Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess I just "assumed" that since you got involved in this particular thread, of all your choices of various threads on this board

You think I can only participate in one thread at any time ?

that you expected to be 'educated' in electric sun theory.

Apparently not by you, but it's no fault of mine.

You've asked me for evidence as well. I was simply discussing the topic with you.

Yeah, rhetoric in place of evidence. That'll work.

I try to respond to EVERYONE that posts here, not just you Belz. :)

And yet you keep addressing me while answering other people. I just found it odd.

Still waiting for that evidence for electrical discharges in plasma.
 
... the energy released in solar flares and the heating of the corona was a theory which he pioneered and aptly nicknamed "magnetic reconnection".

The term simply relates to an E induced, *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process in plasma. Anywhere you see that term, it simply refers to an electrical discharge process in a plasma.
 
Last edited:
What did you think of Dungey's original paper that I handed you? Is that "evidence" in your opinion?
I suspect that Belz... (unlike you) can understand what he reads. Thus he will not be fooled into using an obsolete term for large high current density:
From Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma:
What remains is Dungey's obsolete usage
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (10 months and counting)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011
If you want to continue to documenting your obsession that electrical discharges cause solar flares then please do so and we will conintinue to point out that it is a delusion.


If you want to change that assertion to "electrical discharges happen solar flares" then all you are doing is documenting your ignorance by using an obsolete term (or an obsession with the term "electrical discharge").
 
MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you

All you can do is spew hate
You are wrong. I am not spewing hate. I am stating my pity for the state of your knowledge that your posts display. I pity you. I do not hate you.
I pity you for the state of ignorance of basic physics that you are demonstrating:
Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule)
Michael Mozina's delusion that permeability is inductance!
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length").

I pity you for your inability to learn physics, e.g. as in W.D. Clinger's very clear posts on magnetic reconnection in vacuum:
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 4

I pity you for your inability to understand the electrical discharges do not cause solar flares and your obsession with the obsolete use of the term 'electrical discharge' in magnetic reconnection: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma

I pity you for your dependence on 'I see bunnies in the clouds' logic (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7753306#post7753306).
In another thread: the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the TRACE RD 171A movie!

I pity you for the arrogance of thinking that you know more about specific solar images than a scientist studying them:
the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the Kosovichev movie! (debunked by Dr. Kosovichev)
I applaud your honesty in quoting Dr. Kosovichev.

I pity you for not understanding that you are misrepresenting (to be charitable) Birkeland's work: Michael Mozina's delusions about Birkeland's work (citing his work on brass balls in support of an iron sun idea is especially amusing. And MM: Citations for Birkeland and solar energy sources.

I pity you for not being able to understand the magnetic reconnection is supported by observations:
Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003
and
Eric Priest, Terry Forbes, Magnetic Reconnection, Cambridge University Press 2000, ISBN 0-521-48179-1, contents and sample chapter online
​

Plus:

I pity the fact that you have decided to ignore the scientific literature (textbooks and papers) that states that
  • Magnetic field lines can break and reconnection (magnetic reconnection).
  • Magnetic reconnection is the cause of solar flares.
 
No, your statements are utter gibberish and based upon pure ignorance including a KLUDGED quote mine from a book and author you've never actually read.
How stupid - I do not have to read the entire book to see that Somov states that magnetic Field lines reconnect.

In Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section, I have quoted a large part of section 4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
I did not follow your practice of lying (quote mining) by extracting half of a definition from Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge.

Since you have obssessed about titles before, I will follow your lead :D:
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum....

Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.
(emphasis added)

and remain in pure denial of Dungey's explanation of an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in a plasma.


And lying again: Dungey never explains an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in a plasma. He explains a LARGE CURRENT DENSITY in magnetic reconnection.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (10 months and counting)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011
Today, only someone truly ignorant would use this obsolete term for large current density in magnetic reconnection. A knowledgeable person would use the term that scientists today use - large current density.
 
How stupid - I do not have to read the entire book to see that Somov states that magnetic Field lines reconnect.

How stupid you ignored the parts in YELLOW!

4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
...

Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.

You can't INDUCE an E field in a PURE VACUUM that is utterly devoid of plasma particles. He's also talking about ACCELERATING charged particles. In that cause I don't know what he even means by the term "vacuum". It sounds like a "low density" plasma as best as I can tell, based on the inducement of E and the fact it's accelerating charged particles.

I saw how you KLUDGED the term 'electrical discharge in cosmic plasma' by Peratt. I've also read at least one other entire plasma physics book by Somov where he spends an entire chapter tying this all back to the E orientation, and he clearly explained "reconnection" as an E induced process in plasma.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7766507&postcount=5027

Honestly Clinger,

Your exceptional math skills may in fact be your saving grace if you ponder the problem from the standpoint of sources and sinks in vector calculus. You're literally *OVERTHINKING* the problem IMO and trying to do EVERYTHING related to 'reconnection' in a single step, in a vacuum. You'd literally need a monopole to pull off that trick.

I seriously doubt that any of the rest of the EU haters even comprehends what a source or sink might be in relationship to vector fields, but I have to believe that you do. Your math skills are very likely to be your saving grace here if you use them IMO. Either BOTH Wiki pages are incorrect, or you are incorrectly and improperly turning X into a source and sink. It's really that simple. That is probably the BEST shot I can take at reaching you at the level of mathematics.
 
Last edited:
How stupid you ignored the parts in YELLOW!
How stupid you ignored the parts in YELLOW, RED and BLUE!
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum....

Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.
In a vacuum an electric field is induced. This is basic physics because you have a changing magnetic field and so Maxwell's equations tell you that that an electric field is induced.

Now what happens if you have a charge particle or particles (i.e. you go from a vacuum to a non-vacuum)? Again basic physics - the induced electric field can accelerate them :jaw-dropp!

Somov introduces charged particles at the end of this section because his next section is "4.4.3. Reconnection in plasma".
 
How stupid you ignored the parts in YELLOW, RED and BLUE!

No, I'm not. Somov's "vacuum" evidently includes plasma particles because he also describes INDUCED E fields and the acceleration of PARTICLES. He has actual real PARTICLES in his vacuum apparently. It's not a "pure vacuum". Clinger is working in a PURE vacuum until he graduates to plasma physics. :)

Since Clinger's math skills are exceptional, there's definitely still hope for him. You don't even know what a source or a sink might be as it relates to vector calculus.
 
I seriously doubt that any of the rest of the EU haters even comprehends what a source or sink might be in relationship to vector fields,
You are wrong:
No one here (excecpt in your head) is an "EU hater". I for example pity EUers. Your fantasy has little to do with the EU fantasy. None of then that I have seen seems ignorant enough to claim actual electrical discharges in plasma.
MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you

I know what sources and sinks are in relation to vecorr fields. They are ... sources and sinks in the vector field :eye-poppi!
I know that this has little to do with the fact that magnetic field lines that cross a neutral point have to break: MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point
 
The term simply relates to an E induced, *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process in plasma. Anywhere you see that term, it simply refers to an electrical discharge process in a plasma.


That is as dishonest as any argument yet offered in this thread. Magnetic reconnection does not translate to electrical discharge. Dungey wasn't the idiot the electric Sun proponents seem to believe he was. If he had meant to suggest magnetic reconnection was synonymous with electrical discharge, he would have said that. He didn't. Any claim to that effect is simply false.
 
That is as dishonest as any argument yet offered in this thread. Magnetic reconnection does not translate to electrical discharge.

No, this is just the most dishonest statement yet offered by a hater. It's an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMA according Dungey. You and RC parrot a single term "magnetic reconnection" yet have no understanding whatsoever of the physics it represents. You're like a couple of parrots without a clue.
 
Clinger: The only thing that happens in your vacuum contraption as you change the current in the rods is the vacuum experiences changes in the magnetic flux density *OVER THE WHOLE FIELD*, not only at X. No induced fields will occur in the vacuum, and no particles will be accelerated in the vacuum. No electrical discharge will ensue in the vacuum.

When you get to part 5 and ADD PLASMA, I promise you that all of your maths will (eventually) make sense and Gauss's laws will not be violated in any way, shape or form. E fields will be induced, current will flow, electrons will fly and electrical discharges will ensue.
 
Last edited:
Still wrong: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma
  • It is not a PROCESS .
  • It is an obsolete use of the term ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE to describe large current density in magnetic reconnection.

Keep in mind Clinger that RC and GM do not give a damn about whether you're right or wrong in terms of physics, nor do they care what you look like at the end of this process. In terms of basic EM theory, neither one of them could help you (I know for sure because I quizzed them this weekend), and neither one of them has your math skills. You're pretty much swinging in the wind on your own now. Neither of them even understands the significance of the terms source and sink at it relates to vector calculus and our discussion. IMO it's better to bite the bullet now and be done and move on to part 5 than to let those two lead you down the primrose path any further. Your call.
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind Clinger that RC and GM do not give a damn about whether you're right or wrong in terms of physics,...
Keep in mind Clinger that Michael Mozina is lying.
I care about the physics being right or wrong. I see no problems with the physics or math in your posts.
I can see a good educator providing a clear lesson on magnetic reconnection. The end of the process should be a nice undergraduate level lesson on the MR basics as covered in MR textbooks.

You should follow my previous advice and disregard MM's previous demands that you not go onto part 5.
 
Last edited:
Induced fields in a vacuum

You can't INDUCE an E field in a PURE VACUUM that is utterly devoid of plasma particles.
No induced fields will occur in the vacuum, ...


You have made that particular claim now multiple times in this thread, and it's just plain wrong. Of course you will get induced fields in a vacuum. How could you possibly not get induced fields in a vacuum?

[latex]
Faraday's Law of Induction:
\nabla \times \hbox{{\bf E}} = \frac{\partial \hbox{{\bf B}}}{\partial t}

Ampere's Law:
\nabla \times \hbox{{\bf B}} = \mu_0 \hbox{{\bf J}} + \mu_0 \epsilon_0 \frac{\partial \hbox{{\bf E}}}{\partial t}
[/latex]

Faraday's law of induction works like gangbusters in a vacuum. Set the current density (J) in Ampere's Law to zero and we are back to the vacuum again. Change the electric field and you get an induced magnetic field. Of course in a vacuum there are no charged particles to accelerate, but there are still fields (which you can check by putting test charges into your vacuum and watching them bend to the will of the fields present). Yes, you certainly can induce B and E fields in a vacuum.
 
Priest & Monopoles & Magnetic Reconnection

My "introduction" to MR theory in debate started over at space.com. It's a pity they took down the boards, or I'd cite the conversation for you. The very first paper that I was handed to evaluate on the topic of MR theory just so happened to be a paper written by Priest that was ENTIRELY oriented around the B orientation of Maxwell's equations. From a mathematical orientation, it was actually pretty simple. There weren't very many equations to translate. I thought it might be interesting to see if I could personally translate the formulas to an E orientation. I got to a specific equation however and found out that the energy transfer mechanism Priest was using was a "monopole", something that literally violates the laws of physics, specifically Gauss's law of magnetism. I cried fowl over the whole notion of "magnetic flux transfer" using such a device. Everyone went ballistic and tried to defend the concept even though it clearly violated the laws of physics.

DISCLAIMER: In *FAIRNESS TO PRIEST*, it wasn't his best paper on this topic. I've read MUCH better materials from him since that date and time.

I was then handed a new paper to evaluate from an author called "Birn". It was a MUCH better paper in the sense that it clearly described the "current' that flowed along the magnetic line that created and sustained the "magnetic field" along that so called "line". That "line" however turns out not to be a simple "line", is a "field aligned current". The total "energy flux" through that line is directly related to the flow of current through that field aligned current "line".

I understand the difference on *PAPER* Clinger, but when I wrote that line you decided to build a federal case over, I was specifically thinking of that first paper by Priest that attempted to 'dumb down' an entire current carrying event to a "magnetic flux' event. That's all I meant by that particular sentence. If you can't accept that rather LENGTHY explanation, I really don't know what else to offer you. You go right ahead and harp on that one sentence all you like, but you'll need to come clean on one of my two issues as well. :)


This is an interesting story that invokes several questions.

Can you identify the paper by Priest that you falsified?
Can you show us the "monopole" equation you wound up with and its derivation?
Can you identify the paper by Birn?
Can you identify specific points, in the paper by birn, where you can demonstrate where his "magnetic field line" is in reality a "field aligned current"?


Mozina's original post was 20 October, back on page 101 and my query is 22 Oct and on page 103. A sufficient response showed up 13 November on page 123:

{ ...}
I'm also sorry that Space.com took down their board because I personally did not save the very first paper on "magnetic reconnection" that I was asked to read through on a public forum. I'd like to find that paper so you can fully appreciate where I'm coming from.

The paper was by Priest. In retrospect it taught me something very important, and Priest did me a great favor. That *particular* paper (I'm sure he's written many others because I've personally read many others) just so happened to be a "speculation" paper, a "what if" sort of paper. He was speculating mathematically about "B field line reconnection" *IF* monopoles actually existed in nature. It's important in my learning process in retrospect that I started there actually because I could "in theory" understand what an actual "B field line reconnection" might look like if B field lines *DID* have a "beginning and ending", if they could be taken apart into discrete units. I could CLEARLY understand what he was trying to convey, but I DISMISSED the paper because monopoles do not exist in nature and they violate Gauss's law of magnetism.


I have searched as thoroughly as I can and find no indication of any paper written by anyone which makes any assumption about the actual existence of magnetic monopoles being required for magnetic reconnection. However, I did find these:

Magnetic Null Points due to Multiple Sources of Solar Photospheric Flux
Inverarity & Priest; Solar Physics 186(1/2): 99-121 (May 1999)

Abstract: "How common are magnetic null points in the highly complex magnetic field of the solar atmosphere? In this work we seek to model the magnetic structure of quiet regions by placing magnetic sources and sinks on a hexagonal network of supergranule cells to represent the intense magnetic fields that occur at the boundaries of these cells. The resulting potential coronal magnetic field is then computed analytically and searched numerically for magnetic null points, which are classified according to their types and spine directions. Two relations from the theory of vector fields relate the numbers of null points to the numbers of sources and sinks and these are used to check the numerical results. Previous results relating these quantities for monopolar and dipolar magnetic fields are described and a new one for a particular class of quadrupolar fields arising in this study is derived. We model a three-cell configuration and study the effects of increasing the strength of a central sink and of moving the central sink. A twelve-cell configuration is studied in lesser detail."


The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field
Demoulin & Priest; Astronomy and Astrophysics 258(2): 535-541 (May 1992)

Abstract: "In a highly conducting plasma, the magnetic field topology determines where, for example, current sheets can form, which is of great importance as a potential coronal heating source. With the classical extrapolation of a continuous weak photospheric field, the determination of topology is in general a difficult challenge. Because of the concentration of the photospheric field at intense flux tubes in supergranulation boundaries a more realistic field representation may be a description in terms of magnetic singularities located just below the photosphere. In this paper we analyze in detail the generalization to linear force-free fields of the standard multipole expansion for singular potential fields. Solutions are presented in spherical coordinates with the constraint that all singularities are located in the half-space z is less than 0 below the solar photospheric plane (z = 0). A great variety of solutions is shown to exist depending on two continuous and one discrete parameter. The properties of monopole and dipole solutions in particular are discussed and it is shown that isolated magnetic charges exist only in the potential limit and not in a linear force-free field."

The 1992 paper introduces the idea of monopolar magnetic fields from multipole expansion. It pointedly includes a forma proof that there cannot be any real magnetic monopoles involved. The 1999 paper, which cites the 1992 paper, uses monopolar magnetic fields as "sources" and "sinks" to create magnetic dipoles that look like electric dipoles (where the charged particles are sources & sinks). Neither paper assumes the existence of actual monopoles, but rather seeks to use monopolar fields as a computational device.

Michael Mozina: Is it possible that one of these was that first paper by Priest that you refer to? I cannot find anything else in the literature that includes any monopolar fields in a discussion of magnetic reconnection.

In these papers, monopolar fields are used as a device to simplify calculation. This calculational device is not found in any of my books on plasma physics or magnetic reconnection, nor can I find any recent papers that do this. I can only surmise that the rapid increase in computational power has rendered this kind of computational simplification unnecessary.

Of course, with no more clues than this, I cannot reliably guess which of many papers by Birn might be the one that is relevant here.

I will also add a footnote comment that, while it is certainly true that magnetic monopoles are not consistent with Maxwell's Equations, it is not obviously true that magnetic monopoles violate the laws of physics. Dirac, 1931 proves that if magnetic monopoles exist, then all electric charge must be quantized. Since we now know that all electric charge is in fact quantized, then there is an implication (but no necessity) from Dirac's work that magnetic monopoles could exist. They are in fact predicted by various grand unified theories of particle physics. There are no unambiguous observations of magnetic monopoles on record, and they may indeed not exist. But one cannot assert with confidence that they cannot exist.

I can assert with confidence that magnetic monopoles are not at all involved in any formulation of magnetic reconnection that I have seen, and I cannot find any indication of magnetic monopoles in any papers by Priest other than what I have shown here.
 
How stupid you ignored the parts in YELLOW!



You can't INDUCE an E field in a PURE VACUUM that is utterly devoid of plasma particles. He's also talking about ACCELERATING charged particles. In that cause I don't know what he even means by the term "vacuum". It sounds like a "low density" plasma as best as I can tell, based on the inducement of E and the fact it's accelerating charged particles.

I saw how you KLUDGED the term 'electrical discharge in cosmic plasma' by Peratt. I've also read at least one other entire plasma physics book by Somov where he spends an entire chapter tying this all back to the E orientation, and he clearly explained "reconnection" as an E induced process in plasma.


What??? "You can't INDUCE an E field in a PURE VACUUM" So charged particles need some "plasma particles" between them? You do understand that the vacuum has electrical properties as well as magnetic (otherwise EM waves could not travel) don't you? Isn't that the whole principle of the "EU" that electrical properties always dominate? It seems now you're saying that an E field requires some intervening plasma while the EM properties of the vacuum (and extermination) demonstrates that a magnetic field doesn't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom