Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

wogoga: The fantasy that "normal meteors" have heat shields!

....In any case, you were right insofar as Apollo's reentry would have been quite similar to a normal meteor (suffering substantial vaporization and disintegration) due to its flimsy heat shield ....
That highlighted portion is delusional because you must know that Apollo and other reentry vehicles with heat shields are nothing like normal meteors.
They have heat shields that are designed to allow them to survive reentry and get to the surface. Normal meteors do not have heat shields :jaw-dropp!
Implying that Giordano is not intelligent enough to understand your posts is not good. We are all intelligent enough to know that you are denying the real world where reentry vehicles with heat shields actually reenter the atmosphere and get to the surface, e.g. the Apollo missions to the Moon.

11 January 2017 wogoga: The fantasy that "normal meteors" have heat shields!
 
Last edited:
How could ~ 100 kg ...
How could you remain unable to click in a link after many weeks or understand posts, wogoga? Persisting in ignorance and incredibility does not change the fact that the Apollo mission (and others) were successful.

20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"
27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored
31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
17 November 2016 wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "doctored", "selected" , "small" samples.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site.
17 November 2016 wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon.
17 November 2016 wogoga: An ignorant conclusion that water content has something to do with isotopic composition.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A colorful, highlighted lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition (oxygen isotopes) between lunar and terrestrial rocks.
6 December 2016 wogoga: A "propaganda bluff' conclusion based on ignorance, denial and delusion.
11 January 2017 wogoga: The fantasy that "normal meteors" have heat shields!
 
Last edited:
Why is this ongoing?

Is this thread ongoing because people have nothing of interest to discuss?

I know it's in the nutcases conspiracy section, but really it would be of more interest if the discussion was about the real truth behind the fact that the earth is flat, and the only center of the universe.
 
Is this thread ongoing because people have nothing of interest to discuss?
One reason to continue the thread is that the actual physics of spacecraft and reentry are interesting.

However the real world does not have much chance of convincing conspiracy theorists that the Apollo missions happened. wogoga will continue spouting his ignorance and incredulity regardless of the real-world science that is pointed out to him. Or even the simple fact that Apollo spacecraft actually reentered the Earth's atmosphere without burning up as the astronauts in them survived :jaw-dropp!
 
One reason to continue the thread is that the actual physics of spacecraft and reentry are interesting.

However the real world does not have much chance of convincing conspiracy theorists that the Apollo missions happened. wogoga will continue spouting his ignorance and incredulity regardless of the real-world science that is pointed out to him. Or even the simple fact that Apollo spacecraft actually reentered the Earth's atmosphere without burning up as the astronauts in them survived :jaw-dropp!


Question what was the fastest Soviet/Russian re-entry speed known?
 
Question what was the fastest Soviet/Russian re-entry speed known?

Zond 5 to Zond 8 all returned from the Moon, so about the same speed as an Apollo re-entry. They used modified Soyuz capsules with thicker heat shields.
 
Terrestrial magnetic remanence in Apollo moon rock samples

If we take into account that every kilogram of cargo produces during reentry as much heat as 4 kg of rocket fuel (#55) then the claim that the Apollo missions brought back 381 kg of moon rock becomes quite suspicious, especially if we take into account that the strength of the Apollo heat shield is primarily based on propaganda and public relation (#471, #487, #492).

Apart from the astonishing fact the Apollo rocks have the same isotopic fingerprint as terrestrial rocks (#172) and contain traces of terrestrial life (#184), there is a further problem: Remanent magnetism of moon rocks. Quote from On the natural remanent magnetism of certain mare basalts, 1979:

"After ten years of research directed at understanding lunar magnetism, it remains an enigma. Neither the NRM [Natural Remanent Magnetism] of the returned samples, nor the remanence which gives rise to crustal anomalies is properly understood. Consequently, the implications of lunar magnetism are unclear, and the important developments in lunar science have taken place with little or no contribution from paleomagnetism. Nevertheless, the observation of relatively stable and strong NRM in certain returned samples, and of surface magnetic anomalies, defined intriguing phenomena to be explained."

"These detailed studies of the NRM of a small group of mare basalts epitomize the problem of the interpretation of the lunar sample magnetization. To each simple interpretation, there are clear, if not insurmountable objections, and we are left with inelegant and in somewhat ad hoc explanations of the magnetization. "
​

According to the "NASA-baked moon-rocks" hypothesis (#184), the magnetic remanence of the Apollo rocks is simply terrestrial remanence. Wikipedia on the Earth's magnetic field: Its magnitude at the Earth's surface ranges from 25 to 65 microteslas [5n25 – 5n65 Tesla]. For comparison, Surface vector mapping of magnetic anomalies over the Moon using Kaguya and Lunar Prospector observations, 2015, is "showing the highest intensity of 718 nT [~ 3n7 Tesla] in the Crisium antipodal region."

Magnetic remanence of Apollo rocks comes close to terrestrial remanence. MAGNETISM OF THE MOON AND METEORITES: IS IT ASSOCIATED WITH CRATERING AND COLLISIONAL PROCESSES?, 1991:

"However, some authors have indicated that the deduced maximum field strength of about 50 - 100 μT [5n5 – 6n1 Tesla] is too large to be plausibly generated by a dynamo in a small lunar core, and considerable attention has been directed towards another possible source, impact-generated, transient magnetic fields associated with a TRM or shock magnetization."​

Is there real evidence suggesting that meteoritic or other impacts generate magnetic fields, which are even durable enough to entail "natural remanent magnetism" in surrounding solidifying rocks? I don't think so. And how probable is such a scenario? Isn't the obvious hypothesis that NASA moon rock bakers did not properly take into consideration terrestrial magnetism much simpler?
Cheers, Wolfgang

pandualism.com/d/apollo.html
The capability of changing one's mind as an adult has been neglected by human evolution
 
... especially if we take into account that the strength of the Apollo heat shield is primarily based on propaganda and public relation ...

On the other hand, if we remember to take into account that virtually everything you say about Apollo is wrong, any insinuated problem simply doesn't arise.
 
If we take into account that every kilogram of cargo produces during reentry as much heat as 4 kg of rocket fuel (#55) then the claim that the Apollo missions brought back 381 kg of moon rock becomes quite suspicious,
No, it really doesn't. The heat shield was designed to accommodate that. What you are suggesting is the bizarre notion that the heat shield was designed for the CM alone and did not allow for the hundreds of pounds of samples that they planned to bring back. That is an utterly stupid assertion.

especially if we take into account that the strength of the Apollo heat shield is primarily based on propaganda and public relation (#471, #487, #492).
Nope. You simply made that up out of whole cloth. The design and operation of heat shields was well understood long before Apollo.

Apart from the astonishing fact the Apollo rocks have the same isotopic fingerprint as terrestrial rocks (#172) and contain traces of terrestrial life (#184), there is a further problem: Remanent magnetism of moon rocks. Quote from On the natural remanent magnetism of certain mare basalts, 1979:

"After ten years of research directed at understanding lunar magnetism, it remains an enigma. Neither the NRM [Natural Remanent Magnetism] of the returned samples, nor the remanence which gives rise to crustal anomalies is properly understood. Consequently, the implications of lunar magnetism are unclear, and the important developments in lunar science have taken place with little or no contribution from paleomagnetism. Nevertheless, the observation of relatively stable and strong NRM in certain returned samples, and of surface magnetic anomalies, defined intriguing phenomena to be explained."

"These detailed studies of the NRM of a small group of mare basalts epitomize the problem of the interpretation of the lunar sample magnetization. To each simple interpretation, there are clear, if not insurmountable objections, and we are left with inelegant and in somewhat ad hoc explanations of the magnetization. "
​

According to the "NASA-baked moon-rocks" hypothesis (#184), the magnetic remanence of the Apollo rocks is simply terrestrial remanence. Wikipedia on the Earth's magnetic field: Its magnitude at the Earth's surface ranges from 25 to 65 microteslas [5n25 – 5n65 Tesla]. For comparison, Surface vector mapping of magnetic anomalies over the Moon using Kaguya and Lunar Prospector observations, 2015, is "showing the highest intensity of 718 nT [~ 3n7 Tesla] in the Crisium antipodal region."

Magnetic remanence of Apollo rocks comes close to terrestrial remanence. MAGNETISM OF THE MOON AND METEORITES: IS IT ASSOCIATED WITH CRATERING AND COLLISIONAL PROCESSES?, 1991:

"However, some authors have indicated that the deduced maximum field strength of about 50 - 100 μT [5n5 – 6n1 Tesla] is too large to be plausibly generated by a dynamo in a small lunar core, and considerable attention has been directed towards another possible source, impact-generated, transient magnetic fields associated with a TRM or shock magnetization."​

Is there real evidence suggesting that meteoritic or other impacts generate magnetic fields, which are even durable enough to entail "natural remanent magnetism" in surrounding solidifying rocks? I don't think so. And how probable is such a scenario? Isn't the obvious hypothesis that NASA moon rock bakers did not properly take into consideration terrestrial magnetism much simpler?
Cheers, Wolfgang

pandualism.com/d/apollo.html
The capability of changing one's mind as an adult has been neglected by human evolution

There is nothing mysterious about it. Why you think there is is anyone's guess.

ETA: You do realise that lots of research has happened in the 38 years since 1979, right?
 
Last edited:
...especially if we take into account that the strength of the Apollo heat shield is primarily based on propaganda and public relation (#471, #487, #492).

No, it's based on science that you simply refuse to accept or attempt to understand.

According to the "NASA-baked moon-rocks" hypothesis...

Speculation. Your sources do not describe a credible method for creating apparent Moon rocks out of Earth rocks, and you have proposed no such method yourself.

Is there real evidence suggesting that meteoritic or other impacts generate magnetic fields, which are even durable enough to entail "natural remanent magnetism" in surrounding solidifying rocks? I don't think so. And how probable is such a scenario?

You are not a geologist, and simply throwing shade on their findings from your position of ignorance and denialism is not evidence.
 
If we take into account that ...
We actually take in account that this post cites a web page full of conspiracy theory delusions, lies and paranoia mindlessly parroted by wogoga.

The lies and delusions just in this post
  1. The delusion that Apollo astronauts did not collect Moon rocks when they state that they brought them back from the Moon, we have videos of them collecting the rocks, people removed them from the Apollo capsules after watching them land, they are different from terrestrial rocks, etc. :jaw-dropp!
  2. The lie of "strength of the Apollo heat shield is primarily based on propaganda and public relation"
    The Apollo heat shields were designed using science and tested in experiments. wogoga knows this from this thread. That is why that statement is obviously a lie from wogoga.
  3. The lie of "Apollo rocks have the same isotopic fingerprint as terrestrial rocks"
    Debunking The Apollo Moon Hoax - The Apollo Moon Rocks - Part 1 commenting on the ignorant "baking Moon rocks" delusion from Bill Kaysing:
    1. Elements very common in Earth rocks are absent or in very small amounts: quartz, calcite, magnetite, micas, amphiboles, and sulfide minerals.
    2. The Oxygen isotope ratio is the same for Moon rocks and Earth rocks. But this is the only isotope ratio that is the same.
    3. He deliberately fails to point out that amongst others, Neon 21 and Argon 38 isotopes are found in Moon rocks but not in Earth rocks.
    4. He observes similar elements to Earth rocks, but fails to point out the stunning major point, they occur in hugely different proportions.
    5. Whilst making his point on isotopes, he doesn't notice his source demonstrates that meteorites found on Earth have radically different isotopes to Earth and Moon rocks. Including the one he refers to, the oxygen isotope..
  4. The delusion that not knowing the cause of remanent magnetism of Moon rocks magically makes make terrestrial rocks or not from the Moon.
  5. The lie that remanent magnetism of Moon rocks is terrestrial magnetism.
    Geologists know about terrestrial magnetism in terrestrial rocks. You cite a paper where the remanent magnetism of Moon rocks is a mystery.
  6. The really stupid delusion that science stopped in 1979 with that 1979 paper citation :eek:!
    But this is probably just another lie from wogoga by cherry picking an old paper that fist his fantasies.
If I knew that wogoga was capable of learning abut the real world then I would look up later papers that may have an explanation for the remanent magnetism of Moon rocks. But that evidence is that he seems determined to live in the ignorant and deluded world of Moon hoaxers so that would be a waste of anyone's time.
 
Last edited:
We actually take in account that this post cites a web page full of conspiracy theory delusions, lies and paranoia mindlessly parroted by wogoga.

It's his site. Apparently he's just trying to drum up traffic to it. The numbered references are to where he's constructing his own version of this debate using posts selectively cribbed from this forum. Among the least credible fringe theorists, this is a technique often used to create the illusion that they're winning the debate. They take posts away from a public debate and reproduce it in a private venue, then add their own commentary which, obviously, goes unanswered. Because the dialectical form is legitimately used elsewhere, they don't think what they're doing is unfair.

The Apollo heat shields were designed using science...

They were actually adapted from science already used for similar purposes. This is what is so especially hilarious. It's not as if this was some unsolved problem for which Apollo developed a hitherto unheard-of solution that hasn't been used since. It's not as if this is something on which you just have to take NASA's word. While Apollo contained a certain amount of unprecedented technology, the heat shield was adapted from existing thermal protection systems. The science was not only well established by then, it was based on rather prominent academic research.

You cite a paper where the remanent magnetism of Moon rocks is a mystery.

Remnant magnetism in lunar surface samples is no mystery. While the Moon lacks a global magnetic field, it features several local magnetic fields. Remnant magnetism in samples we think came from deep under the lunar surface are a "mystery" only because the Moon cannot support a thermal dynamo. That's typically the reason large planets have magnetic fields. But it's not the only form of dynamism, and in the years following 1979 we discovered the tidal dynamo.

Because the Moon's orbit and its rotational axis are not coplanar, back when the Moon did have a molten center different portions of it rotated along different axes. The Earth's gravity preferentially affected the rotation according to layers, and -- more importantly -- made the boundary non-spherical. That means you get a mixing of layers and a dynamo. The Moon had a magnetic field until it cooled to the point where fluid effects gave way to mere plasticity, which doesn't allow a meaningful dynamo. Researchers who tried to attribute the remnant magnetism to a thermal dynamo rightly were unable to get it to fit.

If I knew that wogoga was capable of learning abut the real world then I would look up later papers that may have an explanation for the remanent magnetism of Moon rocks.

I agree; he seems to prefer his fantasy world to that of real science.
 
Remnant magnetism in lunar surface samples is no mystery. While the Moon lacks a global magnetic field, it features several local magnetic fields. Remnant magnetism in samples we think came from deep under the lunar surface are a "mystery" only because the Moon cannot support a thermal dynamo. That's typically the reason large planets have magnetic fields. But it's not the only form of dynamism, and in the years following 1979 we discovered the tidal dynamo.

Because the Moon's orbit and its rotational axis are not coplanar, back when the Moon did have a molten center different portions of it rotated along different axes. The Earth's gravity preferentially affected the rotation according to layers, and -- more importantly -- made the boundary non-spherical. That means you get a mixing of layers and a dynamo. The Moon had a magnetic field until it cooled to the point where fluid effects gave way to mere plasticity, which doesn't allow a meaningful dynamo. Researchers who tried to attribute the remnant magnetism to a thermal dynamo rightly were unable to get it to fit.


You probable mean Ancient lunar dynamo may explain magnetized moon rocks, 2011. Quotes:

The presence of magnetized rocks on the surface of the moon, which has no global magnetic field, has been a mystery since the days of the Apollo program. Now a team of scientists has proposed a novel mechanism that could have generated a magnetic field on the moon early in its history.

[The authors of November 10 issue of Nature] describe how an ancient lunar dynamo could have arisen from stirring of the moon's liquid core driven by the motion of the solid mantle above it.

Dwyer and her coauthors calculated the effects of differential motion between the moon's core and mantle. Early in its history, the moon orbited the Earth at a much closer distance than it does today, and it continues to gradually recede from the Earth. At close distances, tidal interactions between the Earth and the moon caused the moon's mantle to rotate slightly differently than the core. This differential motion of the mantle relative to the core stirred the liquid core, creating fluid motions that, in theory, could give rise to a magnetic dynamo.

"The moon wobbles a bit as it spins--that's called precession--but the core is liquid, and it doesn't do exactly the same precession. So the mantle is moving back and forth across the core, and that stirs up the core," explained Nimmo, a professor of Earth and planetary sciences at UCSC.

The researchers found that a lunar dynamo could have operated in this way for at least a billion years. Eventually, however, it would have stopped working as the moon got farther away from the Earth. "The further out the moon moves, the slower the stirring, and at a certain point the lunar dynamo shuts off," Dwyer said.
​
This is a highly speculative theory which probably cannot be backed up by independent research. It reminds me of the former belief in differential rotation of the sun below the convective zone:

Until the advent of helioseismology, the study of wave oscillations in the Sun, very little was known about the internal rotation of the Sun. The differential profile of the surface was thought to extend into the solar interior as rotating cylinders of constant angular momentum. Through helioseismology this is now known not to be the case and the rotation profile of the Sun has been found. On the surface the Sun rotates slowly at the poles and quickly at the equator. This profile extends on roughly radial lines through the solar convection zone to the interior. At the tachocline the rotation abruptly changes to solid-body rotation in the solar radiation zone.
​
Wouldn't friction between different lunar layers rotating at different speeds immediately weaken these differences in rotation speed? In any case, the hypothesis that these Apollo rocks have been created under terrestrial magnetism is more straightforward than such ad-hoc hypotheses concerning the moon.
Cheers, Wolfgang
pandualism.com/d/apollo.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom