Religion's value questioned

Dann said:
Basically we agree, I think, but I have a couple of objections:

I don’t think that Marx, ”compassionately” or otherwise, said ”that the people shouldn't be deprived of religion until their living conditions had improved enough that they didn't need such a thing”.

Perhaps I was over-stating what Marx said a bit. But I wasn't suggesting he had anything good to say about religion in itself.

For years, I'd often heard the phrase, "Marx said religion was the opium of the masses", and it sounded as if he was just making a demeaning comment, casting a slur on religion in the same way that some people say belittling contemptuous things like, "Religious people are just weak people who need an emotional crutch to cope with life". But then I read the quote in context, and realised Marx wasn't being demeaning, but rather had a more sympathetic take on things. I took him to be saying it was natural for people to be religious, given the oppressive conditions they lived under, and if they were to give up religion, their living conditions would need to be improved so they could do without it, and one shouldn't happen without the other:

... Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.

Dann said:
(He also didn’t recommend opium addiction as a way of tackling the suffering caused by capitalism.)

I didn't say he did. He probably recognised that although opium could be good for things like pain relief, hence one reason he may have used it as a metaphor for religion, it could have detrimental effects that religion doesn't have in itself.

Dann said:
And you have to admit that former socialist countries managed to render religion almost non-existent.

Not always in benign ways though.

Dann said:
I hope that you know that a guy like Hitler accused the Jews of being ”corrupt selfish money-grubbers who habitually lied and had harmed the country rather than improving it

Did he?! I didn't realise that. I'm going to have to get out my old copy of Mein Kampf again to remind myself what it says. :-7 Funny how the description fits today's politicians so well. Perhaps it also fitted the Nazis, and Hitler had just looked in the mirror and was thinking about himself, but because of his obsession with Jews, what he said came out as if he was referring to Jews. A kind of reverse Freudian slip. :-7

Dann said:
What is good for the country is usually achieved at the expense of its impecunious citizens.

When I referred to the good of the country, I meant the good of its citizens in general, not what would advance its status best.
 
I took him to be saying it was natural for people to be religious, given the oppressive conditions they lived under, and if they were to give up religion, their living conditions would need to be improved so they could do without it, and one shouldn't happen without the other:
Maybe this is hair splitting, but I want to make sure that we are not on different wavelengths:
I don’t think that Marx would ever describe it as natural for people to be religious, but if you mean to say that religious ideas are a wrong but very understandable reaction to having to cope with a ”heartless world” and a ”vale of tears”, then I agree.
The problem is that it is up to the same people to overthrow the ”soulless conditions” that makes them long for the consolation of religion.

He probably recognised that although opium could be good for things like pain relief, hence one reason he may have used it as a metaphor for religion, it could have detrimental effects that religion doesn't have in itself.

Still, you make it sound as if he might want to recommend religion as the lesser of two evils. I think that it was probably a reference to the opium addiction of the upper classes:

Public concern over opiates, which was influenced by the Temperance Movement, was directed at opiate use by the lower classes. It was believed that working women in industrial towns doped their babies when they went to work. The upper classes could have their addictions, but not the working class, who needed to be protected from themselves
(…)
In 1868, Parliament passed the Pharmacy Act, which restricted the sale of drugs to pharmacists’ shops. It was harder for the masses to get drugs, but use by the upper classes did not change. Although consumption fell, it returned to normal levels with a few years of the act.

http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cach...es"&cd=3&hl=da&ct=clnk&gl=dk&client=firefox-a

(However, Marx wrote his critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right much earlier than 1868.)

Not always in benign ways though.

No, and the malign ways are other examples of an idealist approach to criticizing religion. Not only brutal but also very inefficient.

Did he?! I didn't realise that. I'm going to have to get out my old copy of Mein Kampf again to remind myself what it says. :-7 Funny how the description fits today's politicians so well. Perhaps it also fitted the Nazis, and Hitler had just looked in the mirror and was thinking about himself, but because of his obsession with Jews, what he said came out as if he was referring to Jews. A kind of reverse Freudian slip. :-7

No, he was referring to Jews. Not the Jews of reality, though, but the Jews of his nationalist delusions. As a nationalist he was pretty consistent. He did not see any difference between the nation and its people, which is why he considered the ultimate sacrifice for the nation to be the ultimate self-fulfilment. This is also the reason why he blamed gipsies, Jews (and communists, of course) for the decline of his beloved nation: foreigners and internationalists, all ‘vaterlandslose Gesellen’. That most Jews did not see themselves in this manner (and some ‘Jews’ did not even think of themselves as anything but Germans) did nothing to stop the delusion, which he shared with an awful lot of other nationalists. (Nationalists are always unable to criticize fascism.)

When I referred to the good of the country, I meant the good of its citizens in general, not what would advance its status best.
However, there are no “citizens in general”. Investment bankers are very different from workers. What’s good for one usually isn’t for the other, which is what necessitates class struggle. Patriotism is a way of ignoring this necessity and it is even more prevalent than religion.
 
Dann said:
I don’t think that Marx would ever describe it as natural for people to be religious, but if you mean to say that religious ideas are a wrong but very understandable reaction to having to cope with a ”heartless world” and a ”vale of tears”, then I agree.

That's what I took Marx to be saying he believed.

Dann said:
The problem is that it is up to the same people to overthrow the "soulless conditions" that makes them long for the consolation of religion.

Only partly. Did Marx ever specify Exactly what it was about religion that he thought was hampering the working classes from improving their lot?

I mean, for example, did he think people would have to reach rock bottom in order to be motivated to organise to improve things for themselves, so religion prevented that because it made them too contented to do it? If so, the same criticisms he levelled at religion would have to be levelled at things like loving family relations, or any fun they did manage to have, since that would have a similar effect.

Or did he mean that religion could motivate people to provide some level of social services, which would prevent them from becoming so discontented they'd do something major in order to gain wholesale improvements in their condition?

Or was he arguing, like some have, that the people were taught the Bible verses about working hard for employers, and led to believe that they should never protest and be resigned to their fate, so they wouldn't be motivated enough to improve their conditions in large enough numbers to achieve anything significant?

Or what?

I would personally think there were far greater obstacles in their way than religion. Poverty itself would have been one of them - if they couldn't amass the financial resources necessary to challenge the authorities, they were a lot less likely to be able to do it successfully.

They did manage to organise more and more successfully though, despite religion and evrything else. Here's a brief timeline of the development of unions in the UK. And here's a brief history of UK unions that goes into quite a bit more detail.

There was a growing level of activism, and unions became very popular.

But significant changes were brought about by concerned Middle Class reformers fighting for change from outside. See a fairly brief document: How and why did working conditions for the masses improve 1834-1948?

The decline of religion doesn't seem to have been much of a factor in any of that. In fact, it was partly the religious beliefs of some reformers that led them to campaign so vigorously for improvements in working and living conditions for the people. See, for instance, What 19th-century British reformers teach us about Christian social action today. I expect they also had other reasons for getting involved in social reform apart from the ones specified in that article. Several of the most influential social reformers were committed Christians who believed their Christianity was partly what influenced them.

Dann said:
However, there are no “citizens in general”. Investment bankers are very different from workers. What’s good for one usually isn’t for the other, which is what necessitates class struggle.

True, on the face of it/in the short term. But it's possible to improve the lot of underprivileged citizens without actually harming the rich, and the rich can, after perhaps protesting at first, discover they benefit from the social improvements. For instance, the rich may not have seen the need for the introduction of the national health service in Britain in 1948, having no problems affording medical care, and perhaps feeling penalised at first at having to pay taxes for other people's healthcare. But there can't be many around now who'd object to its existence, since they will themselves have benefited. Rich employers might protest if working hours are shortened by law so they can't drive their employees so hard. But if they then discover that productivity actually rises, because there's a healthier and happier workforce who don't take so many days off for sick leave, which is possible, they may realise it was a good idea.
 
I qould like some feedback on this thought:

Some religions/cults deliberately keep the living conditions down in such a way that it benefits their religion. Like the Taliban preventing girls from going to school.
 
Or the pope denouncing condoms. (We don't need exotic examples of this, do we?)
It's fairly obvious that religion must be the enemy of enlightened education and/or pleasure for pleasure's sake.
 
Only partly. Did Marx ever specify Exactly what it was about religion that he thought was hampering the working classes from improving their lot?

Yes, but .... Marx was a revolutionary so he would have wanted the workers to 'improve their lot' by overthrowing capitalism since capitalism was the reality of their "vale of tears". He also did not approach the problem in the manner of a modern revisionist (i.e. the whole CP movement), who would ascribe to the good working class the noble role of fighting against evil capitalists for the sake of high ideals (the progress of history and stuff like that). So he would be asking why they were doing what they were doing, not why they weren't doing what they were supposed to do according to the high ideals.

I mean, for example, did he think people would have to reach rock bottom in order to be motivated to organise to improve things for themselves, so religion prevented that because it made them too contented to do it? If so, the same criticisms he levelled at religion would have to be levelled at things like loving family relations, or any fun they did manage to have, since that would have a similar effect.

No, he didn't. And you are making it much too easy for yourself now. Instead of reading what he wrote, you just pick out the line about "the opium of the people and start imagining what it could possibly mean! You have the idea that Marx said that religion is mainly alleviating the pain, thus actually a pleasure. Therefore you compare it with things like "fun" (!!!) and wonder if Marx was the kind of guy who would prefer life to be living hell for workers so they would get off their ***es and rise in rebellion already!
However, you completely forget what ought to be a matter of course for people in this forum:
Religion does not simply make people contented by being merely a pleasurable experience! Like drugs - and unlike loving (family or otherwise) relations or fun (usually) - it makes them contented by screwing with their minds. Religion is a delusion, and you don't need to have a lot of experience with believers to discover how false and therefore strenuous the alleged happiness of religious people is.
In my Baptist Sunday school we used to sing this song (in my translation):

"I am happy, I am happy, on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. I am happy, I am happy, 'cause Jesus is my best friend." (In the second stanza in reverse order: "on Sunday, Saturday, Friday ...")

I was usually quite happy but mainly because I liked to sing, which is why I put up with having to sing about this ubiquitous Jesus guy, who was never there anyway.
I mean, if you are actually soooo happy all the time because Jesus is your best friend, you wouldn't have to sing about it the whole time. It is very exhausting having to persuade yourself of a delusion, and therefore "The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness."

Or did he mean that religion could motivate people to provide some level of social services, which would prevent them from becoming so discontented they'd do something major in order to gain wholesale improvements in their condition?

No. Does anything at all seem to indicate that this was his point?
Again: So discontented that ... is not the point! I mean, they are already so discontented that they invent an alternative world, an imaginary world, a fantasy world. Discontented is not the point. Understanding the conditions that produce the discontent is.

Or was he arguing, like some have, that the people were taught the Bible verses about working hard for employers, and led to believe that they should never protest and be resigned to their fate, so they wouldn't be motivated enough to improve their conditions in large enough numbers to achieve anything significant?

There are actually Bible verses "about working hard for employers"? I find it hard to believe! But the Bible is all about serving. In Dylan's version: "You gotta serve somebody." Yes, unfortunately you do, which is what bugs revolutionaries about the present mode of production. And this is also one of the things that Che Guevara got all wrong when day-dreaming about the Soviet Union:
“Cold efficiency and impotent resentment go hand in hand in the big mine, linked despite the hatred by the common need to survive, on the one side,”(so far so good!) and to speculate on the other … maybe one day, some miner will joyfully take up his pick and go and poison his lungs with a smile. They say that’s what it’s like over there, where the red blaze dazzling the world comes from. So they say. I don’t know.”
Longing for a society that is worthy of your self-sacrifice is a perversion more akin to a religious sentiment than to a revolutionary one. He deserves credit for not wanting Cubans to live up to his ideal of unselfishness.


Read what the guy actually wrote. It is no big deal - in spite of his fondness of metaphors. (He was very young when he wrote this!):

The foundation of irreligious criticism is: Man makes religion, religion does not make man. Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again. But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopaedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d’honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification. It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality. The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that world whose spiritual aroma is religion.

Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.

Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower. The criticism of religion disillusions man, so that he will think, act, and fashion his reality like a man who has discarded his illusions and regained his senses, so that he will move around himself as his own true Sun. Religion is only the illusory Sun which revolves around man as long as he does not revolve around himself.

It is, therefore, the task of history, once the other-world of truth has vanished, to establish the truth of this world. It is the immediate task of philosophy, which is in the service of history, to unmask self-estrangement in its unholy forms once the holy form of human self-estrangement has been unmasked. Thus, the criticism of Heaven turns into the criticism of Earth, the criticism of religion into the criticism of law, and the criticism of theology into the criticism of politics.
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/intro.htm


I would personally think there were far greater obstacles in their way than religion. Poverty itself would have been one of them - if they couldn't amass the financial resources necessary to challenge the authorities, they were a lot less likely to be able to do it successfully.

Remember that poverty is what makes them seek the consolation of religion .. instead of overthrowing the conditions that make them poor.

They did manage to organise more and more successfully though, despite religion and everything else. Here's a brief timeline of the development of unions in the UK. And here's a brief history of UK unions that goes into quite a bit more detail.

There was a growing level of activism, and unions became very popular.

But significant changes were brought about by concerned Middle Class reformers fighting for change from outside. See a fairly brief document: How and why did working conditions for the masses improve 1834-1948?

It is true: What middle-class reformers do is to reform. They worry about workers health because they want workers to …. work, not die, an attitude criticized by Oscar Wilde when he turned one of their slogans upside down:
”Work is the curse of the drinking classes.”
But their activities haven’t really stopped exploitation, have they? Nor have trade unions put a stop to exploitation but only managed to regulate the terms of the exploitation.

The decline of religion doesn't seem to have been much of a factor in any of that. In fact, it was partly the religious beliefs of some reformers that led them to campaign so vigorously for improvements in working and living conditions for the people. See, for instance, What 19th-century British reformers teach us about Christian social action today. I expect they also had other reasons for getting involved in social reform apart from the ones specified in that article. Several of the most influential social reformers were committed Christians who believed their Christianity was partly what influenced them.

Yes, I guess so. What is your point? Nobody’s claimed that Christians are evil. They tend to be a very charitable lot, especially for Christmas.

True, on the face of it/in the short term. But it's possible to improve the lot of underprivileged citizens without actually harming the rich, and the rich can, after perhaps protesting at first, discover they benefit from the social improvements. For instance, the rich may not have seen the need for the introduction of the national health service in Britain in 1948, having no problems affording medical care, and perhaps feeling penalised at first at having to pay taxes for other people's healthcare. But there can't be many around now who'd object to its existence, since they will themselves have benefited. Rich employers might protest if working hours are shortened by law so they can't drive their employees so hard. But if they then discover that productivity actually rises, because there's a healthier and happier workforce who don't take so many days off for sick leave, which is possible, they may realise it was a good idea.

Unfortunately the world does not look like that, BN.
‘Why cannot we all just be happy and get along?’ is an attitude that refuses to see the basis for the actual disagreement, the contradictory interests in this society.
Yes, rich employers not only ”might protest if working hours are shortened” – by law or otherwise, they actually do, and in some countries even reformers, good Christians, tend to die at a very early age.
And notice what the attitude of your shrewd employers depend on – even in your very non-confrontational fantasy: ”But (!) if (!) they then discover that productivity actually rises, because there's a healthier and happier workforce who don't take so many days off for sick leave, which is possible, they may realise it was a good idea”

Yes, you are right: Capitalists tend to be very fond of raising productivity and lowering costs and reducing absence, and when they raise productivity, lower costs and reduce absenteeism by making people work harder, lowering wages and threatening employees with dismissals, they don’t do so because they want to make their employees unhealthier and unhappier.
That’s not the purpose, it’s just the consequence.

I can recommend these pages about the reality of capitalism and euphemistic descriptions of it
http://www.ruthlesscriticism.com/capitalindex.htm
http://www.ruthlesscriticism.com/moralityindex.htm

Thus, the criticism of Heaven turns into the criticism of Earth, the criticism of religion into the criticism of law, and the criticism of theology into the criticism of politics.
 
Hey, not so fast

Or the pope denouncing condoms. (We don't need exotic examples of this, do we?)
It's fairly obvious that religion must be the enemy of enlightened education and/or pleasure for pleasure's sake.

Only in its extreme forms. You're making a generalisation. After all, not even all Catholics agree with the pope; and there are Muslims who don't like the extremism of the Taliban.

Dann said:
No, he didn't. And you are making it much too easy for yourself now. Instead of reading what he wrote, you just pick out the line about "the opium of the people and start imagining what it could possibly mean! You have the idea that Marx said that religion is mainly alleviating the pain, thus actually a
pleasure. Therefore you compare it with things like "fun" (!!!) and wonder if Marx was the kind of guy who would prefer life to be living hell for workers
so they would get off their ***es and rise in rebellion already!

No, you misunderstand my intentions. Actually, my question wasn't related to that bit about the opium of the masses. I simply thought there must be more to his thinking than is apparent from that quote. I'm not aware of what other things he said about religion in his lifetime, or even if he did write anything else about it, because I haven't read his writings extensively. But I thought there must be more to his beliefs that I hadn't heard.

I'm not imagining Marx really did think that people needed to reach rock bottom to motivate them to rebel. My question was merely a suggestion, because in all that quote about religion being a set of illusions, he doesn't explain why being an illusion would make it necessary that religion was got rid of. There just has to be something else to his reasoning. I was simply making tentative queries as to what it could be. I wasn't ignoring all that stuff about religion being an illusion. But there has to be something else to his reasoning that he didn't explain, unless it's in such convoluted language I didn't pick it up. But "Religion needs to be got rid of if the people are to be happy" doesn't follow on logically from "Religion is an illusion". There has to have been a step in between in his thinking that isn't apparent in the quote. "Religion is an illusion, so it needs to be got rid of to make people truly happy, because, being an illusion, it ..." does what? That's the bit missing. There has to be something about it being an illusion that makes it so terrible it needs to go.

Thus, I was wondering if his main motivation for wanting to get rid of it might not be to do with it being an illusion at all, but with something else.

After all, simply being an illusion wouldn't make it any worse than many other things, that no one would want to get rid of; they would simply want them modified.

For instance, at the time when Marx wrote his opinion piece in which he made that quote, many doctors believed that disease was caused by fumes in the air. Thus Marx himself probably believed it. He could thus, theoretically, be said to have been under a delusion. The belief was extremely damaging, since although it did save lives, as it prompted people to improve sanitation when they felt under threat themselves, it meant that appalling practices went on unchecked, such as those that so troubled one doctor, who realised women were dying in childbirth because they were being infected by doctors after they went straight from working in the mortuary to delivering babies.

It was over a decade after Marx wrote of religion being an illusion in that famous quote that doctors began to realise in large numbers that germs caused disease. I don't suppose for a moment that Marx would have thought, upon realising the medical profession had been so tragically wrong before, that the whole medical profession ought to be done away with to prevent such a tragedy ever happening again.

Thus: I'm puzzled as to why he believed the illusion of religion was so tremendously damaging that religion didn't simply need to be modified, but it ought to be done away with entirely. I don't understand his thinking. To give an example, there must have been more to it than, "Christianity teaches Jesus rose from the dead and is now offering a place in heaven for the faithful. This is terrible! This pernicious belief must be got rid of if the people are going to be truly happy!" There just must have been more to his thinking. Exactly what was it about his belief that religion is an illusion that made him deem it such a terrible one that it would prevent people from being truly happy unless the entirety of religion was done away with?

Incidentally, I don't recall suggesting Marx equated religion with "fun".

Dann said:
However, you completely forget what ought to be a matter of course for people in this forum:
Religion does not simply make people contented by being merely a pleasurable experience! Like drugs - and unlike loving (family or otherwise) relations
or fun (usually) - it makes them contented by screwing with their minds. Religion is a delusion, and you don't need to have a lot of experience with believers
to discover how false and therefore strenuous the alleged happiness of religious people is.
In my Baptist Sunday school we used to sing this song (in my translation):

"I am happy, I am happy, on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. I am happy, I am happy, 'cause Jesus is my best friend." (In
the second stanza in reverse order: "on Sunday, Saturday, Friday ...")

I was usually quite happy but mainly because I liked to sing, which is why I put up with having to sing about this ubiquitous Jesus guy, who was never there
anyway. I mean, if you are actually soooo happy all the time because Jesus is your best friend, you wouldn't have to sing about it the whole time. It is very exhausting
having to persuade yourself of a delusion, and therefore "The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness."

I can see your point to some extent. I did hear a Christian counsellor once say the people who shouted halleluias loudest in the church services he attended tended to be the ones who confessed to the biggest doubts in confidentiality afterwards, in his experience. And I knew someone myself who would shout "Jesus" and "halleluia" at all kinds of appropriate or inappropriate places in the services, but in reality, he said he was worried because he didn't know if he was even in God's favour.

I've also heard it said that Christians, who are supposed to disapprove of lying, actually tell more lies than anyone else, because of the hymns they sing that they don't believe half the words of. :D

I've also heard of depressed people who were treated disdainfully by other Christians who assumed they ought to be happy all the time or they weren't real Christians.

But I think the extent to which that kind of thing would happen or be a strain on anyone would depend partly on each individual, and partly on the way their particular brand of Christianity was manifesting itself. It isn't universal to Christianity. And I wouldn't understand why anyone would think that kind of thing in itself would be serious enough to get rid of the entirety of religion.

After all, religion can make people genuinely happy. There have been several studies that have found such things as a correlation between attendance at church services, and living longer, lower blood pressure, better mental health, and lower suicide risk. Take this study, for example:

Regular Church Attendance May Lower Suicide Risk

University of Manitoba researchers analyzed data from almost 37,000 people who took part in the Canadian Community Health Survey to study the relationship between spirituality, religious worship and suicidal behavior.

"The main finding of this study is that religious worship attendance is associated with a decreased risk of suicide attempts," study author Daniel Rasic said in a university news release. The researchers didn't examine why religious worship may reduce the risk of suicide attempts. ...

Me said:
Or did he mean that religion could motivate people to provide some level of social services, which would prevent them from becoming so discontented they'd
do something major in order to gain wholesale improvements in their condition?

Dann said:
No. Does anything at all seem to indicate that this was his point?

No. It was mere speculation. Again, I thought maybe there were things he'd written about religion in other writings that I hadn't read.

One thing I was wondering was what, exactly, did Marx perceive the relationship between religion being an illusion, and it being an obstacle to the working class being enthusiastic for revolution, to be. If he didn't think religion would make them less enthusiastic for revolution, then why was religion an issue for him at all? If he did think religion was an obstacle, why? Again, there has to be a step of reasoning in between, "Religion is an illusion" and "It needs to be entirely got rid of". He wanted something that would make the people genuinely happy put in its place - i.e. an improvement in their working and living conditions. But why did he think it would be impossible for them to have both? What made him think religion was such an illusion it was genuinely damaging their lives?

Dann said:
Again: So discontented that ... is not the point! I mean, they are already so discontented that they invent an alternative world, an imaginary world, a fantasy world. Discontented is not the point. Understanding the conditions that produce the discontent is.

They were born and raised into it; they didn't invent it. What I would love to read, if such a thing were to exist, is a research study done by someone of Marx's day, who asked a fair number of people about their motives for being involved in their religion. I know there were a few social historians and researchers in the 19th century. But I don't know if any ever did a study like that; and it might be impossible to do a study like that in any case, since most people might not be too aware of their own motives, and in any case might not want to admit to any that didn't sound that honourable.

But it would be interesting to know whether most had a genuine conviction that what they believed was true and good for them, or whether some just went to church because it gave them a sense of community, and whether some treated religion like a kind of fire insurance - they were too scared not to believe in case they went to hell; or whether some believed simply because they wanted a reward in heaven; or whether some believed because it had never occurred to them that Christianity might not be true, since they were taught it from when they were very little and had never been exposed to alternative opinions. They may have had a variety of motives for believing it. Marx may have been simplifying things by simply calling it an illusion and an opiate.

But though he may have been simplifying things, he certainly used convoluted imagery, or else his translator has made what he wrote seem unnecessarily complex.

For instance, Marx wrote:

Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again.

Blimey. I can imagine someone quoting that on here and saying, "Is this woo?" :D I suppose the quote's something to do with that illusory happiness he talks about. I haven't a clue about the next bit though:

But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world.

Aha, perhaps I have now. Did you italicise the word "man" because Marx was implying the words "unlike God"? But if so, how do you know that was his meaning for sure, albeit it sounds like the only logical one.

This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world.

Inverted? What on earth did he mean by that? I think it needs to be interpreted in the context of some background information on what his thinking was.

In fact, what I would find very interesting would be to find some information on exactly what it was about Marx's personal experiences and observations that shaped his view of religion.

He isn't entirely uncomplimentary about religion, is he.

Religion is ... [the world's] moral sanction, ...

But what on earth did he mean by saying it was the world's "solemn complement"?

The passage is rather too poetic for my liking.

and [the world's] universal basis of consolation and justification.

Justification for what? I have no option but to guess again. Existing?

As for what he means by "universal basis of consolation", does he mean that all the world's population are consoled by it, or that people turn to it for consolation for all ills? It's all rather confusing. As I said, some background information on his views would be needed to genuinely make it easy to understand.

It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality.

Blimey, if only Marx had made the words rhyme a bit more, he could have been right up there with Wordsworth, Shakespeare and the other poets, having his work force-fed to children in literature classes, subverting them on the quiet. :D

The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality.

Poetic styles always give me brainache. This is no exception. I can feel it coming on now. :D

Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering.

And that's supposed to be easy to understand? :D Again, it would be impossible to be sure what he really meant without some background information explaining his views further.

I'm sorry to say this, but I've even got a quibble or two about my favourite bit, the bit that comes next: :)

... The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.

I take him to mean that criticizing religion is in effect criticizing Capitalism, because harsh conditions are what spawns religion. Why did he think the two were so related? Again, it would be interesting to read information about how his own experience of religion shaped his views on it.

Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower.

Oh no, more poetry! I'm going to start losing the will to live in a minute! How can You be so sure of what he was going on about?

The criticism of religion disillusions man, so that he will think, act, and fashion his reality like a man who has discarded his illusions and regained his senses,

Well, at least Marx speaks more plainly here. Still, he doesn't give a word of explanation as to why he imagines that if anyone does become disillusioned with religion, they will "regain their senses". I mean, some people who lose their faith in religion are not sensible at all. For instance, it would still be possible for someone who's given up religion to somehow imagine he could leave his pre-teenage children at home on their own and be fairly confident they were going to be safe.

But then, perhaps by "regain his senses", Marx simply meant a man would realise his working and living conditions were intolerable and want to shake them off,

... which brings us back to the very questions I was asking. Why did he think religion stops people making efforts to improve their living and working conditions?

As for the rest of what he said, again, it's too poetic and ambiguous for me to understand what it means.

Dann said:
There are actually Bible verses "about working hard for employers"? I find it hard to believe!

Thank goodness for that! - At least You're making sense. :D

The Bible doesn't specifically use the word "employer", but there are several verses about working hard in the context of employment.

Dann said:
Remember that poverty is what makes them seek the consolation of religion .. instead of overthrowing the conditions that make them poor.

Perhaps Marx didn't live to see it, but there was growing organisation among the poor to improve their conditions, even while most were still religious. There were organisations with a lot of popular support around when he was alive though, that did campaign for improvements in social conditions, hoping political activism would help bring them about, like the Chartists:

Chartism was a movement for political and social reform in the United Kingdom during the mid-19th century between 1838 and 1848. It takes its name from the People's Charter of 1838, which stipulated the six main aims of the movement as:
•*Suffrage for all men age 21 and over
•*Equal-sized electoral districts
•*Voting by secret ballot
•*An end to the need for a property qualification for Parliament
•*Pay for Members of Parliament
•*Annual election of Parliament

Chartism was possibly the first mass working class labour movement in the world.

The movement did seem to fail at the time. But most of those demands have since been achieved. The only thing we don't get is yearly elections.

Dann said:
It is true: What middle-class reformers do is to reform. They worry about workers health because they want workers to …. work, not die,

Probably, partly. But I think several were genuinely motivated by humanitarianism as well. After all, there were plenty of business owners who didn't think workers dying was an important enough concern to improve working conditions for them. If it was simply a matter of it making good business sense, they would have done.

Dann said:
But their activities haven’t really stopped exploitation, have they?

No, but then no one else's have either. People who want to exploit others will probably always find ways to do so. What those reformers did achieve, however, was to improve living and working conditions a lot.

For instance, they brought in legislation about the safety of machinery in factories, and legislated for factory inspectors to check that working conditions were improving. There were ridiculously few at first, but then more were employed. They also shortened working hours, especially for children. Here are some quotes from people who worked in factories in the 19th century, who speak about things that just don't happen any more, because of the work of the reformers. From a history project:

"Two children I know got employment in a factory when they were five years old………….the spinning men or women employ children if they can get a child to do their business……..the child is paid one shilling or one shilling and six pence, and they will take that (five year old) child before they take an older one who will cost more." George Gould, a Manchester merchant, written in 1816.

"The smallest child in the factories were scavengers……they go under the machine, while it is going……….it is very dangerous when they first come, but they become used to it." Charles Aberdeen worked in a Manchester cotton factory, written in 1832.

"The task first allotted to Robert Blincoe was to pick up the loose cotton, that fell upon the floor. Apparently nothing could be easier……..although he was much terrified by the whirling motion and noise of the machinery and the dust with which he was half suffocated………he soon felt sick and was constantly stooping; his back ached. Blincoe took the liberty to sit down. But this he soon found was strictly forbidden in cotton mills. His overlooker, Mr. Smith, told him he must keep on his legs. This he did for six and a half hours without a break." John Brown, a reporter for "The Lion". Written in 1828.

"We went to the mill at five in the morning. We worked until dinner time and then to nine or ten at night; on Saturday it could be till eleven and often till twelve at night. We were sent to clean the machinery on the Sunday." Man interviewed in 1849 who had worked in a mill as a child.

"In the evening I walked to Cromford and saw the children coming from their work. These children had been at work from 6 o’clock in the morning and it was now 7 o’clock in the evening." Joseph Farington, 22nd August 1801 (diary entry)

"I began work at the mill in Bradford when I was nine years old……we began at six in the morning and worked until nine at night. When business was brisk, we began at five and worked until ten in the evening." Hannah Brown, interviewed in 1832.

"Very often the children are woken at four in the morning. The children are carried on the backs of the older children asleep to the mill, and they see no more of their parents till they go home at night and are sent to bed." Richard Oastler, interviewed in 1832.

"Woodward and other overlookers used to beat me with pieces of thick leather straps made supple by oil, and having an iron buckle at the end, drew blood almost every time it was applied."John Brown quoted in the "Lion" newspaper in 1828.

"Sarah Golding was poorly and so she stopped her machine. James Birch, the overlooker, knocked her to the floor. She got up as well as she could. He knocked her down again. Then she was carried to her house.......she was found dead in her bed. There was another girl called Mary......she knocked her food can to the floor. The master, Mr. Newton, kicked her and caused her to wear away till she died. There was another, Caroline Thompson, who was beaten till she went out of her mind. The overlookers used to cut off the hair of any girl caught talking to a lad. This head shaving was a dreadful punishment. We were more afraid of it than any other punishment for girls are proud of their hair." An interview in 1849 with an unknown woman who worked in a cotton factory as a child.

"When I was seven years old I went to work at Mr Marshall’s factory at Shrewsbury. If a child became sleepy, the overlooker touches the child on the shoulder and says "come here". In the corner of the room there is an iron cistern filled with water. He takes the boy by the legs and dips him in the cistern, and then sends him back to work." Jonathan Downe interviewed in June 1832.

"I have seen my master, Luke Taylor, with a horse whip standing outside the mill when the children have come too late.........he lashed them all the way to the mill." John Fairbrother, an overlooker, interviewed in 1819.

"I work at the silk mill. I am an overlooker and I have to superintend the children at the mill. Their strength goes towards the evening and they get tired. I have been compelled to urge them to work when I knew they could not bear it. I have been disgusted with myself. I felt myself degraded and reduced to the level of a slave-driver. William Rastrick, interviewed in 1832.[/quote]

In 1833, there was a factory act that banned children under 9 from working in factories at all, and limited 9-13 year-olds to working only 9 hours a day and 48 hours a week. Further factory acts throughout the century further improved things.

Such things as I've quoted just don't happen in factories in the West any more.

Dann said:
Yes, I guess so. What is your point? Nobody’s claimed that Christians are evil. They tend to be a very charitable lot, especially for Christmas.

My point is that if Marx thought religion would have to be abolished in order for conditions to improve for workers much, he was wrong. In fact, the opposite was true in some respects - some people were motivated to push for reforms precisely because they were Christians.

Dann said:
And notice what the attitude of your shrewd employers depend on – even in your very non-confrontational fantasy: ”But (!) if (!) they then discover that productivity actually rises, because there's a healthier and happier workforce who don't take so many days off for sick leave, which is possible, they may realise it was a good idea”

That paragraph of mine was in response to your claim that it's impossible to legislate for the good of the citizens of a country in general. I was arguing that it in fact is possible. Whether or not employers eventually realise that shorter working hours are good for them as well as their employees, parliament can legislate for them, knowing that they are in fact legislating for the good of the citizens of the country in general.

Blimey, I don't think I'll write too many posts of this length! I need a cup of tea now.
 
Only in its extreme forms. You're making a generalisation. After all, not even all Catholics agree with the pope; and there are Muslims who don't like the extremism of the Taliban.

I don't see any of them pushing proper sex education (or education in general) in order to make sure that people know how to enjoy the pleasures of sex without the easily avoided consequences of VDs and unwanted pregnancy. I do know that Catholicism is often praised for its contributions to science in the dark middle ages, but it wasn't science meant to reach a wider audience. And we all know what happened to Galilei. I also know that some scientists are able to live with the contradiction of being scientists and religious, which does not make religion the least bit rational.

I'm not imagining Marx really did think that people needed to reach rock bottom to motivate them to rebel. My question was merely a suggestion, because in all that quote about religion being a set of illusions, he doesn't explain why being an illusion would make it necessary that religion was got rid of. There just has to be something else to his reasoning. I was simply making tentative queries as to what it could be. I wasn't ignoring all that stuff about religion being an illusion. But there has to be something else to his reasoning that he didn't explain, unless it's in such convoluted language I didn't pick it up. But "Religion needs to be got rid of if the people are to be happy" doesn't follow on logically from "Religion is an illusion". There has to have been a step in between in his thinking that isn't apparent in the quote. "Religion is an illusion, so it needs to be got rid of to make people truly happy, because, being an illusion, it ..." does what? That's the bit missing. There has to be something about it being an illusion that makes it so terrible it needs to go.

No, not really. That it's an illusion is reason enough to get rid of it.

Thus, I was wondering if his main motivation for wanting to get rid of it might not be to do with it being an illusion at all, but with something else.

After all, simply being an illusion wouldn't make it any worse than many other things, that no one would want to get rid of; they would simply want them modified.

Why would you want to modify an illusion in any other way than by exploding it: disillusionment?

For instance, at the time when Marx wrote his opinion piece in which he made that quote, many doctors believed that disease was caused by fumes in the air. Thus Marx himself probably believed it. He could thus, theoretically, be said to have been under a delusion.

Yes, and I guess he would have welcomed proper knowledge and disillusionment if anybody had offered it to him. And he might have lived longer ....

The belief was extremely damaging,
Yes, it was!
since although it did save lives, as it prompted people to improve sanitation when they felt under threat themselves, it meant that appalling practices went on unchecked, such as those that so troubled one doctor, who realised women were dying in childbirth because they were being infected by doctors after they went straight from working in the mortuary to delivering babies.
And in the end doctors were disillusioned and the problem was (more or less) solved!
It was over a decade after Marx wrote of religion being an illusion in that famous quote that doctors began to realise in large numbers that germs caused disease. I don't suppose for a moment that Marx would have thought, upon realising the medical profession had been so tragically wrong before, that the whole medical profession ought to be done away with to prevent such a tragedy ever happening again.

No, probabaly not. But the illusion was replaced by science, which is what should be done with religion. See? Imaginary contradiction in terms eliminated!

Thus: I'm puzzled as to why he believed the illusion of religion was so tremendously damaging that religion didn't simply need to be modified, but it ought to be done away with entirely.

Because if you start from the beginning and replace Genesis with evolution and then work your way through the whole thing, nothing's left!

I don't understand his thinking. To give an example, there must have been more to it than, "Christianity teaches Jesus rose from the dead and is now offering a place in heaven for the faithful. This is terrible! This pernicious belief must be got rid of if the people are going to be truly happy!" There just must have been more to his thinking. Exactly what was it about his belief that religion is an illusion that made him deem it such a terrible one that it would prevent people from being truly happy unless the entirety of religion was done away with?

Incidentally, I don't recall suggesting Marx equated religion with "fun".

Neither do I, which was my point:
If so, the same criticisms he levelled at religion would have to be levelled at things like loving family relations, or any fun (!) they did manage to have, since that would have a similar effect.
In post 83 you reduced Marx’s critique of religion to: religion = opium = pleasure, fun. Now you want to reduce it to: religion = illusion.
And I’m sorry, but this reduction just isn’t true, which is why your abstraction from his actual critique of religion cannot be compared with an illusion in pre-scientific medicine or, for instance, the illusion of a fairy tale or a magic show. (In the case of the latter, by the way, an enquiring, curious mind does not leave it happy at having been entertained but with the nagging question: How the hell did he manage to fool me like that?)

But I think the extent to which that kind of thing would happen or be a strain on anyone would depend partly on each individual, and partly on the way their particular brand of Christianity was manifesting itself. It isn't universal to Christianity. And I wouldn't understand why anyone would think that kind of thing in itself would be serious enough to get rid of the entirety of religion.

After all, religion can make people genuinely happy.

If you say so, but I find it hard to equate happy at being deluded with genuine happiness.

There have been several studies that have found such things as a correlation between attendance at church services, and living longer, lower blood pressure, better mental health, and lower suicide risk. Take this study, for example:

Regular Church Attendance May Lower Suicide Risk

I will still risk staying away from church, happily. And I know that the correlation has been explained with the joy of being with other people instead of alone, i.e. that the religious content of church services does not have anything to do with the alleged beneficial effects. Thus, the citizens can compete against each other all week long and on Sundays they meet in church to celebrate the ideal (= unlike reality) of fellowship and togetherness.


One thing I was wondering was what, exactly, did Marx perceive the relationship between religion being an illusion, and it being an obstacle to the working class being enthusiastic for revolution, to be. If he didn't think religion would make them less enthusiastic for revolution, then why was religion an issue for him at all? If he did think religion was an obstacle, why?

He didn’t like illusions. He wanted people to mature to the stage where they recognize and treat the world as [what it is[/i] and not as what it isn’t. He wanted people to control their world – not be controlled by their world and merely in control of their imaginary justification of world.

Again, there has to be a step of reasoning in between, "Religion is an illusion" and "It needs to be entirely got rid of". He wanted something that would make the people genuinely happy put in its place - i.e. an improvement in their working and living conditions. But why did he think it would be impossible for them to have both? What made him think religion was such an illusion it was genuinely damaging their lives?

Again: by reducing his critique of religion to: religion = (”such an”) illusion, you manage to create a mystery that was not there in the first place.

1) Marx actually criticizes the people who reduce the critique of religion to: religion = illusion.
2) He points out that religion is there for a reason: People’s lives make them crave an illusion for the consolation this illusion brings them, which is not a natural state of things.
3) A more rational approach to the fact of their miserable lives would be to look at the world as it is, the real world, instead of indulging in imaginary wish-fulfilment. (You’ll get pie in the sky when you die.)
4) If they had not been impotent from the very beginning – i.e. this is not a world that they control, on the contrary they are controlled by the world – they would not have resorted to religion in the first place but would simply have changed the things that caused them harm.
5) Therefore these heartless conditions should be abolished as part of the struggle against religion: the conditions that require illusions.

They were born and raised into it; they didn't invent it.

Sometimes they are born and raised into it, sometimes they modify this spiritual inheritance, and sometimes they make up new illusions. It’s no big deal, and the outcome is much the same in all its variations: religion.

whether some treated religion like a kind of fire insurance - they were too scared not to believe in case they went to hell; or whether some believed simply because they wanted a reward in heaven; or whether some believed because it had never occurred to them that Christianity might not be true, since they were taught it from when they were very little and had never been exposed to alternative opinions. They may have had a variety of motives for believing it. Marx may have been simplifying things by simply calling it an illusion and an opiate.

They may have had a combination of all of these reasons, much the same way a present-day congregation do, but it isn’t very interesting to make the distinction. The distinctions don’t make the common denominator, religion, any different.
And Marx did not, ”simply” or otherwise, call it: illusion+opiate!

I already mentioned that I wasn’t too happy with Marx’s many metaphors, but I don’t find them as convoluted as you do. And the translator cannot be blamed for anything: Hegelian German does not translate well. :)

I’ll return when I have a little more time.
 
Dann said:
I don't see any of them pushing proper sex education (or education in general) in order to make sure that people know how to enjoy the pleasures of sex without the easily avoided consequences of VDs and unwanted pregnancy.

I think there are a few things wrong with that statement.

A. Is pushing such sex education actually the job of religious authorities? It's time the pope realised it would be better for him to stop fuelling controversy about condoms. But would promoting an opposite attitude really be appropriate for him or what he should be about?

B. Have you done enough research to be sure it's so rare for them to do it that you can make statements with the implication that they never do?

C. I'm not sure if you're actually suggesting that teenagers should be educated about "how to enjoy the pleasures of sex". While that might seem a good idea on the surface, can you not imagine the increase in problems it could cause among the irresponsible, not to mention making it more difficult for them to concentrate on subsequent lessons? LOL

D. "the easily avoided consequences of VDs and unwanted pregnancy"? It would be more correct to use the term "more easily". No contraception eliminates the risk. And that's especially when human error comes into play, as it often does, among the youngest sexually active people especially, such as forgetfulness, recklessness under the influence of drink, complacency about the likelihood of anything bad happening to them, etc.

Take this factsheet, for example: Failure Rates of Contraceptives. You'll find the failure rates for the typical user are sometimes a fair bit higher than for the ideal one, but even the lowest failure rates that can be expected are generally higher than zero.

In fact, you'll probably find, if you research the matter, that lots, and quite possibly the vast majority, of those who get pregnant inconveniently or pick up sexually transmitted diseases, have been educated adequately about contraception, but for one reason or another have chosen not to use it, or haven't used it to its best advantage. Education about contraception certainly helps matters. But it isn't a fale-safe solution.

You may be suggesting that education should involve more than that, though, such as education about the risks of making reckless decisions under the influence of alcohol. This would clearly be a good thing; but for a maybe large proportion of teenagers, what feels good at the time, or fitting in with their friends, will trump any education they've been given every time.

Dann said:
And we all know what happened to Galilei.

But you can't take an example of something that happened to one person hundreds of years ago, and use it to support the argument that:

Dann said:
It's fairly obvious that religion must be the enemy of enlightened education

Dann said:
I also know that some scientists are able to live with the contradiction of being scientists and religious, which does not make religion the least bit rational.

It doesn't say anything about "religion" as a whole, unless it can be demonstrated that the whole of religion is anti-science. You could equally say that if scientists are living with the "contradiction" of science and religion, then those scientists are clearly not rational beings, and so what hope is there for science! :) But do they all think they are actually living with contradictions?

Dann said:
No, not really. That it's an illusion is reason enough to get rid of it.

Why?

Dann said:
Why would you want to modify an illusion in any other way than by exploding it: disillusionment?

Well, you've got a point. :) But what if it turns out that only part of what you're calling an illusion really is one, or that you think it's an illusion but you can't be 100% sure? For instance, religion might come with some beliefs that seem strange, some of which might be downright falsehood. But Christianity, at any rate, also comes with a lot of good things, such as all the commands in the New Testament to behave to a high ethical standard. So why not take the view that you'd like to just get rid of the worst excesses of what you consider the illusions, and keep the rest?

Dann said:
No, probabaly not. But the illusion was replaced by science, which is what should be done with religion. See? Imaginary contradiction in terms eliminated!

Well, again you've got a point. :) But again, eliminating religion altogether would be to eliminate its benefits as well as its drawbacks. Christian ethical teaching can inspire people to live better lives. There are lots of testimonies written by people who say their lives were changed by the Christian gospel. To link to just a few:

How to Handle Angry People.
Gamblers Beware.
Leaving Unbelief and Promiscuity to Finding Jesus.
A Captive Set Free.
Three Times a Loser, Now Forever a Winner.
Testimony of Skip Lewis.
A Prodigal in Blue.
The Void.
Testimony of a Police Sergeant.

(Having said that, it's always advisable not to be too hasty to believe such things. For instance, I know someone who was in a top security prison for years because he used to be very violent and had murdered; but he became a Christian, and it seemed he'd completely changed. He stopped being violent altogether. He did a lot of work for outsiders and built up a network of friends. It seemed it could be proved he really had changed when one day, some prisoners who were angry with him tried to throw boiling water over him. He escaped serious injury. But in the old days, he'd have retaliated violently. Now, he didn't.

A number of years after his conversion to Christianity, since he'd had a clean record of good behaviour since then, he was moved gradually to less and less secure prisons. Eventually, he was allowed out of prison once or twice a week on day release. But not long afterwards, there was a problem.

A 17-year-old girl accused him of abduction and rape, and the case went to court. He pleaded not guilty, saying she'd consented. But that would have been odd in itself, since they'd only just met, and he'd married someone while he was in prison, and so should have been living up to the biblical ethic of fidelity to his marriage partner that he professed to be following.

He had indecently assaulted people years earlier, so such behaviour wasn't unknown to him. It had seemed he'd changed. But it's obviously difficult to know whether such a change in people is genuine or will be permanent.)

Still, Christianity can inspire better lifestyle choices in a lot of people. Hence the reason why modifying it would seem better than getting rid of it altogether.

Dann said:
Because if you start from the beginning and replace Genesis with evolution and then work your way through the whole thing, nothing's left!

Only if you decide it has no uses whatsoever and focus entirely on the scientific aspects. What was Marx focusing on though? Didn't he write about religion being an illusion before Charles Darwin published his writings?

Replacing Genesis with a textbook on evolution? Now there's an interesting thought. :D "In the beginning was abiogenesis. ...".

Me said:
If so, the same criticisms he levelled at religion would have to be levelled at things like loving family relations, or any fun (!) they did manage to have,

Ah, so that's where the fun reference came from. I wasn't saying Marx might have equated religion with fun, but was just saying that if he thought religion took the edge off people's desire for improvement so it made them less enthusiastic for revolution, it wasn't the only thing that would do that, so if he was going to be consistent, he ought to criticize other things as well.

Dann said:
you reduced Marx’s critique of religion to: religion = opium = pleasure, fun. Now you want to reduce it to: religion = illusion. And I’m sorry, but this reduction just isn’t true, which is why your abstraction from his actual critique of religion cannot be compared with an illusion in pre-scientific medicine or, for instance, the illusion of a fairy tale or a magic show. (In the case of the latter, by the way, an enquiring, curious
mind does not leave it happy at having been entertained but with the nagging question: How the hell did he manage to fool me like that?)

I'm not "reducing" Marx's critique to either. The reason I asked questions about it was because I was hoping you'd be able to give me some new information that would help me understand it better.

I used the medical comparison with the attitude that religion is an illusion to suggest that surely advocating getting rid of it in its entirety would be unnecessary - why not just get rid of anything about it that can be demonstrated to be doing harm?

Dann said:
If you say so, but I find it hard to equate happy at being deluded with genuine happiness.

But it isn't as simple as that. The happiness would derive from a number of things, like the happiness of knowing that because your family follow Christian teaching, you don't have a husband who goes out and gets drunk and then does who knows what before he gets home, like other women in your neighbourhood do. And so on.

Dann said:
I will still risk staying away from church, happily. And I know that the correlation has been explained with the joy of being with other people instead
of alone, i.e. that the religious content of church services does not have anything to do with the alleged beneficial effects. Thus, the citizens can compete
against each other all week long and on Sundays they meet in church to celebrate the ideal (= unlike reality) of fellowship and togetherness.

Well, I'm sure that's part of it anyway. I'm also sure that not all church services could do the trick, since some are abysmal. :)

Dann said:
He didn’t like illusions. He wanted people to mature to the stage where they recognize and treat the world as what it is and not as what it isn’t.
He wanted people to control their world – not be controlled by their world and merely in control of their imaginary justification of world. ...

1) Marx actually criticizes the people who reduce the critique of religion to: religion = illusion.
2) He points out that religion is there for a reason: People’s lives make them crave an illusion for the consolation this illusion brings them, which is not a natural state of things.
3) A more rational approach to the fact of their miserable lives would be to look at the world as it is, the real world, instead of indulging in imaginary wish-fulfilment. (You’ll get pie in the sky when you die.)
4) If they had not been impotent from the very beginning – i.e. this is not a world that they control, on the contrary they are controlled by the world – they would not have resorted to religion in the first place but would simply have changed the things that caused them harm.
5) Therefore these heartless conditions should be abolished as part of the struggle against religion: the conditions that require illusions.

Aha. Now that makes sense. That's something like what I thought he was saying in the beginning. But it has more to do with control of circumstances. So he was basically against anything that would inhibit the people from taking control of their circumstances with complete self-determination, unless it was there for a very good reason and benefited them? He thought religion was a product of the inability to control their circumstances, but there were now means available, so they should substitute those for religion so they could genuinely improve their lot?
 
I'm overwhelmed with work right now, so just a short comment on the last bit of your post:

Yes, I think that you are right, but please don't reduce his criticism of religion to a question of control. Religion is a question of control, suffering, illusion etc.
In primitive religion you have real people, basically equipped with the same (physiological) ability as we to perceive and consider the whole universe but with almost no means of controlling this universe. It isn't very easy for an intelligent mind to come to terms with an environment that can wipe it out if it so 'chooses': Lightning, hurricanes, floods and droughts.
So in order to achieve peace of mind primitive people resort to the belief that they control their surroundings at least to the extent that they can appease the powerful (albeit imaginary) creatures who control what they have experienced that they themselves don't control. And this kind of peace of mind appears to be so important to them that even very small bands of people tend to leave it to particular person to take care of this job - and allocate the necessary resources: sacrifices.

The scandal of the present day is that people still resort to basically the same kind of behaviour at a time where the societies have at their disposal all the means necessary to control the things that threatened our ancestors: Nobody starves because there is not enough food but because they don't have access to the abundance of it and other riches. TV crews with HD cams and satellite transmission are present at every major hot spot and mass starvation.
Why are many people in developing countries poor? (and not only in developing countries!)
And so are the soldiers, making sure that they stay put.
Globalized hunger, hunger riots and imperialist order problems

Today people are not confronted with nature. (The irony is that the aforementioned camera teams are crazy about children with stomachs distended from hunger on the picturesqe background of deserts!)

"But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world."
A contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right
(By the way, I copied the italics from the text!)

Condoms and sex education:
No, nothing's perfect. People die in traffic every day, but I have never seen that fact used as an argument against the obvious futility of traffic education.
That some people aren't able to handle condoms suitably is not a very good argument against teaching them to do so, is it? :)
 
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/intro.htm
The foundation of irreligious criticism is: Man makes religion, religion does not make man.

This one’s fairly obvious. In spite of Genesis, God did not create people, people created God – and ‘in their image’.

Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again.

Instead of facing reality and dealing with the world as it is, the religious individual invents an ideal of what the world is, an imaginary world, in order to give meaning to the world, i.e. provide it with a purpose that it doesn’t have – maybe because he finds the world meaningless (and misses the meaning that he doesn’t see) or because he does not want to recognize the meaning that it actually has. (The lack of divine meaning is actually what makes us free - unless we have to serve somebody else's purposes.)

But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world.

No, man is an island. We don’t live like Robinson Crusoe, isolated and alone, we live in societies governed by states, and this influences our fantasies. It is no coincidence that medieval religion is full of hierarchies: of angels, humans and nature, the great chain of being. Since people don’t control their world, i.e. society, they invent fantasies to give meaning to, i.e. justify, the world as it is. (The rational answer to conditions like this is obvious.)

Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopaedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d’honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification. It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality.
Philosophers of enlightenment may have dreamed of the truly free individual, but this freedom was not yet reality. (compare with: “The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it”)

The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that world whose spiritual aroma is religion.

Unless you prefer to do battle against windmills …

Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering.

Well, a very servile protest, if at all …

Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions.

In other words: Don’t fight the symptoms, fight what causes the symptoms.

The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.

If people not only want to believe but actually need to believe, you should do something about the conditions causing this. (If they feel that they have no other options, showing them these options, i.e. a way out of their misery, is already a step on the way. And the way out of their misery depends on the conditions that cause their misery. If they imagine that God in his wisdom has punished them with the clap, you should tell them about penicillin. But if they don’t have access to efficient health care anyway, a mere explanation is rather futile. And access may be a question of poverty. Information alone does not make witchdoctors redundant ...)

Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower.

More metaphors. :) But the chain is a rather obvious symbol, isn’t it?, and throwing off the chain even more so. And so are the flowers, the joys that life (in principle) has to offer.

The criticism of religion disillusions man, so that he will think, act, and fashion his reality like a man who has discarded his illusions and regained his senses, so that he will move around himself as his own true Sun. Religion is only the illusory Sun which revolves around man as long as he does not revolve around himself.

Again I find the parallel obvious: the geo-centrism (of the dark Middle Ages) versus the helio-centrism of the Renaissance, compared with ‘deus-centrism’ versus ‘humano-centrism’.

It is, therefore, the task of history, once the other-world of truth has vanished, to establish the truth of this world. It is the immediate task of philosophy, which is in the service of history, to unmask self-estrangement in its unholy forms once the holy form of human self-estrangement has been unmasked. Thus, the criticism of Heaven turns into the criticism of Earth, the criticism of religion into the criticism of law, and the criticism of theology into the criticism of politics.

The “task of history” is Hegelian rubbish and so is ”in the service of history’”/i]. Unlike what also the CP movement claimed, ‘history’ does not have any ‘task’ nor can it be ‘served’. The aim of revolutionaries (which the 25-year-old Marx was only evolving into at this stage) is to persuade people to “throw off the chain” and stop being serfs.
 
Condoms and sex education:
No, nothing's perfect. People die in traffic every day, but I have never seen that fact used as an argument against the obvious futility of traffic education.
That some people aren't able to handle condoms suitably is not a very good argument against teaching them to do so, is it? :)

I didn't say it was. Personally, I think that even if some teenagers are bound to disregard it, sex education ought to involve a range of things, including the emotional pitfalls and other possible drawbacks for the lifestyle of anyone who gets involved too quickly or without enough thought. For instance, information like this:

Cutting Down the Risk of Getting Into a Bad Relationship.
Neglected Heart: The Emotional Dangers of Premature Sexual Involvement.
Post Abortion: Regrets of Women Who Had an Abortion.

Actually, I also think it would be good if education included advice on maintaining good relationships with partners, for instance such things as Tips for Talking - Marriage Communication.
 
It doesn't say anything about "religion" as a whole, unless it can be demonstrated that the whole of religion is anti-science. You could equally say that if scientists are living with the "contradiction" of science and religion, then those scientists are clearly not rational beings, and so what hope is there for science! :)

Yes, you could easily say that, but you would be wrong. Nobody (that I know) is rational 24-7. Making an error does not make you an 'irrational being'.

But do they all think they are actually living with contradictions?

Yes. They have ways of rationalizing the contradiction, but that does not make the whole thing more rational.

Well, you've got a point. :) But what if it turns out that only part of what you're calling an illusion really is one, or that you think it's an illusion but you can't be 100% sure?

Then I'll try to make sure.

For instance, religion might come with some beliefs that seem strange, some of which might be downright falsehood. But Christianity, at any rate, also comes with a lot of good things, such as all the commands in the New Testament to behave to a high ethical standard. So why not take the view that you'd like to just get rid of the worst excesses of what you consider the illusions, and keep the rest?

I'm not too fond of ethics, but I hate the ethics of the Bible, including #2, even though it wasn't nearly as bad as #1. I think that The Bible 3.0 should scrap the prequels completely and start anew. I honestly cannot think of any parts of the Bible that I'd want to keep.
However, I do know some Christians who are nice people - in spite of the Bible.

But again, eliminating religion altogether would be to eliminate its benefits as well as its drawbacks.

Yes, of course. You could say the same thing about addiction to crack.

Christian ethical teaching can inspire people to live better lives.

Yes, and it can inspire people to live worse lives too.

Still, Christianity can inspire better lifestyle choices in a lot of people. Hence the reason why modifying it would seem better than getting rid of it altogether.

I know that many Christians like to believe that if it weren't for 'the good book', they'd be out there murdering, raping and pillaging. It's appears to be part of the delusion.

What was Marx focusing on though? Didn't he write about religion being an illusion before Charles Darwin published his writings?

Yes, but Genesis was wrong a long time before the Origin of Species. :)

Replacing Genesis with a textbook on evolution? Now there's an interesting thought. :D "In the beginning was abiogenesis. ...".

'In the beginning we assume that there was this kinda Big Bang. What caused it, though, is still very much in dispute. Well, approximately 9 or 10 billion years later life appears to have come into existence, at least in this corner of the universe ...'
 
Last edited:
But Christianity, at any rate, also comes with a lot of good things, such as all the commands in the New Testament to behave to a high ethical standard.


Old versus New Testament, Psycho God versus Forgiveness God:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3944358#post3944358
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3944379#post3944379
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3945708#post3945708
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3946076#post3946076
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3947106#post3947106
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3947744#post3947744
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3948057#post3948057
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3948147#post3948147
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3948245#post3948245
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3953663#post3953663

But it isn't as simple as that. The happiness would derive from a number of things, like the happiness of knowing that because your family follow Christian teaching, you don't have a husband who goes out and gets drunk and then does who knows what before he gets home, like other women in your neighbourhood do. And so on.


There are probably more Christian alcoholics than agnostic/atheist alcoholics, at least in Christian societies …
 
Last edited:

Regarding alcoholism, I'd guess that there are many many more alcoholics who identify as Christian than identify as Atheists or agnostics in Christian societies. I wasn't disputing that. But many people who self-identify as Christian don't "follow Christian teaching", and that was the criterion I was specifying for being happy because you have a sober husband. In some working communities of the 19th century, there were methodist groupings who were strict teetotallers. This may possibly have made for less merriment, but it may have meant that such households were more financially secure, less violent etc.

Regarding the way God is portrayed: It's a commonly-held misconception that God's character is portrayed as totally different in the old and new testaments. It isn't actually the case. What changes is the kinds of people each section of the Bible was addressed to, and their purposes. The Old Testament was written for people who lived in a theocracy and were supposed to obey its laws whether they wanted to or not. So some of them were psychopaths and criminals who would have to be scared into it if there was any hope of them doing it. The New Testament, on the other hand, was written for people who actually wanted to obey moral teaching, so it focused more on encouragement, and the finer points of such teaching.

This was illustrated in 1 Timothy:

*8We know that the law is good if one uses it properly. 9We also know that law is made not for the righteous but for lawbreakers and rebels, the ungodly and sinful, the unholy and irreligious; for those who kill their fathers or mothers, for murderers, 10for adulterers and perverts, for slave traders and liars and perjurers and for whatever else is contrary to the sound doctrine 11 that conforms to the glorious gospel of the blessed God, which he entrusted to me.

Wouldn't dealing with that lot turn any God a bit psycho? :)

Since Christians are supposed to want to live moral lives as part of the deal they sign up to, the Old Testament really isn't relevant for Christians. In fact, I think it's a shame that the Christians who put the Bible together all those years ago didn't have the foresight to drop most of the Old Testament from it, keeping just those bits of it that would be necessary for Christians to understand what the New Testament writers meant when they referred to it, and a very small selection of other bits, so people could get the gist of what happened in it. (They could keep the whole Book of Proverbs, since that's got some good moral teaching in it and is fun to read). It would have been a tremendous boon to copyists throughout the centuries, who could have copied many more New Testaments if they hadn't felt obliged to spend so much time on the Old outdated Testament. (Again, it's the New Testament that says the old one is outdated.)

There are lots of sickening and gruesome parts of the Old Testament, and some do sound insanely savage on the face of it. But it's not as simple as God being psycho in the Old Testament and forgiving in the New. The emphases are different, but you get both harsh and merciful aspects in both testaments. For instance, there are several verses in the Old Testament where forgiveness is offered. For example in Isaiah chapter 1:

16 ****** Stop doing wrong,
*17 learn to do right!
****** Seek justice,
****** encourage the oppressed. [a]
****** Defend the cause of the fatherless,
****** plead the case of the widow.

*18 "Come now, let us reason together,"
****** says the LORD.
****** "Though your sins are like scarlet,
****** they shall be as white as snow;
****** though they are red as crimson,
****** they shall be like wool.

The punishments for wrongdoing the prophets foretold were barbaric, - having their land invaded. They seem especially barbaric since the consequences would have been indiscriminate for the most part. But all that the prophets were asking was that people started living decent lives instead of harming each other, saying that if they did, the punishments would not befall the people!

Other Old Testament passages that seem gruesome don't seem so bad in their cultural context. For instance, there's a horrible passage in the Book of Numbers about how if a man suspected his wife of unfaithfulness, but doesn't have absolute proof, he had to go to a priest with her and the priest would give her some bitter water to drink, and if she had been unfaithful, she would eventually develop some physical problems. This sounds horrible, but it may well have in fact prevented women being killed. There's a tradition of honour killings in the Middle East, where men who feel that a woman in their lives has brought shame on the family, often because of a suspicion of infidelity, will just kill her, no questions asked. If that was going on in Old Testament times, then the law about taking wives to the priest instead would actually have been a protective measure for women.

There's a web page called The Bible God: Cruel, Savage, Deranged, Evil, Barbaric, Intolerant, Insanely Jealous, Vengeful and Bloodthirsty? which gives a bit of explanation of the cultural context of some of the old laws, and something about other gruesome Old Testament things. Topics it covers include:

• Killing the Amalekite Babies, and Taking Midianite Virgins Captive
• Isn't God Cruel Because he Didn't Speak Out Against Slavery but Condoned It?
• God Causing Bears to Kill Children for Name-Calling?
• God Admits to the Base Human Vice of Jealousy?
• Did God Command that Babylonian Babies be Killed by being smashed Against Rocks?
• Isn't God Unbelievably Merciless and Heartless for Ordering the Killing of a Man Just for Gathering Sticks on the Sabbath?
• Isn't the Bible Barbaric for Ordering that Rebellious Sons be Stoned to Death?
• Why Should the Bible's Anti-Homosexual Bigotry be Tolerated?
• Women being Forced to Marry their Rapists, and Women being Stoned to Death for Not being Virgins on their Wedding Night
• Isn't the Bible Disgusting for Decreeing that Women had to Undergo a Horrible Ritual Simply Because Their Husbands Jealously Suspected Them of Infidelity?
• Isn't God Unforgiveable and Perverted for Decreeing that Soldiers can Rape War Captives?
• How can God be Loving If We're All Burdened with Original Sin?
• Are we Sent to Hell for All Eternity Simply for Not Believing in Jesus?

That's part one of a series that covers other gruesome things about the Old Testament as well.

To illustrate that God's character is still portrayed as essentially compassionate in the Old Testament, despite its truly barbaric-sounding features, Here's a re-post of lots of Old Testament quotations I put on here in another conversation when I first arrived here. It illustrates that the old and new testaments do in fact have the same main focus - that people are being called on to stop harming one another. Old Testament prophets portrayed God as having a strong core of compassion, so much so that he was made fiercely angry by the harm people were doing to one another, hence his severe punishments. I'll end this post with the quotes about the condemnation of people the prophets made for behaviour that was hurting others:

Amos chapter 3 (NLT)

"My people have forgotten what it means to do right," says the LORD.

Isaiah Chapter 59 (NIV)

3 Your hands are stained with blood, your fingers with guilt. Your lips have spoken lies, and your tongue mutters wicked things. 4 No one calls for justice; no one pleads his case with integrity. They rely on empty arguments and speak lies; they conceive trouble and give birth to evil. 7 Their feet rush into sin; they are swift to shed innocent blood. Their thoughts are evil thoughts; ruin and destruction mark their ways. 8 The way of peace they do not know; there is no justice in their paths. They have turned them into crooked roads; no one who walks in them will know peace. 14 So justice is driven back, and righteousness stands at a distance; truth has stumbled in the streets, honesty cannot enter. 15 Truth is nowhere to be found, and whoever shuns evil becomes a prey.

The LORD looked and was displeased that there was no justice. 16 He saw that there was no one, he was appalled that there was no one to intervene;

Isaiah chapter 5 (NIV)

7 He looked for justice, but saw bloodshed; for righteousness, but heard cries of distress.

Isaiah Chapter 9 (NIV)

16 Those who guide this people mislead them, and those who are guided are led astray. 17 Therefore the Lord will take no pleasure in the young men, nor will he pity the fatherless and widows, for everyone is ungodly and wicked, every mouth speaks vileness.

Amos chapter 2 (TEV)

6 The Lord says, "The people of Israel have sinned again and again, and for this I will certainly punish them. They sell into slavery honest people who cannot pay their debts, the poor who cannot repay even the price of a pair of sandals.

Amos chapter 2 (NLT)

7 They trample helpless people in the dust and deny justice to those who are oppressed. Both father and son sleep with the same woman, corrupting my holy name. 8 At their religious festivals, they lounge around in clothing stolen from their debtors. In the house of their god, they present offerings of wine purchased with stolen money.

Jeremiah chapter 7 (GWT)

29 "Cut off your hair and throw it away. Sing a song of mourning on the bare hills, because in his anger the LORD has rejected and abandoned the people of this generation. 30 The people of Judah have done what I consider evil," declares the LORD. "They set up their detestable idols in the house that is called by my name. They have made it unclean. 31 They have built worship sites at Topheth in the valley of Ben Hinnom in order to burn their sons and daughters as sacrifices. I did not ask for this. It never entered my mind. 32 "That is why the days are coming," declares the LORD, "when that place will no longer be known as Topheth or the valley of Ben Hinnom. Instead, it will be known as Slaughter Valley. They will bury [people] at Topheth because no other place will be left.

Ezekiel chapter 22 (GWT)

1 The LORD spoke his word to me. He said, 2 "Will you judge, son of man? Will you judge the city of murderers? Then tell it about all the disgusting things that it has done. 3 Tell it, 'This is what the Almighty LORD says: [Jerusalem,] you are the city that murders people who live in you. Your time has come. You dishonor yourself with disgusting idols. 4 You are guilty because of the people you have killed. You are dishonored because of the disgusting idols you have made. You have brought an end to your days, and you have come to the end of your years. That is why I will make you a disgrace to the nations and a joke in every land. 5 Those near and those far away will mock you. Your name will be dishonored, and you will be filled with confusion.

6 "'See how all the princes of Israel who live in you have used their power to murder people. 7 People in you hate their fathers and mothers. They oppress foreigners in you. They oppress orphans and widows in you. 8 You have despised my holy things and dishonored the day to worship me. 9 Some of your people slander. They want to kill people. People who live in you eat food sacrificed to idols at the worship sites on the hills, and they sin sexually. 10 Men have sex with their father's wives. 11 Men do disgusting things with their neighbors' wives. Some men sexually dishonor their daughters-in-law. Other men who live in you have sex with their sisters, their father's daughters. 12 Other people take bribes to murder people. You collect interest and make excessive profits. You make profits by mistreating your neighbors. You have forgotten me, declares the Almighty LORD.

13 "'I will use my power against you because of the excessive profits you have made and the murders you have committed. 14 Will you still be brave? Will you remain strong when I deal with you? I, the LORD, have spoken, and I will do it.

23 The LORD spoke his word to me. He said, 24 "Son of man, tell the city, 'You are an unclean land that has not had rain during the day of my anger. You have not been made clean. 25 Your princes are like roaring lions who tear their prey into pieces. They eat people and take their treasures and precious belongings. They turn many women into widows. 26 Your priests violate my teachings and dishonor my holy things. They don't distinguish between what is holy and what is unholy. They don't teach the difference between what is clean and what is unclean. They ignore the days to worship me. So I am dishonored among the people. 27 Your leaders are like wolves that tear their prey into pieces. They murder and destroy people to make excessive profits. 28 Your prophets cover up these things by seeing false visions and by prophesying lies. They say, "This is what the Almighty LORD says." Yet, the LORD hasn't spoken. 29 The common people oppress and rob others. They do wrong to humble people and to poor people. They oppress foreigners for no reason. 31 So I will pour out my anger on you, and with my fiery anger I will consume you. This is because of all the things you have done,'" declares the Almighty LORD.

Jeremiah Chapter 6 (NIV)

13 "From the least to the greatest, all are greedy for gain; prophets and priests alike, all practice deceit."

Jeremiah chapter 9 (NIV)

3 "They make ready their tongue like a bow, to shoot lies; it is not by truth that they triumph in the land. They go from one sin to another; they do not acknowledge me," declares the LORD. 4 "Beware of your friends; do not trust your brothers. For every brother is a deceiver, and every friend a slanderer. 5 Friend deceives friend, and no one speaks the truth. They have taught their tongues to lie; they weary themselves with sinning. 6 You live in the midst of deception; in their deceit they refuse to acknowledge me," declares the LORD. 8 Their tongue is a deadly arrow; it speaks with deceit. With his mouth each speaks cordially to his neighbor, but in his heart he sets a trap for him.

Jeremiah chapter 5 (NIV)

11 The house of Israel and the house of Judah have been utterly unfaithful to me," declares the LORD. 26 "Among my people are wicked men who lie in wait like men who snare birds and like those who set traps to catch men. 27 Like cages full of birds, their houses are full of deceit; they have become rich and powerful 28 and have grown fat and sleek. Their evil deeds have no limit; they do not plead the case of the fatherless to win it, they do not defend the rights of the poor."

Isaiah Chapter 10 (NIV)

22 Woe to those who are heroes at drinking wine and champions at mixing drinks, 23 who acquit the guilty for a bribe, but deny justice to the innocent.

Isaiah Chapter 10 (NIV)

1 Woe to those who make unjust laws, to those who issue oppressive decrees, 2 to deprive the poor of their rights and withhold justice from the oppressed of my people, making widows their prey and robbing the fatherless.

Jeremiah chapter 6 (TEV)

7 As a well keeps its water fresh, so Jerusalem keeps its evil fresh. I hear violence and destruction in the city; sickness and wounds are all I see.

Isaiah chapter 58 (NLT)

1 "Shout with the voice of a trumpet blast. Tell my people Israel of their sins! 2 Yet they act so pious! They come to the Temple every day and seem delighted to hear my laws. You would almost think this was a righteous nation that would never abandon its God. They love to make a show of coming to me and asking me to take action on their behalf.

3 'We have fasted before you!' they say. 'Why aren't you impressed? We have done much penance, and you don't even notice it!'

"I will tell you why! It's because you are living for yourselves even while you are fasting. You keep right on oppressing your workers. 4 What good is fasting when you keep on fighting and quarreling? This kind of fasting will never get you anywhere with me. 5 You humble yourselves by going through the motions of penance, bowing your heads like a blade of grass in the wind. You dress in sackcloth and cover yourselves with ashes. Is this what you call fasting? Do you really think this will please the LORD?

6 "No, the kind of fasting I want calls you to free those who are wrongly imprisoned and to stop oppressing those who work for you. Treat them fairly and give them what they earn. 7 I want you to share your food with the hungry and to welcome poor wanderers into your homes. Give clothes to those who need them, and do not hide from relatives who need your help.

8 "If you do these things, your salvation will come like the dawn. Yes, your healing will come quickly. Your godliness will lead you forward, and the glory of the LORD will protect you from behind. 9 Then when you call, the LORD will answer. 'Yes, I am here,' he will quickly reply.

"Stop oppressing the helpless and stop making false accusations and spreading vicious rumors! 10 Feed the hungry and help those in trouble. Then your light will shine out from the darkness, and the darkness around you will be as bright as day. 11 The LORD will guide you continually, watering your life when you are dry and keeping you healthy, too. You will be like a well-watered garden, like an ever-flowing spring. 12 Your children will rebuild the deserted ruins of your cities. Then you will be known as the people who rebuild their walls and cities.
 
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/intro.htm


This one’s fairly obvious. In spite of Genesis, God did not create people, people created God – and ‘in their image’.



Instead of facing reality and dealing with the world as it is, the religious individual invents an ideal of what the world is, an imaginary world, in order to give meaning to the world, i.e. provide it with a purpose that it doesn’t have – maybe because he finds the world meaningless (and misses the meaning that he doesn’t see) or because he does not want to recognize the meaning that it actually has. (The lack of divine meaning is actually what makes us free - unless we have to serve somebody else's purposes.)



No, man is an island. We don’t live like Robinson Crusoe, isolated and alone, we live in societies governed by states, and this influences our fantasies. It is no coincidence that medieval religion is full of hierarchies: of angels, humans and nature, the great chain of being. Since people don’t control their world, i.e. society, they invent fantasies to give meaning to, i.e. justify, the world as it is. (The rational answer to conditions like this is obvious.)

Philosophers of enlightenment may have dreamed of the truly free individual, but this freedom was not yet reality. (compare with: “The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it”)



Unless you prefer to do battle against windmills …



Well, a very servile protest, if at all …



In other words: Don’t fight the symptoms, fight what causes the symptoms.



If people not only want to believe but actually need to believe, you should do something about the conditions causing this. (If they feel that they have no other options, showing them these options, i.e. a way out of their misery, is already a step on the way. And the way out of their misery depends on the conditions that cause their misery. If they imagine that God in his wisdom has punished them with the clap, you should tell them about penicillin. But if they don’t have access to efficient health care anyway, a mere explanation is rather futile. And access may be a question of poverty. Information alone does not make witchdoctors redundant ...)



More metaphors. :) But the chain is a rather obvious symbol, isn’t it?, and throwing off the chain even more so. And so are the flowers, the joys that life (in principle) has to offer.



Again I find the parallel obvious: the geo-centrism (of the dark Middle Ages) versus the helio-centrism of the Renaissance, compared with ‘deus-centrism’ versus ‘humano-centrism’.



The “task of history” is Hegelian rubbish and so is ”in the service of history’”/i]. Unlike what also the CP movement claimed, ‘history’ does not have any ‘task’ nor can it be ‘served’. The aim of revolutionaries (which the 25-year-old Marx was only evolving into at this stage) is to persuade people to “throw off the chain” and stop being serfs.


Thank you for interpreting that Marx quote for me. His meaning's clearer now. Or at least it will be as long as I can remember what you said. :)

If I had to read any more of his writings in that style though, I think I'd still need a Marx to plain English phrase book. :D

He does seem to have had a more mature attitude to religion than a lot of people, in that rather than just denouncing religious people as stupid and trying to go all out to prove to them that religion's false, he looks at the reasons for its existence and points out that they're the things most in need of change.
 
Me said:
You could equally say that if scientists are living with the "contradiction" of science and religion, then those scientists are clearly not rational beings, and so what hope is there for science! :)

Yes, you could easily say that, but you would be wrong. Nobody (that I know) is rational 24-7. Making an error does not make you an 'irrational being'.

No; but anyone who's committed to a religion will self-identify as a member of that religion, just as a scientist will think of being a scientist as an actual part of his identity. It'll be much more of a significant part of his life than any irrational error he might make along the way. Thus, if it's true that religion and science are inevitably contradictory, then any scientist who's religious will be self-identifying as two contradictory things simultaneously.

Dann said:
Yes. They have ways of rationalizing the contradiction, but that does not make the whole thing more rational.

Doesn't that depend on how rational their rationalisations are? :)

Me said:
Well, you've got a point. :) But what if it turns out that only part of what you're calling an illusion really is one, or that you think it's an illusion but you can't be 100% sure?

Dann said:
Then I'll try to make sure.

But what if what's being called an illusion is something like God's existence? It's impossible to have absolute proof that it is one.

Dann said:
I'm not too fond of ethics, but I hate the ethics of the Bible, including #2, even though it wasn't nearly as bad as #1. I think that The Bible 3.0 should scrap the prequels completely and start anew. I honestly cannot think of any parts of the Bible that I'd want to keep.

Oh, but a lot of the New Testament commands are beautiful, and they can prompt people to think about their lives and inspire them to live a better life. See what I wrote in Post 76, from paragraph 6 onwards, where I quoted lots of the nice New Testament commands.

Me said:
But again, eliminating religion altogether would be to eliminate its benefits as well as its drawbacks.

Dann said:
Yes, of course. You could say the same thing about addiction to crack.

But religion at its best can benefit society and has no concrete drawbacks. Crack addiction on the other hand will be in danger of bringing a community down.

Me said:
Christian ethical teaching can inspire people to live better lives.

Dann said:
Yes, and it can inspire people to live worse lives too.

In what respects? I might have an idea of what you mean. I know there are people who are embittered against Christianity because they were shunned by the Christians they grew up around for being illegitimate, for example. But if the people shunning them had had an informed view of Christian ethics, they wouldn't have thought ostracising someone just for that was acceptable Christian behaviour.

Dann said:
I know that many Christians like to believe that if it weren't for 'the good book', they'd be out there murdering, raping and pillaging. It's appears to
be part of the delusion.

I don't know any Christians who think that. :D

Or ... No, surely not.

I'm thinking of a more moderate form of thinking Christianity's inspired you to improve your life, such as teenagers who started off not getting drunk like their friends because of what the Bible says, but then being glad they did, realising there were good reasons not to get drunk, when they see some of the trouble their friends get into because they do.

Dann said:
Yes, but Genesis was wrong a long time before the Origin of Species.

But what made Marx so sure religion was just an illusion in the days before there was an alternative explanation for how life began?

Having said that, Atheists go back in time a long way.

In fact, I'd say some of the kings and church rulers of the Middle Ages can't really have believed in the God of the Bible, because if they had, they'd have taken instructions such as some of the ones quoted in post 76 seriously, and wouldn't have gone around recklessly starting wars, executing people on false charges, and so on.

Interestingly enough, nearly 500 years before Marx, a priest called John Ball was a leader in what could have turned into a revolution, The Peasants' Revolt, that Marx might have been pleased with, apart from the fact that it got out of control and unnecessarily violent. Actually, I expect you've heard of him. He preached social equality in opposition to church leaders and was very popular with the peasants.

On June 14, 1381, Richard II met with the rebels at Miles End and agreed to "abolish serfdom, feudal service, market monopolies, and restrictions on buying and selling."

But then he didn't. Still, there were long-term improvements in their working conditions.
 
I draw complete distinction between science and religion. They shouldn't ever conflict.

What? You mean they shouldn't ever be allowed to do so, lest it cause one to fall ignominiously by the wayside? But what if some people can perfectly happily reconcile one with the other?

Still, I'll agree if you're saying they should serve completely different purposes. Science is about progressing mankind by advancing knowledge, and religion, or at least some religion, is supposed to be about advancing the good of mankind by making an appeal to people's better nature, to inspire them to live lives that further the social good of mankind, and to behave in a way that's less likely to harm their communities than they might have done otherwise.

That's the ideal. Unfortunately, things often go horribly wrong on both the science and religion fronts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom