Michael Mozina
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2009
- Messages
- 9,361
I do not need to.

Haters are all alike. The topics may change, but the IGNORANCE BY CHOICE and the "knowledge by clairvoyance" is exactly the same.
Um, I hate to break it to you, but you do.
I do not need to.

I do not need to.
Um, I hate to break it to you, but you are still lying...hater rant...
Um, I hate to break it to you, but you do.![]()
Showing your ignorance yet again, MM?Quote mining again and ignoring that induced E field source and sink, and charged particles again are you?
That is giving evidence for the assertion, not quote mining.Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.
I'm curious to know if it was RC or tusenfem who modified or twisted someone's arm into modifying the WIKI page on magnetic lines? That was CLASSIC! I've seen weird and pretty bizarre hater behaviors in my time, but WOW! I've never seen a "fundy" change a WIKI page in the hope of winning a debate before. That was a new low.![]()
I think you and Tim have done a FANTASTIC job of running away from equation 17 in Priest's source/sink paper. You don't want to admit that CURRENTS reconnect, but it's right there in equations 16 and 17.
FYI: You are deluded if you think that I use the "same line".FYI, I've heard creationists use that exact same line after claiming that humans didn't evolve from "monkeys/apes", and I asked them if they'd ever read a book on the topic of evolutionary theory.
(emphasis added)Reconnection provides an elegant, and so far the only, explanation for the motion of chromospheric ribbons and flare loops during solar flares. At the same time, it also accounts for the enormous energy release in solar flares. The ejection of magnetic flux from the Sun during coronal mass ejections and prominence eruptions necessarily requires reconnection; otherwise, the magnetic flux in interplanetary space would build up indefinitely. Reconnection has also been proposed as a mechanism for the heating of solar and stellar coronae to extremely high temperatures
Have you read any books on plasma physics yet?
Have you stopped beating your wife, yet?
Oh it was probably me, the evil tusenfem, hater of EU, misunderstander of Alfvén, false doctor of plasmaastrophysics, sneakily asking someone else to "do the dirty work for me" whilst remaining behind the scenes myself like the elders of Zion that are ruling the world.
Tim and I could probably explain the subtleties to you in Priest's paper, but it would be lost on you anyway. So why bother, I will just continue asking my shady bud to change some more wiki pages.
Um, I hate to break it to you, but you are still lying
MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you.
That is giving evidence for the assertion, not quote mining.
What Somov is saying is
[*]Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process:
[*]Magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point, break and connect again ('reconnect') in it.
I've already explained countless times that there is NOTHING in that NULL *until* you add "current" through the Z axis. That's the whole point that you all seem to want to waltz around. The CURRENT does the physical "reconnecting". Without the plasma it's just a NULL zone, NOTHING more.
" NOTHING in that NULL"? So would that include field lines as well? In that case you are claiming there are no field lines at the null point.
As already explained to you, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets and with no current at the null points. Though you simply tried to assert that as what you called "magnet reconnection" as if magnets were not, well, magnetic.
I'm sure you could explain it, but then you'd have to cop to the fact that "reconnection" is dependent upon current in equations 16&17, so no current, no "magnetic charge". That wouldn't play out well for Clinger who's been claiming that he can create "reconnection" WITHOUT plasma.![]()
FYI, your website is an outright lie. I never claimed "reconnection' didn't occur, I claimed it didn't occur in a vacuum and I claimed it requires CURRENT.
It is a BLATANT LIE that I "deny" the reconnection PROCESS is real.
I never DENIED "reconnection" is a real process.
Physically: Nothing "reconnects", that's just a word we use to name the process. What physically happens is that the magnetic field changes from a higher energy state to a lower energy state, and the energy lost by the field escapes as electromagnetic photons. In the presence of a plasma, that energy will transfer to the plasma and manifest itself as an impulsive increase in plasma kinetic energy.
Mathematically: Field lines are the mathematical tool of choice to describe and analyze any field, ever since Maxwell. Mathematically, the lines of force representing the physical magnetic field literally reconnect, resulting in a change in the topology of the field. The name, "magnetic reconnection", comes from this mathematical reconnection of field lines.
Magnetic lines lack physical substance, they form as a full and complete continuum, and they are physically *incapable* of "reconnecting". Did any of you folks take a class in basic electronics?
The magnetic lines lack physical substance, and they are physically incapable of "disconnecting" or "reconnecting" to any other magnetic field line. These are simply "particle/circuit reconnection" events, not "magnetic reconnection" events. It simply "current sheet acceleration", nothing more.
They clearly do "rule out" your pseudoscientific magnetic reconnection model in these two flares!
The "highly idiosyncratic" understanding/verbiage comes from the "mainstream" because Alfven himself called Parkers "magnetic reconnection" a form of "pseudoscience". Alfven was an electrical engineer by trade and he knew damn well that magnetic lines do not "disconnect' or 'reconnect' to any other magnetic line. The "reconnection" is between two "circuits", not simply two magnetic lines.
What part of "pseudoscience" is still "pseudoscience" don't your understand Tim? Alfven saw Parker's description of "magnetic reconnection' Tim. He knew MHD theory from *BOTH* the B *AND* E orientations. He was an electrical engineer by trade, and no such individual would ever make the mistake of calling a "current flow change" a "magnetic reconnection" event! It's still pseudoscience Tim, and time will not ever change that fact.
See W.D.Clinger's webpage Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection. Here we find ...
This use of "pseudoscience" is just an example of Michael Mozina's inability to understand what Alfvén was actually talking about in his speech at the 1986 workshop on double layers.Throughout this list of sample quotes from Mozina he presents a consistent opinion. He consistently refers to magnetic reconnection as "pseudoscience".
The context implies that the 'pseudo-science' that Alfvén is using is not 'pseudoscience'!Since then I have stressed in a large number of papers the danger of using the frozen-in concept. For example, in a paper "Electric Current Structure of the Magnetosphere" (Alfvén, 1975), I made a table showing the difference between the real plasma and "a fictitious medium" called "the pseudo-plasma," the latter having frozen-in magnetic field lines moving with the plasma. The most important criticism of the "merging" mechanism of energy transfer is due to Heikkila (1973) who with increasing strength has demonstrated that it is wrong. In spite of all this, we have witnessed at the same time an enormously voluminous formalism building up based on this obviously erroneous concept. Indeed, we have been burdened with a gigantic pseudo-science which penetrates large parts of cosmic plasma physics.
I guess that it goes right over your head that things can happen in vacuum (MRx, field lines reconnect, there is an induced electric field, there are no particles to get accelerated, there are no currents in the MRx region),