Sept. 11th were not Evil Geniuses at all, but in fact stupider than I:
The first mistake is your use of the moniker “Genius” to describe the planner(s) of 9/11. While many people may assume that those who rise to power in this country are the best and brightest we have to offer, this simply is not the case. [...] Notice that nowhere is super-intelligence listed there (again, look at our current leader). Of course they need some modicum of intelligence in order to succeed politically. However, it hardly takes a “genius” to rise to positions of power in the U.S., and, I would argue, the most important considerations are money and political connections. In fact, judging your intelligence from this post alone, I would say you are probably more intelligent than many, if not most, of the people that run this country. Thus, I think you may have given too much credit to the Evil Genius which is the topic of this post.
While I appreciate your flattery, I heartily disagree on this point -- to rise to such a position of influence, and to carry out such a vast conspiracy, requires not only uncommon intelligence, but also practice. This has nothing to do with the intelligence, real or imagined, of individual elected leaders, whom I think you also underestimate. Furthermore, your conduct over the past ten pages has spiked any interest I might have had in a more detailed discussion. Instead, let me simply offer a few gripes I have with your response:
1. You refer to many of my argued points as "strawmen:"
It’s very interesting and telling that you began with the ridiculous straw man “no planes” argument. I know it is great cannon fodder for official story defenders, but surely you of all people are smart enough to realize that no one with half a brain thinks that no planes hit the towers.
These are obvious strawmen. As with no planes, surely you are smart enough to know that no one really believes any of this.
They are
not strawmen. Look, I went to extreme lengths to
document where I found these ideas. I did not make them up, not a single one of them. This is all covered in the footnotes in my OP. I even explained
why I went to all the trouble, viz. because some malcontent would just cry
"Strawman!" as a way of dodging the argument if I didn't. Well, I referenced myself, and you did it anyway.
These arguments are not "strawmen" just because you personally think they're stupid. I think they're
all stupid. It's only a "strawman" if I've misrepresented my opponents as a means to support my argument. I haven't misrepresented anything. If it bothers you that people in your precious Truth Movement believe such idiotic things, then perhaps you need to examine your Movement. Don't complain about me.
Folks in the Truth Movement do this all the time -- just see Alex Jones on video with Gravy at Ground Zero if you don't believe me. You need to learn what a "strawman" is before you use that word again. You, as in you personally,
Golden Bear.
2. I'm still perplexed at how someone
claiming to be educated in chemical engineering could so readily believe that explosives, exposed to the incredible fires resulting from aircraft collisions, would be
functionally unaffected. You should know better than I that this simply isn't true, and most definitely would pose an enormous operational risk. No further comment regarding the ridiculous nature of your preferred theory should be necessary.
3. I'm even more fascinated by your claim, referenced above, that Sept. 11th wasn't carried out by Evil Genius at all, but rather Evil Idiots. What this implies is that, in your personal theory, the organizers plotted for years in secret, and had the resources to buy, hire, threaten, or use and then disappear whatever talent they wanted:
If Evil Genius has the resources to pull off 9/11, he probably also has the resources to pay off and/or intimidate key editors and journalists to maintain the cover-up. [...] You are absolutely correct that the Evil Genius has such vast resources at his disposal, that it will extremely difficult, if not impossible, to expose the conspiracy. However, I think most that believe 9/11 was an inside job are doing what they think is right, and hoping for the best.
Yet, despite these enormous resources and time spent planning,
not one person raised a single criticism of the plan that I did, on my own, in a single day's contemplation? That's what you'd have me believe?
As you rejected my premise outright, I now reject yours. And I believe you'll find my opinion is the more carefully considered.
-----
Again, thanks to all who enjoyed my whitepaper. The battle certainly seems to be winding down on scientific grounds -- I haven't seen anything worth responding to in weeks -- which led me to this argument instead. I find the responses so far to be encouraging.