Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The idea that magnetic reconnection in vacuo cannot be accepted unless there is a publication trail for it is weak at best, but pure crackpot when it goes along with ignoring an explicit original proof.

Let me point out the clear difference between your behaviors and Clinger's behaviors in terms of scientific references you each provide to support your statements during public debates. You ALWAYS provide PUBLISHED WORKS to support your case, most of which have been peer reviewed (so I don't have to do it myself), and most of which are very useful and timely references related to the points in debate (including that source/sink paper).

Clinger however made a series of false statements related to *DUNGEY'S* description/definition of 'magnetic reconnection', including the claim it could all be duplicated *WITHOUT* plasma! Mind you he made these claims in *DECEMBER OF 2010*.

He didn't just hand me those "original works" for me to "peer review" for him back in December of 2010, or January of 2011. Oh no. He spent *10 FULL MONTHS* berating my maths skills publicly in cyberspace, and never even produced PART 1! He *STILL* thinks a *NULL* is a "beginning and ending" of B lines! Oy vey! He blatantly baited (without plasma) in his claims and switched (with plasma) in part 5! Epic fail.
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind that Tim was flailing away at EU theory before I personally even became involved in the topic. Tim was slugging it out publicly with Donald Scott before I'd even heard of the idea, even going to all the trouble to put up a website about his criticisms. IMO I simply became a "target" in Tim's mind the moment I started to publicly support Alfven's work.

In case you're keeping score, without a monopole they are all up a metaphysical creek without a physical paddle in terms of B field *LINE* reconnection. Without a monopole, "FOREGETABOUTIT"! B lines cannot be broken into segments. They have no sources or sinks. They have no beginnings or endings. They do have NULLS sometimes. :)

This whole thing has evidently been a sham from the start. Clinger never produced magnetic reconnection without plasma. He simply added plasma and then blamed me for *HIS* mistake in *HIS* original claim. Wow.

You're just a reality HATER.
 
Yawn. [...]
Keep in mind [...]
FYI, I've been [...]
IMO [...]
Don't you think [...]
Sure, [...]
Let me point out [...]


There is nothing of any relevant substance in any of the above replies. This exemplifies Tim's assessment that no objective quantitative argument against the contemporary consensus position on solar physics, or support for an electric Sun conjecture, has ever been offered by any of its advocates in this thread...

Mozina is completely wrong about dark matter, completely wrong about dark energy, completely wrong about magnetic reconnection, completely wrong about any iron surface on the sun, completely wrong about what constitutes empirical science, just plain completely wrong about everything. And I suspect that the vast majority of all you "lurkers" out there have figured that out for yourself. In any case, I stand by what I have posted, and I note that Mozina has never been able to muster an objective argument against any of it.

I predict that my statement of fact above will be met with another uncivil taunt, an incorrect claim that the factual statement amounts to attacking someone, another dishonest attempt to deflect the burden of proof, possibly a strawman, an argument from ignorance or two, and maybe another attempt to redefine terms to spawn a physically impossible fantasy conjecture into existence.

I also predict that given yet another opportunity to present objective quantitative support for the electric Sun conjecture or a reasoned, objective criticism of contemporary plasma/solar physics, some words will be typed, some space on the page will be filled, but not a solitary piece of such criticism or support will be forthcoming.

To more directly address the topic rather than the barren electric Sun arguments: What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
There is nothing of any relevant substance in any of the above replies. This exemplifies Tim's assessment that no objective quantitative argument against the contemporary consensus position on solar physics, or support for an electric Sun conjecture, has ever been offered by any of its advocates in this thread...

Your statement simply demonstrates your DEEP denial of Dungey's description of an electrical discharge process in plasma, AKA a *PLASMA DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMAS AND FLARES* that he describes as "magnetic reconnection".
 
I predict that my statement of fact above will be met with another uncivil taunt, an incorrect claim that the factual statement amounts to attacking someone, another dishonest attempt to deflect the burden of proof, possibly a strawman, an argument from ignorance or two, and maybe another attempt to redefine terms to spawn a physically impossible fantasy conjecture into existence.

I also predict that given yet another opportunity to present objective quantitative support for the electric Sun conjecture or a reasoned, objective criticism of contemporary plasma/solar physics, some words will be typed, some space on the page will be filled, but not a solitary piece of such criticism or support will be forthcoming


Well that was easy...

Your statement simply demonstrates your DEEP denial of Dungey's description of an electrical discharge process in plasma, AKA a *PLASMA DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMAS AND FLARES* that he describes as "magnetic reconnection".


At the very least I was correct with "uncivil taunt" and "attempt to redefine terms to spawn a physically impossible fantasy conjecture into existence". :D

Also as predicted, the opportunity to actually provide the heretofore missing objective support was ignored. So...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
It is absolutely not at all true that monopoles are necessary for magnetic field line reconnection.

That is absolutely a false statement Tim.

This is not just an idle claim, it is something which can be, and has been, formally & logically proven.

If so, that's never been done so far. There's a damn good reason Clinger's claims have never been published Tim. They're utterly bogus. Plasma is not *OPTIONAL* in Dungey's description of "magnetic reconnection".

Mozina can neither understand nor deal with this proof, so he makes up some cheap argument about "origin",

Er, no. I understood his ERROR in claiming B lines 'begin' at the origin of his original graph. That's why I INSISTED he expand the graph and show all the poles. He didn't take the hint.

or some cheap argument about "equation 17"

Huh? You're the individual that handed me that paper and it was directly related to A) the monopole device issue, and B) the source/sink debate we were having at the time. I took the time to FIND THE EXACT EQUATIONS where current is turned into 'magnetic charge' for you. What do you want, egg in your beer?

and runs and hides from the physics he will never in his life understand.

Oh bull, on both counts. I haven't "run" from anything, and I understand you are all up a metaphysical creek without a monopole.

Fear of learning can evidently be a powerful thing. Magnetic field lines can & do terminate at null points.

No, they do not. They simply do not contain magnetic field energy. They are simply empty areas in terms of the magnetic field strength, or have NO field strength at null points, just like a pure vacuum might be empty and devoid of magnetic lines at some empty region of space.

I couldn't even find anything else of value worth responding to in the rest of that post.
 
Last edited:
Well that was easy...




At the very least I was correct with "uncivil taunt"

It is not an uncivil taunt to note that an individual is in denial of scientific fact. You are in denial of the scientific fact that electrical discharges can and do occur in plasmas and flare events.

and "attempt to redefine terms to spawn a physically impossible fantasy conjecture into existence". :D

You're the one trying to redefine Dungey's "scientific terms", specifically the term "electrical discharge".

Also as predicted, the opportunity to actually provide the heretofore missing objective support was ignored. So...

So even though I've provided TONS of evidence to support the idea that electrical discharges occur in flares, round and round you go on that denial/hate-go-round.

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.
 
I don't agree. I've seen the derivation now. No monopoles are necessary for magnetic field line reconnection.

Not in this thread you haven't. If you're talking about Clinger's math, his derivation amounts to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that NOTHING begins, ends or "reconnects" in the NULL in a vacuum.
 
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1986RvMP...58..741T

How exactly is this paper supposed to help your case Tim? It's all a "current" driven process.
You demonstrate your inability to read once again.
No currents and the abstract mentions reconnection of magnetic field lines
Relaxation and magnetic reconnection in plasmas
The theory of plasma relaxation is described and developed. Turbulence, allied with a small resistivity, allows the plasma rapid access to a particular minimum-energy state. This process involves reconnection of magnetic field lines in a manner that destroys all the topological invariants of ideal plasma so that only total magnetic helicity survives. Although this mechanism, and the equations describing the relaxed state, are similar in all systems, the properties of the relaxed state depend crucially on the topology-toroidal or spherical-of the container and on the boundary conditions. Consequently there are several different types of relaxed state, each with its own special characteristics, which are derived and discussed. The measurements made on many experiments, including toroidal pinches, OHTE, multipinch, and spheromaks, are reviewed and shown to be in striking agreement with the theoretical predictions.
 
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1988SoPh..117...77G

I don't really see how this paper helps your case either since it clearly involves PLASMAS and "flares/electrical discharges".
You are lying - There are no "electrical discharges" in the paper.
Flares are not caused by "electrical discharges and are not equivalent: Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.

Plenty of currents and even "effective magnetic charges" (their quote marks)!
Photospheric vortex flows as a cause for two-ribbon flares - A topological model
By using a topological model for the potential magnetic field above the photosphere, the appearance and development of the separator as a result of vortex plasma flows in the locality of the photospheric neutral line are considered. The possible relation of such vortex flows with a flare activity is revealed. The arrangement and shape of the flare ribbons in the chromosphere, the formation of X-ray intersecting loops, and the early appearance of bright 'knots' on flare ribbon edges are naturally explained by the model provided a reconnecting current sheet arises along the separator in the coronal magnetic field of active regions as a result of the evolution of the magnetic field sources in the photosphere.
 
Clinger claimed that Dungey's brand of "reconnection" could occur *WITHOUT* a plasma. Nothing of the sort is physically possible. In part five he FINALLY introduces the thing he said he didn't need so he could actually get anything at equation 16 and any "magnetic charge" at 17.
You need to quote this claim rather than persisting with it as a strawman argument.

His claim was:
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 1
The purpose of this derivation is to show how we can get from Maxwell's equations to Dungey's figures, the first half of Yamada et al's figure 3, and Wikipedia's animation using no mathematics beyond freshman calculus.

He delivered this in part 3:
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3:
...
That reproduces the "figure eight" field of the second figure in [Dungey 1958]:
...
J W Dungey was one of the pioneers who suggested that solar phenomena might be explained by magnetic reconnection. The two-dimensional field shown in figure 1 of [Dungey 1958] can be reproduced and understood in vacuo, with no currents or electric field at all within the region of space shown in that figure.

MR without plasma is possible as he showed.
You would know this if you could understand Somov's textbook rather then persisting with your delusions abut it: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II

Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV
 
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

Not at all Tim. You're just digging yourself in DEEPER. Without any monopoles, nothing like "B *LINE* reconnection" is physically possible. When did you intend to acknowledge that fact?
You are wrong because you have stated that "B *LINE* reconnection" is physically possible in plasma. There are no monopoles in plasma :jaw-dropp!

The precise definition of a field line includes:
  • It does not exist where there is no vector field.
  • Where the vector field magntitude is zero, the density of fleld lines is zero.
At a null point the magnetic field does not exist (B=0). Thus there can be no field line thre because
  • There is no field there.
  • The density of field lines there is zero.
Thus any magnetic field line that crosses a null point cannot exist at the null point. This is described as the magnetic field line breaking at the null point. It ends before the point and starts after the point.

See Fields: Points & Lines II by Tim Thompson on 27th January 2010 with another more modern defintion in another of his posts:Magnetic field lines end at null points II


Also MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.

Or maybe you can answer this now MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0 (15th November 2011) :rolleyes:!
 
Your statement simply demonstrates your DEEP denial of Dungey's description of an electrical discharge process in plasma, AKA a *PLASMA DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMAS AND FLARES* that he describes as "magnetic reconnection".
Your statement merely demonstrates Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.

And more unsupported statements
  • Dungey never uses the term "electrical discharge process"
  • Dungey does not state that a electrical discharge is magnetic reconnection.
I will give you a chance to retract these assertions before adding then to the delusions post.
 
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
Bla, bla, bla ... equations 16 and 17. At that point, Priest simply "converts" current running through the Z axis into "magnetic charge" that attaches itself to "lines" along the X,Y axis. Bla, bla bla ... "redirected" from the Z axis into different directions. They start coming OUT of the Z axis and flowing into the X,Y axis.
Bla, bla, bla ... Changes in the flow of current might also create magnetic flux changes that induce CURRENT in the various lines flowing from the NULL. What CANNOT happen is any sort of B LINE reconnection without a monopole.
"Without a monopole"...? How may times has this straw man been attacked by that fearless pseudoscientific ditherer, Mr. Mozina. Is this really designed to be persuasive commentary or is it a form of dialectic masturbation?
 
What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


Okay, so the single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares are electrical discharges like lightning or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare in his description of the process of magnetic reconnection. Maybe we can get some traction here. Specifically, and objectively, how did Dungey state that magnetic reconnection is like lightning? Where, specifically, did he mention the breakdown of a dielectric medium?
 
"Without a monopole"...? How may times has this straw man been attacked by that fearless pseudoscientific ditherer, Mr. Mozina. Is this really designed to be persuasive commentary or is it a form of dialectic masturbation?
To answer your question: Michael Mozina probably thinks it is persuasive.

Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he can't calculate the divergence of a magnetic field, nor can he calculate the magnetic flux of a magnetic field through a closed surface, so Mozina simply cannot tell whether the magnetic fields that demonstrate magnetic reconnection in vacuo obey Gauss's law for magnetism.

Mozina must realize that everyone with basic competence in mathematics or physics is telling him that the divergence is zero, so Gauss's law holds, so there are no monopoles, but Mozina doesn't trust mathematical or scientific competence.

In fact, Mozina rejects mathematical and scientific competence precisely because that competence yields answers that contradict Mozina's existential faith in his own incompetent interpretation of what one of his personal deities, now deceased, said about the incompatibility between magnetic reconnection and the frozen-in concept that particular deity had helped to popularize. That particular deity, who shared the 1970 Nobel Prize in physics, eventually felt so guilty about his popularization of the frozen-in concept that he referred to it as pseudo-science.

So Mozina rejects the competent conclusion and holds fast to his incompetent conclusion. Through the remarkable cognitive process that was documented by the eponymous Justin Kruger and David Dunning, earning them the 1970 2000 Ig Nobel Prize in Psychology, Mozina has convinced himself that he is right, and that everyone who actually understands Gauss's law for magnetism is wrong.

Michael Mozina probably believes that his blathering about monopoles is persuasive, because he probably believes that everyone who is reading this thread thinks he's an authority on plasma physics. He has, after all, read Cosmic Plasma and four other books on plasma physics. He didn't understand the math, but what difference could that make? He thinks math skills are "pretty damn useless".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom