Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
This has been said before, but in the Great Thread of Repetition it should be said again.

Michael, your mental picture of reconnection is incorrect. Your arguments read like this one: "elephants do not exist, because oviparous mammals are supposed to have RADIAL symmetry, and how does blood circulate to a DETACHABLE NOSE, and why do you ignore Haldane's proof that an animal so large would crush itself?

I have no idea what mental picture you're referring to, such that you think "0+0=0" is an argument against it.

I have no idea what mental picture you're referring to, such that you think the "magnetic wine" thing is an argument against it.

I have no idea what mental picture you're referring to, such that "particle reconnection" means anything at all.

(Remember how, for years, your mental picture of reconnection included "field lines breaking", and your argument against it was "it's impossible for a field line to break"? I remember that.)
 
Did you so completely misunderstand my post or is this willful dissonance designed to continue some game?
Let's try this: Abandon the word discharge!

BS. I won't abandon the word only because you're all in denial of scientific fact! Dungey used used the term. Why shouldn't I use it in relationship to solar flares too? Let me guess?

Do you agree that there is no dielectric material that breaks down in a plasma?

The plasma is IONIZED FURTHER by a discharge, to higher energy states than it might otherwise be ionized.

If so, can we say that you are referring to a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma?

What exactly is wrong with Peratt's definition of a discharge in cosmic plasmas?

I doubt if anyone here would disagree that such rapid depletions of energy can occur. Someone can correct me if I am wrong.

Then accept Perratt's definition and be done with it already.

The substance of the physics here does not depend on semantics;

Evidently it must, or GM and RC would wholeheartedly agree with Dungey that electrical discharges occur in conductors, plasmas, flares and specifically in "reconnection" events. For some reason they're still stuck on a denial-go-round, physics and Dungey be damned.

it is a function of reality and the mathematics that describes it.

Mann and Onel did that for you. Alfven did too. Dungey did it too. You folks don't care about math. You're just as subjective about which math you might accept as any creationist on the planet.

However we need to agree to how words are defined to have meaningful discussion about what the mathematics is describing.

That's why I gave you one already from a published book on plasma physics as applied to space by an author that works at Los Alamos. Evidently he's a "crackpot" too?
 
Last edited:
The fact that you avoided answering:

More importantly, do you agree that lightning on earth does involve the breakdown of a dielectric (air) and consequently is not the same phenomenon as a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma? That is the crux of the debate here; not the meaning of the word "discharge."

is noted.
 
The fact that you avoided answering:



is noted.

The fact GM and RC avoid accepting Dungey's claim that electrical discharges occur in reconnection events, and none of you lift a finger to do anything about it is noted. The fact none of you have shown an empirical connection between highly ionized iron and MR theory is noted. The fact haters don't embrace Lee's work that show an empirical connection between discharges and solar flare events as seen in SDO and many other satellite images is noted. The fact haters don't acknowledge that mathematical and scientific legitimacy of Mann and Onel's work on circuit theory as applied to solar events is noted. The denial processes of EU haters is noted and well documented in this thread.
 
Why are you so reluctant to answer the following question:

More importantly, do you agree that lightning on earth does involve the breakdown of a dielectric (air) and consequently is not the same phenomenon as a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma? That is the crux of the debate here; not the meaning of the word "discharge."

Your answer has the potential of clarifying subsequent discussions. Do you not answer because you enjoy the endless debate more than you care about understanding the physics?
 
Why are you so reluctant to answer the following question:

More importantly, do you agree that lightning on earth does involve the breakdown of a dielectric (air) and consequently is not the same phenomenon as a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma? That is the crux of the debate here; not the meaning of the word "discharge."

Your answer has the potential of clarifying subsequent discussions. Do you not answer because you enjoy the endless debate more than you care about understanding the physics?

I have answered such questions REPEATEDLY. While the first part of your question is true, that lightning on Earth involves the dielectric breakdown of air, turning it to plasma, the highlighted part is *ABSOLUTELY AND POSITIVELY* false. Once the breakdown occurs, and the conductor forms, the rapid release of stored electrical energy by means of a current in plasma is *EXACTLY* the same. The DISCHARGE in Peratt's definition of discharges in plasma is a RELEASE of STORED electric or magnetic energy. It's is NOT the dielectric breakdown process.
 
Last edited:
This is quite baffling. I find it hard to believe that anyone here does not know that air ionizes (briefly becomes a plasma) while carrying a current of electrons during lightening on earth. Of course, this plasma exists for a very brief time since the air reverts back to its neutral state as soon as the electrical potential is dissipated. We also know that the electrical potential that caused the dielectric material (the insulating air) to ionize then caused a current of electrons to flow from the ground to positively charged clouds.
In contrast to the above, a plasma might exist in astronomical environments (including but not limited to the sun) without carrying any current for some period of time, until and unless some electrical potential is encountered or created (I would imagine this could be due to magnetic phenomena or charge separation -- I really don't know.). Now, this current might be sudden and rapid or it might have a slow build-up depending on the local circumstances.
I really don't give a rat's ass if one calls both these two situations discharges or peanuts and I don't know why anyone else cares if Mozina loves to call it discharge as long as he understands the situations are different.
Even though in both cases currents flow within a plasma, they are quite different phenomena (differing causes, duration, etc.) but with some similarities.
Let the experts correct my flawed understanding of this discussion.
 
Once the breakdown occurs, and the conductor forms, the rapid release of stored electrical energy by means of a current in plasma is *EXACTLY* the same. The DISCHARGE in Peratt's definition of discharges in plasma is a RELEASE of STORED electric or magnetic energy. It's is NOT the dielectric breakdown process.

So you acknowledge that "once the breakdown occurs" any "stored electrical energy" is "rapidly released". Good.

You acknowledge that in a plasma, a you don't even need a breakdown; it's already conductive.

Question 1: How did "electrical energy" get "stored" under these circumstances, Michael?

Question 2: Why is Peratt's one-time statement of his definition so important? You're quite literally inviting people to misunderstand you---not good scientific practice. It's like: I have a paper in front of me in which Wolfgang Pauli refers to the light uncharged leptons as "neutrons". I know that everyone nowadays calls them "neutrinos", reserving "neutron" for the lightest uncharged baryon. There are exactly zero troll-physicists who write papers referring to "neutrons" (i.e. Pauli's leptons) and get angry/defensive when people assume the wrong thing. Zero.

You never answer my questions, so I can do it myself.

Answer 1: There is no physics-based answer. The answer is "We presume that it happens because I need it to have happened in order for the rest of my Birkeland-analogy to work. The actual E&M behind it is HEY LOOK AT THIS RUNNING DIFFERENCE IMAGE"

Answer 2: It's just trolling. With the Peratt quote in hand, you can never lose an argument about discharges---you can parry any "that physics is actually wrong" statement with a "let's argue about definitions" gambit. (You have no intention of letting an argument figure out whether the physics is right by either definition.)
 
Mozina Accepts Magnetic Reconnection?

I do not reject the math's associated with "reconnection" theory either Tim. I reject the STUPID NAME you folks assigned to the PLASMA PROCESS.


OK. Reference my post Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described

In the paper Magnetic Reconnection by Yamada, Kulsrud & Ji, we find this statement: "Understanding magnetic reconnection, a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines, provides a key to these questions. In magnetized astrophysical and laboratory plasmas, magnetic reconnection rearranges the magnetic field-line configurations restructuring macroscopic quantities of plasmas such as flow and thermal energy."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the magnetic field lines reconfigure to change the topology of the magnetic field?

In the book Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications by Priest & Forbes we find this statement: "As we shall discuss in more detail later on, magnetic reconnection is essentially a topological restructuring of a magnetic field caused by a change in the connectivity of its field lines. This change allows the release of stored magnetic energy, which in many situations is the dominant source of free energy in a plasma."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the change in the topology of the magnetic field is caused by changes in the connectivity of the magnetic field lines?

In the paper Review of controlled laboratory experiments on physics of magnetic reconnection by Masaaki Yamada we find this statement: "Magnetic reconnection is the topological breaking and rearrangement of magnetic field lines in a plasma and is the most fundamental process in the interplay between plasma and magnetic field (Parker, 1979; Priest, 1984; Vasyliunas, 1975)."

Do you agree with this? Specifically, do you agree that the magnetic field lines break and then rearrange into a different topology?
 
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 V

No particle kinetic energy in equation 16, no discrete magnet energy in 17. It's pretty TRIVIAL alright.
{ ... }
I even showed you the EXACT EQUATIONS where Priest turned his electric water into magnetic wine Tim. What more can I do for you?


Well, actually, no you didn't. I had already read the paper, which you got from me, and I had already seen both equations. The difference between us is that I understand the paper and the equations, while you understand neither the paper nor the equations. Hence, your assessment of their meaning and value is totally screwed up.

From Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 IV ...
This all leads to the obvious final conclusion, as I stated above: "Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina."


Also see Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 III (Mozina Defeated) ...
And from there we are off on the steamroller to equations 16 & 17, which Mozina has elevated to the status of holy mantra in the struggle against the dark side of plasma physics, the evil Darth-Priest (may the lines-of-force be with you) and his "magnetic reconnection magic". Never mind that Mozina cannot read mathematics (he actually does not know or understand the implications of either equation), cannot read English (the authors explicitly say that the currents and monopoles are simultaneous, not one changed into the other), and cannot read physics (there is no magnetic reconnection in this paper).


Also see Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 II and Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 ...
Reference Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{ ... }
Everything you have said here is dead wrong. You do not understand the paper at all, and certainly do not understand the role of equations 16 & 17 in that paper. According to you the authors are "converting current to magnetic charge". Well, no, that's not what they are doing, as I have shown above. Furthermore, neither equation 16 nor equation 17 has a thing to do with magnetic reconnection.


Of course the "bottom line", as shown above, is that those two precious equations you do not understand have nothing at all to do with magnetic reconnection. Not in any way. You screwed up so badly that you are now still arguing hotly that two equations, neither of which has anything to do with the topic at all, somehow defeat the notion of magnetic reconnection. You are not helping your reputation for superior scholarship any here, you know.
 
There's nothing wrong with my math skills.
We need a larger laughing dog.

Like I said, there's nothing wrong with my math skills.
Seriously.

From post #6444, just two days ago:

I have made several posts since last May that thoroughly demonstrate the serious fallacy of believing that magnetic reconnection does not happen in a vacuum. Here is the primary set of posts.



From post #5803, almost three months ago:

It's a sad day for Mozina. His arguments lay strewn and broken on the battlefield of ideas. His ideas are defeated. Destroyed. Crushed. Annihilated. Pulverized. Decimated. Blasted into smithereens. I, on the other hand, am willing to carry the burden, such as it is, of being the hero, the revealer of true science, exalted above the mean shadows of triviality. I am now prepared to magnanimously accept the surrender of Michael Mozina; he has no soldiers left to take the field, no ideas left to fight with, no hope against the juggernaut of relentless & merciless truth. :faint: It's the only thing left to do.
 
What "mathematical ignorance"? I went to all the trouble of speaking your language, citing the exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine, thereby sinking Clinger's ship and all you ignored it! There's nothing wrong with my math skills. There's something wrong with the fact that none of you want to deal with the relevant math that sinks Clinger's ship. You all pretty much run like hell. Care to change course? How about dealing with those two equations I cited and explain to me how Clinger's model is going to work without current running up the Z axis?

“turns electric current into magnetic wine”? Whatever language you think you’re trying to speak here it sure as heck ain’t mathematics. If you have some “relevant math that sinks Clinger's ship.” By all means please mathematically show how it indicates, and exactly where, W.D.Clinger's calculations or assertions were wrong. Oh and for your own edification continuing to refer to equations you simply don’t understand evidently just isn’t any trouble for you and clearly demonstrates you can’t speak the language of mathematics. Here’s a hint: as you claim “There's nothing wrong with my math skills” then it should be no problem for you to take that “exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine” work it into W.D.Clinger calculations finding some error by him and “thereby sinking Clinger's ship” mathematically. Professing “There's nothing wrong with my math skills” while referencing an equation you can’t use to mathematically refute any of W.D.Clinger calculations demonstrates some very substantial problems with your purported “math skills”.


Um.... While OTHER points will in fact experience such things where the field strength is NOT zero, the laws of physics are not different ANYWHERE in the experiment. Clinger shot himself in the foot in the final analysis. He started off trying to demonstrate that the zero point was unique in some way, but all he proved is that it is NOT unique in *ANY WAY*. It's not a special point.

“Um.... “ no one has claimed “the laws of physics are” “different ANYWHERE in the experiment” other than you. A null point is certainly different than “OTHER points” that “will in fact experience such things where the field strength is NOT zero”. Would you and your strawman like to guess how it is different instead of just pretending anyone but you is claiming “the laws of physics are” different somewhere in the experiment? “. Not only have you shoot yourself in the foot you did it while that foot was firmly imbedded in your mouth.


Like I said, there's nothing wrong with my math skills. I pointed to the exact two equations where Priest turned his holy electric water into magnetic wine. It REQUIRES charged particles. It REQUIRES the flow of CHARGED PARTICLES up the Z axis. It REQUIRES plasma! Plasma is NOT OPTIONAL. No current up the Z axis, no DISCHARGE to the X,Y plane, no MAGNETIC WINE!
“Like I said,” if as you claim “there's nothing wrong with my math skills” then you should be able to show your assertions mathematically, By all means please have at it.

Pointing to an equation you don’t understand and claiming its ‘requirements’ are anything other than just the requirements of that equation in that application clearly demonstrates what’s wrong with your “math skills” as do your references to “MAGNETIC WINE!”, whatever you think that means.
 
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 VI

What "mathematical ignorance"? I went to all the trouble of speaking your language, citing the exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine, thereby sinking Clinger's ship and all you ignored it!


I had not noticed this particular comment until The Man posted it.

This is, of course, very false. We did not ignore it. We proved conclusively that you were and are dead wrong, dead wrong, in your assumptions about the equations; see, e.g., my previous post Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 V and posts referenced therein. We thereby also show that your math skills are somewhat deficient by comparisons with your claims.
 
I had not noticed this particular comment until The Man posted it.

This is, of course, very false. We did not ignore it. We proved conclusively that you were and are dead wrong, dead wrong, in your assumptions about the equations; see, e.g., my previous post Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 V and posts referenced therein. We thereby also show that your math skills are somewhat deficient by comparisons with your claims.

Um, the only "ridiculous" attempt you made to SWEEP THE ISSUE UNDER THE CARPET that is even worth responding to, you did in this post Tim:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7808363#post7808363

No it is not. Look at the sentence immediately prior to equation 16. It read as follows, with my added emphasis:
"Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:"

What the HECK is a magnetic charge that you claim is "present". Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes? The only reason it's there at all is because a BIRKELAND CURRENT runs and through that Z axis.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birkeland_current

300px-Magnetic_rope.png


That's a BENNETT PINCH Tim!

The authors then go on to show the current in equation 16 and the magnetic charges in equation 17. This is not a conversion of current into charges, it is a listing of both currents and magnetic charges that are together simultaneously.

In equation 17, they're literally converting CHARGED PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY into "magnetic charges", AKA MONOPOLES!

FYI, here's a link the the relevant page where the two equations are listed:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html
 
Last edited:
We need a larger laughing dog.

You're a man without a larger laughing dog, and not a single atom or particle of physics to your name. Worse yet, your trying to use MHD theory to support your *UTTERLY UNPUBLISHED* nonsense. Wow! Irony overload. I need a bigger exploding ID overload meter. :)
 
Um, the only "ridiculous" attempt you made to SWEEP THE ISSUE UNDER THE CARPET that is even worth responding to, you did in this post Tim:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7808363#post7808363

What the HECK is a magnetic charge that you claim is "present". Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes? The only reason it's there at all is because a BIRKELAND CURRENT runs and through that Z axis.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birkeland_current

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/79/Magnetic_rope.png/300px-Magnetic_rope.png[/qimg]

That's a BENNETT PINCH Tim!

In equation 17, they're literally converting CHARGED PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY into "magnetic charges", AKA MONOPOLES!

FYI, here's a link the the relevant page where the two equations are listed:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html


Math can't be done properly by just looking at it and thinking it means whatever might support a conjecture any more than a picture can be assumed to mean something just because it's a convenient interpretation. On both issues, the misunderstanding of math and the misunderstanding of images, the electric/iron Sun conjecture has failed.
 
Math can't be done properly by just looking at it and thinking it means whatever might support a conjecture any more than a picture can be assumed to mean something just because it's a convenient interpretation. On both issues, the misunderstanding of math and the misunderstanding of images, the electric/iron Sun conjecture has failed.

One thing you have CLEARLY demonstrated in this thread is that you personally do not understand the first thing about high energy solar satellite images. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?". You quite literally know ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about the images because you have no idea what the light source is. Furthermore you claimed that the color around the horizon of the sun in composite iron line images is due to some sort of "Alignment problem" rather than a simple blending of the colors of various wavelengths (as it actually works). You have NO RIGHT to question ANYONE about their "interpretation" of solar satellite images. None. You know NOTHING about them.

Haters run from the relevant maths as this conversation has demonstrated and will demonstrate. Not one of you is ACTUALLY going to explain how those "magnetic charges" are present in the ABSENCE of current. Not one of you can even embrace the fact that "electrical discharges" occur in plasmas and conductors. It's like watching the Titanic sink in slow motion. You can't handle the physics because you don't have plasma particle to your name, and you can't handle the math either. You'll all just try to sweep it under the rug like you've been doing for months now. The haters will just keep attacking the individual and remaining in staunch denial of scientific fact.
 
Last edited:
Haters run from the relevant maths as this conversation has and will demonstrate.
Agreed.

The haters will just keep attacking the individual and remaining in staunch denial of scientific fact.
Agreed.

Here's some of the relevant math:

[size=+2]∇ × B = μ0J[/size]​

To compute the graphs shown in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, I used that equation more than one billion times.

Michael Mozina has run from that equation and its consequences. He has tried to disguise his flight by flaming about irrelevant equations, which he understands as little as Ampère's law. To disguise his staunch denials of scientific fact, he attacks individuals who dare to explain his errors.

He is now linking to pretty pictures on government web sites. That's a welcome change from his usual denialism.
 
Hey, another dark filament photo. That's the sort of data that a physicist would try to compare to a theoretical model.

Michael, since you're a competent plasma physicist and an expert on these filaments, why don't you present (a) the mainstream physics-based model for this sort of filament, and alongside it present (b) your physics-based model for this filament---composition, density, temperature, field map, current density, and the plasma equations that time-evolve OH NEVER MIND.
 
This is quite baffling. I find it hard to believe that anyone here does not know that air ionizes (briefly becomes a plasma) while carrying a current of electrons during lightening on earth. Of course, this plasma exists for a very brief time since the air reverts back to its neutral state as soon as the electrical potential is dissipated. We also know that the electrical potential that caused the dielectric material (the insulating air) to ionize then caused a current of electrons to flow from the ground to positively charged clouds.
In contrast to the above, a plasma might exist in astronomical environments (including but not limited to the sun) without carrying any current for some period of time, until and unless some electrical potential is encountered or created (I would imagine this could be due to magnetic phenomena or charge separation -- I really don't know.). Now, this current might be sudden and rapid or it might have a slow build-up depending on the local circumstances.
I really don't give a rat's ass if one calls both these two situations discharges or peanuts and I don't know why anyone else cares if Mozina loves to call it discharge as long as he understands the situations are different.
Even though in both cases currents flow within a plasma, they are quite different phenomena (differing causes, duration, etc.) but with some similarities.
Let the experts correct my flawed understanding of this discussion.

FYI, it's not "me" that first used the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flare events PS, it was DUNGEY and PERATT that used that term long before I was introduced to EU/PC theory. That is where I got the term in the first place, specifically Peratt's book, Physics Of The Plasma Universe. I quoted him for you.

I also showed you where Dungey used that same term "electrical discharge" in precisely the same way as Paratt defines the term. Dungey is describing the sudden release of stored EM energy in one giant "electrical discharge" during a reconnection event. There's nothing inconsistent about their use of the term. In both instances they describe the RELEASE OF STORED EM ENERGY, not the process of ionizing air! Get RC and GM to wake up and smell the coffee already. They're hopelessly stuck in pure denial at this point. I guess they figure if they never acknowledge Dungey's use of the term and Peratt's definition of the term, they can live in denial forever. The moment they let go of the denial-go-round, they lose the debate.

Instead of embracing the physics, the haters attack the individual, deny the evidence exists, lather rinse, repeat.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom