Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
26 April 2018: A lie that a paper is on his "electrostaticly disrupting the nucleus" delusion.
This is a paper about grains:



A 1981 paper may not be valid 37 yars later. 19 citations in 37 years suggests not. On the other hand one citation is a recent one on 67P.

26 April 2018: An "the effect is scalable" lie (no scalable in the abstract).


Sorry RC, it is hard is'nt!
 
The ELECTRIC COMET model is as follows:

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust (Rock or stone is a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids.)
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust has a size in the range 80to800µm (After being electrostatically machined off of the surface, otherwise it's "consolidated dust", Rock. see 1a)

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero (up to 105 range)
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are double layers at comets

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is negatively charged (can also be positive, this is seen in the data as well. this dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets (The "jets" are as we observe)

7) neutrals go along for the ride

8) the jets form the comets' comas (Double layers form the different regions or boundaries in cometary coma)


My comment in red
 
Quote:
The ELECTRIC COMET model is as follows:

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust (Rock or stone is a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids.)
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust has a size in the range 80to800µm (After being electrostatically machined off of the surface, otherwise it's "consolidated dust", Rock. see 1a)

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero (up to 105 range)
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are double layers at comets

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is negatively charged (can also be positive, this is seen in the data as well. this dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets (The "jets" are as we observe)

7) neutrals go along for the ride

8) the jets form the comets' comas (nested/stairstep/Double layers form the different regions or boundaries in cometary coma)

My comment in red
 
Quote:
The ELECTRIC COMET model is as follows:

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust (cart before the horse, sport. The very well consolidated dust is Rock or stone is a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids.)
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust has a size in the range 80to800µm (After being electrostatically machined off of the surface, otherwise it's "consolidated dust", Rock. see 1a)

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero (up to 105 range. For ziggurat 100’s of thousands of volts, Though not as a straight line (classic electrostatics) but in you guessed it DOUBLE LAYERS. See 3d )
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are double layers at comets (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor)

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System (the Suns radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance)

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is negatively charged (can also be positive, this is seen in the data as well. this dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets (The "jets" are as we observe)

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)

8) the jets form the comets' comas (no the double layers do, see 3D. nested/stairstep/Double layers form the different regions or boundaries in cometary coma)

My comment in brackets.

Just needed to emphasise the double layers above and the neutrals and the premise of the ELECTRIC SUN and clarifie 1a

Sorry there may be more clarifications but not wholesale changes. Pretty good summary otherwise, jt.
 
Last edited:
Is there a less wieldy way of maintaing the list RC?

Your the expert, in this field RC.
 
Last edited:
From H.Laakso paper, Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley I'd postulate 5 orders of magnitude as the range of potential difference involved in comets.

Though the variables involved would make a solid figure impossible.

5 orders of magnitude doesn't even vaguely resemble a solid figure. But even here, you still can't say which 5 orders. Are we talking between 1 volt and 100,000 volts? 100,000 volts and 10,000,000,000 volts?

Hell, do you even understand the question?

So one would ask how many m2 are involved in this estimate?

Why are you asking me about your model? I don't know how your model is supposed to work.
 
5 orders of magnitude doesn't even vaguely resemble a solid figure. But even here, you still can't say which 5 orders. Are we talking between 1 volt and 100,000 volts? 100,000 volts and 10,000,000,000 volts?

Hell, do you even understand the question?



Why are you asking me about your model? I don't know how your model is supposed to work.


Updated 3a for you ziggurat.

But yeah you got it, 1v to 100’s of thousands of volts potential difference. Depending on it’s heliocentric distance and the solar wind.

Oh and btw not my model M.Volwerk et al. Currents in Cometary Comae and Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma, go read ‘em!


Go on you ask him how many m2 we are talking about here, ball park ‘ill do.

We than get some idea over the overall amperage we are talking about here, you know so it can do “work”.

Like turning rock into finely divided dust and accelerating off of the nucleus!

Just for an instance!
 
Last edited:
Updated 3a for you ziggurat.

But yeah you got it, 1v to 100’s of thousands of volts potential difference. Depending on it’s heliocentric distance and the solar wind.

That's a pretty worthless estimate.

Oh and btw not my model M.Volwerk et al. Currents in Cometary Comae and Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma, go read ‘em!

I just did. Nothing in the paper suggests it's about an "electric comet" in the sense that you mean it.

Go on you ask him how many m2 we are talking about here, ball park ‘ill do.

You don't have to ask. You can estimate it from the data in the paper. But most of that current never touches the comet.

We than get some idea over the overall amperage we are talking about here, you know so it can do “work”.

Like turning rock into finely divided dust and accelerating off of the nucleus!

Just for an instance!

The current density is measured in nanoAmps/m2. How much work do you think that's capable of doing? Especially if the voltage is, say, just 1.
 
Thanks for the many comments and clarifications on my summary of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory, as it also been referred to), Sol88.

Likely I won’t have a chance to fold them in to a revised version until tomorrow.

In the meantime... BUMP

Thanks Sol88, it's a nice, short, review paper.

Sadly, however, I did not see any "statement by Vorontsov-Velgaminov". Perhaps you could quote it?


We can?

I don't see how Belton (1999) helps you answer the question I asked. Here it is again:

Why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

Oh, and a reminder as to why this is important: the ELECTRIC COMET model, which I've just updated to include a recent post by you, starts with the word "comets". To have a discussion of this model, it is necessary - critical, in fact - that we all understand what this means (in the model). And in this context, knowing whether what is called, by astronomers, the "return" of a comet is the same "rocky object" or not.
Would you please answer the question in red?

And an answer on the “statement by Vorontsov-Velgaminov” would be nice too.
 
Ziggurat said:
You don't have to ask. You can estimate it from the data in the paper. But most of that current never touches the comet.
.

indeed you can, time of the crossing times velocity of plasma, choose a reasonable length and bezinga!

1 minute * 10 km/s * 1500 km (cometosheathsize) ~ 100 amps, which will be a great overestimate so this should not be taken seriously

indeed also, no the currents in my paper do not go to or touch the comet

and now i am off to nepal
 
Last edited:
indeed you can, time of the crossing times velocity of plasma, choose a reasonable length and bezinga!

1 minute * 10 km/s * 1500 km (cometosheathsize) ~ 100 amps, which will be a great overestimate so this should not be taken seriously

indeed also, no the currents in my paper do not go to or touch the comet

and now i am off to nepal

Really :rolleyes:

Small passage for the totally ignorant...

Identifying the origin of the suprathermal electron populationdeliverscluestothephysicalmechanismbehindtheir acceleration or heating in the collisionless coma. Two mechanisms have been discussed in literature thus far: (i) heating of electrons through wave particle interactions, such as the singing comet waves (understood as an ion Weibel instability [43,52]) or lower hybrid waves [45], and (ii) the acceleration of electrons along the ambipolar electric field [29]. In the second scenario, solar wind electrons traveling toward the comet fall into the potential well that is generated by the gradient in electron number density [53,54]. Electrons born inside, i.e., the cometary electrons, are trapped unless they carry enough energy to escape. The potential scales as the electron thermal energy [29]; hence, only suprathermal electrons will be able to escape the nearcomet environment. Note that this interpretation is valid on subion time scales only, as quasineutrality will act such that electrons must eventually leave the potential well. Without ruling out the influence of wave particle interactions, our simulation favors the ambipolar electric field model, though this may not be the case at other activity phases of the comet.
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Jan Decca

28mhz5.jpg
 
Last edited:
Anyway have a ball in Nepal, tusenfem.

Hope your paper is published whilst your breathing the thinner air.
 
Last edited:
Sorry RC, it is hard is'nt!
It is very easy. A history of over 9 years of ignorance, lies and delusions means that we can start by assuming that posts from you are ignorant, lying or deluded. A few minutes and this is usually found to be the case.

26 April 2018: A lie that a paper is on his "electrostaticly disrupting the nucleus" delusion.
26 April 2018: An "the effect is scalable" lie (no scalable in the abstract).

881 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 23 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
2 December 2014: Sol88 does not notice that Wal Thornhill narrates an ignorant and deluded video about 67P!
18 December 2014: The bad science and delusions in Newton’s Electric Clockwork Solar System by Wal Thornhill.
5 January 2015: Wal Thornhill makes up fantasies about comets
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
Totally lies that ambioolar electric fields = double layers again

Small passage for the totally ignorant...
No one who reads recent posts in this thread is ignorant that you are persistently repeating a ambipolar electric field = double layer lie.
27 April 2018: Totally lies that ambipolar electric field = double layer again :jaw-dropp!

This is a lie lasting a week (so far) which is better then the almost 9 years old comet are rocks lie.
20 April 2018: A "All double layers are electric fields" lie when replying to a "ambipolar electric field" post.
24th April 2018, tusenfem: So, no an ambipolar elelctric field is not a double layer.
26 April 2018: Multiple "electron beam or "jets"" lies about a tusenfem post.
 
Last edited:
Really :rolleyes:

Small passage for the totally ignorant...

[snip]solar wind electrons traveling toward the comet fall into the potential well that is generated by the gradient in electron number density[snip]

Huh. Where have I heard about lower potentials before?

Anywhoo, I’ve always said the comet is at a lower potential than the solar wind it is currently moving thru!

You're both using similar terminology. Looks kind of like there's agreement.

Except for one small problem. Electrons are negatively charged.

Why is that a problem? Because it means that a potential energy well for electrons is actually a HIGHER voltage area, not a lower voltage area. So if electrons are trapped by the potential of the comet, that means that the comet is actually at a higher electric potential than the surrounding solar wind.

I do believe you have everything backwards.
 
Really :rolleyes:

Small passage for the totally ignorant...

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Jan Decca

i guess by the "totally ignorant" you mean yourself
trying, as usual, to combine two totally unrelated topics, current sheets generated by magnetic field gradients, and supra thermal electrons escaping the inner region of the comet and generating an ambipolar electric field (which is not a double layer)
i really need some time off here
 
Thought i’d add this montage doing the rounds at the moment.

rosettasurface.gif



Sublimating ‘Ice”?

Or

Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies X. Wang1,2, J. Schwan1,2, H.-W. Hsu1,2, E. Grün1,2, and M. Horányi1,2

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko T. I. Gombosi1,J.L.Burch2,andM.Horányi

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa,b

I believe this is from the Hapi region.

And for context this it what we see when we zoom out a little

original-1518434244.jpg


ESA/Rosetta/MPS for OSIRIS Team MPS/UPD/LAM/IAA/SSO/INTA/UPM/DASP/IDA
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom