Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge II

I've been waiting forever for you folks to demonstrate *ANY* of your FALSE claims about discharges NOT occurring in conductors, and 4 days I've waited for a mathematical expression of something that CANNOT HAPPEN without mass to accelerate.
So still no answer to
  1. MM: State your position on MR without plasma and list citations to support it
    Asked 20 March 2012
  2. MM: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
  3. MM What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trivial process..." mean?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
You reply confirming your ignorance about electrical discharges.
They require the breakdown of a dielectric medium as Peratt states but see Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!
Luckily you seem to have abandoned your quote mining of the first sentence and added the third sentence. However that makes actually you a bit more deluded about his definition because you ignore the second sentence!
This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium.

And another time with:
Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!
 
He did not quote anyone. He cited the SDO team *AT NASA*.

He lied. Nobody at NASA is that dumb. Everyone at NASA understands that the color above the transition region in an iron ion composite image is directly related to the color assignments of each channel, their relative strengths (intensity) and a blending of the colors from each channel. The green color has NOTHING to do with an 'misalignment' of the RGB images. Nobody at NASA and nobody EXCEPT GM would make that kind of BUSH LEAGUE mistake.
 
Last edited:
MM: Why have you never in almost 2 years, contacted the SDO team about the image

Better yet, where is the QUOTE from the individual he spoke to at NASA, along with their FULL response?
Better yet, when he cited he SDO team at NASA, why have you never in almost 2 years, contacted the SDO team at NASA about the image?

The green line = something 4800 km below the photosphere is your claim. We know that this is physically impossible (How can we detect the less than 1 photon per year from your iron crust?).
Bit it is your claim. It is up to you to support it by making sure that this publicity relation image is a accurate representation of the raw data.
 
He lied. Nobody at NASA is that dumb. Everyone at NASA understands that the color above the transition region in an iron ion composite image is directly related to the color assignments of each channel, their relative strengths (intensity) and a blending of the colors from each channel. The green color has NOTHING to do with an 'misalignment' of the RGB images. Nobody at NASA and nobody EXCEPT GM would make that kind of BUSH LEAGUE mistake.
You are displaying your ignorance yet again.
Everyone at NASA knows that the assignment of colors to each channel is fairly arbitrary. Generally "warmer" colors for warmer channels but there are plenty of inverted color images.
Everyone at NASA knows that that image is a PR image and was processed to look pretty. Nobody at NASA and nobody EXCEPT Michael Mozina would make the kind of BUSH LEAGUE mistake of trying to analyze a PR image.

The only excuse would be if that person had contacted the SDO team and found out the processing that the PR people did to produce the PR image.
Of course a competent person would have got the raw data and processed that!

MM: Why have you never in almost 2 years, contacted the SDO team about the image?
 
Michael Mozina ignorance of solar physics (transition region)

Nope, the transition region is located 4832KM under the photosphere in that SDO image and nothing pokes above the photosphere except coronal loops.
Missed this display of the ignorance of solar physics: The solar transition region is located thousands of kilometers above the photosphere and even above the chromosphere.

This is really easy to understand. Just go to a solar observatory, read a book, attend a lecture, ask an astronomer, etc.
 
So where do things stand?


Where do things stand on this post?

Okay, try again. This has gone unanswered for almost seven years now. So provide a quantitative objective analysis of the running difference image as it relates to the pair of original data images posted above. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to each pixel in the data images to generate the running difference result. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing 4800 kilometers through the photosphere.

To review...

  1. Provide a quantitative objective analysis of the running difference image as it relates to the pair of original data images posted above.

    No analysis offered.​

  2. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to each pixel in the data images to generate the running difference result.

    No explanation offered.​

  3. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible.

    Not done.​

  4. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results.

    No explanation offered.​

  5. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing 4800 kilometers through the photosphere.

    No explanation offered.​
Where do things stand? The claim that the TRACE running difference image is evidence for a solid/rigid surface or that it somehow allows us to see 4800 kilometers beyond the depth where no light can escape from the Sun cannot be supported.
 
Where do things stand on this post?

I already told you DAYS ago where things stand on that post. You don't have the expertize to even "quiz" me on those images and we already played this game. I provided you with a movie that I created based on IDL routines. You incorrectly, erroneously and fraudulently claimed that I didn't create them. Your "expertize" is therefore MEANINGLESS. In fact, you are so clueless about solar physics, you cannot even CORRECTLY identify the light source in either original image!
 
Last edited:
I already told you DAYS ago where things stand on that post. You don't have the expertize to even "quiz" me on those images and we already played this game. I provided you with a movie that I created based on IDL routines. You incorrectly, erroneously and fraudulently claimed that I didn't create them. Your "expertize" is therefore MEANINGLESS. In fact, you are so clueless about solar physics, you cannot even CORRECTLY identify the light source in either original image!


The continued refusal to quantitatively objectively explain the alleged evidence is noted. As are the continued incivility and personal attacks.

I'll post some sample SDO images soon so we can see if the claims about those are quantitatively and objectively supportable.
 
The continued refusal to quantitatively objectively explain the alleged evidence is noted. As are the continued incivility and personal attacks.

I'll post some sample SDO images soon so we can see if the claims about those are quantitatively and objectively supportable.

Look at you run. The moment I point out that you personally can't even *CORRECTLY* describe the light sources in the ORIGINAL images, you run. What are the light sources of those original images GM?

Care to admit that the horizon line color of *ANY* iron ion composite image has NOTHING to do with any "misalignment' of the RGB images?

If you can't correctly deal with those two issues in ORIGINAL images, there is absolutely NO point in trying to talk about RD images. To even discuss ORIGINAL images in terms of PHYSIC, one needs to talk in terms of MHD theory and plasma physics. Between the two of us, I'm the only one that knows for sure that he owns any textbooks (5 total) on that topic! What is the point then of trying to discuss SOLAR PHYSICS with you personally?
 
FYI, still no mathematical expression for the reconnection RATE in the absence of mass and mass acceleration. Like I said, gas can racers.

Your entire understanding of physics, particularly plasma physics is BS, starting with the notion that electrical discharges CANNOT occur in conductors. They can *ONLY* occur in 'conductors'. B lines have no source and no sink, so they have no beginning and no end. "Reconnection" refers to PLASMA behaviors, specifically their BEHAVIORS in the presence of magnetic field changes. That magnetic field energy is CONVERTED into particle kinetic energy. That CONVERSION of energy is what is known as 'reconnection' in the realm of PLASMA physics. Not that most of you even own a textbook on that topic mind you......
 
Still no PUBLISHED or peer reviewed materials that claim charged particles are OPTIONAL in those "vacuums' during 'reconnection'. Don't EVER think about lecturing me about the need for "peer review", and peer review processes. You folks don't actually give a hoot about it.
 
Let's do a quick review folks:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration. Magnetic reconnection occurs on timescales intermediate between slow resistive diffusion of the magnetic field and fast Alfvénic timescales.
 
Either butcher the hell out of that Wiki link like you did with the B lines WIKI page, or accept it's contents, one or the other. I'm going to keep sticking it in your face for weeks on end until you accept that you're hiding behind an equivocation fallacy.

"Reconnection" relates to PLASMA physics. It's a term that relates to PLASMA behaviors in the presence of EM fields and specifically CHANGING MAGNETIC FIELDS. There are three key components listed on the WIKI site, specifically plasmas, changing magnetic fields, and particle acceleration. All RATES of reconnection relate to ALFVENIC timescales, because they relate to PLASMA physics! Holy cow.

I handed you over a dozen PUBLISHED links that all claimed that B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning, and no end. They therefore could NEVER disconnect from one line, nor RECONNECT to any other line. They can FLUX and they can experience FLUX CHANGE, but they cannot RECONNECT!

Only PLASMA PHYSICS describes the process called RECONNECTION! It's not only "flux change". It's the affect of that flux change *ON CHARGED PARTICLES*.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom