Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
[* Uncivil rant snipped. *]


Okay, try again. This has gone unanswered for almost seven years now. So provide a quantitative objective analysis of the running difference image as it relates to the pair of original data images posted above. Explain exactly the process that must be applied to each pixel in the data images to generate the running difference result. Duplicate the process as nearly as possible. Explain exactly where the data comes from, how we can objectively verify that, and how we can independently reproduce the results. Explain how the process and the results can be objectively analyzed by solar physicists so they can also arrive at the conclusion that they're seeing 4800 kilometers through the photosphere.
 
I doubt most folks who read my website or who read my papers doubt the fact that most folks (including most folks at NASA) think that the sun is a PLASMA, without a solid surface. That's pretty much a given.
That is prettry much a given because most people can do basic arithemetic :eye-poppi!
Temperature of the Sun is ~5700 K.
Melting point of iron = 1811 K.

Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked
Anyone who reads your web site (and I have) will quickly conclude that it is a typical crank web site.
The author is obsessed with "I see bunnies in the clouds" logic since there are images and no attempt to understand what is in them, e.g. images of light from Fe ions at temperatures of > 160,000 K is asserted to be from from solid mountain ranges on the Sun :eye-poppi!
The author is ignorant of basic physical facts or basic arithmetic skills (see above and the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the TRACE RD 171A movie! debunked by simple physics).
The author is ignorant of basic solar physics, e.g. that the photosphere is defines as where light escapes from the Sun, it is a ~400 kilometers thick and thus no light can be seen from an "iron surface" 4800 km below the surface (the author's fantasy).
The author ignores the statements of experts (the delusional nature of Michael Mozina's fantasy about the Kosovichev movie! debunked by Dr. Kosovichev).
The author thinks that a public relations image should be analyzed for evidence of the "iron surface" and obsesses on a "green line" in it. He ignores that people who produced the image state that the "green line" is a processing artifact - The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.


I used that information to predict the location of the so called "transition region" which is located UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary in the SDO first light images.
That is an total delustion.

The transition region is defined and measured to be above the photosphere. Scientists looked at the edge of the Sun and found:
It is also a lie - you counted pixels in one SDO public relations image with a processing artifact in it.
 
Last edited:
Helioseismology debunks Micheal Mozina's iron crust fantasy

We can add this to Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked

Helioseismic response to X2.2 solar flare of February 15, 2011 by Alexander G. Kosovichev
...
The impulsively excited acoustic waves formed a compact wavepacket traveling through the solar interior and appearing on the surface as expanding wave ripples.
...
Micheal Mozina, explain why your iron crust did not affect that wave?
After all it pokes out into (and maybe above!) the ~5700 K photosphere so that is visible in TRACE images of > 160,000 K Fe ions.

The simple answer is that the iron crust does not exist.

This iron crust is totally ignored in all helioseismic models and they work!

ETA: Investigation of a Sunspot Complex by Helioseismology (a symposium presentation) has graphs of subsurface sound-speed variations down to 40,000 kilometers - no iron crust!
 
Last edited:
Ya, ya, deflect the conversation away from the 'reconnection' debate since you gas can drag racers can't even describe a rate of reconnection/acceleration without a vehicle/plasma particle to accelerate. :)
 
We can add this to Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked

Helioseismic response to X2.2 solar flare of February 15, 2011 by Alexander G. Kosovichev

Micheal Mozina, explain why your iron crust did not affect that wave?

Why would it? The wave he's measuring is occurring in the surface of PHOTOSPHERE, 4832KM *ABOVE* the solid surface. That's like asking why surface of the Earth at the bottom of the Marianas trench doesn't affect the waves on the surface of the ocean 1 mile above. Why would it?
 
Last edited:
Zeuzzz, it's clear to me from reading pages of this stuff that Mozina doesn't understand basic electro-magnetic physics. While it is good to give people the benefit of the doubt to begin with, that can only go so far.

If you want an example of what happens when someone who does understand physics comes up with a question, check out this rather short thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=230280

I asked a question, didn't get answers I agreed with, or at least I didn't think clarified the issue. More answers came, and I found one that made sense to me, and I think everyone in the thread agreed with it. The thread ended, because learning happened.

Perpetual Student joined this thread not really understanding (forgive me if I've read this wrong) the issues, but with a desire to learn. After reading a bunch of stuff from the various people in the thread and asking Mozina some direct questions, he came to the conclusion that the real physics people here did in fact know what they were talking about.

He now understands magnetic reconnection more than he did before, and doesn't think Mozina has a credible position.
 
Michael Mozina's ignorance of basic arithmetic, i.e. 5700 is > 1811

Ya, ya, deflect the conversation away from the 'reconnection' debate since you gas can drag racers can't even describe a rate of reconnection/acceleration without a vehicle/plasma particle to accelerate. :)
There is no debate.
There is your delusion about an imaginary "rate of reconnection" (Michael Mozina, can you spell "reconnection rate" :D).

There is your delusion that MR can only happen in a plasma when the literature states that you are wrong:
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Peer reviewed material that states plasma is optional in MR

There is your ignorance of physics which means that you cannot understand W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection which has no plasma in it and so just constantly whine about it not having plasma in it :eye-poppi!
But this is not surprising since you are also ignorant of basic arithmetic since you think an iron crust exists on the Sun. The photosphere temperature is ~5700 K, melting point of iron = 1811 K. 5700 is > 1811 thus your iron crust melts.

There is Michael Mozina's delusion that a reconnection rate exists without plasma!
 
Zeuzzz, it's clear to me from reading pages of this stuff that Mozina doesn't understand basic electro-magnetic physics.

That's a riot coming from you guys.

In the REAL WORLD of actual "physics", electrical discharges *ONLY* occur in "conductors". They can ionize iron in the lab and they occur naturally and generate gamma rays in our own atmosphere. In the REAL world of physics, B lines do not begin, do not end, do NOT have a source or a sink. They form as full, continuous loops, actually entire *FIELDS*. In the REAL world of PLASMA physics, "reconnection" is a process in PLASMA, that results in PLASMA ACCELERATION. You guys live in self imposed ignorance, mostly because the vast majority of you have never read, nor do you own a book on plasma physics. Worse yet, your mathematical champ didn't even know what the term "Reconnection rate" even referred to until a WEEK AGO, and he can't come up with a way to mathematically express his claim in the first place!
 
Last edited:
Ya, they worked to find a "stratification subsurface" 4800KM under the photosphere.
Ya, they worked to find a "stratification subsurface" of plasma 4800KM under the surface of the Sun.
Ya, they worked to find a "stratification subsurface" of plasma 20000KM under the surface of the Sun along with currents of plasma going straight hrough the 4800KM subsurface

ETA: This is Investigation of Mass Flows beneath a Sunspot by Time-Distance Helioseismology


I'll bet there are some interesting sound speed variations around 4832KM +- 1200KM. :)
You lose the bet :eye-poppi !

Not that this matters because your ignorance of basic arithmetic (Michael Mozina's ignorance of basic arithmetic, i.e. 5700 is > 1811) debunks your fantasy.
 
Last edited:
There is no debate.

You're right. You don't have any peer reviewed material to support your case and not one of you can even dream up a way to express a rate of reconnection without mass acceleration.

There is your delusion that MR can only happen in a plasma when the literature states that you are wrong:

No, you're in DENIAL of the fact that Somov used moving charged particles called "current", just like my fictional Bowlmov used 15 pound, heavily charge bowling balls in his description of "reconnection'. They both require PHYSICAL PARTICLES to be present in the "vacuum".

There is your ignorance of physics which means that you cannot understand W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection which has no plasma in it and so just constantly whine about it not having plasma in it :eye-poppi!

Clinger didn't derive any such thing since he never expressed and reconnection rate in his nonsense, and he never will. That's why it will NEVER be published *ANYWHERE*.

Like my Drag Race analogy, you guys are dumbing down the *PHYSICAL PROCESS* to the point of absurdity. That's nothing more that an oversimplification fallacy run a muck.
 
Why would it? The wave he's measuring is occurring in the surface of PHOTOSPHERE, 4832KM *ABOVE* the solid surface.
How ignorant - you clam that your maintain ranges are visible in TRACE images which are of the transition region. Thus they must poke above the photosphere and be visible not only via helioseismology but in every image taken of the Sun!
 
How ignorant - you clam that your maintain ranges are visible in TRACE images which are of the transition region. Thus they must poke above the photosphere and be visible not only via helioseismology but in every image taken of the Sun!

Nope, the transition region is located 4832KM under the photosphere in that SDO image and nothing pokes above the photosphere except coronal loops.
 
Last edited:
MM: MR happens in vacuum away from anything else, thus "MR in vacuum"

The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you seem to be ignoring the fact that his "vacuum" is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of two FILAMENTS that MERGE!
The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you remain ignorant of the fact that his vacuum is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of two FILAMENTS that MERGE and that the magnetic reconneciton does not happen at the FILAMENTS :jaw-dropp!

The magnetic reconneciton happens in the vacuum. It is MR in vacuum.

The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you cannot read the simple English in that paper:
Originally Posted by Reality Check
The origins of electrical resistivity in magnetic reconnection: Studies by 2D and 3D macro particle simulations
"A gedanken experiment that illustrates the meaning of electrical resistivity for magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum, and (b) in a plasma (dots represent plasma ions and electrons). The currents J1 and J2 flow in the flux bundles, while J3 in the plasma does not exist initially and is induced by the electric field Et during the reconnection process."
The reason for "magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum" is that the MR happens in vacuum away from the filaments!
The reason for "magnetic reconnection (b) in a plasma" is that the MR happens in plasma away from the filaments!
 
Outstanding questions for Michael Mozina

We still have outstanding questions (no surprise since Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked lists 75 questions about his idea and assertions about Birkeland's work to which MM has made no credible reply):
  1. MM: State your position on MR without plasma and list citations to support it
    Asked 20 March 2012
  2. MM: Why did Somov split "Reconnection in vacuum" from "Reconnection in plasma"?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
  3. MM What does "In a vacuum, magnetic reconnection is a trivial process..." mean?
    Asked on 18th March 2012
4 days and counting...
Any answers yet MM?
 
The interesting thing to me about that paper is that you remain ignorant of the fact that his vacuum is *INCLUSIVE*, not EXCLUSIVE of two FILAMENTS that MERGE and that the magnetic reconneciton does not happen at the FILAMENTS :jaw-dropp!

BS. According to Somov the particle movement is the CAUSE of the change in the field. According to the second author, two PLASMA FILAMENTS ARE REQUIRED! They aren't optional and Clinger claimed plasma was optional.

The magnetic reconneciton happens in the vacuum. It is MR in vacuum.

The FLUX is CAUSED because the currents move toward one another. The "reconnection" happens when that "flux" accelerates charged particles.

The reason for "magnetic reconnection (a) in vacuum" is that the MR happens in vacuum away from the filaments!

It doesn't matter! It's REQUIRES FILAMENTS in order for "reconnection' to occur! Nothing like blatantly denying the blatantly obvious.

The reason for "magnetic reconnection (b) in a plasma" is that the MR happens in plasma away from the filaments!

No, FLUX happens away from the filaments, but the FLUX change has a direct affect ON THE FILAMENTS (ON OBJECTS).

Gas can drag racers. That's what I'll just call you from now on. :(
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina delusion that light is detectable from 4800 km "under the photosphere"

Nope, the transition region is located 4832KM under the photosphere in that SDO image and nothing pokes above the photosphere except coronal loops.
Nope, The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.

Your ignorance of TRACE intruments continues
Your iron mountain ranges poke into the transition regions so that they can be heated to > 160,000 K and be visible in the TRACE 171A pass band.

Your abysmal ignorant of solar physics continues and has become a delusion.
Photosphere
The photosphere of an astronomical object is the region from which externally received light originates.
The delusion seems to include that photosphere = surface of the Sun. It is not a surface, It is a volume about 400 km thick.

You can not detect any light from under the photosphere. You claim is that this iron surface is ""4832KM under the photosphere" (5200 km below the surface of the Sun :rolleyes:)
From Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked:
What is the amount of 171A light emitted by the photosphere and can it be detected?
How can we detect the less than 1 photon per year from your iron crust?
 
4 days and counting...
Any answers yet MM?

I've been waiting forever for you folks to demonstrate *ANY* of your FALSE claims about discharges NOT occurring in conductors, and 4 days I've waited for a mathematical expression of something that CANNOT HAPPEN without mass to accelerate.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.

You've dumbed down a process that according to Wiki:

A) occurs in a plasma
B) involves flux changes of the magnetic field
C) which transfers magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy

You're now dumbing it down to.

A) flux change

Like I said, gas can drag racers, one and all.
 
Last edited:
BS. Nobody at NASA told GM that the green color of the transition region was the result of a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images. GM never even cited a source, and I know damn well that NASA isn't that stupid.
BS. Somebody at NASA told GM that the green line in the image was the result of a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images. GM even even cited NASA as a source, and I know damn well that NASA is smart enough know that a PR image is processed to look pretty and should never be treated as scientific evidence.

The stupidity is that you are virtually calling GM a fraud by accusing him of making up the email without evidence. All you need to do is check with NASA like he says he did.

But your reply to
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.
I have contacted the SDO science team at NASA and have received word back on the image that occupied pretty much all of Michael's attention for the past week. Since he first started crowing about his discovery, over a thousand posts have gone by. During that time Michael has been insulting, belligerent, ignorant of relevant questions, badgering, uncivil, and treated pretty much everyone in this discussion like crap.

Here's the word straight from NASA. When they map the color values, the behavior of the pixels outside the limb is treated differently than the portion of the image over the disk. A gradient filter is applied to the image so the off-disk area will be enhanced to bring out details. That filter causes a discontinuity at the apparent limb because of a slight inequality of the radius of the filter and the solar image.


The green line is there because of the processing. In this image, which I sent along with my communication in order to get a definitive reply, you see arrow "A" pointing to the edge of the filter applied in the image processing software. The arrow "B" is pointing to what amounts to the actual limb of the Sun. The apparent roughness of that "B" edge is due to the emissions picked up by the three filters used to make the composite, all of which are coming from above the photosphere.

A week Years of Michael's uncivil tantrums, bullying, whining, taunting, and complaining. Over a thousand posts exchanged. And the SDO science program at NASA says Michael is wrong.
(my edit and emphasis)
has been since 4th May 2010 (almost 2 years :eye-poppi thus my edit!) and still remains that GM is lying :(.

Come on, MM - one email and you can prove that GM is a fraud.

GM since MM seems incapable of finding any contacts at SDO perhaps you can help him by posting the actual reply if you still have it after nearly 2 years?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom