Despite WHO’s conclusion that a lab leak was “extremely unlikely”, chief researcher now says that patient zero could have been a lab employee
The first outbreak of corona virus in China in the autumn of 2019 could have started with an employee in one of the labs in the city who has been infected by a bat during field work or in one of the labs in Wuhan. An employee who was infected in the field while taking samples belongs to one of the likely hypotheses.
This is the evaluation by Peter Embryo who was leader of the team of experts that the World Health Organisation (WHO) sent to China in the spring of 2021 in order to investigate the origin of the disease.
In fact, he now says to TV 2 that it belongs to one of the probable theories that a person with connection to a lab was one of the first infected.
From extremely unlikely to likely
The experts from WHO issued a report after the journey to China where the theory that the corona infection started with a leak from a lab in Wuhan was described as “extremely unlikely”.
On the other hand it was “likely” according to the experts that the pandemic started by a bat infecting a human. And now Peter Embarek says that the infection could have started by collection of – or work with – bats in connection with the research that was taking place in Wuhan. That is, that an infected lab worker is a likely scenario despite the wording of the report.
An employee who was infected in the field while taking samples belongs to the likely hypotheses. This is where the virus jumps directly from bat to human. In that case it would be a lab worker instead of a random villager, or another person who has regular contact to bats. So that is actually in the likely category, says Peter Embarek to TV 2.
He emphasises that the experts of WHO did not find any direct evidence that the outbreak of corona virus was connected to the research in bats that was conducted in the labs in Wuhan. But the experts did note several issues that should be investigated more closely, according to Peter Embarek.
A difficult cooperation with China
The bats are central to the investigation of the origin of the disease, and the closest known relative to the virus that causes the pandemic lives in bats of the family of horseshoe bats.
There are none of the family of horseshoe bats living in the wild in the Wuhan area, and the only people who are known with certainty who have been close to horseshoe bats are employees at the labs in the city.
Nevertheless it was difficult for the expert team from WHO to even discuss the lab theory with the Chinese.
48 hours before we were finished with the entire mission, we still did not have an agreement that we could discuss the lab part in the report, so we debated until the last moment whether it should be included or not, says Peter Embarek.
The experts did succeed in visiting two labs in Wuhan. Both labs work with – or have worked with – bats, and here the Chinese authorities collected a group of employees who could answer questions.
We could not look at lab books or documents directly from the lab. We got a presentation, and then we talked about it, and asked the questions we wanted to ask, but we saw no documentation whatsoever, says Peter Embarek.
The other lab in Wuhan
Although the top-secured lab at the Wuhan Institute for Virology has garnered most attention, there is, according to the leader of the WHO team of experts, also reason to take a look at the other, which is run by the Chinese Health authorities (CDC).
Their last publication on the work with bats was from 2013, but that does not mean that they haven’t worked with bats since. As far as we understand, they work mostly with parasites, and not so much with virus, so they have worked with parasites from bats, says Peter Embarek.
During the visit he made a remarkable observation.
I ask the management: “How old is the lab?”, and they say “Why this is from December 2019. At that time, December 2, 2019, we moved to new laboratories”, says Peter Embarek.
The new facilities of the CDC is only 500 meter from the market that was the epicentre of the pandemic in the first weeks in December 2019.
It is interesting that the lab moved on December 2, 2019. This is the period when it all began, and it is known that at a lab, it disturbs everything, says Peter Embarek. He adds that it is necessary to gather more knowledge about what happened, if you want to know more about what role the CDC lab might have had.
You also have to move the viral collection, the sample collection, and other collections from one place to the other. This entire procedure is a disturbing element in the daily working of a laboratory, so that is why it at one point also will be interesting to look at this period, and this lab, says Peter Embarek.
The four possibilities
He explains that the visit of WHO was of a scientific nature, and not an actual investigation. For that reason most was dependent on the goodwill of the Chinese hosts.
When the final report had to be written there was also an intensive negotiation about what would be in it.
At start they did not want to have anything about the lab included, because it was impossible, and for that reason one should not waste any more time on that. We insisted that it should be included because it was part of the entire question about the origin of the virus, says Peter Embarek.
He reduced the possible scenarios for how the pandemic began to four possibilities.
Either a bat had infected a human directly.
Or a human was infected by a product that was infected with bat virus.
Or a bat had infected another animal that then in turn had infected a human.
Or it has begun at one of Wuhan’s laboratories.
“Extremely unlikely” was a compromise
The possibility that a lab was involved was very difficult to accept for Peter Embarek’s Chinese counterpart.
I said: “Listen, we need to include this, or we have no report. It will not be approved, or accepted as a reasonable, credible report”, and he could understand that, but he also told me that for them the discussion about a lab is difficult to accept, says Peter Embarek.
In the end he succeeded if the lab theory was categorised as “extremely unlikely”.
Peter Embarek himself tended to think that the theory was “unlikely”, but he accepted a compromise.
There were other things that I wanted settled before we were finished. So it was a conscious choice, he says.
He has himself thought about why the lab theory encountered so much resistance.
It is probably because it means that there is a human error behind such an event, and they are not happy about admitting that. There is this traditional Asian feeling of not wanting to lose face, and the system focuses very much on infallibility, and that everything needs to be perfect. And maybe someone wants to hide something. Who knows? says Peter Embarek.
The important details
When the report of the expert team was published, all four possibilities were included, but although the lab theory was described as “extremely unlikely”, Peter Embarek now says that one should not look so narrowly on the definitions of the expert team.
You need to be careful not to divide, and separate those four hypotheses from each other because they are very closely linked, and you can have scenarios where you go from one hypothesis to another, he says, and gives an example.
The lab leak hypothesis actually covers several scenarios. One of them is that a lab worker is infected in the field while he or she is collecting samples in a bat cave. Even though it belongs under lab leak, it also belongs under the first hypothesis that we have, i.e. direct transfer from bat to human, and we have regarded that hypothesis as a likely hypothesis, says Peter Embarek.
A different kind of investigation
If the theory that the corona virus perhaps escaped from a lab, or came to Wuhan with a lab worker is to be investigated more closely, it will demand an entirely different level of cooperation on the Chinese part.
Then it will no longer be about scientific studies, but more like the kind of audits, where you will execute an almost police-like investigation, and will check everything that there in a lab like that, he says.
You would have to check security books, laboratory books, research plans, and biological collections. You will go through it all, and interview every employee separately. So it is an entirely different work than a scientific investigation, says Peter Embarek.
One of the researchers who is backing up about another investigation of the conditions in China is the Danish evolutionary biologist, and professor at
UC Berkeley in California, Rasmus Nielsen.
I have previously argued relatively vocally that it was not a lab leak. It was just not very likely, Rasmus Nielsen says to TV 2.
However, he is no longer quite as dismissive. For instance, in the beginning of June he wrote on Twitter that he would like to have it cleared up if there really was a lab leak.
He wants clarity because the Chinese authorities have suddenly started strict control of research in the origin of the disease in China.
When I think after all that we should investigate the hypothesis about a lab leak, there are several reasons. One of them is the way the Chinese government has reacted. They have tried to repress all research in this area. We can’t know if it is only because they want to control the narrative, or if it is because they have something to hide, he says. For the time being, the Chinese authorities have only taken a stand about the lab leak theory in one place, and that is in the report from the WHO. And even if the Chinese are extremely rejecting, chief negotiator Peter Embarek thinks it was a victory to even let them consider it.
These are only four pages on the report, but they are very special pages. Four golden pages we have here, I would say. This is the only place where this is discussed from the Chinese side, he says. After the visit of the WHO on Wuhan, China has only related themselves to this question in dismissive terms.
On the 16th of July 2021, the WHO issued a plan for further studies in China. Here the organisation proposes among other things to carry out an audit which will be like a thorough police investigation of relevant labs in Wuhan.
But Zeng Yixin, the deputy health minister of China, completely rejected a new visit.
When I first saw the second phase of the investigation of the origin of the corona virus, I was honestly very surprised, said Zeng Yixin.
In this plan the hypothesis that China has broken the lab procedures and caused a lab leak is to be prioritised. In that regard, I think the plan disregards common sense, and is contrary to science, the representative of the government said .