Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

I guess we'll all have to agree that he's both a liar, and an ignoramus, then?

Okay by me!
Of that, I have little doubt! :)

I've considered the somewhat frightening possibility that he was being truthful about being an engineer AND was being indeliberately muddle-headed about force vs. energy.

There is, after all, at least one practicing engineer by that name. This one works on relatively small-scale projects, and I suppose it's possible that certain basic physics concepts don't play all that big of a role in his day-to-day practical work. I suppose it's also possible that he made a career in engineering without ever having really understood some of those basic concepts. He may get by just fine merely by being familiar with local building codes.
 
I guess we'll all have to agree that he's both a liar, and an ignoramus, then?

Okay by me!

Well, we have seen evidence that he is a liar. As he is demonstrably ignorant of several key physics terms that are pertinent to this discussion (and apparently refuses to acknowledge that as well), I believe he would in fact fit the definition of an ignoramus as well.
 
Of that, I have little doubt! :)

I've considered the somewhat frightening possibility that he was being truthful about being an engineer AND was being indeliberately muddle-headed about force vs. energy.

There is, after all, at least one practicing engineer by that name. This one works on relatively small-scale projects, and I suppose it's possible that certain basic physics concepts don't play all that big of a role in his day-to-day practical work. I suppose it's also possible that he made a career in engineering without ever having really understood some of those basic concepts. He may get by just fine merely by being familiar with local building codes.
Well, energy and motion Are out of the purview of Civil Engineers...They go to great lengths to make sure things don't move. So I guess it is possible that he hasn't dealt with them in many years.
Not likely, though, that even an engineer who has moved into sales or something would forget something so basic.
But we must remember, 1/2 of all engineers (like MD's) graduated in the bottom 1/2 of their class.

"Mechanical Engineers design weapons systems. Civil Engineers design targets."
 
Well, that is for each of us to decide, of course.

But consider: He started out with the premise that he could "debunk" the Stundies (whatever that really means). To do this, he deliberately lied about both on his examples.

When I caught him on the forces question, he initially implied I had manufactured the quote, then, when shown to again be wrong, implied that the quote meant something else. These are "errors" that an engineer who had read the paper with a mind willing to understand simply could not have made, three times in a row. He lied, he knew he had lied, and he tried to smear me as a liar rather than admit it.

As for the KT quote, well, I agree with your analysis, it was a lie from the start, defended by lies, and, when trapped in a corner on that issue, he gave out his fake "I'm sorry, honest mistake" "apology".

He's shown a willingness to lie, to defend those lies with more lies, to attempt to smear other posters as liars to distract attention from his own lies, and to even lie about his willingness to admit errors.

Even if he were to admit to everything, from first lie to last, and to promise never to do it again, how could we trust that promise? A liar will lie about never lying again, just to get off the hook.

You're free to disagree, but I'm also free to never trust his word again, and I won't.

As you said - it's individual choice.

I must say that I'm quite grateful for the physical explanations posted here, as I'm not really qualified to comment much past the basic of that myself.

Linguistic analysis, however, I spent a good two years doing for my VCE (and doing quite well at it, if I do say so myself ;) ), so if people are going to take me up on that they better be darn prepared.

My feeling is not that an admission, retraction and apology will entirely redeem him. But it will at least put him in a position from where he is able to try and gain our trust again (well, mine at least). It's a long hard road, but without this first step he will never have any credibility here again.

I don't think he'll completely run away either, it doesn't seem to be his style. Though he completely ignored my analysis, so I guess I could be wrong about that too.

I hope not.
 
I must say that I'm quite grateful for the physical explanations posted here, as I'm not really qualified to comment much past the basic of that myself.

Linguistic analysis, however, I spent a good two years doing for my VCE (and doing quite well at it, if I do say so myself ;) ), so if people are going to take me up on that they better be darn prepared.


That's one of the ways they try to "divide and conquer". By using two examples from different disciplines, he hopes that, the engineers will say, "He's wrong about the forces thing, but the linguistic analysis seems plausilbe", while the linguists will conclude the opposite. That's why we need all the different JREFer types to work together - we can show why all his examples are flawed.


My feeling is not that an admission, retraction and apology will entirely redeem him. But it will at least put him in a position from where he is able to try and gain our trust again (well, mine at least). It's a long hard road, but without this first step he will never have any credibility here again.


It seems to me that this is just the latest, and most blatant, example of his dishonesty. I can't recall anything he's ever said that wasn't trying to spin something to mean something else. I may just not recall his honest posts, but there's enough dishonesty to make me believe that he is fundamentally untrustworthy. It would take a lot (a LOT!) of work to ever gain my trust. And so far, he seems entirely unwilling to take even the first step you refer to, let alone all the following steps.
 
I'm disappointed myself, but I cannot logically reconcile
1) Your claim to be a civil engineer
with the following:
A) Your claim that Gravitational Potential Energy is a vector. (Or having a "vectoral quality," which is what you backed off to - whatever that means)
B) Your claim that Thermal Energy is a vector by example of heat transfer along a linear conductor. (Counter example: Heat the center of a metal disk. In which direction is the "vector" pointing?)
C) Your mixing "work" with "energy" (and most notably your failure to use the term "force" which is a vector)
All of this is taught in any first semester advanced high-school physics class. This is pre-engineering stuff - so basic that there are really only two probable explanations.
Your formal education was so long ago and is so far removed from your day-to-day work as a civil engineer that you no longer remember parts of it well enough to discuss with any authority
or
You did not receive a 4-year engineering degree from an accredited institution of higher learning.
(Well, there is a third, but)

1. I have never claimed to be a Civil Engineer. I have no idea why I would need to be uniquely qualified as a Civil Engineer to understand this topic.

A. I have not modified my position once. My original post on this topic can be seen at http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2489948#post2489948

B. I haven't claimed that energy isn't scalar, I simply asserted that it has a sense of direction like a vector and no one as yet has shown me that it doesn't. In answer to your problem I would simplify it by taking a cross sectional view of the disc showing the direction of transfer of heat energy from the inner to outer edge.

C. I need you to clarify what you mean when you say I have mixed "work" and "energy" because I do not understand how you then extrapolate this to imply my education must be sub-standard in some way.
 
Last edited:
What's up with all this, William? First you apparently made up an intervening post in a message board that never existed. Then you attributed stuff to a paper that doesn't actually say what you claim. Then you claim not to be able to find the quote one of the other posters cites, even though it's right there on page 4 (page numbers, not PDF page) of the paper and Acrobat Reader has a search function.

Also, the page 14 that you cited does not discuss vector components, it talks about energy and conservation of energy.

You also seem to have force and energy confused or something.

Are you being dishonest with the material you're claiming to use as sources, or are you simply confused?

With respect, without links or more detail I simply do not understand what you are trying to say here. Would you clarfiy a little more for me please.
 
No, gravity is a force. Gravitational potential energy is the measure of the work done by that force. The force does work, which is measured as energy. The energy is not doing any work, it is a measure of work.

You might use the words interchangeably, but that doesn't make you right.

The force is simply a means of expressing the energy flow dynamically, it is not the primary factor in energy problems as you imply. I can describe the transfer of energy from PE to KE in energy terms simply by using conservation of energy without mentioning a single force.

With respect, I do not interchange them, I use them in context.
 
1. I have never claimed to be a Civil Engineer.
???
The point is Beachnut, I am an Engineer.
I'm a civil engineer also, except when I get mad.
I have no idea why I would need to be uniquely qualified as a Civil Engineer to understand this topic.
No one said you NEED to be a Civil Engineer to understand this topic, but you CLAIMED to be a Civil Engineer, and it strains credibility that an engineer would NOT understand this topic.

B. I haven't claimed that energy isn't scalar, I simply asserted that it has a sense of direction like a vector and no one as yet has shown me that it doesn't. In answer to your problem I would simplify it by taking a cross sectional view of the disc showing the direction of transfer of heat energy from the inner to outer edge.
The difference between a scalar and a vector is:
  • a scalar has magnitude
  • a vector has magnitude and direction
To say that energy (a scalar) "has a sense of direction", then, is to say that it is not a scalar at all, but rather a vector.

And I have shown you that energy does not have direction, as have others.
 
B. I haven't claimed that energy isn't scalar, I simply asserted that it has a sense of direction like a vector and no one as yet has shown me that it doesn't.

Consider the following situation.

A spherical shell of material is placed somewhere in interstellar space, sufficiently far from any other masses that the effect of gravity other than its own may be considered negligible. The object has mass, and all parts of it are therefore attracted towards its centre of mass. If the material is shattered into small particles, all will fall into the centre, converting their gravitational potential energy into kinetic energy as they fall. The entire system has spherical symmetry.


What is the direction of the gravitational potential energy?

Dave
 
Your metal bar example also shows a misunderstanding of the terms involved. Simply because a situation involves a direction, that doesn't mean that every term involved is also directional. If I'm in a car and I travel at 50 mph to the north, that doesn't mean that my speed is suddenly a vector. Similarly, because the temperature of a steel bar being heated tends towards equilibrium does not mean that the measure of energy involved is expressed as a vector.

I appreciate that the tone of your post is not adversarial but with respect, if you are travelling 50mph North that is exactly a vector. I think what you are trying to say is that if you are travelling 50mph then that is a scalar quantity, and I agree with that. However, I don't know of any use that that scalar quantity has to Engineers, without the direction it is meaningless. Just like saying I have 2MJ of Energy without understanding how to make it do Work by employing a device that converts the fact that if falls down or flows from hot to cold.

Likewise, you can say energy is scalar and be absolutely right by the text book answer but denying that it has a vectoral quality in that it doesn't "flow" from up to down or hot to cold (in laymen's terms) is impractical.
 
No one said you NEED to be a Civil Engineer to understand this topic, but you CLAIMED to be a Civil Engineer, and it strains credibility that an engineer would NOT understand this topic.

I had a little chuckle at that one. You used my joke about being a civil engineer except when I get mad as a claim on my part that I was a Civil Engineer. :)
 
As has been posted before in the thread, he could just as easily have been asking for a link to purchase a "normal" video. As I've stated, that does not even mean that "normal" video even refers to a magnetic media.

Mobyseven said:
Why are we still even having this discussion, William? This is open and shut - WWGHA defines a 'normal video' as 'not an internet video'. Killtown then asks for a link to a video that is, by definition, not on the internet!

To be fair to killtown (woah! I need to take a shower, now), I think he was saying "Huh ? A link to a "normal" video ? Why, that's not possible." Of course. That's still a stupid thing to post, but it's not the same level of stupid, assuming I'm correct.
 
I appreciate that the tone of your post is not adversarial but with respect, if you are travelling 50mph North that is exactly a vector. I think what you are trying to say is that if you are travelling 50mph then that is a scalar quantity, and I agree with that. However, I don't know of any use that that scalar quantity has to Engineers, without the direction it is meaningless. Just like saying I have 2MJ of Energy without understanding how to make it do Work by employing a device that converts the fact that if falls down or flows from hot to cold.

You're still confused about the terms. In the example I posted, the direction is irrelevant to the speed. The speed is 50mph. The velocity is a vector quantity consisting of the 50mph and the direction. In rough terms, you could say the velocity is 50mph to the north.

If I suddenly started going 50mph to the south, my speed would be the same, but my velocity would be different.

It's not about having "vector qualities" or anything, there are words for things like "speed plus direction." In that case, it's "velocity."

Likewise, you can say energy is scalar and be absolutely right by the text book answer but denying that it has a vectoral quality in that it doesn't "flow" from up to down or hot to cold (in laymen's terms) is impractical.

You misunderstand energy. Energy moving towards equillibrium does not give it a direction that can be quantified as a vector. Another poster mentioned the bar's orientation changing, and asked if this would affect the direction of energy transfer.

Vectors need a precise, mathematically defined direction. You can't simply say "it moves in a direction, therefore it is a vector!" No, that doesn't make energy a vector, or give it a "vectoral quality" (which is a meaningless term, by the way).

By the way, stating something has a "vectoral component" or whatever is equivalent to saying it's a vector, just in a more weasel-esque way.

The force is simply a means of expressing the energy flow dynamically, it is not the primary factor in energy problems as you imply. I can describe the transfer of energy from PE to KE in energy terms simply by using conservation of energy without mentioning a single force.

With respect, I do not interchange them, I use them in context.

I didn't say anything about PE and KE transfer, I said you are mixing force and energy. Those aren't terms that describe force, they describe energy. Force is work done on an object, energy is the amount of work something can do. A term like PE or KE addresses the total work present in an aspect of a system. That energy can be released in different forms.

I implied no such thing.

I had a little chuckle at that one. You used my joke about being a civil engineer except when I get mad as a claim on my part that I was a Civil Engineer. :)

What the hell are you talking about? You at least claimed to be an engineer of some kind, if not a civil engineer (it really isn't that important):

Here, you explicitly claim to be an engineer.

Your joke implicitly states that you are some kind of engineer.

You still show a misunderstanding of simple physics concepts, or a complete inability to state your understanding in a way that anyone but you can comprehend. Your apparent lack of comprehension does not jive with your stated profession.

Unless, of course, "engineer" means something like "railroad engineer" or "hamburger flipping engineer" or something.
 
That's a great quote. Where's it from?
I honestly have no idea. It is so buried in antiquity that it has become a natural law:D
I first heardit back when I was a Coop with NASA in the 1970's. I comes in handy, since I am an ME, doing F-35 Lightning II work, my youngest brother is a CE, doing bridges in Texas, and the middle brother is a ChE with Dow.
Sister teaches music...Church music...
Well, 3 out of 4 is 75%...
 
I had a little chuckle at that one. You used my joke about being a civil engineer except when I get mad as a claim on my part that I was a Civil Engineer. :)

How utterly convenient. So not only the "except when I get mad" was a joke, but "I'm a civil engineer" too ? Woah. You do have a wicked sense of humour, don't you ? :rolleyes:
 
I appreciate that the tone of your post is not adversarial but with respect, if you are travelling 50mph North that is exactly a vector. I think what you are trying to say is that if you are travelling 50mph then that is a scalar quantity, and I agree with that. However, I don't know of any use that that scalar quantity has to Engineers, without the direction it is meaningless. Just like saying I have 2MJ of Energy without understanding how to make it do Work by employing a device that converts the fact that if falls down or flows from hot to cold.
Engineers use speed all the time--when they're doing energy calculations. In KE = ½*m*v2, you can ignore the directional component of the velocity v, treating it as a scalar speed.

Likewise, you can say energy is scalar and be absolutely right by the text book answer but denying that it has a vectoral quality in that it doesn't "flow" from up to down or hot to cold (in laymen's terms) is impractical.
No it's not, because saying that energy has a "vectoral quality" is meaningless gibberish.

When a pole bent back in tension (storing PE) is released, in which direction does the PE convert to KE?
 
That was a joke? I don't get it. In any case, what kind of engineer DO you claim to be?

@ forum.

With respect, if I have to explain it it will lose impact but because it seems to be such a big deal with the forum I'll explain so we can move on. I was joking that when I get mad I might lose civility and hence be an uncivil engineer. I did not expect that making a joke would become a major thread topic.

It is on record on the forum as I have stated it before, I am a Mechanical Engineer but in the US sense I majored in Structures. I have worked in Industry for 20 years or so and have obtained specialist knowledge of certain areas of Metallurgy related to my work. As also stated before I didn't pursue any Post-Graduate Studies but have built my reputation as an Engineer on hard work and results which is reflected in my salary and the constant calls I get from Head Hunters to move to competitors.

I can say no more or less than what I have written above and politely suggest that if you do not accept the sincerity of it then you are wasting your time and mine exchanging posts. It seems to me that there is little point in making posts to me if you do not have any trust that I am what I say I am.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom