Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
But you’re still stumped Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03

And



But go on to say



Ummm...wtf??

Cliffs collapsing? Cracks getting bigger? And vents or orrifices?

Flogging a dead horse.

Nope. All these things either have been seen, or are very likely to occur, given what we know about the comet. What will not occur are electric discharges, that would be obvious to a number of instruments. What will also not occur, is instantaneous outbursts due to electrostatic levitation of dust particles of many microns in size.
So, let's hear the Sol88 version of events, backed up by scientific evidence. Not forgetting the following, which you have conveniently skipped over:

A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.
 
Last edited:
Ummm...you do know the mainstream have no plausible explanation unless it includes the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma!

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
J. Agarwal V. Della Corte P. D. Feldman B. Geiger S. Merouane

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2

So there you have it, sublimating gas can’t do it and no gas emissions observed for this event! But we see dust??

How does a dirtysnowball achieve this feat of cunning?

Oh, I see “dark gas” :rolleyes::blush:


I don’t make many technical posts in this thread for fear of embarrassing myself :o in front those more knowledgable, such as jonesdave, RC and of course tusenfem. I have posted about the EC comet density error, which by itself sinks the EC hypothesis. So I’d like to consider the EC proponents' arguments from 40 thousand feet.

I had a concept in mind for years before I learned the proper term, consilience, from a post elsewhere by JayUtah. Consilience means measurements or observations made by disparate methods or disciplines should be in agreement, for a given phenomenon. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consilience.

From the Wiki on lack of consilience:


Consilience does not forbid deviations: in fact, since not all experiments are perfect, some deviations from established knowledge are expected. However, when the convergence is strong enough, then new evidence inconsistent with the previous conclusion is not usually enough to outweigh that convergence. Without an equally strong convergence on the new result, the weight of evidence will still favor the established result. This means that the new evidence is most likely to be wrong.

Science denialism (for example, AIDS denialism) is often based on a misunderstanding of this property of consilience. A denier may promote small gaps not yet accounted for by the consilient evidence, or small amounts of evidence contradicting a conclusion without accounting for the pre-existing strength resulting from consilience. More generally, to insist that all evidence converge precisely with no deviations would be naïve falsificationism, equivalent to considering a single contrary result to falsify a theory when another explanation, such as equipment malfunction or misinterpretation of results, is much more likely.


IMO this a great explanation of the god-of-the-gaps and false dilemma fallacies in the EC argument. And here’s the nub: it doesn’t matter if the EC proponentl is right on a given point. Hey, even a blind squirrel finds an acorn once in a while :) . The principle of consilience teaches that an error will, in the long run, advance learning. Either the new measuremnt was done incorrectly and we fix the measurement problem, or we have an opportunity to learn something more about the science. Science wins either way. There’s a wonderful Niels Bohr quote IIRC “At last we have a contradiction. Now we have an opportunity to make progress.”
 
MO this a great explanation of the god-of-the-gaps and false dilemma fallacies in the EC argument. And here’s the nub: it doesn’t matter if the EC proponentl is right on a given point. Hey, even a blind squirrel finds an acorn once in a while

Good point! On the other hand, said squirrel might go hurtling into a tree, knocking itself senseless, and making itself look like a complete wazzock!
 
About the Argawal event, I do not agree about the gas. Wehn I look at the Rosina data and the MIP data I see a clear increase in density already starting the day before the event (3 July 2016, 07:50 UT) and actually peaks at noon. I would have to read the Argawal paper again to see what they claim about gas. And actually we are working on a dusty plasma physics paper.

I had a look on PSA and PDS, but those data aren't available on there yet. Pity.
 
Sol88: Cites a paper that is nothing to do with his delusions about comets

DUSTY PLASMA EFFECTS IN COMETS: EXPECTATIONS FOR ROSETTA
D.A. Mendis1 and M. Horányi2
13 November 2017 Sol88: Cites a paper that is nothing to do with his delusions about comets.
No idiocy of comets are rocks.
No stupidity of these rocks being blasted from the Earth in recent times.
No ignorant fantasy of electrical discharges.

ETA: Added idiocy of not knowing what "expected" means :p!
This is a January 2013 review paper published before the Rosetta rendezvous. The dusty plasma being considered is the mainstream coma and tail produced from comet nuclei made of ices and dust via sublimation. The paper starts with the importance of observations of dusty plasma in coma and tails dating from 1985 and then goes trough the theory of electrostatic charging of dust particles, etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie about the T. I. Gombosi paper being about surface grains


Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3
13 November 2107 Sol88: A lie about the T. I. Gombosi paper being about dust and ice grains being ejected from the surface.

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko by T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3 is about grains in the coma.
 
Sol88: Lies about "mainstream have no plausible explanation"

Ummm...you do know the mainstream have no plausible explanation unless it includes the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma!
13 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "mainstream have no plausible explanation".

13 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma" for dust ejection from comet nuclei.
The dust grains are observed to charged after they leave the surface and are a dusty plasma in the coma and tail not on the surface.

13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about his citations - an outburst is not general outgassing.
Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03 by J. Agarwal V. Della Corte P. D. Feldman B. Geiger S. Merouane
is not about non-outburst ejection of dust :eye-poppi!

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko by Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2
is not about outbursts :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
Usual lies as expected from someone who has persisted with 8 years of the ignorant delusions that comets are rocks, etc.
315 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 9 October 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 11 October 2017 Sol88: An insult that tusenfem has "a bit a paper somewhere" saying that he is a smart cookie.
  2. 11 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant idiocy about gas drag + gravity + dust + dusty plasma + a plasma stream.
  3. 11 October 2017 Sol88: Abysmal ignorance about his comet delusions which have nothing to do with this post.
  4. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions.
  5. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Repeats 8 years of the insanely ignorant delusion that comets are rock.
  6. 16 October 2017 Sol88: A lie about any scientists believing in his comet delusions.
  7. 16 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy from the last months that the descriptive name of a model is the model itself.
  8. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions with a random quote and highlight
  9. 7 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that Agarwal, J. et al. need to mention "charge, plasma, electrostatic" in a dust jet paper.
  10. 7 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of "Dusty Plasma" needed in the Agarwal, J. et al paper.
  11. 7 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about the Agarwal, J. et al. paper and "absolutely got them by the short n curlys"
  12. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Cites a paper that is nothing to do with his delusions about comets.
  13. 13 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "mainstream have no plausible explanation".
  14. 13 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about "the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma" for dust ejection from comet nuclei.
  15. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies abut his citations - an outburst is not general outgassing.
  16. 13 November 2017 Sol88: Still lying about the comet science he cites.
 
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko by Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2
Interestingly, Yu. V. Skorov is also an author on a paper that cites his simulated results in the context of observational evidence of ejected granular material including "Decimetre sized chunks".
Seasonal mass transfer on the nucleus of comet 67P/Chuyumov-Gerasimenko
We collect observational evidence that supports the scheme of mass transfer on the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. The obliquity of the rotation axis of 67P causes strong seasonal variations. During perihelion the southern hemisphere is four times more active than the north. Northern territories are widely covered by granular material that indicates back fall originating from the active south. Decimetre sized chunks contain water ice and their trajectories are influenced by an anti-solar force instigated by sublimation. OSIRIS observations suggest that up to 20 % of the particles directly return to the nucleus surface taking several hours of travel time. The back fall covered northern areas are active if illuminated but produce mainly water vapour. The decimetre chunks from the nucleus surface are too small to contain more volatile compounds such as CO 2 or CO. This causes a north-south dichotomy of the composition measurements in the coma. Active particles are trapped in the gravitational minimum of Hapi during northern winter. They are "shock frozen" and only reactivated when the comet approaches the sun after its aphelion passage. The insolation of the big cavity is enhanced by self-heating, i. e. reflection and IR radiation from the walls. This, together with the pristinity of the active back fall, explains the early observed activity of the Hapi region. Sobek may be a role model for the consolidated bottom of Hapi. Mass transfer in the case of 67P strongly influences the evolution of the nucleus and the interpretation of coma measurements.

Also an author on:
09/2017: Cliffs versus plains: Can ROSINA/COPS and OSIRIS data of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko in autumn 2014 constrain inhomogeneous outgassing?
Results: We show that gas activity from only cliff areas produces a fit to the ROSINA/COPS data that is as statistically good as a purely insolation-driven model.

June 2017: Pinnacles on the 67P comet nucleus: Evidence for large scale erosion and hierarchical agglomeration of the nucleus
 
Last edited:
Nope. All these things either have been seen, or are very likely to occur, given what we know about the comet. What will not occur are electric discharges, that would be obvious to a number of instruments. What will also not occur, is instantaneous outbursts due to electrostatic levitation of dust particles of many microns in size.
So, let's hear the Sol88 version of events, backed up by scientific evidence. Not forgetting the following, which you have conveniently skipped over:

Electrostatic??

Mmmmm....I’m under the impression the plasma is extremely dynamic!

And’ since the dust is coupled to this highly dynamic plasma simple 1+1=2 maths ain’t gunna cut it, hence the mainstreams absolute disdain for maths involving dynamic complex plasma’s :rolleyes:
 
Sol88: Lies about what he replies to - what a surprise

Electrostatic??
13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about what he replies to - what a surprise!
jonesdave116 wrote about Sol88's delusion of electrical discharges on comets and the delusion of "Flogging a dead horse". As pointed out many years ago, those electrical discharges would be easily detected from Earth and especially easy for Rosetta.

jonesdave116 wrote about the Nordheim electrostatic paper which is about electrostatic levitation of dust and we have the insanity of thinking this is plasma from Sol88.
A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity
Nordheim, T. A. et al.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S003206331500238X

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet
The two papers are about different phenomena with different size of dust particles.
 
Last edited:
Electrostatic??

Mmmmm....I’m under the impression the plasma is extremely dynamic!

And’ since the dust is coupled to this highly dynamic plasma simple 1+1=2 maths ain’t gunna cut it, hence the mainstreams absolute disdain for maths involving dynamic complex plasma’s :rolleyes:



"disdain"?!


https://www.google.com/search?q=mat...nrrXAhWD7YMKHf7TBi8QvwUIIygA&biw=1280&bih=893

Where exactly (absolute or otherwise) is such "disdain" for the mathematics?

By all means please provide us with the electric comet mathematical models "involving dynamic complex plasma’s" related to comets, naturally lacking mathematical "disdain"?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Denial of basic arithmetic for 8 years now

And’ since the dust is coupled to this highly dynamic plasma simple 1+1=2 maths ain’t gunna cut it, hence the mainstreams absolute disdain for maths involving dynamic complex plasma’s :rolleyes:
13 November 2017 Sol88: An inane remark since he and his cult have been in denial of basic arithmetic for over 8 years now!
The average measured density of comets is 0.6 g/cc. The average measured density of asteroids (rocks) is 3.0 g/cc. Basic arithmetic: 0.6 is not 3.0 :jaw-dropp!
The measured density of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cc!
 
Electrostatic??

Mmmmm....I’m under the impression the plasma is extremely dynamic!

And’ since the dust is coupled to this highly dynamic plasma simple 1+1=2 maths ain’t gunna cut it, hence the mainstreams absolute disdain for maths involving dynamic complex plasma’s :rolleyes:


Hey, woo boy, you forgot this:

Still, a weekends' worth of research should be able to let you figure out if instant levitation is possible.
A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.

LOL!
Please, do tell us, how does this woo work? Lol.
 
Last edited:
Electrostatic??

Mmmmm....I’m under the impression the plasma is extremely dynamic!

And’ since the dust is coupled to this highly dynamic plasma simple 1+1=2 maths ain’t gunna cut it, hence the mainstreams absolute disdain for maths involving dynamic complex plasma’s :rolleyes:

Sorry, what were your qualifications again? Lol.
 
Gaseous counterparts in 67P dusty outbursts. VIRTIS
did not detect any increase in the H2O and CO2 column
densities during the 13{14 Sept. outbursts.
This means that
the trigerring mechanism is not related to a large internal
gas pressure, a mechanism proposed by Prialnik et al.
(1993) for explosive outbursts. As already discussed, these
outbursts were very likely caused by cli collapse as for the
one studied by Pajola et al. (2017). The lifetime of 0.1{
1 m icy grains is 300{800 s for dirty grains, and >
104 s for pure ice grains (Beer, Podolak, & Prialnik 2006;
Gicquel et al. 2012). These long lifetimes may be one of the
reasons why H2O vapour was not detected in the VIRTIS-H
outburst spectra.
Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from
the Sun: dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H
observations


Mmmmmm.....ALICE now VIRTIS-H

Not looking good for the subsurface highly porous "ice" pressurising non existent (CONCERT) chambers thru vents (not observed)!

Leaves mechanical cliff collapse and crack propagation as your ONLY plausible means...

Meantime...over at the ELECTRIC COMET...
 
Last edited:
Hey, woo boy, you forgot this:



LOL!
Please, do tell us, how does this woo work? Lol.
Still, a weekends' worth of research should be able to let you figure out if instant levitation is possible.
A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.

Are you talking

1. Compact particles
2. Fluffly Particles
3. Aggregates

Therefore, in your SIMPLISTIC view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.
Yup Tells :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Sorry, what were your qualifications again? Lol.

?

you just follow real science????

Like this

@Tusenfem,

1. Is the plasma environment around comet 67P dynamic or static?
2. does this plasma environment include complex plasma's?
3. Does the plasma environment include dynmaic flux tubes and electric fields on varying scales?

See that's how you do it JD116, as the experts. Just you see what Tusenfem says. :rolleyes:
 
Sol88: Lies again about yet another 67P paper

13 November 2017 Sol88: Lies again about yet another 67P paper.
[URL="Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from the Sun: dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations"]Comet 67P outbursts and quiescent coma at 1.3 AU from the Sun dust properties from Rosetta/VIRTIS-H observations[/URL]
He lies about this being a paper on the porosity of the comet nucleus. This is the properties of dust ejected from the comet during 1 day with 2 outbursts. The outburst dust contained "very small grains (≤ 100 nm)" that could be silicatic grains or icy grains. No water ice was detected.

13 November 2017 Sol88: An "ice" lie when comets are made of ices and dust.

13 November 2017 Sol88: A "non existent (CONCERT) chambers thru vents (not observed)" delusion.
Double stupidity in that quote.
  1. One paper explained narrow jets on Tempel 1 as from chambers with a vent and Sol88 still ignorantly thinks this is the mechanism for all jets,
  2. CONSERT never looked at the surface of 67P where we have images of jets emitted from pits and trace jets back to cliffs and plains
13 November 2017 Sol88: A "Leaves mechanical cliff collapse and crack propagation as your ONLY plausible means" lie.

For others:
The nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
The CONCERT instrument provided unique data on the inside of the nucleus, at least in the part of the head that was the only place that could be explored. They indicate a material made of a mixture of ice and dust. The nature of dust is similar to that of the carbonaceous chondrites (a class of very primitive meteorites). The material is very porous because 80 percent of the volume is empty, which explains the low density of the comet: 533 kg/m3, while the density of the ice is about 900 kg/m3 and that of the dust some five times greater. The refractive index of the comet material decreases with depth, which implies either that the dust is less abundant, or that the medium is increasingly porous at greater depths.

All this confirms and greatly improves the model published in 1950 by Fred Whipple.
Properties of the 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko interior revealed by CONSERT radar
The Philae lander provides a unique opportunity to investigate the internal structure of a comet nucleus, providing information about its formation and evolution in the early solar system. We present Comet Nucleus Sounding Experiment by Radiowave Transmission (CONSERT) measurements of the interior of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. From the propagation time and form of the signals, the upper part of the ``head'' of 67P is fairly homogeneous on a spatial scale of tens of meters. CONSERT also reduced the size of the uncertainty of Philae's final landing site down to approximately 21 by 34 square meters. The average permittivity is about 1.27, suggesting that this region has a volumetric dust/ice ratio of 0.4 to 2.6 and a porosity of 75 to 85%. The dust component may be comparable to that of carbonaceous chondrites.
The interior of 67P/C-G comet as seen by CONSERT bistatic radar on ROSETTA, key results and implications.
The structure of the nucleus is one of the major unknowns in cometary science. The scientific objectives of the Comet Nucleus Sounding Experiment by Radiowave Transmission (CONSERT) aboard ESA's spacecraft Rosetta are to perform an interior characterization of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko nucleus. This is done by means of a bistatic sounding between the lander Philae laying on the comet's surface and the orbiter Rosetta. Current interpretation of the CONSERT signals is consistent with a highly porous carbon rich primitive body. Internal inhomogeneities are not detected at the wavelength scale and are either smaller, or present a low dielectric contrast. Given the high bulk porosity of 75% inside the sounded part of the nucleus, a likely interior model would be obtained by a mixture, at this 3-m size scale, of voids (vacuum) and blobs with material made of ices and dust with porosity larger than 60%. The absence of any pulse spreading due to scattering allows us to exclude heterogeneity with higher contrast (0.25) and larger size (3m) (but smaller than few wavelengths scale, since larger scales would be responsible for multipath propagation). CONSERT is the first successful radar probe to study the sub-surface of a small body.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom