Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote mining again and ignoring that induced E field source and sink, and charged particles again are you?
Showing your ignorance yet again, MM?

I state that textbooks state that reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process. I then cite my post Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section where Somov states that:
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.
That is giving evidence for the assertion, not quote mining.
What Somov is saying is
  1. Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process:
  2. Magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point, break and connect again ('reconnect') in it.
    This is nothing surprising since it is undergraduate EM and stated thoughout the scientific literature.
    This is also not surprising because it is the definition of MR!
  3. Other interesting things happen
    • Basic EM - a changing magnetic field induces an E field.
    • This induced E filed can accelerate charged particles near the neutral point. Of course you have to have them there first and so you are no longer talking about the trivial case of MR in a vacuum. Oddly enough the next section is MR in a plasma!
:dl:​

You are lying: I am not ignoring the induced E field or the charged particles. Read Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section
 
I'm curious to know if it was RC or tusenfem who modified or twisted someone's arm into modifying the WIKI page on magnetic lines? That was CLASSIC! I've seen weird and pretty bizarre hater behaviors in my time, but WOW! I've never seen a "fundy" change a WIKI page in the hope of winning a debate before. That was a new low. :)

Oh it was probably me, the evil tusenfem, hater of EU, misunderstander of Alfvén, false doctor of plasmaastrophysics, sneakily asking someone else to "do the dirty work for me" whilst remaining behind the scenes myself like the elders of Zion that are ruling the world.
 
I think you and Tim have done a FANTASTIC job of running away from equation 17 in Priest's source/sink paper. You don't want to admit that CURRENTS reconnect, but it's right there in equations 16 and 17.

Tim and I could probably explain the subtleties to you in Priest's paper, but it would be lost on you anyway. So why bother, I will just continue asking my shady bud to change some more wiki pages.
 
FYI, I've heard creationists use that exact same line after claiming that humans didn't evolve from "monkeys/apes", and I asked them if they'd ever read a book on the topic of evolutionary theory.
FYI: You are deluded if you think that I use the "same line".

The point that I am making is that my existing education enables me to read and understand sources such as the extracts from textbooks, e.g. Somov. I am not fooled into stating delusions about what he states (Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section).

I do not have to read an entire textbook on plasma physics to see that the undergraduate physics and math in W.D. Clinger's posts and web site (Magnetic Reconnection) are correct.

I have had 7 years of university education in physics (and chemistry, mathematics and a bit of other stuff). I have read many textbooks. I have been trained to do research and evaluate the results of that research.
Thus I can recall the definition of field lines from the textbooks. I can read the Wikipedia article and see that it confirms my memory. I can read Tim Thompson's post and see that his cited definition is also applicable.
I can thus see what you are blind to: MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.
The Wikipedia interpretation that no sources or sinks means all magnetic field lines do not end is wrong. What it means is that if a magnetic field line ends at a point, there must be another line that begins at that point.

Thus magnetic field lines that cross a neutral point have to end there and start again after the neutral point. Scientists call this magnetic reconnection. This is a trival process in vacuum. It gets really intereating in plasma and there are many textbooks (that you are ignoring) and papers (that you are ignoring) on the topic.

I can read the introduction to Eric Priest, Terry Forbes, Magnetic Reconnection, Cambridge University Press 2000, ISBN 0-521-48179-1, contents and sample chapter online
Reconnection provides an elegant, and so far the only, explanation for the motion of chromospheric ribbons and flare loops during solar flares. At the same time, it also accounts for the enormous energy release in solar flares. The ejection of magnetic flux from the Sun during coronal mass ejections and prominence eruptions necessarily requires reconnection; otherwise, the magnetic flux in interplanetary space would build up indefinitely. Reconnection has also been proposed as a mechanism for the heating of solar and stellar coronae to extremely high temperatures
(emphasis added)
and see that magnetic reconneciton is the probable cause of solar flares.
Can you?

I can read Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003 and see that there is good evidence for MR causing solar flares.
Can you?

I can read a definition of electrical charges and see that it is all about normal electrical discharges like lightning. You cannot: Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!

I can read an 60 year old paper and see that it uses a term for large charge density that I do not see in modern literature. That makes it obsolete. You persist in displaying your ignorance of modern physics by using this outdated term: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.
 
Last edited:
Oh it was probably me, the evil tusenfem, hater of EU, misunderstander of Alfvén, false doctor of plasmaastrophysics, sneakily asking someone else to "do the dirty work for me" whilst remaining behind the scenes myself like the elders of Zion that are ruling the world.

I knew it! :)
 
Tim and I could probably explain the subtleties to you in Priest's paper, but it would be lost on you anyway. So why bother, I will just continue asking my shady bud to change some more wiki pages.

I'm sure you could explain it, but then you'd have to cop to the fact that "reconnection" is dependent upon current in equations 16&17, so no current, no "magnetic charge". That wouldn't play out well for Clinger who's been claiming that he can create "reconnection" WITHOUT plasma. :)
 
That is giving evidence for the assertion, not quote mining.
What Somov is saying is

[*]Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process:
[*]Magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point, break and connect again ('reconnect') in it.

BZZT. He doesn't say anything about B *LINE* reconnection. In fact he specifically mentions that the E field is induced and it's the source of the acceleration of PARTICLES. So much for a PERFECT vacuum, and so much for your parrot routine. All you "understand" is the term "reconnection", but you have no idea what it means. You're simply parroting the term without a clue what it actually means. No current, no "magnetic charge" in equation 17.
 
Last edited:
I've already explained countless times that there is NOTHING in that NULL *until* you add "current" through the Z axis. That's the whole point that you all seem to want to waltz around. The CURRENT does the physical "reconnecting". Without the plasma it's just a NULL zone, NOTHING more.


" NOTHING in that NULL"? So would that include field lines as well? In that case you are claiming there are no field lines at the null point. As already explained to you, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets and with no current at the null points. Though you simply tried to assert that as what you called "magnet reconnection" as if magnets were not, well, magnetic. Oh and what is the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force vectors at any point along the central axis of a straight current carrying wire (hint that axis is a collection of null points or a null line)? Seems you just need to explain this to yourself.
 
" NOTHING in that NULL"? So would that include field lines as well? In that case you are claiming there are no field lines at the null point.

Let's put it this way: If I drop a charged particle, positive or negative, at the X in the NULL, it's not necessarily going to accelerate in any particular direction with respect to X or Y as long as all the pole strengths remain constant. On the other hand, I can drop that test particle anywhere else and watch it accelerate in some direction. That movement and acceleration of a charged particle is a form of "current". That current coming up through the X in Priest's source/sink paper is turned into "magnetic charge" at equation 17. Without current up the Z axis at X, no 'reconnection' process is possible.

As already explained to you, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets and with no current at the null points. Though you simply tried to assert that as what you called "magnet reconnection" as if magnets were not, well, magnetic.

Hmmm. No, that's not quite what I meant. When the magnets are apart, they simply "attract", or "repulse", or create "magnetic flux changes over time" due to movement over time. There was a point in PS's animation where the magnetic are rotating and creating a magnetic flux change as a result. Any of those kinds of processes will INDUCE CURRENT in plasma.

At the level of 'physical things' the magnets themselves can physically "reconnect" and the H lines *INSIDE* the magnets will reconnect accordingly. Likewise, in plasma, the particles themselves can 'reconnect' and the "currents' can "reconnect", but the magnetic lines themselves cannot "reconnect" because no monopoles exist in nature.

Is that any better of any explanation of my position?

You really might want to checkout that magnetic reconnection source/sink paper by Priest and checkout equations 16 and 17. At that point, Priest simply "converts" current running through the Z axis into "magnetic charge" that attaches itself to "lines" along the X,Y axis. What's really going on at the level of physics is that currents are being INDUCED into various X,Y lines, and currents are being "redirected" from the Z axis into different directions. They start coming OUT of the Z axis and flowing into the X,Y axis.

The real 'source' of kinetic energy is the E field, not the NULL. The NULL simply becomes the focal point of current running up through the Z axis. That CURRENT can get redirected into the X,Y axis. Changes in the flow of current might also create magnetic flux changes that induce CURRENT in the various lines flowing from the NULL. What CANNOT happen is any sort of B LINE reconnection without a monopole.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you could explain it, but then you'd have to cop to the fact that "reconnection" is dependent upon current in equations 16&17, so no current, no "magnetic charge". That wouldn't play out well for Clinger who's been claiming that he can create "reconnection" WITHOUT plasma. :)

I guess that it goes right over your head that things can happen in vacuum (MRx, field lines reconnect, there is an induced electric field, there are no particles to get accelerated, there are no currents in the MRx region), and then the same thing can happen in a plasma, but then it becomes more complicated, and currents can flow, and plasma is accelerated perpendicular to the magnetic field in the direction of the curvature radius of the field lines, Hall currents will flow where the ions uncouple from the magnetic field, etc. etc.

But hey, you still don't think that a quasi-neutral plasma can carry a current, so I am not surprised that the subtleties of real plasma physics and MRx are out of your league.
 
Does Mozina Deny Magnetic Reconnection?

See W.D.Clinger's webpage Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection. Here we find ...
"One of those deniers has responded to my demonstration of magnetic reconnection by (surprise!) repeatedly denying magnetic reconnection."

Mozina responds ...

FYI, your website is an outright lie. I never claimed "reconnection' didn't occur, I claimed it didn't occur in a vacuum and I claimed it requires CURRENT.
It is a BLATANT LIE that I "deny" the reconnection PROCESS is real.
I never DENIED "reconnection" is a real process.

Notice the not too clever attempt at "bait & switch"? Clinger is explicit about "denying magnetic reconnection". But in his denials of denying, notice that Mozina uses the word "reconnection" without the modifier "magnetic". Of course, as he has written it, Mozina is quite correct. He has never denied the reality of "reconnection", always insisting on "circuit reconnection" or "current reconnection". But has Mozina ever denied the reality of magnetic reconnection?

It's fact check time.

Fact #1:
This is what Clinger actually says at the top of his page:
"One of those deniers has responded to my demonstration of magnetic reconnection by (surprise!) repeatedly denying magnetic reconnection."

Fact #2a: Clinger's definition of "magnetic reconnection":
See Clinger's webpage Magnetic Reconnection.
"Magnetic reconnection refers to the merging and separation of magnetic field lines that can occur at neutral points of magnetic fields as those fields change over time. Alternatively, magnetic reconnection refers to changes over time in the topology of magnetic field lines."

Fact #2b: My own definition of "magnetic reconnection":
Physically: Nothing "reconnects", that's just a word we use to name the process. What physically happens is that the magnetic field changes from a higher energy state to a lower energy state, and the energy lost by the field escapes as electromagnetic photons. In the presence of a plasma, that energy will transfer to the plasma and manifest itself as an impulsive increase in plasma kinetic energy.

Mathematically: Field lines are the mathematical tool of choice to describe and analyze any field, ever since Maxwell. Mathematically, the lines of force representing the physical magnetic field literally reconnect, resulting in a change in the topology of the field. The name, "magnetic reconnection", comes from this mathematical reconnection of field lines.


It is not difficult to see that my definition given here and Clinger's from his webpage are equivalent to each other. So, what does Mozina think about magnetic reconnection, as defined in this discussion?

From 12 Feb 2009:
Magnetic lines lack physical substance, they form as a full and complete continuum, and they are physically *incapable* of "reconnecting". Did any of you folks take a class in basic electronics?


From 15 Feb 2009:
The magnetic lines lack physical substance, and they are physically incapable of "disconnecting" or "reconnecting" to any other magnetic field line. These are simply "particle/circuit reconnection" events, not "magnetic reconnection" events. It simply "current sheet acceleration", nothing more.


From 4 Jan 2010:
They clearly do "rule out" your pseudoscientific magnetic reconnection model in these two flares!


From 29 Jan 2010:
The "highly idiosyncratic" understanding/verbiage comes from the "mainstream" because Alfven himself called Parkers "magnetic reconnection" a form of "pseudoscience". Alfven was an electrical engineer by trade and he knew damn well that magnetic lines do not "disconnect' or 'reconnect' to any other magnetic line. The "reconnection" is between two "circuits", not simply two magnetic lines.


From 31 Jan 2010:
What part of "pseudoscience" is still "pseudoscience" don't your understand Tim? Alfven saw Parker's description of "magnetic reconnection' Tim. He knew MHD theory from *BOTH* the B *AND* E orientations. He was an electrical engineer by trade, and no such individual would ever make the mistake of calling a "current flow change" a "magnetic reconnection" event! It's still pseudoscience Tim, and time will not ever change that fact.


Throughout this list of sample quotes from Mozina he presents a consistent opinion. He consistently refers to magnetic reconnection as "pseudoscience". He consistently denies that magnetic field lines can "reconnect", appealing to the fact that they are mathematical rather than physical entities. While their mathematical nature is true enough, it is simply a handy excuse to avoid the physics implied by the mathematics. Physically, the magnetic field changes from a higher to a lower energy state, losing energy. Mathematically, the topology of the magnetic field changes, which logically & necessarily requires an explicit reconnection of the mathematical magnetic field lines.

Therefore, if one adopts the Mozina position that field lines cannot reconnect, it is a logically necessary consequence of that position that the topology of the magnetic field cannot change. But a change in the topology of the magnetic field, and the "reconnection" of the magnetic field lines are in fact the heart of the definition of "magnetic reconnection".

Mozina calls Clinger's website "an outright lie". As we can see above, in Mozina's own words, he definitely does deny the reality of magnetic reconnection as it is defined by mainstream science, and that is the claim that Clinger in fact makes. I submit these facts as objective evidence, using Mozina's own words, that Mozina lies about Clinger lying, by falsely claiming that Clinger makes claims that he does not make. Clinger is explicit about Mozina denying magnetic reconnection, and Mozina in his own words is equally explicit in denying the reality of magnetic reconnection.
 
See W.D.Clinger's webpage Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection. Here we find ...

...complete lies and nothing but lies.

I've lost count now how many times I've asked you to meet me in the middle and call the PHYSICAL PROCESS 'current reconnection'. Priest demonstrated *CONCLUSIVELY* that CURRENT gets turned into "magnetic charge" between equations 16&17 in his source/sink paper. The whole 'reconnection' process requires current, otherwise equation 17 nets to ZIP/0/NADDA/NOTHING, and NOTHING reconnects.

Dance around the issue all you like but unless one of you folks has a monopole in your pocket, there is no "B LINE" reconnection going on in a vacuum. I do not deny that the *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process is a REAL physical process, it simply REQUIRES plasma, and REQUIRES currents. No current, equation 17 nets to zero and you've got NOTHING in terms of 'reconnection'.

Magnetic fields have no source or sink. They are not and never could be the source of kinetic energy. The source and sink for the current in equations 16 is the *ELECTRIC FIELD*, not a MAGNETIC NULL. The Z axis to X,Y axis "reconnection" process requires the flow of current through the NULL.
 
Last edited:
Throughout this list of sample quotes from Mozina he presents a consistent opinion. He consistently refers to magnetic reconnection as "pseudoscience".
This use of "pseudoscience" is just an example of Michael Mozina's inability to understand what Alfvén was actually talking about in his speech at the 1986 workshop on double layers.
Alfvén strongly stresses the danger of using the frozen-in concept (not MR)
Since then I have stressed in a large number of papers the danger of using the frozen-in concept. For example, in a paper "Electric Current Structure of the Magnetosphere" (Alfvén, 1975), I made a table showing the difference between the real plasma and "a fictitious medium" called "the pseudo-plasma," the latter having frozen-in magnetic field lines moving with the plasma. The most important criticism of the "merging" mechanism of energy transfer is due to Heikkila (1973) who with increasing strength has demonstrated that it is wrong. In spite of all this, we have witnessed at the same time an enormously voluminous formalism building up based on this obviously erroneous concept. Indeed, we have been burdened with a gigantic pseudo-science which penetrates large parts of cosmic plasma physics.
The context implies that the 'pseudo-science' that Alfvén is using is not 'pseudoscience'!
It is any science that uses 'pseudo-plasma', i.e. plasma with frozen-in magnetic fields.
 
I guess that it goes right over your head that things can happen in vacuum (MRx, field lines reconnect, there is an induced electric field, there are no particles to get accelerated, there are no currents in the MRx region),

By "MRx" you're simply talking about "magnetic flux changes" evidently, and potently topology changes due to changes in B at one or more of the poles. Unless you have a monopole in your pocket, there is nothing PHYSICAL to "reconnect" at a NULL (or anywhere else) in a vacuum.

Sure, when we add plasma, currents are induced, E fields become the source and sink of PARTICLE kinetic energy in the form of CHARGED particles, and Priest can then work his magic at equation 17 and get some "reconnection" happening. No current at equation 16 and equation 17, and 'magnetic charge', and the rate of 'reconnection' is ZERO!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom