Oh, Sweet himself explained the difference quite clearly. He noted that WITHOUT PLASMA no CURRENTS would be INDUCED! That's the part you can't handle.
Apparently you wish to "dumb down" the process to the point that ANY magnetic field FLUX CHANGE ends up being relabeled "magnetic reconnection", with or without plasma, with or without MHD theory, with or without *PUBLISHED MATH*. Actually WITHOUT published math.
Well srcew my nipple nuts and send me to alaska!
No plasma means no currents??? whoddatoughtdat!!!!
I have no idea what I can't handle, but maybe it is your blatand lack of knowledge of basic electrodynamics, let alone plasma physics. Let's look at your next paragraph, where, as usual you are misusing clearly defined physical terms and try to sound important, but instead sound ridiculous.
Your claim that "any magnetic field flux change" ends up beling labeled "magnetic reconnection" is so weird, that I cannot even fathom it, let alone accept that you have ever actually read Alfvén's work.
Example: If I have a coil and I crank up the current in the coil the magnetic field will increase and thus the flux will increase. Reconnection does not come anywhere close to describing this, because it has nothing to do with reconnection, it has to do with changing flux.
However, to you flux and topology apparently are the same thing. I cannot help here, I can only say read some real books about electrodynamics and maybe at some point you will understand that flux and topology are not the same.
Essentially you want to discuss particle VELOCITY, even without particles. I hate to break it to you t, but MHD theory (including the resistive type) is all about the BEHAVIORS OF CHARGED PARTICLES. You can't ignore that relationship and dumb down a current driven *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process to a simply "magnetic flux change". I won't let you.
And? MHD theory is all about the behaviors of charged particles. With them, currents can be induced by those flux changes. Without them, no currents, no discharges, no flares.
No, I am not talking about particles when I talk about a vacuum, I do have that much knowledge.
Yes, MDH is about magnetized fluids, I know that, I am not applying MHD to vacuum though, I apply a vacuum superposition. I do hope you know that Maxwell's equations also apply in vacuum.
Your nagging about MHD makes no sense when I or Tim or anyone else claim to look at a
vacuum model or a
vacuum superposition. Really, what part of the word
vacuum don't you understand?
It means you side doesn't care one iota about math in the final analysis. All that math *INSISTS* that particles are involved in the DISCHARGE/RECONNECTION process. You're trying to DUMB IT DOWN. That's the fallacy in play. As Sweet himself (from *YOUR* reference) noted, no plasma, no induced current as a result of the field movement over time.
No, it does not do that at all, math doesn't, that is your interpretation only. Like the claims above from the post by RC by Priest: "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trival process..." And added to that it is also rather uninteresting, because nothing interesting happens. The field will, because of the lack of plasma, be potential fields, and just gradually move from one state to the other, when we, e.g. bring the two Sweet loops together.
There *AREN'T* any *LINES*. Even that is *DUMBED DOWN* representation of FULL FIELD INTERACTION. No individualized "lines" exist, certainly not in the ABSENCE OF PARTICLES.
Guess you never played with iron shavings and a bar magnet?
As you are always so fond of saying "the magnetic field is a continuum" or something like that, and indeed it is a vector field. The only way to find out how a vector field looks like is by using equipotentials, which in the case of the magnetic field are the magentic field lines. No, they are not real, like said before, they are as real as height contours on a map. However, they play an important role in showing the
topology of the magnetic field and they are also very useful to show
the dynamics of the magnetic field. Therefore, though not real physical objects, they are useful.
They are, actually, as real as your resistor and capacitor and inductor in your circuit representation of a coronal loop.
Boloney. Tim did that. He essentially claimed that any FLUX CHANGE = "magnetic reconnection" and the NULL isn't "special" at all.
Boloney. The one thing Clinger actually did demonstrate is that in terms of Gauss's law, it's NOT SPECIAL IN ANY WAY! The laws are satisfied there like everywhere. Since magnetic fields have no source and no sink, they don't "disconnect", nor do they "reconnect". The only thing they do is "flux" and thereby INDUCE CURRENT in a CONDUCTOR.
No, you are confusing flux and induction with reconnection.
The magnetic null is special (in my opinion) because that is where the magnetic field has zero value and no direction:
B = (0, 0, 0).
And really "the only thing they do is
flux", can you please explain in full detail what you mean when you say that fields "flux." Flux is
not a verb, it is a
noun in physics.
No, it's not "magic". He moved BOTH FIELDS. Of course the Null moves accordingly. DUH! As Sweet points out however, no plasma, no induced current, and oh, no MHD theory.
So what, "he moves both fields" and how exactly is the null to move and please give a
full description with drawings etc. like clinger did to show you are right.
An
of course no MHD, you keep on hitting a dead horse, Mikey, it is only you who seems to have problems about when and when not MDH can be or is applied.
So what if they and Sweet "superimpose" the magnetic fields into a vacuum? The movement of the fields INDUCES current according to Sweet. The lack of any plasmas will result in NO INDUCED current and no flare.
So what? That does that do in the absence of plasma, particularly at a NULL? Nothing! The movement of the WHOLE FIELDS will induce current EVERYWHERE, not just some magic place. The more the field changes in some place or another, the more INDUCED CURRENT will occur, ONLY IN A CONDUCTOR!
No, movement of fields, in a vacuum or in a non-conducting atmosphere induce electric fields (as in the case when plasma is present, you know curl E ~ dB/dt), which however will not generate currents as there are no particles to carry the current.
As long as you cannot do electrodynamics in a vacuum (is like 1st year college stuff) then you are definitely not going to be able to do actual MHD, let along plasma physics.
Ya, it gets "fun" because the currents flow and then MHD theory actually applies. No particles, no velocities to talk about, no induced current, no energy transfer to charged particles as a result of WHOLE FIELD CHANGES.
And there can be energy stored in a system, when there is a plasma, unlike in vacuum where there is only the magnetic energy of the field, moving from one potential to another.
But Sweet sank your ship t. He specifically REQUIRED plasma and current to explain it, and specifically points out that it *WON'T INDUCE CURRENT* in a vacuum! He specifically REFUTES your claim!
I can see I'm going to have to stop by at least once or twice a week to see if any of you actually come up with a PUBLISHED reference to support this nonsense. Thus far, Sweet disproved everything you're claiming because he specifically cited the problem. He specifically noted that for currents to be INDUCED, current (a conductor) MUST be present.
Still waiting for a published paper that supports your claim t. Sweet *DESTROYED* your argument, he didn't help it.
The offhand rejection of any books and papers that talk about vacuum superposition and reconnection, just because in your mind there must be currents flowing, clearly shows that you are not willing whatsoever even to actually think about basic electrodynamics.
Of course it's based on "resistive" MHD because plasmas are NOT perfect conductors. The plasma particles have a PROPERTY of resistance, just like they have a property of being affected by EM fields and they have a property of behaving like a fluid in large numbers. All the properties are represented in RESISTIVE MHD theory, whereas the original brand is missing an important BEHAVIOR of plasma. It does become unstable in the presence of large currents, and "resistive" to that current.
The thing is, that MRx is actually
not based on MDH, it is a fully
plasmaphysical process and MHD, even resistive MDH is only an approximation of actual plasmaphysics. That is why I said that in my claim about the Sweet paper, because he would not have used MDH, but real plasma physics, as at the time that that paper was written the use of MHD was not ubiquitous.
One interesting thing is that these plasma particle, with their property of
being affected by EM fields in the neighbourhood of the X-line are no longer affected by the magnetic field. First the ions decouple from the field and then the electrons decouple, creating the ion and electron diffusion regions. The claim of the EU/PU/EC/ES/PC proponents always comes back to that the charged particles are greatly affected by the magnetic fields and such, however, this is not always the case. There is a certain important quantity, usually called the plasma-beta, which determines what behaviour is more important, to say it simplified: the gas part or the frozen in part.