Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
My god! you have no idea what MHD is!
Just saying "MHD does not apply" does not mean that you actually know what MDH is.

Here is the original Alfvén paper in which he introduced the concept of MHD waves.

Okay, I am going to hate myself for doing this, but I cannot stand the idiocy of sol making claims without actually showing he understands what the concept of MHD is.

So, what every first-year student learns in "introduction to plasma physics" course is the MDH approximation of the plasma physics equations. This means that you do not look at the motion of individual particles, but like the name says, you assume that the plasma is a fluid. This means that the regular equations are averaged over the motion of the particles.

This means that MHD is only applicable if you look at spatial scales that are larger than the largest ion gyro radius and if you look at time scales that are longer than the longest ion gyro period.

So, basically, you have a multi fluid situation, with an electron fluid and a (multi-)ion fluid.

Now, Alfvén made an extra assumption in his paper, namely that the plasma conductivity σ = ∞ (infinitely conducting). If you do that, then you find that this results into E + v x B = 0, which leads to the interesting situation that the plasma and the magnetic field are frozen in.

Of course, space plasmas are very highly conducting, but not infinitely, so this leads to so-called "resistive MHD" in contrast to "ideal MHD" that Aflven wrote up in his 1942 paper. That certainly changes a few things, adding resistivity into the system. For example, then there are restrictions on the frozen in condition. One can only speak of the field being frozen in the plasma as long as you look at time scales which are below the magnetic diffusion time scale. This is basically the inverse of the conductivity.

In ideal MHD, there cannot be parallel electric fields, because of the infinite conductivity. However, does that exclude parallel electric currents? Currents, we know from Maxwell's equations, are either generated by a time varying electric field or by a changing magnetic field:

curl(B) = mu ( J + epsilon dE/dt )

so if something happens to the magnetic field, for example the foot points of a loop can shear, and thereby generate currents.

For the rest I would just point to the excellent chapter by Eric Priest in the Saas-Fee Advanced Course Lecture Notes (which can be found on the internet as pdf)

So actually it is very very simple what MDH means, and how it should be applied, and which limitations there are (and indeed very few of my colleagues seem to forget now and then these limitations, unfortunately)

For instance :blush:
 
Just in case Indagator is not fully up to speed with what has been claimed by the actual proponents of this EC 'model' (rather than their fanboys), and has been shown to be wrong, here are a couple of relevant links:

The definitive outline of this preposterous woo:
http://www.thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf

The 'predictions', on this forum, of one of the co-authors of the aforementioned preposterous woo:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10359420&postcount=2441

If you do an advanced search on 'David Talbott', showing posts only, then you may garner some further information from the horse's mouth. Assuming that part of the body was where this nonsense actually emanated.
 
Last edited:
For instance WHAT? Yes, we know Tusenfem understands plasma physics. So what? What has that got to do with the non-existent electric comet?


Would you like to ask the papers lead author and super duper space plasma physicist what, from the paper
and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure. A tail like no other The RPC-MAG view of Rosetta's tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. M.Volwerk et al
kinetic effects we should expect?
 
Last edited:
A lie that a "Rosetta’s tail excursion" paper is to do with his many comet delusions

ok then from the new paper ...
Replies to a post including "Remember! This is all about you and YOUR model!" with
18 June 2018: A lie that a "Rosetta’s tail excursion" paper is to do with his many comet delusions.

More than 980 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 25 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Another lying question about the "A tail like no other" paper

Would you like to ask the papers lead author and super duper space plasma physicist what, from the paper kinetic effects we should expect?
18 June 2018: Another lying question about the "A tail like no other" paper to detail from his many comet delusions.

The A tail like no other paper is that the late stage tail of 67P is distinctive from other tails the tails of other comets.
Results. It is found that comet 67P does not have a classical draped magnetic field and no bi-lobal tail structure at this late stage of the mission when the comet is already at 2.7 AU distance from the Sun. The main magnetic field direction seems to be more across the tail direction, which may implicate an asymmetric pick-up cloud. During periods of singing comet activity the propagation direction of the waves is at large angles with respect to the magnetic field and to the radial direction towards the comet. Turbulent cascade of magnetic energy from large to small scales is different in the presence of singing as without it

There is a probable lie by quote mining part of a sentence: "and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure" (my emphasis added). The missing context should be the reasons for the kinetic effects in the tail structure being expected.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
@RC

There is a probable lie by quote mining part of a sentence: "and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure" (my emphasis added). The missing context should be the reasons for the kinetic effects in the tail structure being expected.

What kinetic plasma effects should we expect then sport?
 
So what? Do you know what "kinetic effects" means? And if yes, what do you conclude from that?

Just quoting me Yoda style does not impress.

I thought we'd ask the expert?

let's start with the basics, what are kinetic effect wrt plasma at/around a comet?
 
^^^^^^^

Ummmm.....I don’t know.

I reckon this has something to do with it...
So, what every first-year student learns in "introduction to plasma physics" course is the MDH approximation of the plasma physics equations. This means that you do not look at the motion of individual particles, but like the name says, you assume that the plasma is a fluid. This means that the regular equations are averaged over the motion of the particles.
tusenfem.

Now all us layman first year students know what MHD is and where it is and is not applied but what’s this kinetic effects in the near tail region plasma?

So I thought we’d ask the expert?
 
Last edited:
So I thought we’d ask the expert?

So, I'll ask again; of what relevance is it to the electric comet woo? What is the big deal about how a bunch of ionised water (which shouldn't be there in EU wooistry) behaves as a plasma in the tail? What does the electric comet model say should be happening?
 
So I thought we’d ask the expert?

Great idea, Sol88! Let's ask the experts ....

tusenfem! Good Sir! You are under no obligation to "answer me these questions three ..."

However, if you choose to ...

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ... Yes/No

Now your turn, Sol88! As the resident expert in the electric comet, please ...

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No

I am so looking forward to your expert answers, and your expert predictive mathematical model! Share with us your wisdom, Sol88! Show us the value of your electric comet!
 
let's start with the basics, what are kinetic effect wrt plasma at/around a comet?

So, now the electric comet thread has turned into a free online plasma physics course for the benefit of Sol88? I can see how this is useful as a way to avoid the questions raised by JT and Indigator, but it is rather transparent, and may give Indigator an idea of what to expect, and the reason why this thread still exists, despite its subject matter having been debunked multiple times by observation from numerous missions.
So, why not refer to the literature to try to figure out what is being said by Volwerk, et al? They state:

During the tail excursion the magnetic field strength aroundcomet 67P was B ≈ 10 nT; this means that when water ions are picked up by the magnetic field of the solar wind at v ≈ 350 km s−1, the gyro radius of these ions is ρi ≈ 6000 km. This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.

So, type "kinetic plasma; comets" into Google Scholar, and see what comes up. One of the papers is this one:

THE PLASMA ENVIRONMENT OF COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO THROUGHOUT THE ROSETTA MAIN MISSION
Hansen, K. C. et al. (2006)
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...in_Mission/links/02bfe50db32d29295e000000.pdf

I'm certainly no expert on the subject, but I think their description of a hybrid model may give some clues.

A hybrid model describes the plasma environment in a semi-kinetic manner. In the model, electrons are assumed to be a massless charge-neutralizing fluid and are modeled using typical fluid methods (conservation equations). The ions, which have much larger gyroradii, are treated as particles and the code solves individual equations of motion. This method resolves physical structures down to a time scale below the inverse lower hybrid frequency.
The hybrid model that we employ considers two ion species: the solar wind protons and the ion of cometary origin. These cometary ion are significantly heavier than the solar wind protons. In order to correctly model the ions, the dynamic equations include collisions with neutral gas in addition to the Lorentz force. This driver may become significant in dense atmospheres such as near the cometary nucleus.

Might be worth a read, as well as the references therein.
 
So, now the electric comet thread has turned into a free online plasma physics course for the benefit of Sol88? I can see how this is useful as a way to avoid the questions raised by JT and Indigator, but it is rather transparent, and may give Indigator an idea of what to expect, and the reason why this thread still exists, despite its subject matter having been debunked multiple times by observation from numerous missions.
So, why not refer to the literature to try to figure out what is being said by Volwerk, et al? They state:



So, type "kinetic plasma; comets" into Google Scholar, and see what comes up. One of the papers is this one:

THE PLASMA ENVIRONMENT OF COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO THROUGHOUT THE ROSETTA MAIN MISSION
Hansen, K. C. et al. (2006)
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...in_Mission/links/02bfe50db32d29295e000000.pdf

I'm certainly no expert on the subject, but I think their description of a hybrid model may give some clues.



Might be worth a read, as well as the references therein.

It’s all about education!! :thumbsup:

And yes, you certainly are no expert on the subject. :rolleyes:

But you are correct in
I can see how this is useful as a way to avoid the questions raised by JT and Indigator,...

So...

I thought we’d ask the expert. :D

Save all that misinformation
 
Sorry Rc did'nt know you where the expert in space plasma?

What kinetic effects could we reasonable expect from a comet?

You know a little on Debye length and it's importance in space plasma/s, I thought?
 
Last edited:
Great idea, Sol88! Let's ask the experts ....

tusenfem! Good Sir! You are under no obligation to "answer me these questions three ..."

However, if you choose to ...

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ... Yes/No

Now your turn, Sol88! As the resident expert in the electric comet, please ...

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No

I am so looking forward to your expert answers, and your expert predictive mathematical model! Share with us your wisdom, Sol88! Show us the value of your electric comet!

Good luck!
 
Acknowledges that the electric comet is a delusion that cannot answer questions

Good luck!
19 June 2018: Acknowledges that the electric comet is a delusion that cannot answer reasonable questions.
Indagator asks electric comet experts Yes/No questions and specifically Sol88 as in "Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...". and gets no answer :eye-poppi!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom