Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

This is a highly speculative theory which probably cannot be backed up by independent research.

That's just a creative way of saying you don't know anything about this theory, didn't research it beyond some frantic Googling once you found out about it, and have nothing educated or meaningful to say about it. So in order to shift attention away from your veiled admission of ignorance you quickly pivot into something else...

It reminds me of...

You really need to get used to the fact that you are not in any way an expert in this field and cannot bluff your way past those of us who practice this science professionally.

Wouldn't friction between different lunar layers rotating at different speeds immediately weaken these differences in rotation speed?

No, not immediately but over time. Which is why it explains how the Moon could have once had a magnetic field but no longer does. It's a theory that explains remnant (not "remanent" as you ignorantly wrote) magnetism using only known physical phenomena. It doesn't require vast conspiracies.

In any case, the hypothesis that these Apollo rocks have been created under terrestrial magnetism is more straightforward than such ad-hoc hypotheses concerning the moon.

No, it isn't more straightforward because it presupposes a Magic Moonrock Making Machine that you simply have decided must exist and be able to do all the things you attribute to it, and the surrounding conspiracy to create and then hide it. You don't get to make your theory look parsimonious by omitting the discussion of the non-parsimonious parts of it.
 
wogoga: A delusion that the magnetism of Moon rocks is from Earth's magnetic field

...This is a highly speculative theory which probably cannot be backed up by independent research.
2 March 2017 wogoga: A delusion that the magnetism of Moon rocks is from the Earth's magnetic field.
This is several delusions packed into 1:
  • That the Moon rocks were not collected from the Moon, i.e. calling the astronauts who collected the rocks liars, etc.
  • That rocks that are definitely not terrestrial were magically created in labs here on Earth.
  • Doubles up on the magic with 1960's technology that can fool 50 years of progress in analyzing rocks.
  • That the geniuses who created the rocks were so stupid that they did not know that the Moon does not have a current magnetic field and so allowed the rocks to have anomalous magnetism :eye-poppi!
In the real world there is science - Ancient lunar dynamo may explain magnetized moon rocks.
Magnetic fields can be generated by dynamos as in the case of the Earth today.
A dynamo needs a molten core in the Moon.
The Moon started off as molten - including its core - either when it formed independently of Earth or more probably when an impact created it.
As the Moon cooled a mantle was formed.
Tidal forces means that the molten core could rotate at a different rate than the mantle leading to the possibility of a magnetic field.
Thus it is likely that the early Moon had a magnetic field which would cause the magnetism in Moon rocks.
The evidence for this is that we have rocks from the Moon with magnetism that could be caused by that magnetic field :jaw-dropp!
The paper is A long-lived lunar dynamo driven by continuous mechanical stirring by Dwyer et. al. Nature 479, 212–214 (10 November 2011).. This paper has been cited 49 times in refereed journals in 6 years - a god rate.
Just published in 2017: Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535

This is one mechanism proposed for an early Moon magnetic field - also see A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization

We have highlighting "novel mechanism" as if proposing solutions to scientific problems was a bad thing!
 
Last edited:
In the real world there is science

As usual, wogoga tries to parlay his own ignorance as some sort of cogent argument. He wants to defer responsibility for the hypothesis that remanence occurs because the Apollo samples are really Earth rocks. In fact it's his hypothesis -- or rather, his unfounded speculation. That he refers to his own web page in the third person doesn't suddenly give it objective credibility. He throws out a few cherry-picked straw men that he can throw shade on and beg the question of insufficiency, then concludes that because no other theories present themselves, the "other" theory must be true (the other theory being, of course, his conjecture). And when presented with other possibilities, he merely conjectures further that they won't stand up.
 
Just published in 2017: Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535

This is one mechanism proposed for an early Moon magnetic field - also see A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization


Quote from the abstract of Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535, 2017:

The lunar sample with the oldest known paleomagnetic record is the 4.25 billion year old troctolite 76535. Previous studies of unoriented subsamples of 76535 found evidence for a dynamo field with a paleointensity of several tens of microteslas [i.e. ~ 5n5 Tesla]. … We infer a field paleointensity of approximately 20-40 μT [5n2 - 5n4 Tesla], supporting the previous conclusion that a lunar dynamo existed at 4.25 Ga [9p425 years ago].
​
Quotes from the abstract of A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization, 2014:

For reasonable initial conditions, a solid inner core between 100 and 200 km is always produced. During its growth, a surface magnetic field of about 0.3 μT [3n3 Tesla] is generated and is predicted to last several billion years.
​
A hypothetical magnetic field of ~ 3n3 T = 0.000,000,3 Tesla obviously cannot explain field intensities of ~ 5n3 T = 0.000,03 Tesla. Thus, paleo-intensities derived from the Apollo 17 sample in the one paper are two orders of magnitude stronger than the intensity explained by the other paper.
However, all mentioned paleo-intensity values for troctolite 76535 (from 5n2 to several 5n1 Tesla) come suspiciously close to terrestrial magnetism (5n25 - 5n65 Tesla).

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com/d/apollo.html
 
Quote from the abstract of Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535, 2017:

"The lunar sample with the oldest known paleomagnetic record is the 4.25 billion year old troctolite 76535. Previous studies of unoriented subsamples of 76535 found evidence for a dynamo field with a paleointensity of several tens of microteslas . … We infer a field paleointensity of approximately 20-40 μT, supporting the previous conclusion that a lunar dynamo existed at 4.25 Ga."

Quotes from the abstract of A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization, 2014:

"For reasonable initial conditions, a solid inner core between 100 and 200 km is always produced. During its growth, a surface magnetic field of about 0.3 μT is generated and is predicted to last several billion years."

A hypothetical magnetic field of ~ 0.000,000,3 Tesla obviously cannot explain field intensities of ~ 0.000,03 Tesla. Thus, paleo-intensities derived from the Apollo 17 sample in the one paper are two orders of magnitude stronger than the intensity explained by the other paper.

However, all mentioned paleo-intensity values for troctolite 76535 come suspiciously close to terrestrial magnetism



Remember the bits where the local intense variations were discussed?

Your insistence on using pointlessly obscure notation suggests you are trying to hide facts and prevent comparison of your conclusions with reality.
 
Last edited:
Remember the bits where the local intense variations were discussed?

Your insistence on using pointlessly obscure notation suggests you are trying to hide facts and prevent comparison of your conclusions with reality.

Well, the only place where expending an effort to learn it would be in order to parse wogoga's posts. It is of no use whatsoever anywhere else and is functionally useless and error prone.

It would be a waste of time to do so, especially since wogoga himself makes errors all over the place with it.

ETA: I am pretty sure his numbers are borked in his most recent post, but can't be bothered to decrypt it.
 
Last edited:
...are two orders of magnitude stronger than the intensity explained by the other paper.

Which is a meaningless statement without an error analysis that you do not provide. Please provide it, in ordinary notation. And has been already noted, you provide no justification for attributing the inferred intensity from the Apollo 17 sample to an ancient dynamo effect alone. Also strange that one day you're saying lunar dynamo theories are "probably" not supported by evidence, and the next day you're saying that the numbers are reliable enough to rule them out as a source of remnant magnetism.

And yes, until you use standard notation, no one is going to pay attention to your little attempts to play scientist.
 
Maybe using private notation should be added to The Crackpot Index.

I always considered private notation to be essentially the same as #14. Predecessors to the Crackpot Index noted that inventing and using private terminology when well-established terminology exists is a sign of crackpottery. Usually it's just a sign of unfamiliarity with the relevant fields of study and current state of knowledge. In wogoga's case I think he's trying to make a case that his notation is better. It's not ignorance of the prevailing system; it's disdain for it. It would be hard to make a case that he insists on using his own notation in order to obscure the facts, since he has repeatedly directed attention to where he describes how to use it. But it's clear to me he's trying to establish himself as some sort of authority in the physical sciences without actually paying the dues to get it. Inventing a "better" notation appears to me like part of that ploy.
 
wogoga: Usual inane notation and lies about what he cites

Quote from the abstract of ...
6 March 2017 wogoga: Usual inane notation and lies about what he cites :jaw-dropp!
wogoga lies about the papers.
  1. A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization, 2014 has a calculation of the early Lunar magnetic field strength from their model.
  2. Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535, 2017 is a calculation of the early Lunar magnetic field strength from troctolite 76535
These are not the same thing :jaw-dropp!

A rational person would conclude that the 2017 calculation from a sample shows that the 2014 model result was probably wrong.
 
Last edited:
wogoga: Lies abut a citation containing "paleo-intensity values"

However, all mentioned paleo-intensity values for troctolite 76535...

6 March 2017 wogoga: Lies abut a citation containing "paleo-intensity values".
The word paleo does not appear in 76535 Troctolite which is about the chemical & isotopic composition and age of the sample. I see no magnetic field values in the PDF.
 
wogoga: The delusion that the magnetism of troctolite 76535 makes it terrestrial

...come suspiciously close to terrestrial magnetism

6 March 2017 wogoga: The delusion that the magnetism of troctolite 76535 makes it terrestrial when it is documented as collected on the Moon and has features that make it impossible to have been manufactured like all Moon rocks, especially using 1960's technology.
 
Last edited:
20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"
27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored
31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
17 November 2016 wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "doctored", "selected" , "small" samples.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site.
17 November 2016 wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon.
17 November 2016 wogoga: An ignorant conclusion that water content has something to do with isotopic composition.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A colorful, highlighted lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition (oxygen isotopes) between lunar and terrestrial rocks.
6 December 2016 wogoga: A "propaganda bluff' conclusion based on ignorance, denial and delusion.
11 January 2017 wogoga: The fantasy that "normal meteors" have heat shields!
22 February 2017 wogoga: Conspiracy theory delusions, lies and paranoia in his post about his web page.
2 March 2017 wogoga: A delusion that the magnetism of Moon rocks is from the Earth's magnetic field.
6 March 2017 wogoga: Usual inane notation and lies about what he cites!
6 March 2017 wogoga: Lies abut a citation containing "paleo-intensity values".
6 March 2017 wogoga: The delusion that the magnetism of troctolite 76535 makes it terrestrial when it is documented as collected on the Moon and has features that make it impossible to have been manufactured like all Moon rocks, especially using 1960's technology.
 
Thus, paleo-intensities derived from the Apollo 17 sample in the one paper [of 2017] are two orders of magnitude stronger than the intensity explained by the other paper [of 2014].

Which is a meaningless statement without an error analysis that you do not provide.


No comment!


A rational person would conclude that the 2017 calculation from a sample shows that the 2014 model result was probably wrong.


Thus moon-rock faking remains the most reasonable explanation for Earth-like magnetization of Apollo "moon rocks".
Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com/d/apollo.html
 
Last edited:
No comment!

If you decline to provide an error analysis then no one is obliged to respect your claim that the results are significant or for the reasons you offer. Of course I think we both know the real reason is that you have no clue what an error analysis is or how to go about writing one. You are not an unsung genius.
 
Thus moon-rock faking remains the most reasonable explanation for Earth-like magnetization of Apollo "moon rocks".

Not the most reasonable at all, because it requires causes and effects for which you have no evidence. The other explanation requires nothing more than simple error.

Here is the standard jumping-off point for discussing what makes a reasonable explanation.
 
wogoga : The irrational repeating of a delusion of Moon rocks being faked

Thus moon-rock faking ...
26 April 2017 wogoga: The irrational repeating of a delusion of Moon rocks being faked because he cannot understand what he quotes!
What I wrote in full (no lie by quote mining):
6 March 2017 wogoga: Usual inane notation and lies about what he cites :jaw-dropp!
wogoga lies about the papers.
  1. A long-lived lunar dynamo powered by core crystallization, 2014 has a calculation of the early Lunar magnetic field strength from their model.
  2. Further evidence for early lunar magnetism from troctolite 76535, 2017 is a calculation of the early Lunar magnetic field strength from troctolite 76535
These are not the same thing :jaw-dropp!

A rational person would conclude that the 2017 calculation from a sample shows that the 2014 model result was probably wrong.
The last sentence is two simple facts
  1. Science progresses so that later results can show that earlier results were wrong.
    A paper in 2017 based on 3 more years of more understanding of Lunar geology can show that a 2014 model is wrong.
  2. Empirical data always triumphs over models.
    An actual measurement of a sample shows that any model of the sample is either right or wrong. In this case the model is likely to be wrong because it does not match the empirical data - needs a Duh!

26 April 2017 wogoga: A lie about "Earth-like magnetization" of the rocks collected from the Moon by Apollo missions.
The Moon rocks have Lunar-like magnetization which cannot be the result of the Earth's magnetic field because they were collected on the Moon :eek:!
The evidence that wogoga cited and cannot understand is that troctolite 76535 was magnetized "4249 ± 12 million years ago (Ma)" with no significant reheating events since then.
 
Last edited:
20 October 2016 wogoga: Quote mining + a lie of "a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated"
27 October 2016 wogoga: The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the issue of reentry heat being ignored
31 October 2016 wogoga: Repeats ignorance about ablative heat shields
31 October 2016 wogoga: A "PR" lie about the APOLLO EXPERIENCE REPORT – THERMAL PROTECTION SUBSYSTEM
31 October 2016 wogoga: A lie about the Apollo missions being easily faked with 1960s technology
17 November 2016 wogoga: Paranoiac conspiracy theory leads to a fantasy of "doctored", "selected" , "small" samples.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A quote from an obviously deluded "scienceagainstevolution" web site.
17 November 2016 wogoga: Thinks that water will be different on he Moon.
17 November 2016 wogoga: An ignorant conclusion that water content has something to do with isotopic composition.
17 November 2016 wogoga: A colorful, highlighted lie about Herwartz et.al which points out different composition (oxygen isotopes) between lunar and terrestrial rocks.
6 December 2016 wogoga: A "propaganda bluff' conclusion based on ignorance, denial and delusion.
11 January 2017 wogoga: The fantasy that "normal meteors" have heat shields!
22 February 2017 wogoga: Conspiracy theory delusions, lies and paranoia in his post about his web page.
2 March 2017 wogoga: A delusion that the magnetism of Moon rocks is from the Earth's magnetic field.
6 March 2017 wogoga: Usual inane notation and lies about what he cites!
6 March 2017 wogoga: Lies abut a citation containing "paleo-intensity values".
6 March 2017 wogoga: The delusion that the magnetism of troctolite 76535 makes it terrestrial when it is documented as collected on the Moon and has features that make it impossible to have been manufactured like all Moon rocks, especially using 1960's technology.
Is this the shotgun approach to lunacy?
 
No comment!

Thus moon-rock faking remains the most reasonable explanation for Earth-like magnetization of Apollo "moon rocks".
Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com/d/apollo.html

In case you overlooked it smartcooky provided an excellent debunking of your Earth produced Lunar Rocks.
Yep, and some even show impact craters from micrometeorites, something that simply cannot happen on Earth because micrometeorites rarely make it intact through the atmosphere, and when they do, they do not arrive at the surface with anywhere near enough velocity to make an impact crater.

Here is an interesting article on moon rock from a scientist who has been studying them for almost 50 years. Dr. Randy Korotev is a lunar geochemist at the Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences at Washington University in St Louis.

http://meteorites.wustl.edu/lunar/howdoweknow.htm

On claims that the Apollo Lunar samples were faked in a Government Laboratory, Dr Korotev has this to say (your point emphasized);

"Any geoscientist (and there have been thousands from all over the world) who has studied lunar samples knows that anyone who thinks the Apollo lunar samples were created on Earth as part of government conspiracy doesn't know much about rocks. The Apollo samples are just too good. They tell a self-consistent story with a complexly interwoven plot that's better than any story any conspirator could have conceived. I've studied lunar rocks and soils for 45+ years and I couldn't make even a poor imitation of a lunar breccia, lunar soil, or a mare basalt in the lab. And with all due respect to my clever colleagues in government labs, no one in "the Government" could do it either, even now that we know what lunar rocks are like. Lunar samples show evidence of formation in an extremely dry environment with essentially no free oxygen and little gravity. Some have impact craters on the surface and many display evidence for a suite of unanticipated and complicated effects associated with large and small meteorite impacts. Lunar rocks and soil contain gases (hydrogen, helium, nitrogen, neon, argon, krypton, and xenon) derived from the solar wind with isotope ratios different than Earth forms of the same gases. They contain crystal damage from cosmic rays. Lunar igneous rocks have crystallization ages, determined by techniques involving radioisotopes, that are older than any known Earth rocks. (Anyone who figures out how to fake that is worthy of a Nobel Prize.) It was easier and cheaper to go to the Moon and bring back some rocks than it would have been to create all these fascinating features on Earth."

It would be easier to go to the Moon and bring back a few hundred pounds of rocks than to try and manufacture them here on Earth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom