Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

When you figure out how to fake 800+ lbs of lunar rocks and soil that have unique and distinct physical characteristics, let us know. "Radiation oven" is not the answer so don't even try that one. It fails to explain gas bubbles inside millions of year old rocks with features from cooling in a low gravity vacuum environment. Also, NASA exchanged samples with the Soviets.

Also, geologists around the world have studied the rocks for decades and not one has ever suggested the rocks have any origin other than lunar. And no, they don't need to look at "another lunar rock" to identify a lunar rock by characteristic features impossible to create on earth.

What I wrote here is wrong. T
hey probably used an artificial atmosphere with at least radioactive 40Argon in order to mislead radioactive dating techniques.

A quote from Age Determinations and Isotopic Abundance Measurements on Lunar Samples, 1970:

The presence of an anomalously large quantity of 40Ar, in a sample of type C breccia precluded the calculation of its K-Ar age.
​

A simple hypothesis for such an anomalously large quantity of 40Argon is an error in the process of "moon rock" baking. The NASA bakers would have mistakenly added too much of the ingredient 40Argon.
Logically consistent creationists are pleased with lunar rocks: The Age of the Moon

It would be quite easy for an unprejudiced scientific research to decide whether Apollo moon rocks are faked, and if yes, to exactly determine how the Apollo moon rock samples were created. Some "moon rocks" are simply special meteorites (or maybe even very special terrestrial stones) which are now called "lunar meteorites". An interesting list of lunar meteorites: List

Secondary meteorites originating from a primary impact on the moon enter our atmosphere with a speed as high as Apollo reentry speed! Thus the high proportion of "lunar" meteorites among all meteorites becomes rather unrealistic. Small pieces catapulted out of the lunar surface and accelerated to more than the moon's escape velocity of 1620 m/s would mostly vaporize in terrestrial atmosphere. Reaching regions close to the poles such as Antarctica is even more improbable. So how is it possible that "0.11% of all meteorite stones found in Antarctica are of lunar origin" (Source)?

Cheers, Wolfgang

Centuries ago, those being knowledgeable and courageous enough to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the Inquisition were hated by those having naïve faith in the Holy Church

You grossly understate the case, in bold above. Remaining crap spoilered for clarity.

The lunar sample repository has 800+ pounds, examined by scientists around the world. The samples compendium has papers written about the samples available for public access. Any Joe Schmoe can go to any university on earth and get a geology degree and access the samples personally.

I don't speak to wogoga, I speak to the ages: there is no way on earth to fake all the characteristics of a moon rock or handful of moon dirt in the same sample. The only way to do it is on the moon.
 
Last edited:
What I wrote here is wrong. They probably used an artificial atmosphere with at least radioactive 40Argon in order to mislead

Or they didn't and you're just taking wild stabs in the dark to mask your ignorance.

A quote from Age Determinations and Isotopic Abundance Measurements on Lunar Samples, 1970:

The presence of an anomalously large quantity of 40Ar, in a sample of type C breccia precluded the calculation of its K-Ar age.

But not the other sample types.

A simple hypothesis for such an anomalously large quantity of 40Argon is an error in the process of "moon rock" baking. The NASA bakers would have mistakenly added too much of the ingredient 40Argon.

Or you are making **** up again.

Describe to us the methodology you think was employed. I have a version of that paper in the original Lunar Science Conference Proceedings, so I can check your version against the authors'.

It would be quite easy for an unprejudiced scientific research to decide whether Apollo moon rocks are faked,

Yes, it would, yet no-one ever has

and if yes, to exactly determine how the Apollo moon rock samples were created. Some "moon rocks" are simply special meteorites (or maybe even very special terrestrial stones) which are now called "lunar meteorites". An interesting list of lunar meteorites: List

If you are implying that the Apollo samples are just meteorites this is not true, because the meteorites differ from Apollo samples in a few key areas.

Secondary meteorites originating from a primary impact on the moon enter our atmosphere with a speed as high as Apollo reentry speed! Thus the high proportion of "lunar" meteorites among all meteorites becomes rather unrealistic.

In which case how come there are enough to make up the Apollo samples? Which is it? Do they exist or not?

Small pieces catapulted out of the lunar surface and accelerated to more than the moon's escape velocity of 1620 m/s would mostly vaporize in terrestrial atmosphere.

And many do - this is why they are rare. Duh!

Reaching regions close to the poles such as Antarctica is even more improbable.

In your uneducated opinion. Give us the odds. Why is it more or less possible than other meteorites?

So how is it possible that "0.11% of all meteorite stones found in Antarctica are of lunar origin(Source)?

Ask yourself how it is that they know the meteorites they find in Antarctica are lunar in origin.

If meteorites can make it down to the surface, why can't an Apollo command module?
 
It would be quite easy for an unprejudiced scientific research to decide whether Apollo moon rocks are faked, and if yes, to exactly determine how the Apollo moon rock samples were created.

So why hasn't it been done? The scientific community speaks with one confirmatory voice on the authenticity of the Apollo specimens. You're once again simply asserting the existence of a Magic Moon Rock Faking Machine without being able to tell how exactly it would work. Because you don't know how any such thing could work, you defer the explanation to unnamed others and declare, without evidence, that it would be easy for them to plug the hole in your argument. Then, disingenuously, you suggest that if they won't, then they're prejudiced. Your argument is purely wishful thinking.

Some "moon rocks" are simply special meteorites...

Nope. ignorant conspiracy theorists often claim this, but a geologist can show you the many differences between lunar meteorites and Apollo samples. Those differences include, but are not limited to, aqueous inflitration, oxidation layers, ionization layers, etc. You're suggesting geologists can't recognize the difference between specimens recovered in situ from long soaks in radically different environments.

Reaching regions close to the poles such as Antarctica is even more improbable. So how is it possible that "0.11% of all meteorite stones found in Antarctica are of lunar origin"

Because you measure that probability against your ignorant and unevidenced expectations, as is the case in your argument at large. You aren't an unsung genius. You aren't a shrewd detective. You're just regurgitating the long-debunked stuff written by previous conspiracy theorists.
 
I said, "no handwaving", wogoga. It's not just that you don't understand how reentry and ablative shielding works. It's that you have no explanation and no evidence for how the actual program was faked; magic moon-rock faking machines (as Jay put it) don't cut it. Heck, you're not even dimly aware of the vast scope of the evidence (including the international scientific consensus) regarding the lunar samples. And no, you're not the first pretend expert with a degree from U. Google.
 
I don't speak to wogoga, I speak to the ages: there is no way on earth to fake all the characteristics of a moon rock or handful of moon dirt in the same sample. The only way to do it is on the moon.

I don't see how faking them on the moon helps. Might as well fake the whole moon.

...hey, wait a minute...
 
Has our pretend expert figured out where the three Luna sample return missions got there stuff from?
 
What I wrote here is wrong.
What you wrote and are still writing is an ignorant fantasy that shows you know nothing at all about geology and the lunar samples, wogoga.
Geologists agree that the lunar samples came from the Moon because of their unique features.
They did not only come from the Apollo missions. Russia had 3 successful lunar sample return missions, Luna 20, etc. China is planning one for 2017.
Moon rocks
The Apollo program collected 380 kilograms (838 lb) of Moon rocks during the six manned missions. Analyses by scientists worldwide all agree that these rocks came from the Moon – no published accounts in peer-reviewed scientific journals exist that dispute this claim. The Apollo samples are easily distinguishable from both meteorites and Earth rocks[7] in that they show a lack of hydrous alteration products, they show evidence of having undergone impact events on an airless body, and they have unique geochemical traits. Furthermore, most are more than 200 million years older than the oldest Earth rocks. The Moon rocks also share the same traits as Soviet samples.[183]
... However, the first Antarctic lunar meteorite was found in 1979, and its lunar origin was not recognized until 1982.[188]
So this "moon rocks faked from lunar meteorites" delusion has to include a time machine :eek:!

Fox TV and the Apollo Moon Hoax
DID WE LAND ON THE MOON? Debunking of the Moon Hoax Theory
Conspiracy Theory: Did We Go to the Moon? is a geologist examining the moon hoax delusion
What leaps out in comparing the two pictures is the complete absence of water-bearing minerals, and the total absence of alteration in the lunar rock. Water is ubiquitous on earth - it's present in magma, rocks deep in the crust are changed by hot fluids, and rocks near the surface are altered by surface water. Olivine in particular is easily altered. In the second picture, the olivine is fractured but the fractures are absolutely clean. You simply do not see unaltered olivine on earth.

This could not have been faked. These rocks have grains easily visible to the unaided eye, which means they cooled slowly. To have made these materials synthetically would have required keeping the rocks at 1100 C for years, cooling them slowly at thousands of pounds per square inch pressure. It would have taken years to create the apparatus, years more to get the hang of making the materials, and then years more to create the final result. Starting from Sputnik I in 1957, there would not have been enough time to do it. And, you'd have to synthesize several different types of rock in hundred-pound lots.
Fake Moon Rocks?
A lunar sample from Apollo 16 called Troctolite... where is the fusion crust?

Not one lunar sample has been melted due to entry into the earth's atmosphere!

Many hoax supporters also claim that only NASA employees are allowed to study moon samples. The picture below is of me studying moon samples. Microscopes are supplied too for free. I do not work for NASA nor do the 15,000 or so estimated number of people a year that see these samples from Britain's National Space Centre.

Lesson; Ask the real experts and don't listen to people making things up.

Apollo 11 Moon landing: conspiracy theories debunked
9) The rocks brought back from the Moon are identical to rocks collected by scientific expeditions to Antarctica.

Some Moon rocks have been found on Earth, but they are all scorched and oxidised from their entry into the Earth’s atmosphere as asteroids. Geologists have confirmed with complete certainty that the Apollo rocks must have been brought from the Moon by man.



Not a surprise given the ignorance and fantasies in this thread, e.g.
20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored 31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
 
Last edited:
Just to emphasize the point about scientists examining lunar samples, this is a photograph of the volumes I own of proceedings from the first 5 lunar science conferences. If I owned all of the volumes there would be another 4 on the shelf. They deal almost exclusively with Apollo lunar samples, with the odd paper on the ones obtained by the USSR thrown in for good measure and some articles on other Apollo data and samples.

14dh4xc.jpg
 
Last edited:
Just to emphasize the point about scientists examining lunar samples, this is a photograph of the volumes I own of proceedings from the first 5 lunar science conferences. If I owned all of the volumes there would be another 4 on the shelf. They deal almost exclusively with Apollo lunar samples, with the odd paper on the ones obtained by the USSR thrown in for good measure and some articles on other Apollo data and samples.

[qimg]http://i66.tinypic.com/14dh4xc.jpg[/qimg]

Is that a hard copy of the papers in the Lunar Samples Compendium?
 
Is that a hard copy of the papers in the Lunar Samples Compendium?

It's research done on the samples and then presented at the conferences. As is the way with academic research it will also have been published in slightly different forms in academic journals. You'll see references to the lunar science conferences at the end of the sample descriptions.

It's pretty dry stuff but I like the pictures :D

Speaking of references, you don't often see them written up like this:

King E.A. and a cast of thousands (1969) Lunar Sample
Information Catalog, Apollo 11. Lunar Receiving
Laboratory, MSC 412 pp

https://curator.jsc.nasa.gov/lunar/lsc/10002.pdf
 
Last edited:
Even if the NASA-baked moon-rocks hypothesis should eventually turn out to be untenable, it remains a legitimate hypothesis for me as long as I do not know of serious objections.

Here are several serious objections:

1) Hundreds of geologists around the world have studied and continue to study the lunar rocks. Not one has ever raised any objection.


"Friendly" researches receive carefully selected, maybe even freshly doctored small samples from NASA, normally in order to deal with one single question. It may be unlikely that no one of the receivers has become suspicious, yet outing suspicions representing scientific taboos is not everyone's hobby.

Take e.g. 9/11. Every unprejudiced scientist with common sense comes to the conclusion that the twin towers and WTC7 have been brought down by explosives, whereas the rest of the WTC buildings such as the Marriott hotel were destroyed in a way expected for steel-frame buildings in the absence of explosives. Nevertheless, if you rely on peer reviewed articles and the mainstream media you get a completely different picture (i.e. a fully disinformative one).


2) If you want to study lunar rocks you can. Nothing is preventing you from getting a geology degree and sending in your request for a specific sample to study.


Quote from The Age of the Moon, scienceagainstevolution.org, 2008:

Even before the Apollo 11 astronauts brought rocks back from the moon, scientists from all over the world were clamoring to get the chance to analyze them. Therefore, NASA gave many scientists the opportunity to write proposals telling how they would analyze the moon rocks if they were given the opportunity. Based on the merit of the proposals and the qualifications of the scientists, they allowed a few select scientists access to the samples.​

Quote from APOLLO MOON ROCKS REVEAL NEW SECRETS, 2014:

In the four decades since the Apollo Moon landings, scientists have studied only about ten percent of the lunar rocks and dust collected by astronauts from 1969 to 1972.​


3) Volcanically created rocks have internal gas pockets. These gas pockets in lunar rocks have physical characteristics which differ greatly from earth rocks of similar chemistry, because they cooled in a different gravity than earth rocks.


"Different gravity" at cooling is quite irrelevant. Relevant are pressure (weight above) and atmospheric composition. I do not doubt that Apollo moon samples on the one hand and genuine moon rocks on the other hand are different from terrestrial rocks. Apollo samples are assumed to be "the result of magmatic degassing during the eruption of lunar magmas into the near-vacuum of the Moon’s surface" leading to "rapidly quenched lunar volcanic glasses".

Quotes from High Pre-Eruptive Water Contents Preserved in Lunar Melt Inclusions, Jul 2011:

Melt inclusions are small samples of magma trapped within crystals that grow in the magma before eruption. By virtue of their enclosure within their host crystals, melt inclusions are protected from loss of volatiles by degassing during magma eruption [or moon-rock baking]. … The most important aspect of our volatile data on lunar melt inclusions is their similarity to melt inclusions from primitive samples of terrestrial mid-ocean ridge basalts, like those recovered from spreading centers located within transform faults; the melt inclusions from [Apollo sample] 74220 are markedly similar to melt inclusions from the Siqueiros Fracture Zone on the East Pacific Rise, some of the most primitive mid-ocean ridge magmas that have been measured.​

Thus we should not apriori exclude a further explanation for "the paradox of identical isotopic compositions of Earth and the Moon" (Science, Jun 2014), namely that Apollo samples are in fact terrestrial. Scientific taboos can do a lot of harm to science!

Cheers, Wolfgang
A compilation of my postings of this thread
 
Take e.g. 9/11. Every unprejudiced scientist with common sense comes to the conclusion that the twin towers and WTC7 have been brought down by explosives, whereas the rest of the WTC buildings such as the Marriott hotel were destroyed in a way expected for steel-frame buildings in the absence of explosives.


Bollocks. Only prejudiced amateurs and fantasists stepping far outside their areas of expertise believe any such thing, and in fact the peer-reviewed literature has comprehensive descriptions of how the collapses really happened that are universally accepted in general terms (while there is understandably some disagreement over the details) within the structural engineering community. I'm not surprised, though, that once you've decided to believe one load of complete rubbish you've jumped straight overboard and swallowed every lunatic theory you can find hook, line and sinker. As long as the conspiracy industry has a good supply of useful idiots, it will continue to bamboozle.

Dave
 
It may be unlikely that no one of the receivers has become suspicious, yet outing suspicions representing scientific taboos is not everyone's hobby.

No, you're still frantically trying to argue, with no evidence, that scientists are either too scared to speak up or too stupid to know their business. That's not an argument. It's a speculative excuse for why the evidence says one thing but you say the opposite.

Take e.g. 9/11. Every unprejudiced scientist with common sense comes to the conclusion that the twin towers and WTC7 have been brought down by explosives...

Utter nonsense. But there you go again with the careful qualification that the only scientists you trust are the "unprejudiced" ones who agree with you. We need no more evidence than that for the filtration of evidence that's going on in your mind.


...they allowed a few select scientists access to the samples.

That was the case forty years ago. How about now?

In the four decades since the Apollo Moon landings, scientists have studied only about ten percent of the lunar rocks and dust collected by astronauts from 1969 to 1972.

Apples and oranges. You're trying desperately to argue the sentiment that the Apollo samples can't have been studied sufficiently to determine their authenticity if only some certain percentage of it has been looked at. You beg the question of what amount is probative. You further insinuate that NASA is being stingy with the samples. To a certain extent that is true, because some research requires pristine specimens and the 400 kg we have has to last for the foreseeable future. But you beg the questions that the meting out precludes effective study, shuts out scientists who may question authenticity, or is for any reason other than responsible curation.

None of that argument addresses the large volume of research that actually exists. You seem to be saying it can't exist because NASA allegedly doles out the specimens or restricts access. But it does exist.

"Different gravity" at cooling is quite irrelevant.

Mostly true. A few researchers once thought this, but modern geology seems to have abandoned that hypothesis.

You concede that there must be differences between real Moon rocks and real Earth rocks. Your smattering of context-free quotes intended to challenge by noting unexpected similarities that both undermines your own argument (i.e., that geologists can study Apollo samples only if they are suitably prejudiced) and fails to support your contention that Moon rocks are necessarily Earth rocks and that geologists wouldn't be able to tell.

And we're still a long, long way from you telling us in suitable detail how your Magic Moonrock Faking Machine -- the one so necessary to your argument -- is supposed to work.
 
Thing is wogoga that Apollo sample 74220 was collected on the moon. The photographs of its sample location are in a magazine that has other photographs - photographs that show details not known prior to the landing, details confirmed by Japanese, Chinese and Indian probes. The magazine also contains time and date specific images of Earth. The sample was found on live TV. The sample has been analysed by a lot of people - see your own link to see them.

All you have for evidence cherry picked misunderstandings and...erm...nothing else - other than fabrications.

Your claim that NASA doctors the samples is false. Your claims that Apollo samples are terrestrial are false. Those kind of fabrications.
 
"Friendly" researches receive carefully selected, maybe even freshly doctored small samples from NASA, normally in order to deal with one single question.

Except that we have lunar samples that are not from the Apollo Missions, and these have been studied and compared to the Apollo samples.

The USSR gained its own sample returns from its rover program, and meteorites have been identified as of having lunar origin due to their similarity to the Apollo and Soviet Samples.

One of the most important finds however was in 1998 when the Lunar Prospector craft surveyed the mineral composition of the lunar surface.

Prior to 1998 it was believed that much of the Lunar surface had a high concentration of Potassium, Rare Earth Elements and Phosphorus, or KREEP. This was because the samples from Apollos 12, 14, and 15 showed these minerals to be in high concentration. Apollo 11, 16 and 17 did not show quite as high levels, with 11 being the highest of those. The results of the 1998 survey revealed the truth. There is a large area of the Earth facing side that is very high in KREEP, while the rest of the surface is low in it. The landing sites for 12, 14, and 15 are inside that area, Apollo 11 landed in a small area just outside of the main area, and 16 and 17 landed in non-KREEP regions, just as their samples showed. There is no way that anyone at NASA could have known this composition prior to 1998, yet the rock samples are correct to the Lunar Prospector map.

Now of course you could suggest that NASA faked the map, but this raises few questions. Why would you change the recipes for the samples from 12, 14 and 15? Why would you fake a map that any country that gains the ability to survey the moon with their own satellites (i.e, Russia, Japan, China, India) can replicate and show that you faked the mapping?

You can learn more about Lunar Meteorites here, and more about How we know a rock is a moon rock here.
 
wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "selected" samples etc.

"Friendly" researches receive carefully selected, maybe even freshly doctored small samples from NASA, normally in order to deal with one single question.
17 November 2016 wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "doctored", "selected" , "small" samples.

Any researcher can receive any Moon rock to use responsibly to answer as many questions that they like. Many of the Moon rocks are not even held by NASA :jaw-dropp! Geologists can for example go to Britain's National Space Centre and look at samples through microscopes.

Fox TV and the Apollo Moon Hoax
DID WE LAND ON THE MOON? Debunking of the Moon Hoax Theory
Conspiracy Theory: Did We Go to the Moon? is a geologist examining the moon hoax delusion.
Fake Moon Rocks? is an other geologist and "The picture below is of me studying moon samples"
Apollo 11 Moon landing: conspiracy theories debunked

The other ignorance and fantasies in this thread include
20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored 31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom