Ban circumcision in San Fran???

you accused there four VERY esteemed and VERY professional organizations, of having the views they do simply because they are probably filled with Jews. and if they are not filled with Jews, then the Jews that are there have threatened to label anyone who questions them on these issues, an anti-Semite.


No, I didn't. I said one or two people push this sort of crap, and the rest sit on their hands for fear of being vilified. Nothing about anybody threatening anyone. One only needs to observe your behaviour right now to see how this fear can be well-founded without anyone saying a word.

you argue this, with no evidence. just mere speculation. and then you add in this BS about kosher-slaughter rituals, as if that has ANYTHING to do with the thread.

don't act all shocked if someone accuses you of anti-Semitism, when you CHOOSE to express anti-Semitism.


I said I was speculating. And yes, child abuse and animal abuse often go hand in hand, so I think it has a lot to do with the thread.

And if objecting to child abuse and animal abuse is anti-Semitic, in your view, then I think you have more problems than you realise.

Rolfe.
 
Too bad. It's gone there. You could have tried answering the serious points I and others were making, but no....


Yup, it's gone there because of Thunder's "my people, right or wrong, and see how fine I am" position, devoid of any honest debate. It's completely futile to engage the fellow, like Legend has experienced in good faith.
 
Yup, those damn Juden volk. :rolleyes:


Would you like another chip for the other shoulder to balance yourself up?

You do realise you're giving a perfect example of just what I was talking about, don't you? If it's "Jewish" child abuse or animal abuse, nobody dare object, because someone will bring up the holocaust.

So who Godwinned this thread - you or me?

Rolfe.
 
I knew you'd indicate you'd read that post of mine, even though you have been systematically ignoring everything else I posted in this thread.

as to your silly and strange accusation of being ignored by me, you are 100% wrong.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270642#post7270642

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270476#post7270476

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270500#post7270500

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270507#post7270507

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270537#post7270537

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270463#post7270463

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7270079#post7270079

Too bad. It's gone there. You could have tried answering the serious points I and others were making, but no....

soo, you decided to go down the road of anti-Semitism, due to an imaginary sense of being ignored. nice.
 
Last edited:
And if objecting to child abuse and animal abuse is anti-Semitic, in your view, then I think you have more problems than you realise.

what a massive and pathetic strawman.

oh, and what problems do I have? please inform me....I'm very curious.
 
I think, quod erat demonstrandum.

I said plenty about circumcision earlier in the thread.

And you will note that I didn't criticize you for any of that. You know why? Because that was legitimate argument.

Well, I don't care. I'm against child abuse and I'm against animal cruelty, no matter who does it, and you don't get a pass from me by bleating "anti-Semitism".

Evidently you DO care about who does it, or you wouldn't have even mentioned the prevalence of Jewish doctors. If this claim of yours is to be believed, then the fact that their Jewish doesn't make it any different than if they had been athiest, or druid, or whatever.

And the obvious fact is I'm NOT calling your posts antisemitic because you attacked circumcision. I called your posts antisemitic because you DID, in fact, try to single out people for criticism because they're Jewish. So I frankly DON'T believe this claim of yours that you don't care who does it, because you're acting like you care a lot.
 
One only needs to observe your behaviour right now to see how this fear can be well-founded without anyone saying a word.

wait, so now its MY fault, as a Jew, that you decided to LIE about me ignoring all of your posts, and then blaim the findings and opinions of the BMA, AAP, NIH, and NEJM, on Jewish dominance and/or threats? wow.

holy guacamole.

at the very least, are you going to apologize to me for falsely-accusing me of ignoring all of your posts?
 
Last edited:
You do realise you're giving a perfect example of just what I was talking about, don't you? If it's "Jewish" child abuse or animal abuse, nobody dare object, because someone will bring up the holocaust.

No, Rolfe. You don't get to post antisemitic posts and get a free pass. This isn't about you objecting to circumcision. NONE of my criticism of you is about your opposition to circumcision. The fact that you're portraying my criticism as being about circumcision allows you to pretend to be the victim, but that's a lie. I didn't call your posts antisemitic until, well, they started to actually be antisemitic.
 
ok, back to the thread.

anyone here got any info from an esteemed and widely-respected Western agency or organization, that believes that baby-male circumcision clearly causes more harm than good, and should be discouraged if not made illegal?

if so, please post a link to the article/report..and quote a paragraph or two from its summary.

thanks.
 
Last edited:
And you will note that I didn't criticize you for any of that. You know why? Because that was legitimate argument.


But, did I see you acknowledging, or discussing? I don't think so. And Thunder, despite his trawl back through his posts, only cherry-picked points he wanted to address.

How many times did I ask, how many cases of necrotising fasciitis are too many? Never an answer though.

All Thunder could do was misrepresent me, on several occasions.

Evidently you DO care about who does it, or you wouldn't have even mentioned the prevalence of Jewish doctors. If this claim of yours is to be believed, then the fact that their Jewish doesn't make it any different than if they had been athiest, or druid, or whatever.


Look, if atheist or druid doctors were arguing in favour of their own particular flavour of child abuse, I'd be criticising that too. My entire point is that (some, one or two) Jewish doctors on these committees tend to approach the issue from the same viewpoint we have become all too familiar with from Thunder's posts, and that they don't get the vigorous opposition they should get, because they're afraid of being branded anti-Semitic.

I could hardly make that point without mentioning Jewish doctors, you know.

Now you find me these druid doctors who are getting virgin sacrifice a free pass in the BMA guidelines, with the opposition fearing to argue against this for fear of being accused of being anti-druid, and I'll take exactly the same line.

And the obvious fact is I'm NOT calling your posts antisemitic because you attacked circumcision. I called your posts antisemitic because you DID, in fact, try to single out people for criticism because they're Jewish. So I frankly DON'T believe this claim of yours that you don't care who does it, because you're acting like you care a lot.


I pointed out that when people with Thunder's outlook get into a position of authority in the medical profession (and in politics), they tend to promote these views. And that such is the fear of being attacked as anti-Semitic, they often don't get the vigorous opposition they should experience.

This is a simple fact. It's the same with homoeopaths, and the fear that opposing those who advocate "integrated medicine" will be branded politically incorrect.

You think you get a free pass to do what you like, because anyone who points out the evil in what you are doing can be vilified as anti-Semitic. Well, not here you don't.

Rolfe.
 
at the very least, are you going to apologize to me for falsely-accusing me of ignoring all of your posts?


Are you going to follow the link I posted several times to the baby with necrotising fasciitis, realise that this was a direct result of a non-therapeutic circumcision, and tell me how many cases like that you think are acceptable jsust so you can exercise your precious "parental rights"?

Rolfe.
 
My entire point is that (some, one or two) Jewish doctors on these committees tend to approach the issue from the same viewpoint we have become all too familiar with from Thunder's posts, and that they don't get the vigorous opposition they should get, because they're afraid of being branded anti-Semitic.

prove it.

I pointed out that when people with Thunder's outlook get into a position of authority in the medical profession (and in politics), they tend to promote these views. And that such is the fear of being attacked as anti-Semitic, they often don't get the vigorous opposition they should experience.

prove it.

You think you get a free pass to do what you like, because anyone who points out the evil in what you are doing can be vilified as anti-Semitic.

prove it.



wow, you seem to be suggesting that the only reason a Gentile doctor would declare male-baby circumcision benign or beneficial, is due to fear of being called an anti-Semite. yikes.
 
No, Rolfe. You don't get to post antisemitic posts and get a free pass. This isn't about you objecting to circumcision. NONE of my criticism of you is about your opposition to circumcision. The fact that you're portraying my criticism as being about circumcision allows you to pretend to be the victim, but that's a lie. I didn't call your posts antisemitic until, well, they started to actually be antisemitic.


If it were druids demanding that they be allowed to carry out virgin sacrifice because it was their religious tradition, or Mormons demanding that they be allowed to marry ten-year-old girls because it's their religious tradition, or anything else like that, I'll add Moslems and halal slaughter as well if it will make you any happier, sure, I'm going to object.

Your reaction to my pointing out how these weasel-worded policies get written is as perfect a demonstration of what I was talking about as could possibly be imagined.

Rolfe.
 
Are you going to follow the link I posted several times to the baby with necrotising fasciitis, realise that this was a direct result of a non-therapeutic circumcision, and tell me how many cases like that you think are acceptable jsust so you can exercise your precious "parental rights"?

one baby has this medical problem. I feel horrible for this baby.

what percent of baby-male circumcisions lead to such a problem?

1%? .001%? .00001%?

oh, and I just LOVE the name of your unbiased, impartial website:

"Circumstitions.com" :p

I link to the New England Journal of Medicine, you link to Circumstitions.com. I don't know what to say.


...try a well-respected medical agency or organization, if you can.
 
Last edited:
Your reaction to my pointing out how these weasel-worded policies get written is as perfect a demonstration of what I was talking about as could possibly be imagined.

weasel-worded policies? who are these weisels wording these policies?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom