Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
In this context, comet 67 but comet in general; charged particle(inc nanodust) acceleration, beaming or jetting of particles(inc nanodust), Particle heating, energetic particle trapping, strong electric fields and electric currents.

For instance.

Fair call, tusenfem?

Wrong. Correct, Tusenfem?
Sol, you are totally thick when it comes to plasma physics. Yes? I know more than you do, and that isn't saying much! I know s*** about plasma physics. However, despite only giving it the tiniest bit of attention, for about 4 years, I seem to know more about it than you do. How sad is that?
 
Maybe you would like to comment

What kinetic plasma effects are you talking about in the above quote from your paper?

Here's a thought, loony tunes; how about you actually learn about plasma physics to the level that Tusenfem has? And then you could talk to him on the same level. Yes? As it is, you are clueless, (along with everybody else in EU) about plasma physics. Yes?
Why on Earth would anybody listen to you loons about plasma physics? Give me one good reason. You can't even do basic maths, you idiots! Prove me wrong.
 
Hey Sol88, any reason why you are avoiding answering questions?

Why bother?

It's very simple: Comets are rocks discharging in the solar wind....

and an new model is being called for!!

Interview with Matt Taylor

The dirtysnowball (Whipples) model is dead along with the nebula hypothesis and all the way to the very top THE BIG BANG. RIP

You heard it first from Matt!
 
Last edited:
Here's a thought, loony tunes; how about you actually learn about plasma physics to the level that Tusenfem has? And then you could talk to him on the same level. Yes? As it is, you are clueless, (along with everybody else in EU) about plasma physics. Yes?
Why on Earth would anybody listen to you loons about plasma physics? Give me one good reason. You can't even do basic maths, you idiots! Prove me wrong.

Are you defending tusenfem?

Settle Grettle, I Just asked a question!

again from tusenfem's paper:

During the tail excursion the magnetic field strength around comet 67P was B ~ 10 nT; this means that when water ions are picked up by the magnetic field of the solar wind at v ~ 350 km s..1, the gyro radius of these ions is .i~ 6000 km. This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.

ok understood but I asked for clarification on

Another possibility is that this lull in singing power is caused by kinetic plasma effects. Assuming that the magnetic field is mainly in one direction, which is validated by the histograms, then, according to numerical simulations for weakly outgassing comet 67P (Koenders et al. 2015, 2016), the influence of the presence of the comet should only be seen in one hemisphere. This would fit with the orbit of Rosetta

What in laymens terms are the kinetic plasma effects that would be expected? I don't know why you're getting so prickly?

PS

The link to Koenders, C., Glassmeier, K.-H., Richter, I., Ranocha, H., & Motschmann, U.2015, Planet. Space Sci., 105, 101 comes back with
This reference is not linked with the ADS database at the moment. This page will automatically redirect to the referenced article when the link is found.
 
A repeated and so now insane delusion that the mainstream comet model is dead

The dirtysnowball (Whipples) model is dead
21 June 2018: A repeated and now insane delusion that the mainstream comet model is dead.

Everything that we have learned about every comet says that they are made of ices and dust. Every paper he has cited (thus the insane part of the delusion) has been about comets made of ices and dust.
 
Aa deluded and insulting lie about Matt Taylor

...You heard it first from Matt!
21 June 2018: A deluded and insulting lie about Matt Taylor.

21 June 2018: A lie that an interview with Matt Taylor is calling for new models.
21 June 2018: An interview with Matt Taylor (a rational scientist) to derail from his many comet delusions.

Matt Taylor is an expert on comets and so it is an insulting lie to associate him with the many delusions of the electric comet.

It is a deluded lie that Matt Taylor commented on the nebula hypothesis or the Big Bang.
 
I might also ask for the

This means that, although the comet is not very active, it still is having an effect on the solar wind. Somehow sunward and transverse magnetic fields are favoured in the near tail region, whereas at Earth the solar wind has a regular distribution of angles.
how does this finding fit with Identification of comet Hyakutake's
extremely long ion tail from magnetic field signatures
Geraint H. Jones*, Andre  Balogh* & Timothy S. Horbury

On the basis of plasma instrument measurements, the structure encountered by Ulysses was apparently not pressure-balanced, nor apparently was charge neutrality maintained, as the electron number density remained comparatively stable. As violation of these conditions was unlikely, another source of pressure, such as heavy ions, must have been present; these would have been outside the detection range of the plasma instrument

what's being violated? and why would the violations be unlikely?
 
Usual lying question ("defending tusenfem") to derail from his many comet delusions

Are you defending tusenfem?
21 June 2018: Usual lying question ("defending tusenfem") to derail from his many comet delusions.

jonesdave116's post emphasizes that Sol88 has been intentionally ignorant, deluded and lying about science for the past 9 years and his cult prophets have done the same for even longer.

tusenfem may select to answer the question for the education of the other posters who are not persistently ignorant or deluded or lying.
tusenfem may select to not waste his time because it will evoke more ignorance, delusions and lies.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
2 lying "what's being violated" questions to detail from his many comet delusions

what's being violated?
21 June 2018: 2 lying "what's being violated" questions to detail from his many comet delusions.

What is being violated is in what he quotes - charge neutrality.

Violations of charge neutrality is unlikely because matter is in general neutral. Atoms have equal amounts of electrons and protons. Ionization does not change that. Thus plasmas have equal amounts of electrons and protons. However electrons and protons move. They especially move differently in magnetic fields. There is a possibility of volumes with more electrons than protons and vice versa. Magnetic fields in space far from the Sun tend to be small. Therefore violations of charge neutrality in a comet tails are unlikely rather than impossible.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
21 June 2018: 2 lying "what's being violated" questions to detail from his many comet delusions.

What is being violated is in what he quotes - charge neutrality.

Violations of charge neutrality is unlikely because matter is in general neutral. Atoms have equal amounts of electrons and protons. Ionization does not change that. Thus plasmas have equal amounts of electrons and protons. However electrons and protons move. They especially move differently in magnetic fields. There is a possibility of volumes with more electrons than protons and vice versa. Magnetic fields in space far from the Sun tend to be small. Therefore violations of charge neutrality in a comet tails are unlikely rather than impossible.

Booya! :D :thumbsup:

Though, you forgot to add the different masses of electrons and ions. This is important!

Onya ya drongo! :blush:
 
Last edited:
Sol88!

Some important things to think about, while I compose my next post!

"To measure is to know." --- Lord Kelvin

"There is no philosophy which is not founded upon knowledge of the phenomena, but it is absolutely necessary to be a mathematician to get any profit from this knowledge." --- Daniel Bernoulli (1763)

"Science is the one human activity that is truly progressive. The body of positive knowledge is transmitted from generation to generation." --- Edwin Hubble

"Mathematics is the key and door to the sciences." --- Galileo Galilei

"A man does not attain the status of Galileo merely because he is persecuted; he must also be right." --- Stephen Jay Gould (1975)

"Galileo was no idiot. Only an idiot could believe that science requires martyrdom - that may be necessary in religion, but in time a scientific result will establish itself." --- David Hilbert

"X-rays will prove to be a hoax." --- Lord Kelvin

FYI - Upon seeing the scientific results (including an x-ray of his own hand), Lord Kelvin changed his view of x-rays!

"The electric comet, electric star, and electric universe are a hoax!" --- Indagator (2018)

Sol88, have you got any "eu" results (i.e., basic physics and a predictive mathematical model) to convince me I'm wrong?
 
Oi, RC

Clearly, the near-tail has a completely different structure than
simple draped fields

What type of structure does it have then, if not simple draped fields, tusenfem?

Complex draped fields?

also

This behaviour is not reflected in the RPC means that the weakly outgassing comet has an influence on the magnetic field structure.

This means that, although the comet is not very active, it still is having an effect on the solar wind. Somehow sunward and transverse magnetic fields are favoured in the near tail region, whereas at Earth the solar wind has a regular distribution of angles.

Even all the way back to and presumably well beyond 3.0 odd AU? Identification of comet Hyakutake's extremely long ion tail from magnetic field signatures Geraint H. Jones, Andre  Balogh & Timothy S. Horbury

As numerical simulations for the tail excursion become available, this behaviour of the magnetic field should be checked.
Checked against what? do we have a model? other than the Electric Comet?

Other small scale structures were also observed, for example current sheets between oppositely directed draped magnetic fields in the coma (Volwerk et al. 2017),
which are not discussed in this paper

Pity paints a more holistic picture, kinetic effects and all.

Another possibility is that this lull in singing power is caused by kinetic plasma effects.

Ohh...kinetic plasma effects...what equations are more suited here, tusenfem?

When there is strong energy input at frequency f1, then there is a strong cascade to higher frequencies, spreading the energy, and thereby flattening the spectrum.
That's very interesting!

but this may well bean effect from the enormous differences in fly-by velocities of the spacecraft
It is a real pity along with the instruments time resolution. :(

It should be noticed that these waves were observed in the far tail of the comets, for example at distances R>0:1 AU down the tail for comet Kohoutek, whereas
Rosetta did not venture out beyond 1000 km.
Wow tails are REALLY BIG structures!!

Again, this seems to indicate that the presence of the cross-field current has an influence on the turbulent cascade.
ELECTRIC CURRENT!! :)

The clock-angle of the magnetic field in the tail shows a rotation of the field, which is slowly moving down-tail

Could be a frame of reference thing? The enormous differences in fly-by velocities of the spacecraft and their angle thru these current sheets, reckon we'll find in the data after a few more papers of current both going to and from a comet. Like in the Birkeland current model Don Scott ponied up a few years back now.

Any way just a few observation from tusenfems paper.

Care to discuss?
 
Sol88!

Based on observations (i.e., 9+ years of ISF posts), I find your reasoning and behaviour to be consistent with that displayed by practitioners of fundamentalist religions!

Blind faith in an easily debunked belief system! No desire to do the hard work, like learning, reasoning, and researching! And an absolutists belief that, "You are always right! You could never, ever, under in circumstances be wrong! Everyone else is wrong because they don't understand your ... electric universe!" And yet, you make absolutely no effort to explain! Where's the math and physics, my friend! To begin, I am certain you won't find any of your "science" and "models" in mainstream papers and textbooks! If you could, then please enlighten the scientific community ...

Using electrodynamics and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

I have made a simple request! You respond with silence! Your silence says THERE IS NO ELECTRIC COMET!

Prove me wrong! If you can't, find someone from the "eu" that can! Or continue to run and hide!

I'll still be here ..... waiting for you ...... or anyone else from the "eu" willing to subject there "science" to a little "peer" review!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom